High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18161/2021dismissed

Makhan Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-03-19Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary4 pages

!"!#!

$!!! !#!

%&'

()*+,-.+/010,234 4

)56)270286 444+*0*0,2+9 :+91;1 7*)*+,-;2<)=)2. *6+91 >?+1@,2.+2*1 !AB C"DA E F!A!!

$ 9+1+2*

94G474H6)*0)IJ.K,/)*+-,9*6+@+*0*0,2+9

947L)@)276,9+MI(JGI;2<)=4

94:05)16)*9)*6IJ.K,/)*+-,99+1@,2.+2*1N,4O)2. !A!!

$P EQ !DR 4 S6+ @9+1+2* 0K0T 90* +*0*0,2 ;2.+9 J9*0/T+1 UV ,- *6+ ,21*0*;*0,2 ,- W2.0)I 01 -,9 X;)16028 *6+ 0Y@;82+. ,9.+91 .)*+. 4 O4

J22+Z;9+ .09+/*028 9+/,K+9M ,- +Z/+11 )Y,;2* ,- @+210,2 @)0.I L0*6 ) -;9*6+9 @9)M+9 1++5028 9+T+)1+ ,- -;TT @+210,2 )2. 9+-;2. ,- *6+ )Y,;2* L9,28TM .+.;/*+.1,-)94 4 [+)92+. /,;21+T /,2*+2.1 *6)* *6+ @+*0*0,2+9 L)1 9+8;T)9TM 9+/+0K028 @+210,2 *0TT *6+ 011;)2/+ ,- *6+ 0Y@;82+. ,9.+9I ,2 *6+ =)101 ,- L60/6 0* L)1 9+-0Z+. )2. 9+/,K+9M *, *6+ *;2+ ,- ?1 II VU L)1 020*0)*+.I /0*028 *6)* *6+9+ 6). =++2 )2 +99,9 L60T+ /,Y@;*028 601 @+210,24 J8890+K+. =M *6+ 1)Y+I 6+ 8,* ) T+8)T 2,*0/+ 1+9K+. ,2 44 I /T)0Y028 *6)* 102/+ *6+9+ L)1 2, -9);. ,9 Y019+@9+1+2*)*0,2,2601@)9*I*6+)/*0,2,-*6+9+1@,2.+2*101;2<;1*)2.)9=0*9)9M4 4 ,2*9)90TMI T+)92+.

/,;21+T )@@+)9028 ,2 =+6)T- ,- *6+ 9+1@,2.+2* N,4OH)25I L60T+ 9+-+99028 *, @)9) 2,4 ,- *6+ L90**+2 1*)*+Y+2* 1;=Y0*1 *6)* @+210,2 6). =++2 02).K+9*+2*TM Y01/)T/;T)*+. *, =+ ?14 OVUI 021*+). ,- *6+ /,99+/* )Y,;2* ,- ?

)M .;9028 )

#$ % & '

(

# ( '

# ) ( $ * ) +

( '## ' #'

, -# # '"

# -

$ ( #

$ ) )$ - /% 0 1+ (

-- ' -#$

")"

# '

' ,

3" - # 5 6789:;55 <:=>?55 @AB55 <C7CD55 EF55 G7;H7=755 7=I55 EC?D;AJ5 K&L - + ' % M% + ( '

( -))( 5 <N;:=ID;O:C55 <:=>?55 @AB55 <C7CD55 EF5 PN=O7955 7=I55 EC?D;AJ5 0 ' % M% 5 P7;Q7A?55 <:=>?5 @AB5<C7CD567=Q5EF5R=I:75 + M M ' M% % % %

* (

# # " - ') #')

### -., - * # '"

# -

$ '## '

- )( ( ' ( #

--#$"

5 6789:;55 <:=>?5

#+ # ) " #

# -# S2

)) )) ,,

-. -

% ) - # # -. -

# + ) ( $ + "

# ') #')

###

# -

T # +

$ ( '#

''+ ( '

(

) % U

'#'$'

+ '

(

)) # -

# "

$% U # +

+ ( '

( $

)) ') #')

###

# -

T+ ) # '"

#) %

-# ,$ + # ) ) # ' ) -#

))+ # )')

(T -

T '

#') ) (

,$ (

#$ '') $T

' #, ( ")) , ,"

$+ ) # - '

( '))

) # "

$+ + -

( $ # - ' -

V + ( $# # # -#

+ # '"

# - '

-- ' -#$

- #

# # % #')

-# ,$ )

-' -

# ' % # + ') #')

###

# -

T+

$ ( '#

'' -

))+ -# ( '

(

)

# $ # * ) %

# -# + '

# -

))

# + ( '

# "

!"!# $# %

'& #

# ' '( % #

') # !

# !( * # # ##!# +(', '# & ) '#( ' -!#'& & #, &.

.) !

# '( "!()$# '

'(. & ) '#( # #

'# &. #

( /) 0!(), % !

#' #

, % ( 1 ( # ( '.

#.# ( '(&.# '

(/) 0!() 2$ #3$(4 5 6 1'#

' 7 89:;9<=77 >?@A=7

', ' $ ' %

# '# % ) . (

1 .

# #%'!

(, '(#! B

( !

) &'

(#C'D #( #'# #

# % #

'& # & ($( ' '$!# '( &

'( '1!

## '# )

, 1 #!) # '$ %' # '($&

'.'& # $ * '(1 ##

' '$!# %!

( # '. ## #

## #

#' # '( $.

1 .

%' #( &. %'. $# . #'

$# $$)

#& %'

( +# !

# #(( #'# #

'# $

. '( $

. &#% #

## '( #

(#C'D '( #'# #

(#C'D '#) . ' '

(&!

) ').

'( &'

# /'#) *!# #. * $

(#)

'# #! '#

'& #. #

(#C'D '( '

# ' !(! & # %!

( &

'& #

!( # & #

1( &. $ !

# #( #'# # ! -!# '

'(. & ((( &. # !

# 2 5 ## ( ' E'$' F'

G /#'# !"'&

# H ((( I ' %

' 5 ## ( ' E/!

( "# /) G /#'# !"'&

# H ((( J K LK C# # '

#' # # % )

) #

&. # C'D '( #

1 . # '# # &'D #) #

1 . ' & !

( &. # !

# &.

) # # "!()$# # $'## /#'# !"'& '( # G 6' -

# ' #

#( ' 5 / '( () #'# # '( "!()$# #

'& # # '# # (' 6 ' %'

'( ' 31 C 0!()$# # !

# F* 2I ## ( ' EC'

& /) G ! /#'# '

.'' '( # H ((( J # #( #'# '

$#'D

'# #

' &

# ('(#'$!# '('&(!

. 1 ( '&1'(

(

'( &. # !

# #

!#(

(( &. # !

## !

!" # " " !

!" $#

$" % &'( ) "*

$"+ )

# ' +

' " $ '

& % &'

$# , -./0/1,2/3,/14,56781497:8;,581<.,=>6?7/@, ( A !!& # '

(B ( C ! *

!" !

# !"

' % &' ! #! #

*( D( )

% &' +

'+ $# '

( , =,EFEG,-HEIJHEKL,@, , MIJNO, , PQRSTRUSUV, , 4819>., W&X

Y XZ Y XZ