High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19910/2014disposed of

Khori Gaon Colony Kalyan Samiti F.Bad v. State Of Haryana & ORS.

2016-04-25Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih10 pages

!" #"$%&%' (

) *+% ,-* ,- . /%!% 0"!%!%" 1"&2& .! !" - #!+"& 0"&3#"!& 4' 5 64 .. 17 8 . 5 64 .66 "&"!' 4. 9%:4 %8."%#:$ !";%!+ 4 2 : ,; 8#:$ !"

!+"3"!%!%"% ((<)

( 4 +2%; , 8#:$ !"

!+"3"!%!%"%

4 #+%.%=+8##,8 - 8

"&3#"!& 4 ""3 > ,- 8#:$ !" # 4* ;%:"#%8#:$ !" 44+%&+.+ / 8#:$ !"

"&3#"!(%

??? +"!+""3!"& ,$ ,3 3"&/ -@" ,,;"#!&""!+" 92#=/"!A

@""

""#!!+""3!"&!A B +"!+"!+"92#=/"!&+2,#@""3!"#%!+"#%="&!A ??? 66 +%& #" &+ ,, #%&3&" !; ;%! 3"!%!%& %"

# ((<)

(8 !+" C2"&!% %:,:"# #"!"/% !% %& $// % @!+ ;":"8 !+" $!& "@"%=$2,,"#2! /%:%,%!"!%!%

, #/" &2%=) $"&8&%!2 !"#%:%,, ="6 >> 328 ; & 32$+ &"# @- !+" "3 !/"! 2%&/ D"&3#"! E

/ !+" 42%$%3 , 3 !%8 %# @ #8 32&2 ! ! & ," #""# # !"# (

F 42! !% ; & $$#%=,- & $!%"# %

:2 !+" "3 !/"!8!+", #; &,-%=3" #: $ !8 3"3," "$ $+"# !+""23 :" 3"%# !%/" # &"! 23 9+2==%"&G9+3%"&G>2$+ G32$$ +2&"& 2# (

3"&&8 %$,2#%= $+%,#"8 323! ! @" %+ @%!%= % !+" & %# $,- &%$" # !+" 3"!%!%" %" *+% ,- * ,- . /%!%%& &&$% !% !+&"9+2==%#;",,"&!; &% !+"-"

8;+"!+" 2!+%!%"&"&!"#!#"/,%!% !+"&" "$ $+/"!& ! $," !+" &%!"8 %:%, %! "!%!%

; & 3"

""# @- !+" 3"!%!%"&&$% !% ! ; & 3 -"# !+ ! !+"% 9+2==%"&G9+3%"& @" "=2, %H"# % ,!" !%:" $$23 !& !+" $,- D*+% ,-E @" ,,!!"# &2%! @," ,!" !%:" &%!"8 % !"/& !+" #"$%&% "#""# @- !+" %:%&%

"$+ !+%& $2! % )B< )8 #"$%#"#

D"I2"(E8 $&"&2&; &" $+"#@"!;"" !+" $2&", !+" 3 !%"&8 !+ ! % !+" ":"! "3"&"! !% %& / #"@-!+"3"!%!%"%"&3"$! !+"%$, %/8!+"& /"&+ ,,@" #"$%#"#% $$# $";%!+, ; #2#"!+""I%&!%=3,%$-8!+" ;%! 3"!%!% ; & #%&3&"# :%#" #" # !"# B

B D"I2" E $$#%=,-8 "3"&"! !% # !"# (

B8 ; & /:"# @- !+" &&$% !% 2! %! #%# ! -%",# - ! =%@," "&2,! "&2,! !,-8 3"!%!%" = % 33 $+"# !+%& $2! :%#"

