High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18227/2016dismissed

The Managing Committee Dav Senior Secondary School Shahbad Markanda Th Satpal Batra v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-11-22Mr. Justice Darshan Singh11 pages

!"#"$%

&%'(&)*

!"# $ # $

*+ %

& '()'%*& +

&, , -!. "

/ 0

1 &

& "

*'2&." 3 &

& / 0

1

&

$ $

"

&

& . !.

, ,

5 )

$

65 7" & , 5 $

8/ %9'%:

%::1

"

"

';)'':& -"

" " "

. & 5 "

" $

"

. 4 $

" 5 &"

'; )'': "

&

6 $ 7& .

8/ %(9%)

%::0 &'%%::*

"

+

"

& .

.

#

"$ $

$ " "

%')'':

"

&

+

<

!. " $ =&%*)'%'

. $ &.

$

-';)'%'

67 0 $ &

4 $

,

& .

$ " &

& 5 "$ , , "

4 $

,

> ""

$ "

"

&

& 8/ %0;%:

)'%'

3

-';)'%'& +

&

$ "

3 &

0%)'%*&

$

$ " "

" &

+

&" #

&"

"

/

$ 4 $ 4?

@+5 A

+

'; )'%0 &

&& &

&

=

$

! .@)'')A1

(1%

5

"

B

C -!. & " -, ,+

& !. " ?

-

(

/ 0

1"

,

-%;%::(<

&'%%::; '% %::9<

&'%%::;<

&':%::* &'9%::0 $

"

.

$ $

%')'': 0

9/ ;1 $ =&)'%:::D

&

, ,

%'

" &

+

%'E% %'E)$

-)'%::'&#

" "

, ,

4 $ B

" $ 3

"

5 , ,

" & 4 $

* &

" $ / $ &%9)'%* ,

! "

# $" % "

" &

& '

()*+ ,

- . "

# /" %

"

"

" &

& '

()*+ 0

12,113 ! 4 #

)*+

. !

,1, 333 - . 4 # #

) *+ -

.

' #"(' "

& #)*+ .

# ) *+ 5 6 9 D / %C) & "

$ #

-)'''@%A %*: 8/ 0919

)'''

! $

'%)'%%&

$ "

&

F3

3"

.F &

& $

$

, ; D/ 0

9" .

D

/ 0

9 && "

$

$ $

/ *C9 $ $

$ &

/ %

(

%')'':

$ &

""

.

&$

"

" &

&

$ &

& "

$ $

&

"

$ &

&

"

&

.

/ %

(

"

/ *C9" $ "

& " 4"$! - .$ @+A

@)'%0A%'

0)(

&$

"

$ "

&.

" / 0

9"

$

1 $

.

@ / 0

1 A" " "

" & & . $

! . $ G $ @)''9A (

% > & "

$

"

& "$ &

$

$ &

&

$& "

"

&

8" &

.

"

5 " 5 &

$

&

" " & $ & "

3

"

" " ,

" "

"

&

)@A

@

$ A %:;%@H%:;% IA "

& " ,

& "5 &

/ $

%:1*@)AJ %''D " %:;%

" ,

$

" " "

. $

&

D $ $& & & 3

"

"

H I

$

&

$

%:;% D "

"

3 "

& )0

)1

@

$ A %:;( :

!"#

& $

&

&

&& "

$ "&

&&

. " & & & D

&

#

"

$ $ "&

F3

3"

.F $

%' !"# &

&&

4

& $&

"

$

" &

$&# &

&

$

%::0

%::; 5 %%

"$

&" " " #

" #

" $ " "

.

& $ "5 &

K.

& $ ! . L D %:9( (;; "

&

#

$ & ))9

&5

" "

,

5$& # "

'

"

",,.

/ # & "

#

#

#'

"

" #

"

"

" "

#

"

# 9 "'

#

"

# ' " 4

:" 4

: " " '

" # ' : " "

4

$ # "

4

"4 " & '

#

" #

4

'

"

'

" " $ 4 ' 4

# " '

"

"

: " "

$ " " " #

$ # " " " #

& '

"

''" " "

"#"

" # '

4#

"4 '

# ;

" "

# $ # 4'

"

"# ' "

4 $ #

# "4

# " '" " 4 "# "4 '

#

' '" " #

" # '

"

; ' "

"4 ' 4' '#

" "

#$ # " # "

"

'

"

"

"

#

$ # ' "

& $ & "

""

" " " #

'

' :"

" $ # 4 " # #

'

;' " "

" ,,. '

"

" # : " <

9 !

!"## $! % &

#' $ ()

* + !

*% 2;4 "

4

& "

# '

' " "

"#"

" #'

#

'=# # "

'"#

'" "

"

" "

" ' "

#

$ # # # >

4

" 4

#4

4

:

'" '

'4 "

" "#"

" # '

"

; "4

" # "

'

" : " #

' " "

; # "4

' # #

" "

"

"

= # " #

# ' " #

" #'

"

'

4 ' 4# "" " '

' " "

;

# "# '

"

" " #

#

$ # 4"

" "

'#

"

" #'

"

;

4 #

#

"

# & "

'""#

"

#

'

" "

'

''" " "

4 ' "

" " " "

"

'" #

"

"

%)

& +

& " "

#

5

&

"

&

# & #

&

# " $

" &

& "

& 3 "

%0

3

"

0*1

#

(?

@

#