← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/597/2021allowed

Kawal Singh And Another v. Chander Shekhar Aggarwal And Others

2022-04-20Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal12 pages

    

 



    



 

   



   



   ! "

 !

#!

 !

" #

$  !%&

 # $   !' $ #

$  ! ( "))#$ #!' '

#$  !  $#$  * !( + & , #$  !-  .

# $   / !+#

$  ! 

# $  !,

+#$   0#1 2 ! &

#$  * !

#!$ 

 3

  

) + 

(& (# ) 

 

41 

$    #*256

 7

89#

$ 

    #

+ 



 

 

 (



:  

  

 

 

   

   

 4  *;2*#    

  

  

        + 



   +  &$+   ,

 

  +

)

     (

     +          < (& *

 $    *     &+  /;2   + &6 ,' 

 

9   

  *021;    *   

$ 

 +   

,$ +

+  

 = 6 9,>?4   $ +

/#;2##@=6  , A &?

B &9      $ @   + &  +   >?>>     ,'  

    +  

< 

< 

9  ,  (   +

     *00#*0##@=  6   4   -

   <&   <

  < B 4 &9 B  (  (&>?>>>?4 + 

   B (   (=

  6

9  ,    >?>>      

+    1               

 

 + /+  + & +  @    

+>?4 $9,>?>>  

  +

B  

  0+  +&     +>?4 6$9,>?>>

+ &

  +

  # 



@ +

 + 

@ +

@ 

 + &

 >?4 $ ()   6$ 9      <

      

  @ & # + &#

   # !

<

%

(( (&>?>> 6$

9,&(

@ 



+

+

+( #

#  +#   #  

 #    #       + #          >?4     $       $    &

  

     &>?>> +

 





 #  

&# #



 &

( @ (&>?4  

  @ &   6$

9,>?>> ( ( 

 



@ +



+ & +



 + &   

   <9,

  >?4$  +  



+  



 

    >?>> ( 



                 > CAC

>A4!?

>4A 4?, ,"D 4%,4A BE   <

>?4C?

C,C4?    ,->  >?4  C  -C?'  22 D>  C'-,  4?  ,->  C  B?FBB C'-,? 4>C4?4AB?ECBB"> 'C>?,4>?>>G  C

(



 *#

 

   2#  

E 

  *# $

   ? - &#  ( 



 2  &

  ( &



  

+   (  ,

  

  = :C

##

+  +(& &   

 $      

(+

 + 

($#

+&

&( 

- H( +&

&

  +

)

 

 +

&  

 

 & &





&   

 +







+ &



    & 



 I  +  (

 ( 

 

 $       

 

   

   +



* 

 

 $

            # ,

  ! #  

   '

 +     .+( @!



  &     6 &

9  & 

- H(

+&+   ( 



$ 



 G 

 

41

 C   + &    *

  & 

 





# 



)

+

(

   ,

     

(&

  &,   ) 

  





= * *

  



 





##



)

 

( +



   ,



& $& /;2   

 + & 

   

 $& ,A    



, *

   #

   & ( ,     

         1  

  (  +( 



 $ &       $&

   #  * $



#   $  $

   $  1$  & 5 2 ***1 

  $&

 ,A    

 $

#   (  & #   -  



     (



( B  

 

 $     & 

   

  B  





        

  (&      (     &  

E ) 



#  

J

<+





+



C (    

$  

 (&

  

+

 

<  

 +  

  4  1    ** 

 -     



 + 

&$+   ##) + 

 (&  (  ( 

    #  



 *

 & +      

  (&    (   

( #





  

'

 4     #    ( + &  ,  #     

 

  /      ( $  &

 ) 



 

*

 & C (  $ &  ( 

     1# 

+

( ? 

  <



# 

&# 

+  *   $ -  ) + 

(& +



(() !*+ ,-./ 01"

*2..*--*3 /45.

/++

6

%  &6$ "3/0*47*47*8 01"

"9"*-:*)*+



&  &'$ -*-, (;

3/11* 01"

#+*(2<4,3 *47 (8)*4:

'

6  %-   

      &

&

           C

 ) -  

(

(&    

  * 

)(  #*2*5  (&$   *69    #*20/#

(   +#    

  

  

 0#1 2    

$&      #   

 $<

    #   (   ( ) -     +

+ 

 #    ()        0#  1     2        

4 

  

 !

&

#  



 *

  

(+ + +   

( 4   

41

#

$  

   () # & +  

41

   C    #   



 0  

(  (

  

41 **6 

 9

 

69$ 

()  



  

  # # 

69$ ) 



 + +



(((& &  B

<+



 (

 

69 41

 

69

  

  

   ( 

 



C    # 

 $  

             J #     $          +        +    ++   

,

#

$

 &$ 

   

 C  (





 *

 

 



+ ) ")#?

+.

# $.

#?

 .

#!

.

#  ) $$$

 

    *  # & ++

+(&((

 0  +   $ ( &   , 7 

  8

(

    +    (

   

            (

     

 $&$  

  

 

   &               $  

     

 $ 

  C  





#  (      $# 

  #  ++   +

    

) 



 

  

+(  41

?#"   <+

41

**69

C$ 

 

 +  +



(((& & &  # (  $ 

((&C  

 #  /$ ) 

(

  *69   #*20/  

*69$  J &

    

&( (

(& &

+ 

< 

  (  

#

)

 

(  C &  #

 + #

&# 

$&

 

   + #&

 $+    ,  <            

  

  /

   *

  

 1  # + 

      $ &      #  #   

 

 +

(C+&( 

$  &  *

 2





&  +  ,

$  

&$(  $

  

(& *C

 $ +  



 1

 +

 * (

  I  $  1<   22&

$  5 2 +#        +     /**0  (

 *  1 22&

++

+*1/*//*0 +    + +

#$#  

+

   $  +   (  ( (

 C

  # +

 - #       ) 

E    



 $ &   (  

 1# +&(     &  

 $ #  <+



  

 ,



( &  

+   #  (  

) + *+,,8

.*/ 01"

-*-, (;

*.*3*1.-3*$   %    

   ) + 3/ *3/ *4=4*47*1 (-*+* 01"

,8*49/-.*+ #*8*4- *47 (-.,31$  

 ! & ) 

# & $+ +



+ #

 

+

& $ C     <+

  + #



(&   41

  ,               

  

  /

 (  )    *



)(  #*55#  (  

 

+



)

  

 & 

C     # 

  & & 

(

 ++   ?#

&I  

 

 +- 

 * $& ,

+  (<+

 &

+ $  



  



$<

   #()   

 

 

+ + 

#&   

&  ()      +

( &  

   

+ +  

4 



#4 

  &

   

  C    #+  ( 



 41

 

 +   4  ) 



#    ,

#  #   +   4  >$ 

# +&( 

 )

     





+

   (<+

(&        +

+ 

    $

) +   (& 



  /# +&( 

B   6

9# +  <+



+

( &         # 

&#     - 

# 

 <

   

  4  0    *0

   *5   ,  

41

69

 ( #,  

 ()    & 

 

()   C "3/0*47*47*8 1

6

9#       

$ $  ,  # 

   #$   

)

# 



 #+ +( + , + #

 

 +

 &$<

+ 

#

 C

-*-, (;

3/11*6

9  <+

+

  < <

  (  +  ,-  )  

41

 

69,+  $ (&A 6 

>  + 9 #*20* - #

$  ) +   (&   



  /$   , ) + $(  $

    

J &#

$  

#

, 

(&  ((&# 

   + 

 +   (                   

   ,    

   (    5;



+

 

 

#  &#

 

!

#!  

  E 

@  D @? E( D @?