High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25517/2012allowed

Ranjit Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2017-10-06Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi12 pages

!"!#$ % &

#'!

!#()* )&" !

!#&"

+&","

,#'

-* )&" ".#/# "

0$ 120

!"# $%% !"

& " '"( 3

& *"! "# "

" +" !" ,

, -./ , . - "

23"

2" "

01 2 " " ! !" %"# %" # (5 %555%"

&6'!

!#() #/ )&"6"

,#'

-01.2# !

' "(! "%" 2 755" 6(

"!" " & "#* "

!%"%7

!66 " 8&" !% '"( ) ! " ,#'

- (&! ,8 ,& 8 &6! 98 "":; ,8"45<&'"( 9 " - -- " &"5!"% -- !"

!# !

" 02"5!"% :

;

" 5 !3 02"5!"% :.

;

45" !3 02"5!"% :.

45" ! . #" (" %"! <"%

= ">"58&"""%5#"!" (5 "! !& &"5!"% ("

% !" (" 5"%

! "* !%"%7

!# % ! # "%#&"5!"% " '# "% %

! ( # #* " %# & ) ""%5 !" ( !

"%% (5

! "

!%8&" %5559",.& ;) # &#""%%# % " & !" "" & "

&"5!"% (" !&% 4, 5" ! %" !% ;" ?

6") &#! &"&"5!"% ( " '# " !&%4, 45" ! & &# "%%!+"%( !% "" &"5# - --) #"!

"%% ( & 2755# !

+%5 " #" ; -- "%"6"%"667

! " 8&" !% &! % ! ( "&%"!!"%"(% '@

. # - -- ; '"( % !0: "520/ 2 :%

# . &(

" '"( % !0: "52:% --4) & "%!"#*

!%8&"# %%# &"5!"% 02:

" 5 !3 02:

45" !3" 02:

?5" ! "

"!"(!

"%% &")3,= &3

#/ )&"+"

,#'

- #/ )&"77>

" &!5 #&!

" " !""

" &"5&"5!"%(

" " %%# &"5 !"%

!%"%8 %&7

!" !%"%7

! 02"5A": ?

&%""5 : ;

B"%&"5:

05!"%23 02: ?

&%""5:??

B"%&"5 : "

;5" !3 02: ?

&%""5: ?

B"%&"5 :.

. "

-5" !3" 0 2:.

&%""5:4?

B"%&"5 :;?

;5" ! ? &"5!"%#""&& (5 <

"#" ! "

! " &"5!"%#%( --?

" <

; "

#"(5 "!&""

"% 1" &"5

&"5!"% "

!&% ;,-, ;5" %" !+%5 "#" ? - # (5 &"5!"% & #" 1

--?"

!&% -5" %" !:

" "

!&% ; 5" .

--- &"5 !"%

: ;.

"#& "( %

%" !" "(5 $%% !" "&&" ( "% & ! " !""!!" '

&6'!

!#()1" "9",.& ;) " % "%%5 ( " & &"5!"%&! % ! --?) &"(""

!+! & 5"#"# %&"5 " ' #" %"!%"&&" ( "% &" " " !%8&"

'"(!& # "

"!"%

% !"% "= ="!

# ""&""!" "&""!

"! &6"%( " '"( !" ?, ;,-C C , ?4. " ? --; !%" "%% !%"% 8 %& 7

!, "

!"!! %5 #"%% !%"% 8 %&7

!," !" 6 ! " "!"%

& 6'!

!#() #/ )&"+&","

,#'

- #/ )&"9",.& ;"&&%!"(% "# &(!" ;,-, ;!

&"5!"%"( ""!!

% ,

, - /6, .?-"

" (5 <

(5 ' " 6 "% ( " &!"( ( "

"' (!" ;,-, ;" !

02 &"5!"% " ("&& (5 - 6 " " !% &"" " "%& !&" !"

+ "" !" "!" # !""

"(+&" "%%# &"5!"% (" ! !&%

;,-, ;5" !" (" 5#%(! !" %"#%"#(5

&6'!

!#()?" "

9",.& ;

+ "#"&

& 6'!

!#()1" "9",.& ;

#"# "&# '"( !%"% !!"( &"5!"%# !

"( " ' " "$ "(% & !D) #""# " (5 % "E

! " # $

" !

# !

? " !# " &"

' ( ) " * + :%"%5 & !"" - --#" "# !

"%%#"$(

&"5!"%!&%

45"" 45" !" !""5(

" !%"%8 %&7

! ""&&"!

(5#"5 % #& &")3

?" "0&"2 # !

"%% "&"5!"% " "( # !

#""&"# ( >"5 ! " + "%!#"

&"5 !"% 8 &!5 "

" # & " "

#" &" # !

" & "&"5 &"5!"%#" "" # ( >"5 ! <# &"5!"% ! ( % (% 1!"% !&% ;,-, ;5"#"""# !

#"%" "% !"" - --# !

"%%# "

&"5!"% "

!&% 4, ?5" %" ! 5!"%) &#"" ( %" %$ #"(

! "(5'

& 6'!

