High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14680/2017dismissed

Gulab Singh And ORS. v. Board Of Governors, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar National Institute Of Technology And ANR.

2017-07-26Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan8 pages

!"#$ %&'(#&)*+(,-.

,+%+%*&,-.

,-.!.

*#-)*/*0,-&*-.#&)#&*+(,-

,.1*&),&+.

4 2

-,.,&+ -,.,&+ -,.,&+ -,.,&+ 2- 52#"%6 ,&%*-)0*7#+,8%+( 25!"),,1 (,*-#& )0*7#+,/*-+(,1,+%+%*&,-.

2- (,+#&2%++#" ,&%*-)0*7#+,8%+( 2- )%+#-'#&)2- %0,6 %&'"# )0*7#+,.

/*-+(,-,.1*&),&+3&.+%+!+, 9:9:9:

9:9:9:

(%.*-),-.(#"")%.1*.,*/%0%"-%+ ,+%+%*& */ ;!"#$ %&'( < *+(,-. 0 *#-) */ *0,-&*-. #&) ;!"#$ %&'( < *+(,-. 0 *#-) */ *0,-&*-. #&) ;!"#$ %&'( < *+(,-. 0 *#-) */ *0,-&*-. #&) ;!"#$ %&'( < *+(,-. 0 *#-) */ *0,-&*-. #&) #&*+(,-= #&*+(,-= #&*+(,-= #&*+(,-= %0%"-%+ ,+%+%*& >*/ ;#(!"5#1**-< ;#(!"5#1**-< ;#(!"5#1**-< ;#(!"5#1**-< #&*+(,- 0 *#-)*/*0,-&*-.#&)#&*+(,-= #&*+(,- 0 *#-)*/*0,-&*-.#&)#&*+(,-= #&*+(,- 0 *#-)*/*0,-&*-.#&)#&*+(,-= #&*+(,- 0 *#-)*/*0,-&*-.#&)#&*+(,-= #&) %0%"-%+ ,+%+%*& */ ; -%?#&6# < *+(,-. 0 *#-) */ ; -%?#&6# < *+(,-. 0 *#-) */ ; -%?#&6# < *+(,-. 0 *#-) */ ; -%?#&6# < *+(,-. 0 *#-) */ *0,-&*-. #&) #&*+(,-= *0,-&*-. #&) #&*+(,-= *0,-&*-. #&) #&*+(,-= *0,-&*-. #&) #&*+(,-= #. +(, %..!, %&0*"0,) %& +(,., +(-,, 1,+%+%*&.%.%),&+%7#"

,+%+%*&,-. %& +(%. $!&7( */ 1,+%+%*&. 1*..,.. +(, @!#"%/%7#+%*&*/2 %&+(,%--,.1,7+%0,)%.7%1"%&,.#&)(#0, 8*-6,) #. ..%.+#&+ -*/,..*-. *& 7*&+-#7+!#" $#.%. 8%+( +(,

- A$,)6#- #+%*&#" &.+%+!+, */ ,7(&*"*'? #"#&)(#-

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

0,(,A,&+"?#-'!,)+(#+$?0%-+!,*/#)0,-+%.,A,&+ )#+,) +(,-,.1*&),&+%.#)*1+%&'+(,A,+(*)*"*'?8(,-,$? *&,.,+*/7*&+-#7+!#",A1"*?,,.%..*!'(++*$,-,1"#7,)$?# .%A%"#-#--#&',A,&+#&).!7(1-*1*.,)#7+%*&%.%"",'#" !&F!.+ !&/#%-#.#".*!&7*&.+%+!+%*&#"

+%.#-'!,)+(#+.%&7,1,+%+%*&,-.

(#0,$,,&,&'#',)#/+,-)!,#)0,-+%.,A,&+#&)$?/*""*8%&'# 1-*7,..*/.,",7+%*& $,%+*&7*&+-#7+!#"$#.%. +(,?#-,0,.+,) 8%+(#-%'(++*7*&+%&!,+%"".!7(+%A,+(,-,'!"#-#11*%&+A,&+. #-,A#), &.!11*-+*/.!7(7*&+,&+%*& -,"%#&7,%.1"#7,)!1*& +(,F!)'A,&+*/+(,1,G*!-+%&#-'!-1#-+#1 %&'(0 +#+, #-'!-1#-+#1 %&'(0 +#+, #-'!-1#-+#1 %&'(0 +#+, #-'!-1#-+#1 %&'(0 +#+, */ */ */ */ !&F#$ ;=B !1-,A,*!-+#.,.> !&F#$ ;=B !1-,A,*!-+#.,.> !&F#$ ;=B !1-,A,*!-+#.,.> !&F#$ ;=B !1-,A,*!-+#.,.>

