High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4252/2023dismissed

Harpal Singh And Others v. Union Of India And Others Through Seceretary

2024-07-29Mr. Justice Suvir Sehgal5 pages

! "#$%$ & !#'% () *%"+$+(,-&.&

&

&

&

- /0 &

1 12 1

!"

! #$%&'()*% % %# #$%&'()*% +)!

"

%,,*%

--- 12 1

&

0 .

!"

)'

!%,, '"

)+ !

%/)( ' +"( ("

$

% 1"

(),( *)22) 3#

)+,%4% '+%* 5 )!

%6 )+*) (

&+%*#%,$) 7%6

+)20859505:5 ;1 4%1 )+ $

("

$ & $

!%(

%$$)%*!

'!"

)## "*, 55<)+!

)

"#") )+ '"%

%","

7 )'

'% ' .<.55:55&

=# 09& 4!

/1& ,

''"") %, "*>#'7 & )?

$#&!%

'%$$,"*%") 5@.:5:.@&

=# 0&+",

&# 9)+ *&.@A&

6"

7*) %") )+'

,%1"

+","

7)+ /B # 8 )+ !

/"%") % ) *","%") *&.@@A+)/ ("1!

%+ ')% C!

*)+ .@@AD 8 %* %'"

7)!

+","

7)+!

% !%,% ')4

/1!

4% %*3#" '+))#0"

7)+ %") %,"7!4%1

)<. )"+"*%") '5::95:.8&4%

# )+ %") %, "7!4%1 *& .@9A )2$

#!)"1 % *3#"

0*#20 & )7%& %

)# ' %4%' '% ..:@5:.9&%

7*)2$

%") +)!

,% '%*3#" '"

",,%7

B!& "*)7%

%"

+"

'4"!!

4%'&$

% 4 ,, %") %,"7!4%1#!)"1)+ '"% )#7!

)%

/"%);14%''% '58:95:.@&

=# 0.&/"%)0*#20 )22"

&

)9&

!% ' !

*)2$

%") +) %7"*#,#%,,% ') .<E.$ 3#% 1%'% '%4%'

' 58:E$

3#% 1%'+)

"'

"%,% '*)22 *"%,,% '/

"'

),%"#2 *

+", ' /B &

=# 05&/ +)

"*>#'7 &%,) 74"!% %$$,"*%") &

=# 0&# 9 )+!

*&.@A&

6"

7, %( )+!

)#)

%"

)/B

%+ *) 7 !

'

,%1 $$,"*%") 4% *)

' /1

/1+","

7 $,1&

=# 08&% '%+ *)

&%$$,"*%")

!%

'

*,"

'/1)'

&

=# 09&4!"*!!%

"2$#7

9 )#

,+)!

!% %7# '!%,

'''"") %, >#'7 !% '"

7!

%$$,"*%") +)*) %") )+'

,%1 4"!)#*)

"'

"

7!

=$,% %") 7"(

/1!

+)!

'

,%1 +","

7!

)/B

!% )#7!

7% "'

)+!

)'

# *!%,,

A !%( !

%'*)#

,+)!

% '*)

"'

'!"

%7#2

<

), 3#

)/ *)

"'

'"

4!

$)("

)+ 9)+!

*&.@A% %$$,"*%/, ))/B

+", # !

*)+.@@A !"

2% "

),)

7%% '!%

#$ )#"

% #2/ )+*%

E 8 )+ !

* )+ .@@A $)("'

% $ ")' )+ ,"2"%") )+!

2) +)$ "

7)/B

+)2!

)+ "$)+!

"7

'*)$1)+!

4%'/1!

&4!"*!*%

+#!

=

'/1% )!

$ ")')+:'%1 &"+!

$%1*!%,,

7"

4%'"

%/, ) !)4 #++"*"

*%#

!"

, ', 7%,

! " 3 #$

$ #

$ % &

'!( )*+ ,

-

* ! .! / % ' & & 0

.

-

&

&1& 2 1&

& &

!" )&#$ )#!% !

,'!%!

,"2"%") +)+","

7)/B

$

*"/ 8)+!

* )+ .@@A % ' !

=

) 4!"*! " *% / *)

' "

%, *"*#2 *"/ '!%

*,%"+"

'!% 9)+!

*& .@A.& "

) %$$,"*%/, ) *)

!

'

,%1 / 1) ' !

$ ")'

$

*"/ 8)+!

*)+.@@A

#,"

!% %$$,"*%") # 9)+!

*&.@A.&"

)#

'/1 $)("

))#/0 & 8)+!

*)+.@@A ",, 7%,"1)"2$)$"

14"!"2$#7

')'

&$%

''"") %, "* >#'7 & )?

$#& 4!"*! ')

) *%,, +) %

+

@ "

'"

7 )2 "&%,,!

% !

/1'"

' .:

'"

7%$$,"*%") &"+% 1&%

')+ &.&

12 1 0 JUDGE F!

$ %6"

7G

G ) F!

$)%/,

G )