← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14603/2017dismissed

Shanti Devi & ANR v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2023-01-11Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj9 pages





    

 

!"#$ "%&'&#() *+ (!& ",& (- (#!+". 

*! !"#$ ./ (  (-#!+".'   

)0 1

 *2 * 

      

  

  !" #  $   $ % & 2 * 

3  ' 

      (   

 (#  

 

 )

           *   )   $  + 

 ,  ) '*   )*  

 

 

) ( * (#    ) (  # 

 , 

  

  ) 

* #   -*    

  )      )

* # * -  

 -*  -*  (

  (    *

) 

  ) )  *

      ' 

* #. ) -*   -*  (

  

   

(  

 )           





 



 )      *  $    ) ,      

)   )    

  

*   $ ) 



/          

       0 

*  

 ' 

 

)  #      

    ) ) 12 3 #14 * 5

)    *  

 

  )   **  ' 

      

         

*(*

 

  

   

     )

* #. ) -*   -* (#  )*   6 *) 7 

)





     *  

     '

(*  #          (# *

  (*

    *  

 8 

) )     9

  1:14      ) (   8  8   '         )

   ,  ) '*   )

)

 (#

 

*  (#   !   ) #     68#7;(&1/1:(   '  0   *   5  

      

 !"

 !#

 $%   &%  '

(! "

    )   

  *+  ,&- " .

 ./-  1

'2 13    + ,!     4       *      45 *44   4  4    67 ! , * ,    67   

4    ,5* 4 , 4 

 4 51      4     , 5       5    4    *     ,   *  

   / 

 4 *   + , 4 &-! ./-  1

 5 4  

  4   

4         5      4    ) $"(8'8 4 49:

   - 8

!; *5    )

     

  4     <  

  *

4  -+  44         *  

        , =  ,   *  (  * 

  )   **      

  



# 0 

              )

 ( < ##

(*     

 #   * ( (*(#*'

)



(# 

 

 <    #    ((



 * 



  *    %4 6+7   8 *     8  (   ,

<

 ) ;(    ( 

 (#3 ) ;

8

 %141:'    

(*     $ 5 *    

 *  )(# *;     (# #    *(  )" #     6"=7 ;(   

    >11/ ) )       '  0         5   5      4    ) $"(8'8 4 49:

   - 8

!; *5    )

     

  4     <  

  *

4  -+  44      *

    ,  2 * *44 4 4    67 ! , * ,      67   

4         4 ,       4        

  <" 1 #  4 5  2 *  4    5    4 5  2 *  3   ;      4     ,> 1

3  1

   4 67   , * * 2   5  4 ,   , 5       5    4    *     ,   *  

  /

4*  + ,4&-!  .

/44 !-  1

 5 4 4           4   



4     

4   5      4    ) $"(8'8 4 49:

   - 8

!; *5    )

    

  4     <  

  *

4  +  44      *

   ,  "    **        5 * 4  4.?

. 8 4'

7 .,!   " 5   ! < "# <<  #          @+ ,    , A   ! 3' 8 , ;  

  -    1

 ."! - '

 ! < .  @&- :  )";2 

 + 4 4 4 35 *   8  :   4 5  2 *   * 8B' < "4  < 

    

 4  

 4* - 5     ,! 4 ,! ,         4   4 5   3  + ,!"  #     4 C 7,  4 2 ! & 5   4 4!  427!67  46 *  !6  46  !D6 43  6 !  9 

  4 4!C 0  4 & 0

!  *67   :!& 01

  4 6 7  9      5  2 *  *   /   !     4   35  * 6 1

!$6   48 6  :  4 5  1  *        4 5  1 */  !   4/ '0 !  * 3 ! 2 7 9  /  '0  4    4 3 ! 1

  4 2 7 9! D   *

 &5    4 D  6    :   4 5  : * 4   4 4 B   4 *0 

 )  + ,! * 4   5 *  4   4* D  !1*    5 :  1 1*  % < , 6 1

*   ** %      ,1    5 1 1 $'

7 (  ,    *  67       

     +   *     3   4 6  1

!     4 6  1

 *  4     4   35  $   (   *  4  4 67  *  *   61 > !3  ! 0   0        4 67            35          

,/)

 !  35          *  1   5 1 1$'

7 (/

 !67  

 4    

  , 

   

         35  $4 

 4   67 ( *    5  *     467 *    4 < ,   5  2 *     *   0   467 

 

        ! "  ! #   )     *+ 

, &-    " .  ./-   

'2 13   + ,!  4       *       4  5  *    44     4  4   

 67 ! , * ,   67       

 4     , 5 * 4 ,  4   

 4 51   4  , 5      5  

  4     *     ,   *  

    / 

 4 *   + ,4&-!./-  1

 5 4      4   

4       

    4    ) $"(8'8 4  49:

   - 8

!; *5  )

  

4   <  

  *

4  -+  44     *

   , A* !  9 :-8 5             +  4        ;-6    ) $"( 8'8    *  7    # / 

#!  %  0A * ! 3    4      4 ,  ,   $   *4 ( %4   "

  3       4    5 

        E   5

> 1

   4 9 8 5  :

 $  3 5 (! ;   5   %      44  4 

6 ! ;  , *     4     

 <"1# 4 5  2 *  4    5    4 5  2 *  3   ;      4      , >  1

  3   1

    4

5  67   , * *  5   5 

 * < 44 ,

 = #       + ,!  *  4   67   4   45 2 * * %   

4 

  3 1 $ ( $   * 4  (  4   4  

 = ,   

  (      , < # '*  ( 

(#  $ + $ >:+&5>>1&     (# ?*  )     * )  ,

   -*  ,      @, 3  

  

)

  (   <        *        ( 

(     

(  ,   

            *  6

5         )7     

   (

 *    ) (( )    @  )   *       (    # (     #  1:   1/  #

      )     )     

 5 (    '   

  8     *  #    #;  *  

)

 

# (   <             <       ) (   8       (* (#       

 (    ( *    

#   (  ,  ( #   )  *

 # 

  *

  <  ( * (#8 8    )  

# *  ( *    )

6 < # 0  )

   

 *   

'    

# (   

      ( *

  '     ) # *

'

  ( ( # 

 

 * (     *  (7 ./3  2 * 

. 8 .#.      B 0   F>  B  F>