High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17052/2020dismissed

Nitin Negi v. State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commissioner,Punjab And Another

2024-01-29Mr. Justice Namit Kumar17 pages

!"# $ !! %& '

( # ) '* ++ ( ,($%) %

(# +- $ %)).%& ' ( ## ( ( '*/ *

$ ( # / # ) $

(

1 , /

( 2)34'*# /(( ($ !

( #

## ! !# ' ( '&

( ( (

# ( & ' $ 3 ! #

( % /(( 5

## ! # $* # $% ##$

!# ## ! '* *

(

( # 6

-(' $

( $

(# #

(

(# (7 ( (

(. ( / / , $ 1 !#$ *2 4/ (# " ! "# $ 8 !% ( (

( % & '% /($ ( 6 $ '( (

$$ / !$*!!' !

(!!' ) 6

$ / (

( ( ( 4 !$

2# 4 :!

(

6 ( :* -$ ( " * !

( 6 +

(

(# 2/

( 4!

##$

!# ## ! : ( ##$

# 1 ( ##$ / '!

'*( ((

* & ' '& $$ ' ( /$$ # ( 3 ! *

;

/% $

% / *

(

(# (/

$ '$

## !

$ 1 # !# ( (

<# & ' #

( % /(( !!! 5 5 $ -(

: 6% ( '!

( ($ $ / (( ##$ %/((/

$'*

$ 1 * $ '$ (

(5 /$$' /($ 1 *

(

( # (

' (

(

(/((

(

6 ;%

(

:* %

! & *

'* ! ( $ # !

$ 3 ! $ )

-6

(

! & *% # ##$

## ! !# ' ##$ 2)364 -(

% $

0 % # , ( #

'! ( ( / ( # ( # (& '$ 3 ! #

( ;

/% # '!

(

( ( # ( !

$ 2 (4 3 ! ! & ' (

$ = 9 % ' ( (

( & ' '& (%(5 ( ## ! %(/$$ ## & '$ 3 !

( /$$'!

( '*# & '$ #

( / ( #

* ! (

## ! ;

/%# & ($ !

## ! !# ' ( ((

# ( & ' $ 3 ! #

( % /(( 5

## ! # $* # $ ##$

!# ## ! '* *

(

(# 6 > $

(# ( $ !

## ! !# ( / $* '& '*# (

$$*$$ $ ' *;'!

(# (

(

! & * $ # (!

$ 3 ! '* ! ( '!

( ##$

## ! !# % /(( ( / $* '

& '* # !# 2)34; ('!

$ ( (# (

# (& '$ 3 !

( % ( ## ! % ( ( $$ # ( & ' $ #

( / ( #

* ! (

## ! ; ( ( #$ $ # $*

!# ## ! '* ( .

& '% "# !

$-($ # ! ( # $*

" #

$ %&&'

'% (() &*+

$-*&,.*+

/,% !12&%

.%)

3&45 /7& /.* -3

-22%%&% !8%&%

"359!8%&'

00% $-8'+

(& %

3&45

"354:9 "*2 11&2&9

& 21'72& " "8% &

.3&,% 1'7 .,&.

",2)

2 ,, ,,%% 73 & %354 &, 58

%7 1%&) 1'7 .,&.

21'72& " "8% -'%%9((( ( &

.3&,% 2&'7 &&, 3'

(<=) ,,

1'7 >% 02, & 5%% 43,.2&

/&?5' "312 -3 (&, ,'8, %

* 1@ -3 *',

54 &5'

1&33% 02'7 ,%, 21'7 , 8

%3,,& 0&&'

%% 18, 21'72&

( >% 03* *', 2 ,* & 21'7 ,%

&' *% 02'7 11&2&) *

3*7 &&, 23% &%, % >**

02'7 ,%, 21'7 3&5' 2

0&&'

%% %3'&.

02 21'7?% ,*

00&.