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

,7-!%+A,&+!",. +(,1,+%+%*&,-.#-,,"%'%$",+*(*")+(, 1*.+*/..%.+#&+ -*/,..*-;*&7*&+-#7+$#.%.=,0,&#.*/)#+,#&) #'#%&.++(,$#76)-*1*/+(,%-8*-6#&)7*&)!7+$,%&',G,A1"#-? +(,? 7#&&*+ $, -,1"#7,) $? #&*+(,- .%A%"#- 7*&+-#7+!#" #--#&',A,&+

1*&&*+%7,*/A*+%*&(#0%&'$,,&%..!,) #8-%++,& .+#+,A,&+(#.$,,&/%",)#&)1"#7,)*&-,7*-)*&$,(#"/*/+(, -,.1*&),&+ .+#&)(#.$,,&+#6,&+(#+&,8,7-!%+A,&+!",. /*- #7!"+? %& #+%*&#" &.+%+!+,. */ ,7(&*"*'? #"" *0,- +(, 7*!&+-? %& &'%&,,-%&' 7%,&7,. !A#&%+%,. #&) -7(%+,7+!-, (#0,$,,&,&/*-7,) +(,.#A,(#0%&'$,,&#)*1+,)$?+(,*#-) */ *0,-&*-. ;+(, *0,-&%&' *)?= */ +(, -,.1*&),&+ *& +%..!$A%++,)+(#++(,&,8!",.8,-,7%-7!"#+,)$? +(,2%&%.+-?*/ ,8 ,"(%*&> #&)+(,#11-*0#"$?

+(,*#-)*/*0,-&*-.%.)#+,) &.!11*-+*/.!7( .+#&) )*7!A,&+. #+ &&,G!-,. #&) -,.1,7+%0,"? #-, #11,&),)#"*&'8%+(+(,8-%++,&.+#+,A,&+ ,#-&,) ,&%*-*!&.,"-,1-,.,&+%&'+(,-,.1*&),&+ 8*!") 7*&+,&) +(#+ #. 1,- .!7( !",. (

%. +(, A%&%A!A @!#"%/%7#+%*& /*- $,%&' ,"%'%$", /*- +(, -,7-!%+A,&+ */ ..%.+#&+ -*/,..*-.;7*&+-#7+$#.%.= 8(,-,#.+(,1,+%+%*&,-.1*..,..+(, @!#"%/%7#+%*&*/2 +%..!$A%++,)+(#++(,#)0,-+%.,A,&+ $,#-%&' )#+,) %.%&+,-A.*/+(,&,8,7-!%+A,&+ !",.#&)+(,/#7!"+?8*!")$,-,7-!%+,)*&7*&+-#7+!#"$#.%.%& +(,"%'(+*/+(,@!#"%/%7#+%*&.,&!A,-#+,)+(,-,%& > ,#-&,)7*!&.,"/*-+(,1#-+%,.(#0,$,,&(,#-)#+ ",&'+( +%.$?&*88,"".,++",)+(#+*&,7*&+-#7+!#"E#)(*7 ,A1"*?,, 7#&&*+ $, -,1"#7,) $? #&*+(,- 7*&+-#7+!#"E#)(*7 ,A1"*?,, *8,0,- #7*&+-#7+!#",&'#',A,&+%&/#0*!-*/#& ,A1"*?,,8*!")#"8#?.$,.!$F,7++*-%'(+*/+(,,A1"*?,-+* -,.*-++*#A,+(*)*/-,'!"#-#11*%&+A,&+ +8*!")#".*$,*1,&

/*-+(,,A1"*?,-+*)%.1,&.,8%+(+(,.,-0%7,*/#7*&+-#7+!#" ,A1"*?,,%/+(,8*-6#&)7*&)!7+%./*!&)8#&+%&' /+(,-,$,&* -,@!%-,A,&+*/8*-6 %+8*!")#'#%&$,*1,&/*-+(,,A1"*?,-+* )%.3,&'#',+(,7*&+-#7+!#"#11*%&+A,&+ 0,&/*-,&'#'%&'#& ,A1"*?,, *& 7*&+-#7+!#" $#.%. *- +(,-,#/+,- #+ +(, .+#', */ 7*&.%),-%&' .!7( ,A1"*?,, /*- ,G+,&.%*& */ +(, 7*&+-#7+!#" #..%'&A,&+ +(, ,A1"*?,- (#. # -%'(+ +* 1-,.7-%$, ,..,&+%#" @!#"%/%7#+%*&.

