← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/275/2008disposed of

Lal Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2025-08-19Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja6 pages

    

  

   



 !"#$%&!$&"$ & '$'

$&( $ !)*++ 

        

   



)  ,-  + . / .  

!"  



 $%&'(&')&**+ !, "   

 $%-./.0-./(%&**+ !12  3     $%(-++%&**+ !4  5 6  77777 / .  +

- 8   992"9 4 -- 

"  $       4   

          99 :"

#  

    2"9  -& $  

  3 9

& 1#

  

#

  &<*+&**'

4 

"% "9%  5"

 4



   

 %#  3 

-+   -+<. 

  # / Brief facts of the case are that

 # 4  %#

"       

   8

;

0  #     *.*(&**- &&*-&**&

" 

 .0)

  -+<.

 "4

9  "

= #1!;

 " # )-3-/9;

 



  # /-*-&**/

    /(

.        #  

  4       



   %#    #    3  





" 

-+ -+<.

3  

 9 >  9 4

"  # &<*+&**'

 

  # 9

 "4   

    !    "

#$  %

# & ' (!) (&    *& *&  +# ,   ++ + - &) ."  & /  0 

0   "

' *&    #1 ( $



  #  

#

4

"      

  9    2"9  ) 9"    

  #     &<*+&**'

 

0

"

 %# "49   

"# ##   ?9"



 

"49  

# 



 

 

4 

993    "

 "

 

"

 &+*&&*** @?%.<  #      -'  9          

  ***A%   4

 "49  @?%.<4   



9# 4  "4 

" " 





 ' B     "

 "49   

 

# 

9 4

4 #          

 @?%/&    @?%/.   --*+-<<<-(---<<< #   2"

4" = #1!

" - )( ***A% @?%/& / &( ***A% @?%/.

 

"   

 C .&( 

  

  "

"49       9"   #        

  "

  "   ?9 9

@?%/&%/.#  

 9 

9@?%.<  "4 = "9



 +    "  

  "   43 "4

 "49

 9 4   %#

$ < ##4 D4  ? "

!"#$ %#&%'()''&*&#+%'&&,#!##+##+% '&  -.,/   3 

"  

9 

93

93

 &+*&&*** @?%.<  -'9 

 ***A% 

 '

(& <.-A%;



 

      ?9   

 9

4   ##4 D4  ? " !"#$0&

"

 



  

%  

 "44" 4  "

E 4

@?%/&%/. <- !    "94   " 9  4 "#  "49

9 4   "





  

@?%.<# 4  4 /*

# 9 B

 

  "   " # 

9 



4  "E 4

 

 

4  4

"



  #  

# 

$" 9





 #9 

 "   9@?%.<1   9 

"/*



4  94 3 4      9 "4 

  9@?%.< <& $"     9@?%.<

 &+*&&***

 " 

. -+<. 



#

*.*(&**- 

9 -.F            -.  9  

   4        

9   @?%.<#  3

   #   93      

 "42



4 

"   ? 9-. # ? "  % $###########&

   &  2 ++- 3 +  +  & +  ) , # 42    . - &  *&  +  -  + " . - & "   +%

 +% & + &# 5  - 2 "  & 

    6& "  + -  *&      2 + -

7   !  ! .) ' *&    8++#1 </ !  9@?%.<4    9 

9 "-'9

 "



" 9   

4  -*      

#     9  "'(

  "

 "

= #!1

         "     3    

   A    #

9     "

"

 

 

" 

 

-.F  "

-A/" 9@?%.< " 

9

4

C 112A% 9    #  = @? 4

 

    



   

     -.F 

 

"

   -A/  93 "

 - @?%.< 

=+..(   &+*&&*** -'9 ***A% '

(& &.-A% + ('

((.A% ( '- '*/A% --  



  

#  #

 

  4 9

;

%#     "4  

"  -+<.

 -&

       

 -<*+&*&(  / .  

3

3A

A=  4

A= .%+ !+

'$!+ ("0$ - $%.&&-%&**' B0!  B93  & $%.&&&%&**' B0!   69 

/ $%.&&/%&**' B0!    . $%.&.)%&**' B0!    ( $%....%&**' B0!   ,   ) $%(-++%&**+ B0! ,      ' $%...(%&**' B0!    + $%-./.%&**+ B0!      < $%-./(%&**+ B0!      -* $%&')%&**+ B0! B93