High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13020/2018disposed of

J.S. Mandhok v. Oriental Insurance Comapny Ltd And ANR.

2025-02-10Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj19 pages

CWP-13020-2018 ! "! # $ % " ! ! #

& '(& ! )* )! + ,,,,,

!" " #!$ %&" '! "(% "))$ %&" '!

***** * )! +-! + ,#

-"&'" .' /" "/- &#

0 1"

! /2 "3 )' ! " '-!4-"

!! 21 566756+89:- ;<% .!&! !

!"% & 1"

! "3)' .!-"3

&%''& "" $! !"%"

"&! ! &-

.% 5 ! '"& ' ! &"

" !" ! "

!,( !''&'! "1 -"&&/ "3'60+6+;=>

" / "% ''&"#"1 ''&!" #"! ."

#-1" %&'")-503" " ."

-13 / -#! - +76?5668$ .!1 %# "

% "1 ""# " @!" "$ ! ' 1-"3 / " "1 #"% " &!4- 666+?=' +$60$=852 )#! "1"31-'0/!& $"

! 1 -1 0 !"!%1-"3/'! ."

!.% "&& " !& ."

& "

" '") &" "

"/"1 4-3 ."

" "#" !/ ! 4-3 ''&

-)/ ! '&!"#)# % $.!"'$% 55+5566=$! & 1"3-!3/ ! "13'A/%"1'

%&.!&! !"11) 4-"1'&"''--/ 13/B$"#" ! > !" !

&'&"113 -)/ !" ! % /" ") '/! - '/5+6?5668"

!!"

"1"

3!" %!&!"#! / ''&"!1%"/!""( #!$"

!-1 $ & - " %&/ !"%# ' / - ! 1-"13 / ' ! C"1 -"& 9/ 13 < &!/$ +;;? " "

! -& ' !

&/ "3 ? !"

# ' " ' "13 "#" !/$ !

! 1

1 ! / )' &1- #

$#"-3$1"%&"

/$ D&)-! "/. )- !/D-!$! ."

"1 1 /

"11."& - -105'! &!/+;;?

0 7 !" ! /"

-/- % ! ''& ' !

&/ "3 4- # ' 1"

' ! /2 "3 )' )- 3 !

&/ "3 1"

13 " "/- ' ?$>;$6=82 4-"! E .%1-"3&)-' % '- " 0$55$78;2 "#" #"-3% &!4-==+>+;!

&/ "3"1 "

- ! !"!/"#)' !"11"1 ) 1"

"!"1 8 !" ! -/- " 5>6>56+6$ +>6+56+5$ 6>6556+0$ " 6+6?56+> 4- # ' ! 1"

'! /"#)' .%$.!"&."

",- !/)3!

&/ "3$! "

"&! ! &-% F +?;?8 ' 56+> .!&! & ' / ."

- +56=56+> 066056+8$!. ."

'' )3 ! &- " & !

& ! "' " '! .!" './!

= !""'! & .

- )3! &-$!

"&! ! ''& ' !

.! " &' & 3 ' ! "' " -)/ ! "

1&" +66>56+8$4- # !1"

'! "3)' ; !" !

&/ "3 % 1 566756+8 '/ ! !" "' & # ! &"

$ &/

" "11."&4-"1!"1''! $.!&!.-1 !"%)"

)1 ! !)"

'4-"1'3# %&- ! "'! /%"1$ !"

) "

% .! ''& '/ - 56+8 .!- "3

&% ''& "" ! "

"&! ! ''& ' !

> &/ "3 ,#&1"'&"!")% 1$!.%$ "

% # "3 &1"'&" $ !

&/ "3 % 1 6;6=56+8 "

, ! &" "

"1 &-/ .!&!. -)/ +6 !"'$% "!1 5?6;56+8$!

&/ "3 '/ ! !" " "/- ' +5;;>2 !"

)

"& "

! .'6=6756+8 ++ "/- ' ?+$;872 ."