11&2&% % 2

3% %18 0&&'

&,& 02'7

,%, 2A&.

1%% 58 -'%%9((( () '.''7 212%%5'

11&2&% && .&, 0

'1% %&5' 1,) >** 23% %10,

3'%

* &%,& %3* 21'72&

8%, .* >** & @%, &7 2 03*

* 54 5&.

&5' 02'7 . 8

0&&'

%% >** 0% 2 ,*

%' 5,9>&&) 21'72& &&

'2, 00, >*8 '1% 2

0 %% 8

( *% 5& &%,, 111 * &,

8> >*' 1'7 & 11&2&%

A&.

'3 02 1'7 8&2& (&,

21% % &,&% %

8'5' &'7 87 ,%8&.

% 8&% 8'5' 3

, B3 1%% 83% ,12&% &%32,

*% 11&2&% &%,5'7

,3&.

8&% 7&.

3 32&% 02

1& 2A

*% *% , 0'& & 00&7

>A&.

,12&% % %%

8&2& 2A&.

%'&% 02 >, *

-0

&,,%

(21%& 31 &

>''

'% 1 '.2 .* 73&.

B3'0, 1%&% >* >&.

* 3& 5&.

3, 83% ,12&% 8&2&

* " 8&2& *% ,,, 8> 1'7

& .3&,% %'7) & ,%&

/&?5' "312 -3 (&,) % 2%*

D32 .1'

%3% " /7&C) 0, %

58) * 8&2& *% &%,, ''

&%3&% %%3, 02 2 2 &

11&2&% *% ,,, 8> 1'7

18, 5&0 &'7 ,%8&.

&,,% % 1

,&% 1@ -3 0,

*&0*) 548 "*2 '2, .&

& .3&,% 1%&% >*

0''

.% 2&&, 5'>:

$ +

,1&,& 225 02'7 ,%,

8&2& 21'7) >* ,% *&%%

#(( (#(E

$+ * 02'7 &,.& ,%8% 22,

%%%& '0 02 0&&'

,%3&

3*7 &&, 23% &%, % >**

02'7 ,%, 21'7 3&5' 2

0&&'

%% %3'&.

02 21'7?% ,*

$5+ 11'& %*3',

'.5' %35' 1% ''

%1 3&,

18%& '8& 32& 3'%

#F( "

11 . '2 3', '@, >*8 03&,

&%%7

(& % %8, .% "- -)

>,>% . '@& 27 ''>, % 1 1'7

&%3&% %%3, 02 2 2

* '> . '2

%*3',) *>8) & % '@, 5'>

. % 31 C-C 5'>

= 7% %

31 C!C

/>8) ,2&%8 !12& 27

'@ 311 . '2 7% ,%8&.

. '.5'7 %*''

,2&, >* 0&

, 11'& ,

$5+ '@& ,3&'

B3'0&

12%%5'

/>8) 31 C!C 2&232 *

%&,, &%%7

31 C-C 11&&.

3*7 27 21'7 '@ &,&%

1%%&.

3&45 #&.3. 1, %@ 2&*%

* 1%&% % 11&, %*''

*8 1%% &

@2&&

3&45

#&.3.

B38'&

3'& %&,, *%* *% B3'07 %

&&, #&.3. H&.

!12&

,3&)

3&45 >*& 1%5, 1,) (0 * %*

0'% B3'07 %) *%* 27 ,' >* 'A *

21'7 % 1 3'%

$+ * 102 % &&@39

27 3%,

!12& 00% %&&.

'&.

,32& % .8& &&@39(() %352,

11&&.

3*7 >*& 1, = 2&*% 02

, ,* ,%5'7 1%&21'7 %

% 27

11&2& 23% 2, >*& 1,

& 7 >*& !12& 7% *

,12&% *3.* 9,1'72& -''

&3& 5',

B3%%

& &&, &'7 >*& 1,

7% 02 , ,* ,%5'7 21'7

1%& >* %1'

118'

%&&'

!12& && !12& I

0 > $

( # ( '!

