High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19126/2015dismissed

Sunil Sharma And ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-10-01Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik11 pages

!"# $ %

" &

!"#$% & '

()*& )!"#$ &+

,*!-.) &+" '

( ) !"# $ % " & # ,&%!"#$ &+ ///// *"(+ $*,-.!+"/#01!$!+(02#0( $*,-.!+"/#01!"(/"($#.2("2 &&+ $ ++)0

%"&(",12

30 "&+12 4&&&(",& "0+" &* ,12 ///// $!+(02#0(3/ 5)& "%&

, " $ 6 %" $

3& $&

, & % + &

+$ 0" -" 3$& 7 & 8-39: + $ $ %& ) $ + $ $; +!++

7 &8!9:&,&, $"

, $ " ++ +$ 0" !++"

<5 .) ="$ $& "7-+>5: # $

7 &8& 9: 3& + &# 0 " ! $ + $ &,& * $ ="$ " (0 3$& $ ? # ) @ "&A & ? # )A - @0&&% ? # ) $ $ " 3$& ,) .

A && *)" ? # ) & &"&) *# B ? # ) .)

$ # " "# C

# " ++

DD + -3 + $ $ $& + ,#"0)) $

"83&.) ="$ $& "7-+>5: # $

9 & $+ &-3+ $ $0++ "0)"

$$ $$0 0) "+

") # $ ) -# -# E"

3& # <$

& ""> E& &$<&% 6 > 7: << << << : G-3G -" 3$& & # 0($ ++ "

& " &

$ " B$ ++ " 0

& A << << <<

C +&

0++ ")+ & # $ &

+ 6

"<+ $+$

" $ 4 !++"

<5& &$ "

$$ $$ 0 "&+$

" D & "!++"

< & $ +++ "&&0)"

$$ $$ 0 # ""& $ $$ 0 "

&6 "0 $"

" $&" "5$ %" & 0$ %" $ =<> # $ " &) $

) ."

$++" &# , & 6 " & <+ $ #

0 , & #$$ #" && < <+ $+&

)+$)0)" 0$"" % ,, # &"

$ &$ ,,$) << << <<

0 * , !$" $ 6

" <+ $

) "

$ $ $$0 !$" $ 6

" <+ $

)

++ & & 0) "

$ $ $$ 0 7: : 74: 7D: << << <<

4 -3 + $ : $ + $ $ 7, % ) $: ; ! 7, & ) $:;5=;53$& + $ $;+ =,, ; E3 7, $: % & H,,, $, I" # )A

: $ % & .

; J ;5!;! % & .

& 0($

$ &# ,

" .) $& =

)3 7.3=3: ; $& 3$& =

)37 3=3: #: ," $" $$" ! "#$ $%!&> : $ + $ 7, %) $:; ! 7, & ) $: ; 5=; 53$& + $ ; + =,, ; E3 7, $:% &H ,,, $, I" # )A

: ) $& , <+ $ -3 $+$ $

: $% &.

; J ;5!; !% &.

&0($ #:

$ &# ,

" .) 3$& =

)37.3=3: ; $& 3$&

)37 3=3: << << << << 3& , #$ & + & & +

"",& " $+ $ $!0&)&# 0 "&", "

$"$ "!",0 " "

$"$ " +% &&",0 "&,&, " 0) "

, $ " $ 0 "

" ) & 0 "

$ 0)"

,$ >0)"

$ "$ E $""&" $A" < ")

0 0 ,", $+ $ $! 3& &" $6 ,$&",$0"0 & +$ ++ E + " & +$ -3 &) $A& )A5 ,)& $ $ $ "

$ & 0"0%, ""&,&"

$"$ " 3& & "

$ & $ -3 + $ $ 0%, $"&,&"

$"$ " 0 ) "0 .90 + @, %)#-# !"& "& 7 : KK & " & & $ "& #$ 6

+$ 0" # +3& "$ " "

$ %& & " 0 & 6

0 +$ 0" &+ 6

.90 + ' " # $) #

!# "& 4 ++74: & "&! " +& & +$ + 0 $ ) + )++ )

$+!)+# &

& + ) ++

$ + 0 )

<""++

$ I% "$ )0$ % & & "$ & 6

) ++ ) 3& -# $+ )>6

&+ 6 %& $&" 0 $& $ 0 $ 0 , 6

, & 0

) &$"

" # $$& ! * # 5$& & (", +" E"( ,& " & # (0 " &

47 : EB 7(0 .): C % $ " , , " & & + L+ 3$& & *+ ! .0") 6 # &+ L+ 3&! & *+ . &"M

)

(03&, " % & "

&# 0 +$ 0" & % + %& $& 0 " $$ $ $ 3& & " &

& ! .0") *+ & $" & + L+ 3$& &0(", %$& $ " " & <$ & +%

& ""

+$ 0 * +

$$ "

,+&) 0)"&+ " ("

# %3&& "&

% ,

F7C:NN.%#& $ &&%+&#0 6"0)&(0-#0

"+&,& & 6

3&+ L+ 3&!