B 8 #2%= !+" 3"#"$- !+" & %# 3"!%!%8 "3"&"! !% &2@/%!!"# @- !+" 3"!%!%"&&$% !% ; &"9"$!"#:%#"#"# !"#<

B8!+"& /"; &#%&/%&&"#

B &;%!+# ;;%!+,%@"!-! && %,!+"& %##"! 33" &!+ ! 3% ! !+" %&!%!2!% !+%& 3"!%!%8 3"!%!%" + # ":" 33 $+"# !+" 5@," .23"/" 2! 2#" !%$," B !+" &!%!2!% #% 8 @2! :%#" #" # !"# (

D"I2" E8 !+" 3"!%!%" ; & 3"/%!!"# ! ;%!+# ; !+" 3"!%!% ;%!+ ,%@"!-! 33 $+!+%&$2! "#"&& , %!&=%": $"+ !%& +;8!+"3"!%!%"%&@"

"!+%&$2! ! %& / %! %"# !+ ! !+" $,- %& % "I%&!"$" &%$" B :"8 /&! 9+2==% #;",,"& + :" @"" %&&2"# !% $ #&#8 !%#"3!&#2,- 33:"#@-!+" "3 !/"! # #.233,- "%3" !%%!+" " #$ !"%=!!+"""#& !+"$$23 !&4&! !+""&%#"!& !+"$,- "",,"# & :!"&8 !+"% /"& 33" % !+" :!"5& ,%&! !+" $$""# " # !+"- + :" @"" 3:%#"# :!" %#"!%!- $ #& %&&2"# @- ,"$!%//%&&% #% !92&!!+ !8 "; !+"$$23 !& + :" ":" @"" %&&2"# ","$!%$%!- $"$!%& 2!+"8 &2:"-& ;"" ,& $#2$!"# @- !+" "&2& "3 !/"!8 :"/"! #% 8 % !+" -"

& ,& %

2&2 ! ! !+" #%"$!%& %&&2"# @- !+" %:%&% "$+ !+%& $2! % )B< )!%!,"#JH # + !,-!+"&:.! !" - !+"&8 + # /2, !"# "+ @%,%! !%&$+"/" ! 3:%#" $$//# !% ! 3"&& % %,,"= , $$23 !% #8 !+""

"8 3"!%!%"& ! ;"" "!%!,"# ! @" "+ @%,%! !"# "!%!%"&%!+";%!3"!%!%%" ((<)

(8 ,&323! !@"!+"$$23 !& !+"$,- #/"/@"& !+"3"!%!%" &&$% !%K*+% ,-* ,- . /%!%

6" "# &"% $2&", !+" 3"!%!%" &2@/%!& !+ ! !+"/ !!"%+ #%&&C2 ",-$:""#@- #"$%&%"#""#@- !+" %:%&% "$+ !+%&$2!%

! 8 % %#"!%$ , $%$2/&! $"&8!+"3"!%!%&3"

""#@-!+" +2==%#;",,"&8;+ ;"" % 2 2!+%H"# $$23 !% :"/"! , # % $"! % $,%"&% %# @ # # $+>2, 8;"" ,,;"# ##%"$!%& ;"" %&&2"# ! "+ @%,%! !" !+"/ &2@9"$! ! 2, %,,/"! $"! % $#%!%& &"! 2! % !+" #" #8 #2%= !+" 3"#"$- 33" , @"

" !+" 5@," .23"/" 2!8 = %&! !+" & %# #"$%&%8 /"# "+ @%,%! !% &$+"/" ! 3:%#" ,!" !%:" $$//# !% ! 2 2!+%H"# $$23 !& !+" :"/"!, #8%!"/& !+"#"$%&%# !"#

% ,,-8 +"&2@/%!&!+ !!+"#"@"%= && %,"#%"<

BD"I2" BE%&3 ,3 @,-""2&8 !+""; &+ #,- -@ &%& !+" 2!+%!%"&!"$# %#%=!+ !!+"$$23 !& !+"$,-+ # %#""#"$ $+"#23!+", #%C2"&!%,-%!+"-"