# 62 4

( '

# $* ( ' '* (

& '$

6 :%/(( 8,, % >* ,%,

8&2& 21'7 '8% 5*&, *%* 2&

*',&) >* %3,7&.

2 ,*

21'7 B3'0, & 21'72&

8&2& %13% 1%& 4&

8&2& 45) ,1&,& *', 27 ''>,

11'7 -21&

3*7) >*& 1, & 7 02 ,

&&.

. 247 ,3&'

B3'0&

319C-C C!C 8&2&

& *32&& &%,&%) *% '% 5&

,,, % %1'

& 2 2%3 @&, *%

5&0% ''

', ,%8&.

(& %3* %%) &

11'& 21'72& 27 2, >*& %@

2&*% 02 , %%3 *% &%3&%

',7 2,

* ,2&%8 !12& %*3',

21' 1%% .8&.

21'72& >* 1,

&& 2&*% 02 , %%3& *%

&%3&%

03* '@& %*''

''>, 3&,

&7 32%&% I ? (

(

# % $ $ '!

(

(# ( / $*'& '* # : ? (

( ( % $

$ ( '!

( # ( ' $

## ! !# ' ; ( $*'& '*#

$*( ##$

' '* (#

* ! (

(

( $*((

# ( & ' $ 3 ! #

( ;

( '!

( # $

6 : '$ / # 62 4

(

( # ;% (

% '!

( !# # $*$ $ $

5 * '* ( ) $

(

1 1 ( ( $ $

( # #

( -(

(

( # 6 /($ ( /

( !#$ * 2!

(

( # 4 !

##$

!# ## ! : %/((/ $*#$'* # $

0 -(

% !

(

(# !

( ##$

((

* & ' '& $$ ' (/$$# ( & '3 ! *

% /(( / $* #$ '* # $

@0& 73 B3% -'%%9( 1%

*% 32 & .3&, &%B3& 31&

,* 73 *3%5&, "*

.,%* "&.* .) >*

>% & 21'7 *% 32

*% &02 73 % 1 B3'0&% ', ,>&

" 8

1%& *8&.

1%%, * %&,,

$>*

3&45 % %354+ '& &',

-'%%9( 1% & .3&,

*3.* % 1

0 %352, 73

E3 *8 1%%, * %&,,

@2&& 02

27 "*') &.

E3 *8

%3,,

3&45 31 * %&,,

8& >&.

%352, 73) >% 2&&, 73 *8

1%%, &7 @2&&

3&45 #&.3.) E3

*& '.5' -'%%9( 1% *%

32 & .3&,) 73 B3%

-'%% ( 1% & .3&,

>3', &%,, % >*& 73 %352 &%%7

10 *8&.

1%%, * %&,, @2&&

3&45

*% 73 &02& 1'%

",9 $(& &.'%*+

%,&)

-&%32 !%13%

,%%'

32)

>&%**I

% !

(

( # !

##$ : 6 '!

( ( / # ( % $ & ''& % (

!# ## ! ! *' %/((/ $'*# (/ *

$ 1 / (# #

! 6 (

(# (

(

! & *

: * # !

$ 3 ! % ( '!

##$ , ## ! !# ' /(( ( ' & '* # ( ((

# (& '$ 3 ! #

( %/(( 5

## ! # $* # $

##$

!# ## ! '* *

(

(# 6 8 ! ( # $

( $* # '

% $ $* $ 3 5 $

#!'$ %

(

(# ( $*'& '*# $*% # '$ /# 62 4

( $* % ' # $

( !/ $( / ( '&

( # /( ( .

! !#$ *$ '((<(! ($%/( * (

(

(!#$ *

5 $

!#$ *! ( #

& ( .

! & '% # ($ ! * ' $$ /

##$*

!# ## ! '* ( !# * / ( #

! (

(

! & * $ 5 $

. # AB A"B ## ! -( # / $

' ##$ '$ (# (# /

(

( $*/((

( 6 ( # ' $ $*

! ($ /( / * ( !