!#()1" "9",.& ;

! !&% 4, ?5" %" ! "

!"% "("

. "! &(% ! !&% ;,-, ?5" %" ! " "

!"% (5 %5 '

& 6'!

?" "

9",.& ;

; ""!"" ' # !

"%% "( """# "' !#""# "

&"56 !

!"&"

#/)& & /") #/ )&"6&","

&#!6 "

#/ )&"95>5; ,.&=,& ""5 4#"

%" %%# E ; "

# <

,)("% 8! E+"%&"5 +"%#*F!"(&"

"'"!*%

! &%"! 8! !&%( "' " " " %5&! "

E+"%&"5 +"% #*F""!!&" +"%5!%" !% ;" ? 6" %

"("!! E+"%&"5 +"%#*F!"( " !% ; :""(% !%" !" (" %% (%!" " 1# ('!

( "!

&(%

E=+"%&"5 +"%#*F" ""%% ( " !" ! " &"5 &"!* &! 5 ! !

!""% +"% !" " " !

! " % &"5!"%& "

!" !"%"" +"%&"5 +"%#* " &/!# &!8@(& # )!()&.

@ ',#!& A,8/B !- &-!

& &@-, ! )& &',"

-8 (&,#/" !# /!#( " ) "#!&" ## !#6C

4 D, 8!

@/ &!#!88,"

4A)#.

@!B

!#!"/# ,#/&6 8!/"

, &@&,8"EB , !6!#"

&, !#"4A)# .&"#"& &,!

/&=/!&# ",& " &(!6#.

@ .&

!#4 A)# .&= &= 8A& /& &

& #"&&= # )& /&!"(!6#.

@.&

!#4 A)# "#!&!""

../

! !# @- &4A)# /6 # !# &=# " & (!6# & B.&!# E.

""!#(

D,!&!#( )!()& D, 8!!

!#" & !# # !6 & ! !# @F &"= )6# , 8!

!"A)# ',#!& = @ - /& A!#( )!()& .

@ # )!" "#!&" A!

6!8

!#( )= #/

D, 8.

@&D, 8A&C) /!&# !

# )" (&,#/" A,8/ - - "/ # !# 88!(!-8 &!

A)! ) ) " &

!# 8#B," A!

) -'

",() - )!6//# )&&!#/

#@(/(&,#/ ","

!# )',/(=# " )!() ,& E&!-,# 89=.) "!"",..8!/;

?6/" %%6"G"%=1! "& H 6"I0 -442.- -44 0JG2?

.0 -442 ) - K"(5""!

* "'

$!"%' &" ( 0&

&"" 2,-."

." !# " /"."

" !#$ %"

" !#$ ."

# 1 "%" !

! 2

& " " %" $ !

! % $ " ! " *

." !# ' ) "/" !

" ."

"." !#! +

%! +# "$!"( "

&"5 ' "(%" &6 #/ &"6"++&

() #9555;5 %% % ""!" * ! +"%5*&"5&"5# 6#" % E!

$ " ."

." !# 1 $

%" !" 2 3 4 " %"

" $ # ." * $

! %"

) 5 6" $ $ !

+0& "&&%2

? 6"%"!" 8 A!

#"L

""# #"" ""' !#" "

&"5!"%" &

"&& &"5) 8 A!

30#( #/ )&"6"

,#'

- #/ )&"4 < 9>; 9!6!8;7<"

""%"# "% ' (5 & % "E)

$ %"

" " / %"

$" " $ %"

&" 2

7."

." !#8$ ."

9=.) "!"",..8!/;

$ " "

%"9

%" ! :

*" $ 7."

." !#8 " ';<= ) " ! '

2 "

" " $

" %" !

" !

" +

"5"5% " "'!" "

"%"5 "" &"!%"%5 # ' "&"%" ( 5" ! "!&" # "5("#!) + "&"5""%5""

!" "1&(5"# " 6"5 " "(!(5 =1! " && !"!

& %) 1!'!"%"" !

"# !

" # "7 !" & %"L" 1 &"5 !"%!!""%%1! % %" !"# " %" !1!&# !"( "(% " "5 %"

" "%"5 "" !"*# !

# %%5!"%

4 <# " "" #&!! " # "

( "' 1 " !"!%"&"5"('!

&"5!"% '"# "!! % % ! ( "%"5"'!"%&!%"#

& 6'!

!#()?" " 9",.& ;

# "8 A!

""%"5 + " " % " !"" - --# !

"%%# "

&"5!"%!&% 4, 45" %" ! 5!"% ""(% %" " " " !" ,

, - / , .?-"

# "( &! "

&"5!"%#%(" "%"(%!&% ;,-, ;

5" !"!

"&%"! "%"!*%"

" !/ "* '!"%&&5 (

%%# ""%"#!&" "8&"

- % "1

!" "

!"!# '

&6'!

!#()?" "9",.& ;"!+%5 &#&"%%# ""

"% # !+"%

" (5 " ) & " ! !"%!%" &"5" "%%#"! &"%" "# "& . " !&

-& %4 9 3

;

#> ? >@ ? >@