Madhu Grover v. Indian Oil Corporation And ORS
!"#"
$% & &
'% () '& * * *
!
"
!
"
#### * *
+ & ,- ./
" ! %%&'%%( "
"
)*+ "" ,*
-.
./ %.-& 1-2 3 4 % +! ! " " "5 ! 6 7 8!6 7
!!
+" 3 " !
" + "
!* 6 7 +" +
" * " 9 * * 5 "6 7 3 3 !3 " ""! "+! +
" 1
*+ "5 "
+ 1 1- %& -.
%.-:
" *! " -2/5 ""
!
"
! 1-
! +6 7 " " ++ "
" +! ! +!!
" + " 9 " 9 1 " " !
* 9
! "
" + !!
" + "
1 ! ! 3!
"! "
+ " " ! "
& +
3+ ! + "
9 "! !"
! * 9"
3 " " 999 "%;90:.9+-;)9" 9 9!' +'
* 9 " ! ""
< " ! ! "5 * +" * "/...)* "5 !3
"" ! ! "* + 9
* 9999 "%;90:.9+
! ! 3
!
1 3" 3
& " ! +
+"! "'* + ""
! "'* + ""
9 "
6 "! 6 "
" *5 +"! <93 ! +
< + 9"! "' ""
! "' ""
9
"6 "! 6
"
" *5 < + 9"! ! ! " * * +5 + 9 ! 9 "6 9 "5 9 !+!!
9* -.
./ %.-& ! " *
!!
9* 1-2
"
)*,* "
*
" " ! 39 !!
* *
+! ) + 9
* ! "%;90:.9
9 "3 +"!3! ! $ *9 1--+! ! ++
9
+! ) + *9 +! + + 9 "%;90:.9 "9 9 +! " +1 =89 "5 5 3>-.." :.
?/9 @ -.." :.
?/9 4 2%" %/ .&9 < 2." %( ?;
9 /?;
/;, 9 $! %(A1/B/ :/9
+ *
9 *
B " 1-%+!!
"!
>*
+
! ! "* +9 *%;90:.9
C "
"+
3! ! + 9 1?+! 9
+!"+ ! " 1
" 1 =D3 > < " + 9 -.. " D3 @ < "
+ 9 -.." D34 9 2."
3< < " + 9 2." B " "
+!+ " 9 *! * +
9 "
" 9 !9 !
"
! 1-:
C + "
! " 1 + 3 9* 1-2
, !
"
7 *
" " 1
3 3 "
+!!*
9* -2 C "!
*9
*3 " *
! + 3 ""
" 9 1 " ! *9"
0 3 "+ " "
!
+ * !9 4 3!
"! !
+! + "
*
C + ! + +3! ! ! !
+
+ 3 1
* !< ! E )*+ +*
!
*
9 C " " "! ! !
"!" + " + 3!3 3 9 " + +"
! "9 "%;90:.9+ 9 +!+ ""
$ *9 "
1-'-+! 9 !
" ++ "
*
9 ! * " +!+
:.9 " 9 ::
;:9+! * 9 :.9 +%( ?:9 +!+
+:.9 + ++9 %;9 +3 " * 9
! !
+ !
" +!+ 9 " !* ,
*""
+ ! C 9 3! " 9 "5 "+ "3!
"! ! ! ! 93 ""! * 9 " 9 ++ 9
1-'-+! " +!+
3 * C "
!
* 9 +!
!
!
" !
+ 9 9 !* 8 9 ">0
!
3 4 ! +
! 9
" 1 + 9*3 ! +!+9 1-2 * " + +" 3 %.-& 9 * !3 " "! 3
9 9 3 * 3 %.%.
5 + ! 3 "
+ + + 3 3* 3 +
!
* " 3
! ! ! , !
"
* " 3 ! !
C 3 + 9 +
* 9 3 ! * + 3 %.%.+! 9
3 * "
3 " 9 "
"
+
"
)*,* " +!
1 3 %.-&
1-2 1
1 "+! !
+ " + +!
+ !
!!
" " + 5 "
" 9 +
! 9 " + " !* 3!
"! " !
+
9
*9 "%;90:.9 * 3!
"! 9 + "
"
** ! "
" + !
" *! * " " *! " + + + * 3 1 !9 !
"
9 "
+ +
*"! !
< " 9 +!
! !
*
+! !
" + + 9
9
9 %;9 0 :.9
C +
" +!
+ 3 1-'-!
"
C, + + + " 9 :.9 " ' * :.
$ +!
) 3 ! "
" !) + 9
*
! ":.9 " " 9 * 4 !
+ !3" 9 >0
8 9 + !3+ *
* +! + ! +* +
+ ! ! ! !
+
+ 3! " ""
*
1 +3
! ""9 "
" 9 !
!*3!
"!
" 1
! ! 3 ! , ""!+! !
* 3 ! " + ! %%& "
" 9
*
!3 " 3 3 + 9 3 " ! 3 !
3 + !
3""
! * " 3! ! , !
+ " 3 ""!!!9!
"39
9
C +
!
,* * / $2 -3 + @ )* '4 @
'4