(

(!#$ * -(;

B'$#! "### $

%&'# $( ')* + ,

- # $ ./ .

0! /($ ( !$ ( ($ <

% 21&'7) /.* -3 ,, A &

&%,& & 2% %.&0& %&% ,1,

,% 1%%, 11''&% $,,

+) &2'7) 3&, ,,

& .3&, >% 12%%5'

>*& 1, * 7% 02 , ,*

&&, 21'7 *&%%

47 *,3 "&.*)

5* "&.* *, ,, & <

&,,3

5* "&.*) &

.3&,) 3&, ,,

3', *8 5& &%,, &'7 ''

*0)

5* "&.* >% &,, &'.5' &

.3&,

&,'7) & 0%, .3&,

8> -22 &%3, 11''&%

&%, '2% ,1&,&% 21'7% >* *,

,, *&%%) 8, & , ,,

;) *,

@'3,, &2% 1%&% &'3,&.

5* "&.*)

02 '% 1&,&.

%% &

.3&,) 53% *7 3', & '&.

11&, & .3&,) %& 2 *&

* 7% *, @1, 0 ,* &&,

5, >&& *&%%

/, /.* -3

53&'% 11', * 2&, 0%, 19 &,& '.5'7 &

.3&,) && ,&% %%3, /.* -3

53&'% >3', *8 5& %%3,

"3* ,&%

3', *8 5& %%3, &'7 >*& 17 11*&.

53&'

/.* -3 *, %5'%*, 12

0 %) ,2&%&.

03'0''2& 2%

&,&%

%13',

3'%.3'&%1'7

&%3&%00

22&,)

'8&

%3*

&%,&

/, 0%, %21' @% 5&

, 3) >3', *8 5& &%%7 @2&

2 .& .&

(& &%& %) &

%21' %%3 11&2&) * *8

5& 1, 3&,% '.&) 0% 2 50

-9''*5, &*) *& 50 -9#3A&>

-6

&*) *0) 50 /.* -3

/.* -3 2 *% &> 5& , *% -3

(0 &'7 19B3% '.5'7

5* "&.*

.3&,

@2&,) >3', *8 5& &%%7 @2&

2 .&) 7 .&

* &%& 5%8&%

*8 5& ,, &'7 ,2&% *> 43,'

,00& '8'% *% 5& >%, &&&.

08'3% '.&

"3'7) 53%

5* "&.* *,

11*, 43,'

032 && 7% 0 ,*

*% 0*) >*%) &

.3&, 12%%5' &'7 >*& * 7% ,*

5, >&&) 2 ,%8, *8 5&

4, %. 0% &&2&

H &%&, , 8&

11&2&% .3', &2%

H* %3* &2%

*8 5& ', ,>&) %2 *8 %'7 0''>,

H* '2% & .3&,)

@,) 8'5' 8&% $>** & 0'',

>7 11&2&+) %'& 1%%

*% ,1, 21& 3*7

* %,

1%%) &%%'7 *% 0) 5%, &

218 21%%& .,& '.5' &,,%)

& %2 %3* 'A & *8&.

&@3% 54

%3.* *8,

(& * >,%) >* * >

&,,% 53 &'7 & 8&7 8'5') * %*3',

') &%1& 548 &

,2& >** > %*3', *%&

5%& 1%5, ) 0 %'& 1%%

*% 0''>,) % *) @% , 3

*%&.

& > &,,% .&% %'7

8'5' 8&7) & %*>& 5%, & %&)

091'7 && 5&%%

* 87 54 2A&.

18%&

& .3&,) 18, %3 02'7

,1&,& & 8&2& 21'7) >* *%

3&03&'7 ,, *&%%

& %3* ,*) 02'7

%3,,&'7 0&,% %'0 , %%) & 3&

5%& % %' 5, >&&

!'7 %A&.

