High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19342/2015disposed of

Jasvir Kaur Chahal & ORS. v. State Of Punjab & ORS.

2015-12-24Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh12 pages

"#$ %$&'(')*

+"(,'+-".+/"/"0")%#/$+( $#'#')$+( ,$+(.( 1#"#$ .)2"3")%#/$+( $(4)%$)#( * 56 1 6 1

+$($)#* +1"7$$+1"&/%$,"8%,&"#$8

+#/$4$#'#')$+( +7'#1$#/'8%%08 .)2"3

++$(4)%$)# +1")2$$,1/"+7"81+%,&"#$89'#/ + 1"3'"8%,&"#$8

++$(4)%$)#:

/")%';"+/ +).4"7.4#"81$)'+%,&"#$9'#/ +".#"7 "#/")'"8%,&"#$8

++$(4)%$)#:

")2"3 )',$+('#< +'7"+ +$$#1'%/.8%,&"#$8

++$(4)%$)#:

)') )%'" + "/'"8%,&"#$8

++$(4)%$)# :

6 18 +"0!

=>?

<#/'("440'&"#')84$#'#')$+8+"(,'+-".+/"/"08 ($$@(#9'#/%+"9"("4$#'#')$+ +7#/'(4$#'#')89'#/0'3$+#<#"44+"&/ #/'(.+#";"') ++$%+$(("0 /$+;+'$,")&$(8')"&&+%")&$9'#/0"9 $ +$#/$"440'&"#')'("009$%8'#)$$%(#3$(#"#$%#/"##/$ +$(4)%$)#:

%7')'(#+"#')+$(4)%$)#!/"(#"@$)"4+$0'7')"+< 32$&#') ') #/$ 9+'##$) (#"#$7$)# '0$% #/"# #/'( 4$#'#') '#($0 '( )#

7"')#"')"30$'),'$9 #/$ "&##/"#$740<$$( #/$ %7')'(#+"#')8 9/'&/')&0.%$("00#/$4$#'#')$+(8 "009'#/')#/$4.+,'$9 1$&#')

#/$%7')'(#+"#',$+'3.)"0(&#8= +1")2$$,1/"+7"80$"+)$%1$)'+&.)($0"44$"+'); +#/$

%7')'(#+"#')8(.37'#(#/"#8"("7"##$+ "&#8#/$&)#$)#')7"%$3< #/$4$#'#')$+(')4"+" #/'(4$#'#')8##/$$

$&##/"##/$+$'()#/$+ $A."00<$

'&"&'.(+$7$%<","'0"30$##/$78$B&$4##"44+"&/#/'(.+# .)%$++#'&0$> #/$)(#'#.#') )%'"8'(')&++$&#8'),'$9

"&# #/"# #/$ $740<$$( #/$ %7')'(#+"#') "+$ ')&0.%$% ') #/$ B40")"#')#1$&#')! #/$&# = 84.+(.")##9/'&/#/$'+

'+(#+$7$%<')+$(4$&# +$%+$(("0 ")<;+'$,")&$+"'($%";"')(##/$'+ $740<$+8 '$ #/$ %7')'(#+"#')8 9.0% 0'$ 3$ +$ #/$ $)#+"0 %7')'(#+"#',$+'3.)"0")%)##/'(.+# /$&)#$)#') 0$"+)$%1$)'+&.)($0'(3,'.(0<&++$&# ")%#/$4$#'#')$+(&")3$4.##&(#()#/"#&.)#8 +%$0'3$+"#$0<7"@');

")')&++$&#(#"#$7$)#9$,$+8(')&$#/$4$#'#')'(3$');#+")( $++$%# #/$0$"+)$%$)#+"0%7')'(#+"#',$+'3.)"0/")%';"+/$)&/!8")%#/$ (#"<;+")#$%'(3$');,"&"#$% +#/$+$"()(3$');;',$) .+#/$+"/$"%8 )#/'); .+#/$+'(3$');("'%)#/"#'((.$++$&#0<8#/$",$+7$)#7"%$') 4"+" #/$4$#'#')(/.0%)#/",$3$$)7"%$ )($A.$)#0<89/'0$"009');#/'("440'&"#')")%4$+7'##'); 4$#'#')$+8+"(,'+-".+/"/"08#9'#/%+"9 +7#/'(4$#'#')8'#'( 7"%$&0$"+#/"#'

(/$/"(")< .+#/$+;+'$,")&$8"#"(.3($A.$)#(#";$8(/$ 9.0% '+(#"44+"&/#/$$)#+"0%7')'(#+"#',$+'3.)"08 ++$%+$(("0

(.&/;+'$,")&$

/$4$#'#')$+(')#/'(4$#'#')"+$($$@');"%'+$&#')##/$ +$(4)%$)#(#"009#/$7#&)#').$')($+,'&$#'00#/$";$ > <$"+(8') ,'$9 #/$0$##$+%"#$%

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

$ #/$ (#"< 4$+"#'); ') ",.+ #/$ 4$#'#')$+(8;+")#$%,'%$+%$+%"#$%> 8"009');#/$7#&)#').$ ')($+,'&$3$<)%#/$";$ =<$"+()$$%(#3$($##0$%8"((.37'##$%3< + 1/"+7"8 3$ +$ #/$ 7"##$+ '( #+")( $++$% # #/$ 0$"+)$% +'3.)"0 /")%';"+/$)&/!8'),'$9 #/$ "&##/"##/$(#"<9"(;+")#$%3<#/'( .