&% )3 ! 5;6;56+8)#! "" ' '/-56+811 /)56+8 " !"'! !"

)#-1"13&%#! +5 ! $ 11 )# "##% )3 ! & ' !

&/ "31"

#! "" '/! "'! 1"%# !''&55+5566=11-56+8$ '.! " +5+556+8$ 6?6556+= " 5+6056+=$ .! " '-! 4- 1"

! "/ "1 .! +=G ' 1"3 "3/$ .!- !

&% "1 6>6?56+='/!''&'

0/"#!/!"!&/ "-!3 ' "3/ ! " )3 !/ /" # "" ' "3 )' .! 23 44 +0 !&- 1'! &

!"! " 1 /"" '"& - )1/ "&&-' 1"3!1"

"3/)' "%#! -&'&/" )#

! / )' $ ! ."

-")1 - -

/ &"1"/ -1"&,''-

+> ! &- 1 %!/13 &

!" ! % !-#! !

-)/ ! "

1&"'%1-"3/" !

"1"31-'!& $!.%$! "/."

"&& " ! & ."

& "

" ' ") & " .#13 / ! "13 ' A/%"1 '/ %& .!&! !"11 ) "

4-"1'&"''--/ 13/B% 55+5566= +? !&- 1 -)/ !"! ' "13 %1" '!-1 $ & - " %&/ ! %/" ") '/ ! - '/ 5+6?5668$ "

"11# )3 !

&/ "3" !"

"1"

3!" %!&!"#! / ''& " ! 1%" /$ !""( #! .!1 # ' 1-"3 /$"

! %&/ "

"1"#" ! ."

"1 ' )3! )-! "/."

%$ & ! "13 / - ! ."

' A/%"1 '/ %& .!&! !"11) 4-"1'&"''--/ 13/B$! "/1#"113 1 ! ' ! / )' &1- # $ 1"% &"

/$ D$ ##"- "

.11"

""11."&"

-105'! &!/+;;?'! 503" ' %&

-/- '' $ 13 ! E . %1-"3 &)- !

% D- " #"-3"/-# ?$>;$6=82 " 0$55$78;2

&%13$."

+7 ! &- 1 1"& 1"& ! (- #/ ' ! E)1 - /-!/"'). 56.7. !&! ...83..4

7 "

9":1#;")<:.!!&-!"

!1 !"$

+8 !&- 1 -)/ !"! 1 " '+=G ".'! "'! 1"%#!''&55+5566=11!

" ' 1"

' ! "1 - " ")1 ! ! &1"/$ ! 1"& 1"&!&"

'*4=.2(!&3 . !). 5

9<;)>?$.!!"

:&-!"

) % !'11.#

% ( %))*

+= ! &- 1 %!/13 &

!" ! "& ' !

"3!&/

""11."&13.'-56+8" .!- "3

&% ''& "" )3 "

")1

8 & "" ! "/ !-1 ) ! .'! "' ! 1"%# ! ''& 55+5566= " '/ - 56+8 !

&/ "3$ % "! 1 6;6=56+8$ /" !

!" ! &/ "-!3 !"

#" ! &/

" "11."&)"

>7?02 " "

=0>+2 $"1' +5$;;>2 " '-!4- !/ &" &-/ +; ! &- 1 -)/ !" ! & ' ! "' & "11 ! &-/ .!- "3 1"3 " !"' % 1 5?6;56+8$ !

&/ "3 '/ ! !" " "/- ' +5;;>2 !"

) "& "

.'6=6756+8%$5;6;56+8$! &% ""/-' ?+$;872 )#!"" ' '/-56+811 /)56+8" '/!! !"

)#-1"13&%# ! ! "&&- 56 ! & ' !

&/ "3 1"

# ! "" .'! "'! 1"%#!''&55+5566=11-56+8 ."

11#"1" - - "")1

&! 23 $ 5+ !&- '!

-)/ !" -

- !" ! '%1-"3/ &!/+76?5668" #"% "&!4-' +$60$=852 )#!"/-'!/!