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

*/ &+(,#$.,&7,*/#.1,7%/%77(#"",&',#&) 1-#?,- +(%.*!-+8*!")-,/-#%&/-*A,A$#-6%&'!1*&#&,G,-7%.,

+*,G#A%&,+(,0#"%)%+?*/+(,&,8,7-!%+A,&+!",. B *7*!&+,-.!7(.%+!#+%*& ",#-&,).,&%*-7*!&.,"8*!") .!$A%++(#++(,0#"%)%+?*/+(,!",.&,,)&*+$,'*&,%&+*#.%+%. +(,1",#),)7#.,*/+(,-,.1*&),&++(#++(,&,8,7-!%+A,&+ !",. #/+,- 7%-7!"#+%*& $? +(, 2%&%.+-? */ !A#& ,.*!-7,

,0,"*1A,&+ 8,-, #11-*0,) $? +(, *#-) */ *0,-&*-. *& ,#-&,)7*!&.,"#-'!,.+(#++(,@!,.+%*&8*!")$, #. -,'#-). #11"%7#$%"%+? */ +(, &,8 ,7-!%+A,&+ !",. %& # .%+!#+%*&8(,-,+(,-,7-!%+A,&+1-*7,..(#.$,,&%&%+%#+,)%&+(, "%'(+*/#)0,-+%.,A,&+ )#+,) 8(,-,#.+(,#11-*0#"

$?+(,*#-)*/*0,-&*-.(#.$,,&#77*-),).!$.,@!,&+"?%& 1*%&+*/+%A, '#%&.+ +(, $#76)-*1 */ .!7( .!$A%..%*& +(, 1,+%+%*&,-.7#& #+$,.+ 1",#)+(#+ %+%.+(,2*),",7-!%+A,&+ !",. ;&&,G!-, = #"*&' 8%+( +(, %0%" -%+ ,+%+%*&

*/+(#+.+%""(*")+(,/%,") 0,&%/%+.*#..!A,) #7+%*& */ +(, -,.1*&),&+ %& 1-,.7-%$%&' (

#. +(, ,..,&+%#"

@!#"%/%7#+%*&/*-+(,1*.+*/..%.+#&+ -*/,..*-;7*&+-#7+$#.%.= 8*!")&*+7#""/*-#&?%&+,-/,-,&7, C ,+%+%*&,-..,,6+*-,"?!1*&!",*/.!7(!",.#&) 8(%7(-,#).#./*""*8.

H ,1!+#+%*&E*&+-#7+!#"11*%&+A,&+.

,1!+#+%*&E*&+-#7+!#"11*%&+A,&+.

,1!+#+%*&E*&+-#7+!#"11*%&+A,&+. #7!"+? 8(*#-,#11*%&+,)*&7*&+-#7+!#"$#.%. .(#""$,/*-#/%G,)1,-%*)&*+,G7,,)%&'/%0,?,#-. #7!"+? 8%+(*!+ (

),'-,, .(#"" $, -,7-!%+,) *& 7*&+-#7+$#.%.*&"?

&+(,.+-,&'+(*/!",-,31-*)!7,)(,-,%&#$*0, %+ %. 7*&+,&),) +(#+ +(, 1,+%+%*&,-. 1*..,..%&' +(, 2

@!#"%/%7#+%*&#-,,"%'%$",+*$,7*&.%),-,)/*-+(,1*.+*/..%.+#&+ -*/,..*-;7*&+-#7+!#"$#.%.=#&)+(,-,.1*&),&+7#&&*+1-,.7-%$, (

),'-,,#.#&,..,&+%#"1-,3-,@!%.%+, &+(,7*&.%),-,)0%,8*/+(,*!-+ +(,1,+%+%*&,-.#-, A%.3-,#)%&'!",*/+(,2*),",7-!%+A,&+!",. !", ;)=),/%&,.4/#7!"+?4#&)A,#&. -*/,..*-. ..*7%#+, -*/,..*-. #&)..%.+#&+ -*/,..*-.*/+(, 4.

1"#%&-,#)%&'*/!", $-%&'. /*-+( %+. %A1*-+ % , -,'!"#- -,7-!%+A,&+ +* +(, /#7!"+?

%&7"!)%&'+(,1*.+*/..%.+#&+ -*/,..*-%.&*++*$,A#),/-*A &*&3 (

),'-,,(*"),-.