%3*

'2) & & *%%) 131% >**

>% &8,

!'7

%&.

%3* '2) &,7 54 %3.*

*8,

* &%& &8%7 8'% 8&

*3.* 47 *,3 "&.*) 0* 11'&

$ 5* "&.*+ %A&.

.3&, *, ,, & <

5* "&.* %3.*

43,'

,%%) 0% 2) 11*&.

-9''*5, &*

%3* 2) * >% &

%388&.

.* & .3&,

3&, ,,

% ',7 &, 58)

& .3&, 3&,

< 12%%5' >*& * 7%

,* 5, >&& *&%%

&>) %@&

7% *8 1%%, 57) % %3*) * & &

%388&.

-3% 53&'% %*3', 0''

17 &7

%721*7 %7&,2) % % %%3 ,&%

11&2&%) >*3 0&

1%5, &2%

-3% %311%, 7 "&

-'3%?% 5.

& -*%2% 8) ,%53% .0

11&2&) ''

*% >* %A

3?%

&8&&

-3%

53&'%

23%

3&,%&,) 87 %3* %721*7) 21%%&

,%&) >*& ,&% %%3,

& .3&,) 3', ,18

''7 &,7 02'7 B3&.

0&&'

%311)

*57) 13%* & 1&37 3'7 &,.&) ,%3

218%* 02'7

!%& *0 3', 3

) 2%1', %721*7 21%%& I 0 8 ( (;

B'$#! 1

+ 2#

$3 /( ($

* 87 54 ,1&,&

,%, 21'7% >* ,, *&%% '8

3&@1, 22, *,%*1 ,%%% 3%,

02'7 %3,,& ,2% &&.

225

02'7

"& ,* 3, >7 5A

;

)

>** 7) 11''& >% 03 7% ',) &&

%, * &', 11&, 0 * &,

247 '&.

(& * >,%) 0 &&&

1,) 23&% &* 2, 32&

,1&,& ,%, 8&2& %8& >**

&& &3.,) , *% 32& 3'%

)" 9(

( 2#4 # +

$ "!( ($ C& 1&1'% >** ''7 ,%&5' 02

83% 43,'

1,&% 0, 58)

2& ,1&,& ,%, 21'7 && '2

% .* & *%* &&.

247

3&'%% 3'% ,2&%8 &%3&% >**

.3'

21'72&21%%&

18, &%,& '2 %3*

,1&,& 0 *%* 52% 24) -3 &&

%%3 > &3 2&,23% ,&.

135' 21'7 11& %3* ,1&,& 0 '1%

2&7 7%

( '% &%%& 8> -3%

'&.

2 .1 5>& , ,*

21'7 , %352%%& 11'& &

'.5' ,1&,& %300& ,> & &0&

02'7 ,%, >% , &,

-0

%%%&

@9.

21'72&21%%&

: -( "#) +

$ ./.3 (5!( ($

( >''

%', 135' 00

B3, 2, %'7 ,*&.

2&,7

B32&

-&%3&

-21%%&

& @1& .&'

8%&

*% 5& 2, , *'1 58&.

02'7

22,'7) >* *% '% % 5, &) , 8

22, %%

-21%%&

.* 53 &%%&

.8&2&135' 21'72&

*,7 00

"3* 18%& *% 5& 2,

18, 22, %3 ,1&,&%

,%,

8) '% >''

%',

&& '2, % 2

.* %1''7 0 1%%. 2

*% ., & 2, 43,.2& "312

-3

! C# / (

% (#

## ! !# '

* ! (

(

( 6 /((/ !

( $ /

-(#

$ /

$ ## ! !# '

! (

( !#$ *! %/(( '3 * !

(# ( '

1 ( / ,

( # % '

% ( !# # $*$ $ $

5 *

'* ( 5 $*% (# / # !/ (

( (# , < D< ( ( # '$ D<