"1"3 ' ,# %1-"3 / .%$ ! &

!" % 1 6>675668$."

&%3 ! !"- -106

= - ! "

# A 1-"3 / ' ! C"1 -"&9/ 13 < &!/$+;;?B$;6 "3 & 1"

./1"13$% % 09"<'! -1$! .'&-"1/ ' ! & ' ;6 "3 % .! ! / -!3

# -!3 " !" ! 4- ' ! ''& ,# %1-"3/! &"$! !/"

"3 4- ' &-"1/' !1" . & ';6 "3 ! & ."

."% '')3!&/ "-!3.!-"."# '! '/!&/ "-!3$! " ! ''&'/5+6?5668" /" ") '/ - "-"-!H /"-&!") &'/ - ."

%1"'-1+='C"1 -"& 9< -1 $ +;8?$ .!&! ! 1")1 '

& 1"3"&'! '- "-! ") &!

&/ "3% 1 60685668$!&&%3 ! !" ! "

1&"!"

)"&& " 4- !/ '

- // "13 55 !&- 1'-!&

!"!"&& "&'1-"3 / -)(& #1"& &1""& " &" ) &1"/ "

" /" ' #! ! !& /" " .11'-1 -"-!H ") & &-- 13 '/ 5+6?5668 50+65668 " & ! % )"&,' -

&//-&"'/!''&$&

& 1"3"&."

","#" !/ 50 !&- 1"#- !"! & 1"3"-!3$"'## !-#!!&!"# !"

.11"

!4-3 $! " )3! " !&& &

$!1 !""/ 13

;

/ ) 1% /13 -)/

' "

1&" " !

"/ -)(&!"&& "&)3!&/ "-!3!&"

' %1-"3 / ."

(& "&&- ' " %#1"& 4-3 #"#" !/" ! "/."

/" ! % 55+5566= &$ " "13 ' A/%"1 '/ %& .!&! !"11 ) " 4-"1'&" ' '-- / 13/B ."

"1 / 5> ! &- 1 -)/ !" ! ' " "

"1 "#" ! ")% ' ! & 1"3 "-!3 .!&! ."

"1 (& % +>6?566; '-! -)/ !" !

)/% '/! %&% 55+5566= " !)' ' " !/)' " "3")1 " / 13$ .! !"

) /% /

'/ ! %& "&& "& .! ! C"1 -"& 9 -&$ & 1 "

"1< -1 $+;8? &$! 1 !)' "

&1"/ )3!/D-!/$! !"

"1 '1 " 5668566;.!&!."

(& (& )3 +7+5566;" !

"/."

"1 &%3 % 1 5=+5566; 5? ! &- 1 &

!" &/

" "11."& !"

) "11. - -105'! &!/$+;;?"

&"1&"

$" "'& #"11! %- & '! ."

& )3 !

&/ "3 !" ! .-1 ) 1 ! &/

" "11."& 4-"1 !"1' ' ! .!&! .-1 !"% )"

)1!/!)"

'4-"1'3# %&- ! "' ! /%"1.!''&'/-56+8" .!-

&%''&

+6 "" "&&-'! "/!- $"11"

)1)' "3")1!

!"%"1"

3) 57 !&- 1"#- !"&/ 1"&'! '! &-

066056+8$! "'! ."

& %

566756+8" &/

""11."&4-"1!"1''! $ .!&! .-1 !"% ) "

)1 ! ! )"

' 4-"1'3# %&- "'/! /%"1.!''&'/-56+8$ .!- "3

&% ''& "" $ ."

& ) 1"

// "13 58 ! &- 1 1"& 1"& ! (- #/ ' E)1 - /-!&"

'&.34)3.. ! 4 54. $ .9 "<;"")>1< ")1 !!"&/

""11."& )#" 13&"

&"1& "" !"! &- !"

) % '% 14-& 1"

# - !/ "13 .-1 1"/ 13'/ -&!&/

""11."& 5= ! &- 1 -)/ !" ! !"

