High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/29291/2025allowed

Gurnam Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others

2025-08-18Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

-5 !"#$<"9 #' !"#$<"9 #' !"#$<"9 #' !"#$<"9 #'(!A (!A (!A (!A,-5 ,-5 ,-5 ,-5

<#! "( D3"!

#"( ="(( &<#! "(

!!"#$% D3"(:#<"!( '

' "("!'

"("!'

1) 3

)

) (3 =%#!>,<=#9!"$#!

! ":"!

#"(3 3=9

" #%&3 3 8 ,<=#9!"$# 3<"":>?,<=#9!"

# "$#"(:#<"!( #3<.3 @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ ) ) ) ),3/)2 ,3/)2 ,3/)2 ,3/)2

" :"("! :"!

# ( &"" $ 8"< <" # 5A #$ ! "

* + +( !,-./ /$#( #!0

12$#C( #$ #34 <!"<53-73-7/";" 2,<" #(75,.., 5,6, 7#$! " < "8#<", A6-/$#( #!0 12,"

(!""< !#8 9" ! # +#!, 9!# <88(&("C"!:#9""< ! ""

"$# # ! " &( ( #$ 9#

("E$$ <= ! <!"< 73-53-5 /";" 2,?

9 ((!!"<!# ="&"" "$$"9!"<&"!?""! ":!

"(3 3 -3-43-5,! "$#88#?

# <"?(:(("<' ":"!

#" (::#9 "< /";" 2 < !

! ""$# #! "&( "$$"9!"<&"!?""! ":!

"(3

9"#$ #!

(#!(""+ C( #$ 88 9#("C"!

8 :#9""< (#$9#

(" = &""

((!",3!

( :! ::"9" # &" %&<99":!(#!

9"3 3<"":>?, # &" 8$ #$ 3 = <" =+8! $#"(:#<"! # "9#<3 <"8

, 3,%& & 8$ #$ "(:#<"! #3 !!" #$ <=#9!" ("!""<::"9"

, <=#9!" < $ 8"< #(3F.3 "( "&"!+"#

":!

"("< "9!"<!

C! "$9! #$9#

!#"!! "

(!!"

"!("9#<"<

! "$#88#?

"' ( 88 ::" &"$#" ! " ! 8 2 " :"!

#" #!E 88C #*<!"! ""$!

(!!" $# :"!

#" ( ?"88 $9! #$ 9# ::"9"

(!!" ( 88 <# (!!"

"!( #$ ! "

("3 ! ( #!E 88C

(!!"

"!(#$! ":

<"# 9#$""9 ! 8#!E 88C

2 9("! "(!!

#$= <"#9#$""9 &" <8* <"!

$ ! "

"(:"9!

="9# #$! ""( < $

2 " ! 8 # 9 ##("!#"!! "(!

! # (# " #

#! ? # ?#8< ($$ "!(!<

( "9#<"< ! # #

(( #"E<= $!" "9#< (! :!

"( < ::" <"9#<"<! "

! " ( < :!

"( "(:"9!

=" 9#("

($9!

##$! 8 $!""9#< ! "(!!"

! " #$ ! " $#"(

(!!"( 88(&

!(":# (#"9#<"<(!#? "! "88!

!# 9#

(" < ( !# (!!" 9#9""< # 63-43-5 $!"($ ;"<&*! 8#!E 88C "9#< (!!"

"!( #$ ! "

( #$ ! " 9# ! C ! "

("3 ( < ? " * (9

<", ! " ! 8 #!E 88C <# ! " ""<$8 $# "9#< ! "

"( C ! " $9! #$ ! "

( 88 &" #:" !# ! " ! 8

(!!" !# "

! " "9#< ! "

"(&*: *( 98:#9"((#&* ( <""

"< ::#: !" &* ! "

(!!"3 !"

"! (!#&""9#<"<&*?* ,! ":!

"(9#9""<( 88 88 ! # = <"# 9#$""9 &* ("8,(&%"9!!#! "(!

($9!

$$ 9"3 #!E 88C (!!" * 8(# !!"

"!(#$! ":!

"("9#<"< #

(( #", ::# !"< &* ! "

8< &" (# " <=#9!" = !! "3 9("! "(!!"

(# " #

(( #", (9

=#9!"( 88$ ( $$ <= !"

"!( !# ! " "$$"9! ! ! ! "

"< &"$#"

E " < "E( "

(!!"

"!((:"8?<! !

< &"" <8* <"!

$ "< &* ! "

"83

( ( 88 &" (&%"9! !# 8 #!E 88C (!!"3

"!(#$88! "$$"9!"<:!

", ! " ! 8 #!E 88C #!#! "&( (#$! "(!!"

"!( ! "$$"9!"<:!

"( =""!""< # ? "! " ! " 9#

. .

