Gurinder Pal Singh v. Surjit Singh And Others
"
! "#$ %$&'(')
2 3!!
*$+(,(
!
-./ /
$"%!
& '
"
$"( & '
!
)"* + +!
,,,,,
0" 1
!!
-
!
" " .
'
!!
2
!
!
!! # #
#
! " " 4
/
!! !& '
! !! ":
! +3 & "+ !! + #
!
1"- # '
!! "4
& !! / !
!
!
# " $ '
& ! ! #
/ 5!
" * &
6 7/ ! + '7'> ??$">
/4'7"88" $"%!9:.
(* (;"+)"#"<",(')="+% ")%#4$+(0
/ %$&'%$%)
0."5 ')%$+&% 6
2220# #
9
/ 5!
# /
!! " )
! / 5!
!!
5!
!
" $ '
&
#
# / 8
&#
" -" &
" !!
%'(8'(($%"
! 4 !
2
!
1 "- #
$
+ 4/ &(2
A
;
4/ <= '
#
"
" @ !
$+ + )"
>" >" D
&
$?
&A
; <=" " %
4/ !
!! !
&
'
/ !
&
!
'
!
! " " D
' 42 /
)"61D: -@ @ A
;
'
<= = / '
!
)"
B #
!
)"B
!
)"" 4
/'
!
1"- /
#
# C D"-E !
" !
# #
!
!
" "
2 !
/
!
D" " D " " D"
!
@
"*
" " D&
E!
/
& # #2 #
/ & ! ' #2"* /
'
# /
/
" &
#
#
5!
" * /
'
!
!
/
#
"
!
1"
&
!
"B 1"- & 8 !
!
"*
1"
!
!
&
" -"
/ #
!
&
4/
!!
! G
# #!
#
' "6# & /
#
4/ #
+ " " * /
&
#
#
# 2
1"-& 8!
"F &
4/
/ 1"@@ 8!
#
'
/
"H'
#
"* !
!
/ #
!
/
D" #
!
)"* +!
'
!! /
/
/ '
/
!'
' ":
5!
1"
!
/
/1"& & 8 # /
/
" @" * /
E!
/
3 "* !
/ # 3 !
/B
/ 3 # /
/ DE
!!5 " * /
6 + ( )!
* +!
!
, $ - #! * . "/0
!
"#$ %
&'&&& /
/
/
!
"*
!
!'
"+ 3
&
" F &
4/ #
1"&D &-8 #
!
" & !
!
/
"
>" )
!
"* *
"
!
"*
/
"
'
/'
&# !
/
4/ / !
& # #2
2
1" -& 8 !
" 6# # & '
#
!
!'
" & /
'
4/
1"@@ 8!
$ I
!! 6
D"*
J
/
# &
!
! & & / &
&
! H5/ > #
&
4/
"&
4/
!!
! "
" /
& I-:" !$
!
E / 8/ 4
# !'
/ H5 5/ "6# & & I-:" ! $
/ E # 3 !
/
3 # /
B
/
3
# /
#
E" & 4/
/
3 # /
DE !! 5 " * # " 4&
#
/
4/ 1"
&@> 8" $ '
&
# # / !
#2 "
" J
!
1"
# &
" )
'
/ " 4
4/
/
H5/ > !
"!
#& !
1"& &->8
B # #
1"& & 8 / 4/ " J
4/ #
!
1" &>>&-8A
1"- = # $%
&
' (
( (
*
+, +'
!!!)-
+ !
!!!)- +.
!!!)-
) +'
/!
'.0)- + '.0)- * , + .
*
' #
/'
&
!
#
") /+ !
&
6 7/ ! +& / #
/
#
! "6 7/ ! + ;/#"#$ "+:")"*("
"(9'+;",+A."5 ')%$+& 6 2 @ @
B'7'(')"> )#+>>$+ ;/ *( "4"%$7"
& /4$##: ")% ")#4$+A @! / !
& / /
! " * B$ $)$+"> ")"=$+0;/ *( /,("88" 48"( #4$+(A *>, ,8$1 / 20 6 7/ ! + !
!
&
/
' /
!
-" *
/ !
/ /
4/ &
I
!
3 !
'
'
!
)"
".
&
)"
#
' 8
#
4/
" " D
'
'
/ !
)"
B
3 & #
!
"
" *
&# &/ !
!
" " D& J*1/
)">
@" " D
& D>&D& @* +
* / !
)"
/ 8! " *
J*1)">
@"
" " D& !
)"
$ + & $*+
3
K
# A
;
K$*+<='
-" -" >
#
/
+
I
"1
K$*+ !
>
-" -" >
# ;1 & &
.
2
#
3 4 5 $
!
2
# &
#6
7
&
8##
9 9 )8
9&  )8
5
"
D" /
/'
#
! '
K$*+")
/&!
/
! !
!/ / "6# &+
2
2 !!
"+
&
/
/
4/ "6 # & /'
& #
!
4/ # ' # !
!
"* ' #
!
!
@" 4 + B6 71 + +!
!
, $ - #! 31/ 1*!
2 8!!*"!. *!
5
!# !
0 *0,
3
:
*!
$
$ $ - #! 31/ 1*!
.!
- 41, "!.
*!
737 3. , '
9
3 ;
$
<
3"
>" 4+ /'
B:
*!
$
$ - #! 31/ 1*!
241,"!.*!
!
5;<=
!
"# $ %
:.
.;
5
3
= -
(;+ =
6
5
; $ 4
5
&
&
5
> ;
;
&
& ;
;
3 ;
3 3 ;
5
&
>
3
3 " "
! '
"4 4&
!
" * ' # /'
& !
#
" "
!! &
&
!
! 6 5
)
6 + ? ?@ )% @ )%