"1"

3 ) ! &/

" "11."& '/ - 56+8 .!- "3

&% ''& "" "&&- ' ! "/ - -"& ' -1 05 ' !

&!/ +;;? " ! "/- "3")1 ! D-!$ ! 1 ' &/

" "11."& .' '/55+5566="

&1"/ )3!/ 5; ! "#-/ !"

) " )3 ! &- 1 ' !

++ 06 !"% !" ! 1" &- 1 "

"# )!"1' ' !

" " !"

# !-#! ! 1"

# "

.11 "

! &-/

"1 !(- #/ 1 - )3!&- 1'! " 4.4 0+ @' & #'-!$.-1 ) :"/! 1%"-1 '!C"1 -"&/ 13 &!/+;;?$ " ! "/")#:"& )1.' - "1 +

-%.

(

-&.

-%.

+5 -.

(

-%.

-&.

-".

(

-3.

1 /

-4.

- .

+0 5! , 6

( !,

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

( ,

-%.

(

% 7 %))

-&.

-%.

05 - "1'-10695<'!"' -1 /", &3 "1 &1" !" " & ' %1-"3 / 4- "&& "& )3 !

# "-!3 % ! -1 " !" &"

#"-!3 '- #"! /

'/ )'!:

3'!

&' ! &$!/

!"11)&/''&%'/! "':

3'!

+> 00 %$ "

-1 06 90< 9)< ' ! -1 $ " & ' &-"1/ ' & ) & / " /"3 ) #" )3!"

#"-!3- " '"& 0> ! &"

" !" $ ! "

1 ' +76?5668" "1 -)/ "&!4-' +$60$=852 )#! "1"3' 0 /!

& !

&/ "3$ % 1 6>675668&%3 ! !"!!3!"%&% "3 4- '/! '&-"1/'!& !&

."% ')3!/ 0? !

&/ "31"/ " "13'"/%"1 '/ %& .!&! !"11)" 4-"1'&"''--/ 13/B % 55+5566=$"

- !1 )3!"

11""-!3%

+>6?566; 07 !

- ! ! 566756+8 % .!&! !

&/ "3 !"

% &/

" "11."& 4-"1 !"1' ' ! .!&! .-1 !"% )"

)1! !)"

'4-"1'3# %&- !

" ' ! /%"1.! ''& '/ - 56+8 .!- "3

&% ''& "" "&&-'! "/ .%$! &1"/# !"! "/ !-1 ) ! .'! "'! 1"%# !''&55+5566=" '/-56+8 08 D/""

#'-105$ /"' !""/ 13.! /

$ /% $ &/ -1 13 /" !"11 '' !

"1 &1"!"/

"11."& 1'&"1&-1"

+? ! )"

' $ .!&! "

& 1"

! &&1- !" /

"11."& ", $.!&!"/ 13 "13 .-1 !"%)1 $!"

!&&-/ "& ' /

"1/%"1 '/ %&% !"' %.)&/ &1")31,# "-)-15'-105.!)3 -1" !"!/

" 11."& !"11 ) 1

!" ! "/- ' //-/ - -10?!- $! -)!"/

"11."&- -1 05 ", !""/ 13 1 0= D-!$" 1""

#'! % '-105)# ' ! /"'1 "&# -1 05$ .!&! "$ !" "

&'!/ -!3" !"!& " !

-)(&% " '"&'!/ -!3" '-!!&/ -!3 4- & .!! ! &"

% '

&"1 & "$' $!4-"-/!'I" !1%"'"& 0; & "

1 1".$ "1."3 "3")1 '/ !

""/ 13&"

)!/ 13/" '/"3!

"$/

"11."&/"3"1 )#" '/ "' /

"1 /%"1 !-#!$ "/ "#/ .! ! &&1- !" ! /

" 11."& ", !" " / 13 /"3 ) 1 $)-$"/'!%.!"-1, $& '.!&! " /" ' #!$ /

" 11."& " #! " " !