C"(!

( $#< !# &" = "$$"9!"<?

! #!! ""&"

* 8 < 9#

(" < ( &"" *+ <#$ $8"9"#9#"9 #3 (!!" ( 88 8(# ":#! ( $!" (""+ $# # $#

" ! 8 #!E 88C "<( ! " $#88#?

$9!( $$ 9",9#9""<

<' 2 G "! " ! "" ( * :"!

#",*"< !

2G "! "! "" (* "="<:!*#! "! :"!

2G "! "*99("< $$"<"H

"":#!&"(&

!!"<& <!"#$ " 3"3-53-A3-53I * #! " 99("< #! " ! ! "

:"!

#H *#! "9# !#$$"9!"<E <E ! ""(:#<"!(,*"< ! "

"< (&""<"98"<#98

&"$#"!

(#!&"$#"! "";!

I .3 (!!# ! " $#"( <#<" , ":#!<!"<A3-43-5 $#

! "< 8 (!!" (!8((,# (& &"""9"

="<,?

9 (!+"# "9#<3(:"

"! "":#!,! " 8#! ( "9#<"<($#88#?(' B/ 2 ( :" (!!"

"! # "8* 8+

(# 88" &3 " ( 8

(# #$ >

" ( 8 +#!, (

"( <"! +#!, 9!#

"( <"! #$ = 88 9!#, % !>

"( <"!#$ = 88"

9! #, + !

"( <"! #$ = 88"

#, ! > K "( <"! #$ = 88"

(# 88" %"?83 8? ="&""$#< =#8="<

2 ( :" (!!"

!E=

"(:#<"!E9# !E"

2 ( :" ! " (! :#98 # :#9""< #$ -, !#!8 #$ "

! :"(#(, # #$ >

"( <"! #$ &, +#!, 9!#38J

"( <"! #$ = 88" &, 9! #,

(# #$ ! #$ = 88" ! , " ( ,>++

(##$

!, !, " &3 " ( 8 +#!, >K ""8#?

$"#$( ! , " ( 8 +#!,

(# #$ >

&, " ( 8 +#!, ""!# ?

$" #$ >

&, " ( 8 +#!, ##$+

"( <"!#$ < !

, 9! 8< <(99("< ! ":"("! 3 ! #$ , ! "" ( #8* #"

(9(", "8* %

< "*" ?

!"(( "8* < !"

"! #$ - "

! " * ( " :"< (! "

! " #$

7 ! " :!

"( # * #$ !

#98

"<$$"<"3 73

""$#",$# ! "(!!"

(#! ((!

($ "<! !! "9# " ", =#8!* < ! " (

* + < #$ <" $8"9"

:#9""< ( " #! :"< 9("3 " #

8 (!!"

"!( $$ 9"#$! "9( ""?

! 3

"":#! ( ""&*(&

!!"< 8*#&8 "<3I ! " 99("< ( &"" <"98"< "!(#$! ":!

"(!#! "9(", #

! ":"("!9("

" ( &"" ="< ! ?

! #!

" # 9#"9 #3 #"#=", (! * #$ ! " :!

"( !# ! "

!( #$ 88 ! " :!

"( < ! "

#"<&#=""!!9 "< < :8"("$#*#+ <:"(83 73 )""<9#("8$#"(:#<" !( #3F.<

!(! "$9!#$ :!

"( = 9#

("<,<(!!"(! ! " (##&%"9!

9("! "

< 88 8 :#9""< ( (&("C"! ! ""

"!# (! ! " :"!

#"( "

C( "<3 53

88*,8""< !!"9#("8 8 ((!!"<##&%"9!

9("

! " (C ( "<&("<:#! "9#

("/";"23 63 =" "<8""<#("8$# #! ":!

"(< ="9"$88* #"! # ! ""9#<(#$! "9("3 43

( #! < ! " #1&8" :"; #! ( ":"!"<8* <"8!

! ! " (( "#$";"9 ("#$% (< # <" #7A#$! "#<"!# C( :#9""

#9# :#<&8"#$$"

"9"( ! "9("(#$

=(3 !!" #$ =(3 !!" #$ =(3 !!" #$ =(3 !!" #$ $ %& < #! ", -/-2 $ %& < #! ", -/-2 $ %& < #! ", -/-2 $ %& < #! ", -/-2

.-.

.-., >8?

F >8?

F F F F F #! "(=(3 #! "(=(3 #! "(=(3 #! "(=(3

!!"#$%&F#! ",--4

!!"#$%&F#! ",--4 4/.2/

82-5 4/.2/

82-5< #:8 #:8 #:8 #:8 < #! " =(3 !!" #$ < #! " =(3 !!" #$ < #! " =(3 !!" #$ < #! " =(3 !!" #$ < * <"( , -/72 333 < * <"( , -/72 333 < * <"( , -/72 333 < * <"( , -/72 333 3 3 3 3 /

82 .

