Balwinder Kumar v. Union Of India And ORS.
!"#$ &"'()*+ #,#$ &-./*0&
1(*(
".&23(
(4.(
!"# $%&'(# )*%
(''
"+$%,-# !"# $%&'(#
(' "+$%,-#
() 5
63&0&,.'&, "34
77777
(' "+$
8&-./*0&3&(&44&'3.3(**. '## 9##%"3(*".&(:;<*&(3;"3. .&. #
= >?* 8 @ 4&((. A+ 3 & .0(& A*&,3&.;&3>"(3BC@.(0((;3 ;&44'& $ $9$$ !D9#$
"."'3&;;3"-;.()8 &@ <*+ 4 (*44. . .&. #$$ >?*8 $@E A@
*(30 . .&. =
#$$ >?* 8 @, -3A+34-&(0."0('E '@ . " 3 44& *3+ .&. #$ #$$% >?* 8%@, -3A+ 3 &44& 4". &;&( 3 0&.3&(A.(0((.E .@ . .&. D = #$$% >?* 8=@ 4&((. A+ 3
-;*3+.(0((;3-&44'&E @ ""'.(.&.#!
#$$%,D
&.#=
>?*(8 ,8#&.8D@
5
63&0&, &. '*( 4(; 3 4 (*A0. 3& 3 4, &''* " .&3 " 3( "&3, . &440.&.%
#$$$,-&(&44.'04&((&;*.
&(6F8&>'@
#$$=,3(*A0.&&44'&"& "3.&+(,A*'*.&.3""'-;3*&.&A&. '04;''*0(&'(&(3(-"3&."&(': #
#$$=,3 -&('3&;8(3.*. * "3 &-&+6&(>('4&.
44&@ *(, 3 4 .*+ 4. 3 &"0. '3&;8(3 ;; &(( A+. 3(' &. &( (*A0.3 .'*0(4&;3(("3(-",:0.'&'"'&'
-&(&-.G.*(- "
!
#$$=,3*(,3&&A(4.
'&0A! .&+(, ,"0
#$$=#
#$$=&.#=
#$$=
#$$= -,...&.#%
#$$ ,&<*+ ""'-&( &44. &. <*+ -&('.*'.
34&;&(*A0.
4+9&(("3&;0&.&A(-3&4&+".44;3 '3&;8(39<*+,A*3<*+ ""'"*.3&34( 3&A*& &A( &. 3 ('4&+ *3+, . . .&.
=
#$$ >?*8 @,04(.&4*(30"0&"0(' 34((&.3&(*A0.&&44&A"3 (4.(
#$$%>?*8!@,-3'3-&(,..&. #$$%>?*8%@,.(0((.A;0A&. 34".
&-4A"3(4.(#% #$$%>?*8 @
-,..&.D = #$$%>?*8=@,34-&(
. "0.3&3-43&(AG'.A+(4. 3 4((&.3&0.&0'+&44&.&. #$$%&.&(4 3 &0( 0&. 3 - 4, . ( .&. #! #$$%,
&.#=
>?*(8 ,8#&.8D@,34 -&("0.3&3(4("";30'+&44&3 ('4&.44& *( (&''*"'4"3.&. #=
>?*8 @,'&*("&'&''*.34&((& &3.( 4". ;&44'&,-3'3-&(&''04&. A+&&44'&(:;'.&".&+"#$ %.&+( &.
&((3&A;3&44'&(:;'.&".&+ (&A(33&3.&+-&(3&-"* (*A0.3&3*;33&.(0((.3 ;&44'&&''*"0&,A*(3*.3&&.G*.'&. 0( 3..&.#
=>?* 8 @G';3 ;& 44'&(,3*(,(*(&&A&.&AA(8&(.
3&3&.3&.'*("34,&44&(. 34&4A:&."3-3&3.*.'3&;(4"'+ ;&&.G*(".&..('&""',",3'(" (.&.#=
,D
&.#!
#$$% >?*(8 ,8# &.8D@&.3*()8
!" #$"%&' &' ( "!
##
!-#*#+,# .'/0$# #1#/
2 ##3-#/4# #"!#5 $6- ((''
7%86#99# #1# $$!9 !,$
:%#99# "#$"&; & . :8$$!#706!#07,0":, 0 8*: '<&''; 76$! =$! 6#99# 0
!# 7>8$"76 #"
#70/ $!
8# $! $ 8!# !# 7 !# $" 89$ 0 * 9$ *!
8! $ ?7 - "$:"
#
"
&
#$"%. &
!-#*#+,# .'/0$# #1#/ 2 ##3-#/4# #"!#5 $6- ((''
7% 0 *9$ #1# $$!9 !,$
:%#99# "#$"&''< :8$$!#706!#07,0":, 0 8*: <'; 76$! =$!6 #99# 0
!# 7 >8$" 76
$!
8# 6 0 * 9$ 9"
1 $ ?7 - "$:"
# 6#!76# 3"$ 7, 0 *9$ $?7 - "$:"
##$# $
"
.
/ #$"%& ''
5/ <<.
7%,86#99# $ =@ #$"'<'
:% = "#$"&( ' :8$$!#70/ $ :,"$!#$$! 90
:,86#99# #"99# / !86#99# 8#$7:*#""$ =@ $!
8# / 0 *9$ $$!- "$:6 " /6,#6 7, $60 *9$ $$!- "$
"
" )# *
&< 'A 4*(& " 3 '( " ?* 8D, 3 4-&(.*+"0.-&+A&':303"*+,#$$%3&3 (4("";30'+&44&,+0&.(&.0*0&. ..&&30.+, ,A+"; ;&44'&&"3;&4" #$ %.&+( ;&'"&-(A(( 343*;3&&.
0.+"&&44&-3'3-&(&(A&.
&44&(3&34 3&.A.;&..."-&+.('43(' '& .3(''*0(&'(,3"&'.3-&3" 0&"0 (',&""-;34'.*,&''.&'-3&-
343&(A&A(&A(33(&A('"& 4."! .&+(-3*&+4"
3&44&'3"343&. A+&.+A*&':&.&('& &.,3",'&A40. (: .'& " ;&' A+ &:; 3 '&*( " &' "0 3 '("3.&.#=
,-"3.&.#!
#$$%
?4&& 3&( '0 "3 3 3 - 4 3
&44'&(:;'.&".&+&(-3&343&.A .;"0*+,#$$%'0A,#$
-333&.&(:."0. &.3#$
6*'3;&'&A;&;A+&+*" &;34,&334(3*.3&A.(0((.A+ 04(;3'(("-&(;30"3*
3";;&((,-..""-33&(( ;A+3-3.(0((;3 ;&44'&3;*. ".&+
(*&+,3-4(&.(.(0((.
)*%
(''
"1 0
(' "1 $%,-# $%,-# $23+ 45 7 7 68 49 :;
< ) 6;
7 7 4=
) 6;