Harbinder Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH 1.
!!"##
2.
3.
"
$% &'()* $#+,-./*%&0%++%/& ! " # # ! $ %&'()*++,(*-). # /" ! /
/
! $ %&'(0-)*(*-)+
%&0%++%/&1+#$%)
12 !
!
/ " / "" / 3 "/"! * / 2 /
! "
2 !" & -)-)*--, 4 !
/ " -)-)*--,4 3 " "" / " / / "
2 " " /
/ -)-)*--, / "
2 $ / & 2 5 "
2 / ! -)-)*--,/ "" -)-,*--, % & " " 6 1 !
2 & 72)34#- 562 1 -. "'1 2 &
1 !
&'(+*-.(*-*-" '+!73-!84 - 562' ! -,-8*-** / "2
2)3'! 9: 2 /
/
"2/ 2 )++%/ " *))**-)*
" " 2 " !
, !
/" /
!""2 " !" / " 2 &
-59:!-!84#- 562 / ! / " !
" *.-;*--+4 ! " "< ! "" ! / -)-)*--, ; " !
"
!
! 0 = & " 2 !"& !">& ! /2 "
%)8 & " ! " "/" / 2)3'! 9:4 !
! -)-)*--, ! -)-)*--, 8 = ! / ) ?2 *--, "
& 2 5 / / "!" ""
! ) ?2 *--, $ ! 2 / & "
! " " (= (=/ ( @# 6 5!
95! "1!
(==:
6 & *!
*--,$ .>)>*--,( %5==>*-8.
(= A ! / !
2 !" %-+ / &" 9%: !" ).8 & ="" / " "
# !
" ! 2
" ""
/ " & " ! " " (=
(= "2( 9:
" 2 !"" & "
! 95 :" *--, 9:
"" !
!
/ ! )2 ?2 *--, * = & " ! " " (= (= " ) * ""
/ "" " 9):( @ " (=( " (== " !"" & " ! " " (== "" "2 # "
2 /
4 2 "" !
2 /76 & 2 7 2 # B 11 !" ! 2 # 6 5!
$ .>)>*--,(%5==>*-8.
6 & *!
*--,B . 3 ! ""
) ?2 *--, " !
& " ! " / 2 /
! ) ?2 *--,!
2 " !
" (= (= & " ! " +
"" ! !"& # $ ! *. ?"2 )++, !"& C5" )++, A !
/ !
2 ! 8) / ! %+8 !"& ! )+80" *9:*9": " ."
)% ( 9
@3"2 ! B ! & / "
2
& ""!" 2 ! # 2 = 4 & 2 "! ! D
"2 ! E 3
@ ! B ! "
& E
#;3<!!3!88 7!# (9): 2
" " !
& "
! " " == """2 2 & " A / " ""
& " ! " " = F= !
& G=
& " ! " " == "" "2 "
2 H 9*: !
"
"
2 ! & " ! " " == CA ! I! & ""
CA ! 3"2 !
" 9%:4 CA ! 2 ! ""
!
! !
2
/ AJ K ! 9,:'
" ! !
2 ""
2 ! "2! 5
"
#562!<!3-<!$533773=# 2 " # " 5 / !!""2!
" ""
" 2 & " ! "
2 !
" !B 9 " :
)- I!
" *9:9": )++," =
" ! 2 "< / & ""/
3"2 ! " " 5 2 ! !
!"& " ""
2 & " ! " )) = "7! !
/& / A " 2!
6"2' ! /3"2 !
!" ""
/ / #5 !
"!" 2 !
# ) ?2 *--, / 6"2' C"
2 ) )+.. ! / "< 2 6 *. !
*--; 3 " /" $ %
4 !! ! "7! ( @' " 2 =
*+%*-)- 2 CA ! C ' "2 6 "2 ?2
> *-)- ! / / / 2 /& 2 4 2
A ()4 2 "2 !! 2 ! *%-**-)-9 A )>*: "2 -8-.*-)- " 5! 6 K! )+;*--.
/ ! "2/ /
/ # ! -)-)*--,/
!
"< -)-)*--, /@6 & 2 B "" "!" / 5! 6 / =6" **)*-)-B )* 6 1 !
!
" %)8(
& " ! " / 73"2 ! 7 !" ( @' !
!" K"
"< /"" /
"
2 !
I! ! "2/ !
3"2 ! /"" "
! " )+.. ! !
2"2 "< *.%*--;
/ "2 /!
/ ! & ! ! / ))*--,B 9 " :
)% '
" !
"2 / ! 2 " 6 1 !
" ( @5 ! / !
!" "2/ !
)+.."" "< !
3"2 ! /""
! ))*--,4 / ( ! 6 & 9 A (): ! / # ! / -)-)*--, /"" "!"
4 A (* & " ! " ! 2 !"! >! %-;*--.
A (%:4 /""!
2 #5 " " ! 2 "!" 2 ! # ! ))*--, = / / ""
/
!!
"2 ! /
"
/ !
! 3" ! ! !!
"2 !"! %-;*--.
A (%: / & 2
/ " "!" ""
"
2 /
/ ))*--, "< ), = ! !" "
2
73"2 ! 7!
" !" " ! 6 1 !
& ! 6! -!8<#- 5621 -. 4 / " ( @4 ! 2 6 !
!"
# " ! !
2 1 ! ! "
" / " 2 ! " / 3 J3"2
! K !
2 / &5 J3"2
! K !
" *9:
! 2 2 / !"5/ !
! ;) !" !4
/ @ "B
" )9%:9: " " "! " )9%:9: " !
" """2 2 & /
2 " )++- /
" " " LB 1 !
!
!" ""
/( @)8 / !!!! J3"2
! K !
&5 " "2 !
! " 4 2
" "!" ! 4
! "2
/ " "/ 2 ! A 2 2"
/ /"" " !" & !"
9 $ ,: = 2 !
!"/ "
/
22 " ! ! " 2/ " " "!
4 2
2 "
2 !"& !" = ""2 !"& !" " / !
2"
B ); ! 2 ! 2
"< / " & 4 / """"/ 3"2
! ! *9: )++," !
) ?2 *--, C
"<
2/ "
/
2 ! > " 4 2 ) ?2 *--, 2 / & 2 5
! ! ""2 & 2 5
/ "2"!" ) ?2 *--,/ " "!" ! )0 ""2 "" ""
/ A
"" " 2 " " -)-)*--, )8 =! " "" " M0N ! " / "" !" "< ).
2 "! " ! ! "## %&0%++%/&
+, ;* '
> O >$ '
"
O >$