. /

8 ::"8 #37A . /

8 ::"8 #37A #$ - <"9 <"< # ! #$ #$ - <"9 <"< # ! #$ #$ - <"9 <"< # ! #$ #$ - <"9 <"< # ! #$ $$$$

":!"

&",

":!"

&",

":!"

&",

":!"

&", -2 -2 -2 -23 ":#:#( ##$8?!

! !"

""($# ! "$#"( < <"9 #(" <""<&*! " #1&8":";# !<!

(#! (' /2 #?" E( 7A 333 = ?

<"< ($$"9!"<&* /&2

#?"=",?

<"! ":#?"

/92

"<"8 : 9 :8"

! ! ! 9 &" =#+"

"9# J 9#

!!"(?

9 "#="?

89 9!"8 +"9#

#$ !

8"8!

/<2

"( <:#?" (#!!#&

=#8= "

#( < <":= !* # #$$"9"( 8 + (9 #$$"9"("#!:

:9!#(#9 "!*3 /"2

# 7A 333 9(!

<=9" !""(!#$%(!

( <!* 9(!"< :# ! "

"8<! !! "

<" # .-4 ""

! ""#$3

#! 9 ((! "<,? "! "(9 :!(#$! "&#<*E!"# /$2

9 ";"9 (" ! ! " :"

(( &8"#8* $!" !

# < 9 "

< ! "! 83 9 ";" ?

8"! " !!" ((!

88 /2 8"C( # ?

9 "#$: =!" 9#( <" !"9"<"!( #$ 99("< < ? "! " " ( "<! "9# ="(!"< ?

! !

( #! 9 &* #.-#$! "#<"3 ""!"! "9!

8"";"9 (9 :#?" "< !# C( ! " :#9""< " &"!?"" ! " :!

"( ! "

8*<:"<#

!8*#$

"9 8!(9!

#(# #!

:#$

8*< (:!"(3 &"";"9 ("< ! ":#("9!

#( < (" #( #$$"9"( #$ "!8 +" <", :", <9# !* "!93 ( =!" !"< ="(" #( !( <!* :# ! "

#! !# 9"(?"883 ! "9# ##$

#!, ! ! :"; #!

! ?#8<#!"$("!#C( "8* &"9(" $ <( 9 (("(( !" #$ % "(

% "( $8 9!"<#= !8E<"8 9!"

#$?":#( ("< "!93 <( #$

#! ?#8< &"

! " "= <"9" ( 9#88"9!"< $!" "( ""! ( $ 8"<E9 "( $ "9 (" 9#! &" 9 "< #!

<" #9# :#<&8"#$$"9"("=" !",

#! ("C "<!# $ ! " 99("<, 9#<9! #$ ! "

?( &(9#< # ? "! " "

!!#"!" !#9#

("3

"(!!!#*:#= ##$

#5A#$

,-. (( (! "(!!!# #*:#= ##$ #7A#$ $333 ""$#",! "&#="

( <: 9 :8"

"(#$8??#8<::8*!#:"!

#<" #5A#$

, -.(?"88 3

6 A3

(, +"":

= "? ! " $# "( < $9!( < 9 9 (!9"(, ( #! ( #$ ! " 9#( <""< #:

# !

! ( $ ! 9(" !# ";"9 ("

% (< #= ="(!"<E(5A#$

,-.!# C( ! " (' 2 !!

C "!(!#! ":

!C !* #(!:!

9("#$(&(!!

8%(!

"#$$"9"(88""<":

":!

"( ="9#

=2 (:"! "":#!"9"

=#8!* !(!"L /=2 # !E=

(

("# (#?= #("C"!8*, ! " :"!

:#9""< (?

88& :"9"< "(F?

8899#< 8*$! "! "

9"L :

8*#$: =!"!"L

("<L "<! "9#

(( <!#&"

":#!"< !# =" "!""< !# =#8 3 ( 88#?"<3 #34 <!"< 53-73-7/ ";"2,<" #(7 75,..,5,6,7#$! "

< "8 8 #<", A6- /$# ( #! 0 1 12, "

(!""< ! #8 9" !!

+#!, 9! # < 88 9#( ("C"!

8 :#9""< ( ! ""$# # ! "&( (#$9#

("E$$ < = !<!"<73-53-5/";"

2,", " "&*,C( "<C! ":"!

#"( (3 -3 "< ::8 9!

#/(2, $*,( 888(#(!<< (:#("<#$3 (!A (!A (!A (!A, , , ,

= G "! "(:"+ G "! "":#!

-5 -5 -5 -5

E"(#"<' "(E /

)

)2 !&8"' "(E