!", )*,. 1,-A%+#/#7!"+?A,A$,- +*$,-,7-!%+,) *&7*&+-#7+$#.%.,0,&8%+(*!+ (

),'-,, *8,0,- !",7#&&*+$,-,#)%&#A#&&,-+*1"#7,#&,A$#-'* !1*&+(,-,.1*&),&+&*++*%&.%.+!1*&# (

),'-,,,0,&/*- #11*%&+%&' # /#7!"+? A,A$,- *& 7*&+-#7+!#" $#.%. + 8*!") #"8#?.$,*1,&/*-+(,,A1"*?,-+*-#%.,+(,$#-#&)+*%&.%.+ !1*&#1#-+%7!"#-@!#"%/%7#+%*&% , (

),'-,,,0,&/*-,&'#'%&'

/#7!"+?A,A$,-.*&7*&+-#7+!#"$#.%.#&)#+1#-8%+(+(,-,'!"#- #11*%&+,,.

!7(7*!-.,*/#7+%*& %/#)*1+,) 8*")&*+*//,&) !",*/+(, #7!"+?!",. #..!A%&'+(#+%+%..!7( !",.8(%7((*")+(,/%,")#.(#.$,,&7#&0#..,)*&$,(#"/*/+(, 1,+%+%*&,-.

*,G7,1+%*& #..!7( 7#&$,+#6,&+*+(,#7+%*&*/ +(, -,.1*&),&+ %& 1-,.7-%$%&' (

),'-,, #. +(, ,..,&+%#"

@!#"%/%7#+%*&/*--,7-!%+A,&+*/..%.+#&+ -*/,..*-.;7*&+-#7+!#" $#.%.=#.1,-#)0,-+%.,A,&+ */ (,-,%. (*8,0,- *&,#.1,7+*/+(,A#++,-#&)!&),- 8(%7( "%A%+,)1-*+,7+%*&8*!")$,#0#%"#$",+*+(,1,+%+%*&,-. "#!.,*/+(,,&,-#"&.+-!7+%*&.#&)&/*-A#+%*& 7*&+#%&,)

%&+(,#)0,-+%.,A,&+$,#-%&' E-,#).#./*""*8.

H & 7#., */ &*&3#0#%"#$%"%+? */ 7#&)%)#+,. 8%+( 2 ,7( #&) (

%& -,",0#&+ $-#&7( */

&'%&,,-%&' 7#&)%)#+,. 8%+( ,7( #&) 2 ,7( %& -,",0#&+$-#&7(8%+(/%-.+7"#..$*+(#+#&) ",0," A#?$,7*&.%),-,)*&.,A,.+,-$#.%.#+#'-*...#"#-? */JC E31,-A*&+( (,*+(,--,",0#&+7*&)%+%*&.

/*-.!7(7#.,.8%""$,.#A,#.#$*0, I > &),- 7"#!., %& 7#., */ &*&3#0#%"#$%"%+? */ 7#&)%)#+,.1*..,..%&' (

@!#"%/%7#+%*& 7#&)%)#+,.8%+( #&)2 %&-,",0#&+-#&7(#-,+*$,7*&.%),-,) 77*-)%&'"?

%+%.)%-,7+,)+(#+%/.!7(#&,0,&+!#"%+?#-%.,.#&)7#&)%)#+,. 1*..,.. (

@!#"%/%7#+%*& #-, &*+ #0#%"#$", +(,& %+ %. +(, 1,+%+%*&,-.(,-,%&8(*8*!")(#0,#1-,/,-,&+%#"+*$,,&'#',) #...%.+#&+ -*/,..*-.*&7*&+-#7+!#"$#.%.#.*11*.,)+*/-,.( 7#&)%)#+,.#".*1*..,..%&'.%A%"#-@!#"%/%7#+%*&. !7(0%,8%.

$,%&'+#6,&#'#%&.++(,!&37*&+-*0,-+,)/#7+!#"1-,A%.,+(#++(, 8*-6#&)7*&)!7+*/+(,1,+%+%*&,-.%&+(,1-,0%*!.7#),A%7

,..%*&.(#)$,,&/*!&)+*$,.#+%./#7+*-?

!+/*-.!7("%A%+,)1-*+,7+%*& +(,8-%+1,+%+%*&.#-, )%.A%..,) ;

= ;

*+,

*+, (,+(,-.1,#6%&'E-,#.*&,)

,.E (,+(,-,1*-+#$",

,.E