#!+2&;""!",%=%@,"%!"/& !+"3,%$- " $! 8 ," "# $2&", "&3#"!& &2@/%!& !+ ! $$"#"#,- !+" , # % C2"&!% %& ;"# @- !+"

"3 !/"! 2%&/ # !+" 3"!%!%"& + :" %=+!8 !%!," %!""&! !+""% " &2@/%!& !+ ! !+" 3"!%!%"& + # !"&3 &&"# %!!+":"/"!, # #+ #$ 2&"#"$ $+/"!&#% -":"!8%$/3,% $" !+"#"3 &&"#@-!+%&$2!8# !"# B

%$" @" " !+" &&$% !% ;""

#"# 33!2%!- +" %=8 @2! & !+"- ;"" 2# ! + :" $ 2&"#

( "$ $+/"!&,-%!+"-"

8!+"-;""!",%=%@,"!&""> "+ @%,%! !%%!"/& , 2&"D%%%E !+"3,%$-8%!3&!2, !"& !+ ! %+ @%! ! + & ! @" % $$23 !% !+" :"/"!G:"/"! ="$-, # &

B " + :" +" # ," "# $2&", !+" 3 !%"& # 3"2&"#!+"3 3"@> !"/& !+"#"# !"# B

BD"I2"E8 3 &&"# @- !+%& $2!8 2!+%!%"& 323! ! + :" $&%#""# !+" $, %/ !+"3"!%!%"8%!"/& !+""I%&!%=3,%$-#8 !+" $$23 !&;""! 2#",%=%@,"8:%#"#"@"%= && %,"## !"# <

B D"I2" BE8 !+"% $, %/& ;"" "9"$!"# +" $$,2&% %:"# !" #&!+2&'

"#$ %%" & ' (

) * + , & - .

/. ,

#0123 4 4 -

- 5

. , . 4 -. 6

2 7 4 4 -

"#$

%%" 4

' -

%0%%%

:.) -

2 ,

. -5

. 4

#01 - .

/.,

#01

)

2 ;

.-5

< 5= < 5-

0# 5

53 - 5

- - 3 . -5

5 .

0# 3

;

. . ;

;

4 < ? - 3 ;

3 @:

3, :>

09 A - .- . 5

BBB BBB BBB -

- - . < ;

. "3 #

/. -

##23

. . 5

5 .

- 5

- - ;

4 - 4 .

- - 5

3 5 5 - 4 4 -

. = 4

- 5

= - 5

0# 4 3

. . .

- - ;

4 5

3 ;

3 5

BBB BBB BBB ;

5 . .

5 A

- - ;

4 5

. .

5 . .

- *

3 5 .

- -

. "3# 5 -

C I $%"8 !+" &+! C2"&!% !+ ! ; & "C2%"# ! @" #"!"/%"# @- !+" 2!+%!%"& ; &K ;+"!+" !+" /"/@"& !+" 3"!%!%"&&$% !%8 ;+ 323! ! @" % $$23 !% $"! % 3!%& !+", #8;""%#""#%3&&"&&%&%$"

B !"/& , 2&" D%%%E !+" 3,%$- ,- !+&" %+ @%! !& ;"" "!%!,"#

"+ @%,%! !%8 ;+ + # 2 2!+%H"#,- $$23%"# !+" :"/"! , # &

B8 ;+"" & !+" 3"!%!%"& ;"" 2# ! + :" "$ $+"# !+" &%!" ,-%!+"-"

#!+2&;""!",%=%@," @ " ,-&%& !+" #" !+ ! + & @"" %/32="#8 ":" ,& !+ ! %#%=& "$#"# @- !+" 2!+%!%"& & "= #& "$ $+/"! 3&&"&&% !+" $$23 !& 23 !+" :"/"! , # &%$"

8 " 3" &" 3":"&" # $-3!%$ "

""$"!!+""3!# !"# (

8&2@/%!!"#@-!+"2%&!

%$" !+" 2%&/ "3 !/"!8 ;+ 323!& ! + :" :%&%!"#

F !+" &%!"