&'!/ -!3&& #13! &"

" '/ .!&! /"3 ) #" $ .-1 &

"13 % .! ! / -!3#"#! "/$"&"

.%$

+7 '-!&1"' !" -&! &.-1 )%- 13) (- &"1 %. >6 '-!&

"3&!"%!-#!! - !/ ' /

"1'/ %&."

/ 55+5566=$)-&!"11#!"

)" ! & 1"3 & # !

!!- $ !1#"13%"1 3'! - !/'/%"1'/ %&&") # >+ % !-#! ! &1"/ !" ! 1

"3)' )-! .! "1 .!!"

1&")13' -1 05 ' ! &!/ % !-#! !

&'& 1/"3 )(& !"

) " 1&" ."

'1 )3 !

3#"

1&")13'! -105!1/'! &1"/ !- # '" %. ' ! ")% -1 " ! 1/ 13' ,#&/

""11."& >5 '""

!1".1" .)3! E)1- /- 8

9 - "< && $.-1 ) )" / ! #- 1 1" .$ .!1 & # &"

' #" ' /

"11."&$.!&! 4- !- %3

(

; "%

; %)*&

>0 ! &"

$ ! :"/ ! %"- & " .!&! " 11- "%13 :

)3 ! E)1 - / -!")%/ (- #/$ /"13'!"

!"!

$ ! / -!3 !"

'"&$ 1' ", & " "11 ! 1%" "

& " !"

#" /

" 11."&$!-#!'/! "'! "11.# -&!"11."& >> !- $! &"

$!13!#'& ")' ! &- .!! ! &/ "-!3 ."

&& #"# /

"11."&! .'-56+8 >? F!" !.%'-!"

"!"%!-#! '! &/ "-!3 & .!! ! &"

&"11 ' "& ' "

+= &/

" "11."&$ !.%$ .! /" !" -&! " & " &" ) 13 /%# ' " "

1&" )3 ! / 13 >7 ! "/ " % !-1" "

-&!$%!-#!$ . " &"3'/$!.%$! "/ ":& .!&!!"

) // "134-&,'11.- !&/ "-!3 !- :

& ", " :

- & $ ! % ' ,#

1&")13 ' -1 05$ "

.!! &/

" "11."&

"3")1 >8 -&! & ."

!.% ", )3 ! &/ "-!3! &"

1156+8! !"

)&-- 13

# 1 " / ' ! "

)1 )' &1- #

"&!# ! #! - " % '1# &/ :

1"" !"

) #% "

.!3 & ."

", )3 !

! "/ >= %"")13$ ! ."

1 ! &/

" "11."& "

! #- 1 1" . ! &"

' ! - - "<$)-! "/."

'" '"13=J3" >; ! )- -3 ' ! / 13 - !" " / 13.!!"

% ! - !"%3"1#"' & " ' ! "

)1 )' ! / 13 &" ) ")" '" ?6 "

!"%)#%)3

.!3&-1 & ! )'"1

+; ?+

- 13 ! !"

%-"113 "

13 ' &/

""11."&+66>56+8$ - -"!1)3#" )3 ! &-% 066056+8" !&/ "-!3.!1 & # ! " ' ! $ #" &/

" "11."&)3& #"

&"1&"

$% 566756+8 ?5 ! )'&-1 !- )1"

%.!-&/ 11# !/ ' ! 1#"$ "

&"1 :& "1 &&-/ "& !"% )

!."

.!3!&&

$'"3$!"

)#" /- !- ) & - )"1".'-11/'! .!&!!/"

% '! ?0 ! . !- "13 "11. " !

566756+8 3#1"

'&/

""11."&'/! " ' /%"1 55+5566= "

" !

& &/ -!)'.!''&'/! "'! /%"1" 1"

! "/ .! K 7G "-/ '/ 55+5566= " ' /%"1$.!" '!/!

'& '&' & 3'! 9* )! +;

" - # =

F!!

",#2"

2 F!! ")1 2