&. &*+ 0

"+ ,$+ & "

,&* + L+ 3&3$& 6E &+"> ! .0") *+ 6 L+ 3$& $+0 + ," "

,+& $0 "&& 6

* +

$ "

,+&)% " 0 0 ) 0 +# E " & ) " <$ " ," , #+%$0$ " &,"

"0 $E , "&$

+ " +$ +

) $"

6 " + $ + + ) <$ #

$ %& $&& $&) # #

$ " " <+ &

" $" $ & , % # + 0 $&$<&& & %&, " "& &+$ + 6

"=)

!++"

<O5O"% & & ,) " ,& &+ "! D & 3&) &#""," $&

% & &"+%&+ )"" +0

&"7=+& ++

":P !&* # 5$& & (",+" & # -+ " & # .) " & EB 7

D: .C4K& "&& ""&+# ! 4 & 6 # 3& 5$& , (", .90 + 5 '" # ? E"

!E K " 5 2"# " & # .) " &!E K 3&& "&

% ,

$> F4 NNNNE $ & 0# & & " " +# ! 4 )&# ,)$&$$& , # & $&$ ,

L$ & +

$$+" & + & & "$ & "

" $ 0 " $ 0 6 " & ,"

" & & 6

! $ + $ &,& , " $ 0 " 0 0 0 )

"& &+&#0 "# " ,, , -" 3$& & # 0($ & $& $" ! $"

" %& & $6 " % ", 0) "

, , $ $0 " 0 + % & &$"

" %&& "" $ &,& , " 3& ", ) 0 0 & +$ $6 ", "

3&++ ++ $& , 0($ + $ $ $& !+&6 & $"

" & " 0 ", & " &,& , " E $0 "00 )0 + , # %&0($ # % !&+$$ 0< " $" 0 , +>," ", $+ $ $! $ " 0

& + ) $ %)

< & ,& 6

& ++ ++ 3& " 0 , ", &,& , $ $ & ,& 6

" & % "

% & & <$ # " $& $"

$ $

%& $& & 0 < % & & 0($ + , "$ & $& , ,$&

K !* # 5$& & B "&#3& .)"& CK7: B44& ""> FC3 "&$& " , &+

" , # 0 )< & & , +$ ,6

$ +&& 0# ) +$ + 6

& 0 6

)&+ )&$00 &+"> +% && ,&6

&& % # ""% 0)& L"

)& " ) ,&+$ + 6

+# + 6

"+0++ "+ &+0

$# $%& $& 6 & + $ + " E $ " &"

) 0 &

& , &"0+ & ,&6

") & & + $ %& $& &) 0) & ") ,

"0)+ 6

)

$" &+$ + 6

6 &#)+ &# , $& 6

0 $ "" , &+ "+ & $&&+ & #

0 "7 $: & L $ % ) , & & < 6

<"0)0$& , )%

&#+ ) +% " !

& 0 , "

$" & <+ ) &% +# "" & +$ + 6

) &

) & + $ + " & < & P $&# %% "0)%* # 5$&(", (0? # )"&#!&% "7 : EB " &# (0"& 7D: B ! M

5$& & (", +" *# .)"& K474: BD& ""> F E $

" &# %&0"

)&" 0&

&+"> "# " " ""+ 3& ++ 0 % " # ) & "

, & & + )> & " %0 "+$ 0&6

%& $& ) & $)

" & +$

" & + $ +# $-

) %& )& &+ ) % " %%&&+$

"$"

# $ + %& $& & $0 6 " 3& % "

%& "

,& ,& & ,&(0 & "0 # ) " 6 ) "$ $0 " "% & $& $

) & ,& "$ 6

)0"#, &+$

" +

%& $&&+ )> &+$ 0" %6

!" # $! $%&'% ()*%

) 0$ 5 *# ?"& 4C %& " < $& $ &&,# % & ,& ) "%$ 6

&%$ ", ? # ) )#-*-# "!E D & B"& + # &0$ ) &"0#"&&+$ $" $6

&$% "

)& # + $ ) %& & & 0 " ) $ "" 0) & + & I""3& $6

&#0 ""% 0) 0 "

, ) +# & & $$+ $ $+

$ &% & % " & & & 0 $ )

" " < $ "

& & &+$ 0"0 , &&<$6 # $& $

)& ,& & & % " 0 # & " "" ) %

0 $)&)+$ + ,

+ << << << 3 $$ " & % & 6 +" & "" &

#" & "&%&&6

++ 0)+$ )+$ 0"0)&+ )> $

"&$& +$ # & +$ 0" 6 # & ,& $" $ 6

& +"0)++

,++ &+P .90 + ! 3% " & # Q

# &

& ,& " & 7 K: 44 & " & +$ , & ,& 6

$ 0 $ "" # # ! D& $"

" % & & ,& 6

0 $& , & " $"

" % & 6

# ! D 3&& "&

% ,

$ F B

,&0#0)& -# $, , 53 6

+ * + 3 " &

&<$ &6

$0& "0 "

$ ) 0 ! & ,& 6

%& $& +$ 0" + $ $& $ 0 $ "" # # ! D&$"

"% && ,&6

0 $& , & " $"

" % & 6

# ! D P E# % &0#%

"&$& -# & " ) <$ & +% $ " " +# ! 4 & $& 0 , , # $0$&

,"<$+$$ # )& & 3&+$ , &6

6 " +

<+"$ "L$&<+&#

<"+ $

&$0"0($ ("

# % 3& %

" & +$ , +>," ! $ + $ $ ", , , $ $ 0 " 0

, 0 )%& $&)% $ &% ( "

$ & * " '

()*+(, - 8*- 9