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

B8 % !"/& !+" #"8 "#""# @- !+" %:%&% "$+8 # !"# B

B D"I2" E 2! %! -%",#"# "&2,!8 "I$"3! !+ ! "; "3"&"! !%:"& !+"3"!%!%"&&$% !%;""$"$ ,,"# +" %= (

B @- !+" %"$! 2%&/ #8 %! ; & ,-

!"!+"3"!%!%" = % 33 $+"#!+%&$2!8@"%= ==%":"# % $!% @- !+" 2!+%!%"&8 :%#"

B8 "&3#"!& $ 2&"# 33" $"

B # 3 &&"# !+" #" # !"# <

B D"I2" BE8 "9"$!%= !+" $, %/ !+" 3"!%!%"8 !+" / !!" ; & ,%&!"#

B @"

" !+%& $2!+ !@"%=&8 33!2%!- +" %=!+ !; & ,,"="#! + :"@""

#"#@-"&3#"!!!+"

%$"@" "& !+" &&$% !%)

B8 # -3%!!+"3 &&%= !+"#"

2#"$+ ,,"="8; & ,& $&"C2"$" -":"!8 ,,!+" $$23 !& ;"" "C2%"# ! @" +" # &"3 !",- # =%:" 33!2%!- ! 3#2$" !+" "C2%&%!" / !"% , % &233! !+"% $, %/&8!#"!"/%"!+"%",%=%@%,%!-8%!"/& , 2&"D%%%E !+" .$+"/" !;%!+&! #%= !+ ! +" %= ; &

#"# ! "; !+" "3"&"! !%:"& !+" &&$% !% !+%= %& @2=+! "$#8," &! -$="!$"#%@,"/ !"% ,8;+%$+$2,#&+;!+ ! !+"/"/@"& !+"3"!%!%"&&$% !%+ #%#""#!"&3 &&"# 2 2!+%H"#,- $$23%"# !+" :"/"! , # ,- % !+" -"

!+" %&!!%/"+ !@"%=&8;" "%/3",,"#!&"! &%#" !+"#"# !"#<

BD"I2"BE #"/%!!+"/ !!" "$&%#" !% $$#%=,-8!+"#"# !"#<

BD"I2"BE %& &"! &%#" # !+" / !!" %& "/%!!"# ! "&3#"! "$&%#" !% !+" $, %/ !+" /"/@"& !+" 3"!%!%" &&$% !%8;+&"3 !%$2, & #"C2%&%!"#"! %,& "&"!2!% !+",%&! /"/@"&D"I2"<E $+ !+"/"/@"&&+ ,,@"

#"# 33!2%!- +" %= # !+"% $, %/& &+ ,, @" #"$%#"# %#%:%#2 ,,- "&3#"!& &+ ,, /2, !" &$+"#2," % !+%&"= # #!% -!+"& /"! ,,!+"/"/@"&;":"8% - !+" /"/@"& ;2,# %, ! #+"" ! !+" & %# &$+"#2,"8 !+"% $, %/&+ ,,@"#""/"#!+ :"@"""9"$!"#!%""I"$%&"&+ ,, @"$/3,"!"#;%!+% 3"%# !+""/!+& /!# -;":"8 ;"/2&!$, % -!+ !:%#"!+%&#";"+ :""%!+"#"!"/%"#!+" ",%=%@%,%!- - !+&" /"/@"& !+"% "!%!,"/"! ,,!/"! ,!" !" &%!"& "+ @%,%! !% +" #" &! !2&

C2 = !"# @- !+%& $2! B

8 ;+%$+ %& % 3" !%8 &+ ,, $!%2" ! 3" !" 3"%# !; ;"">& !" !+" 2!+%!%"&32$"#%!&#"$%&% "!%!%& "#%&3&"# %!+" @:"!"/& ( S.J. VAZIFDAR ) ( ARUN PALLI ) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE JUDGE 25.04.2016 Rajan