8")%#/'(4$#'#')9"(+%$+$%#3$/$"+%"0);9'#/#/"#4$#'#') #/"(3$$)4')#$%.#3<0$"+)$%1$)'+&.)($0 +#/$ %7')'(#+"#')8 #/"# #/$ 4$#'#')$+(8 9/ "+$ "00 $740<$$( #/$ ,$+)7$)#&00$;$(')#/$%7')'(#+"#')8"+$;,$+)$%3<"($4"+"#$($# +.0$( "( +$;"+%( #/$'+ ($+,'&$ &)%'#')(8 9/'&/ "+$ #'#0$% "( #/$ )%'#')( 1$+,'&$ )')$++'#+< /")%';"+/740<$$( .0$(8

))$B.+$ 9'#/#/$9+'##$)(#"#$7$)# '0$%3<#/$("'%+$(4)%$)#!

.0$ #/$"

+$("'% .0$(+$"%("(.)%$+*:

" !

$ ),'$9 #/$ "&##/"#$740<$$( #/$ %7')'(#+"#')"+$ (.32$&###/$("7$($+,'&$&)%'#')("("+$$740<$$( #/$,$+)7$)# .)2"38 +1/"+7"#/$)4')#$%# .0$> #/$ .)2"3','01$+,'&$

.0$(D0.7$:8 "+#!89/'&/+$"%("( 009(*:

E%&'( )*

-. /

* *

' (

+, 0

&1/ * #

'( # "2 3 '6( )* #

" ! )

+'78 +(

-. 0

-1

) '( ! 0

# #

) '%(: ) #

4 "

* #

-. ;'

( : #

'(' ('(

# # #9 #

/$("'%+.0$'("0( 009$%.43<('B5#$(58))$ 9/'&/ '(+$0$,")###/$'((.$ &)#').")&$ #/$(#"<+%$+') ",.+ 4$#'#')$+(8"##/'((#";$"#0$"(# ),'$9 #/$"

+$("'%+.0$(8 +1/"+7"(.37'##$%#/"##/$ &"$ #/$4$#'#')$+('()#'%$)#'&"0##/"# #/$4$#'#')$+') 89/'(")$740<$$ "4+',"#$&00$;$"

'0'"#$%##/$

)',$+('#</$+$ +$8#/$</",$)+';/##&)#').$')($+,'&$3$<)%#/$ ";$(#'4.0"#$%')#/$(#"#.#+<+.0$(")%"((.&/8#/$(#"<+%$+;+")#$%4+'+ ##/$+$(4)%$)#(4.##');')")"44$"+")&$')#/$($4$#'#')(8%$($+,$(#3$ ,"&"#$% 6$"+)$%1$)'+&.)($0/"("0(4')#$%#4"+";+"4/ 4+$0'7')"+<32$&#')(+"'($%')#/$9+'##$)(#"#$7$)# '0$%)3$/"0

+$(4)%$)#(")%8#(.37'##/"##/$4$#'#')$+(/",$"&#."00<3$$) ;+")#$%$B#$)(') ($+,'&$ +"4$+'% )$F#9<$"+(3$<)%#/$";$

=<$"+(8"('((/9)')#/$#"30$4+,'%$%')#/$("'%4"+";+"4/ 9+'##$)(#"#$7$)#4$+.("0#/$+$ (/9(#/"##/$4$#'#')$+9//"()9 9'#/%+"9) +7#/$4$#'#')8'$+"(,'+-".+/"/"089"(;+")#$%") $B#$)(') )$<$"+.4# 84$#'#')$+81.@/%$,1');/89"( ;+")#$%")$B#$)(') )$<$"+.4# >84$#'#')$+8 1/"+7"89"(;+")#$%$B#$)(') #9<$"+(8.4# ")%4$#'#')$+ 8$$0"7";4"089"(;+")#$%$B#$)(').4# 8";"') +"

4$+'% #9<$"+(/.(8#/$+#/")1.@/%$,1');/8"00#/$+4$#'#')$+( /",$"0("0+$"%<5$B/".(#$%5#/$4$+'% $B#$)(');+")#$%##/$78# &)#').$')($+,'&$3$<)%#/$";$ =<$"+( +1"&/%$,"80$"+)$%&.)($0 +#/$4$#'#')$+(8)#/$#/$+ /")%8/"((.37'##$%#/"##/'(4$#'#')")% ? 83#/

4$+#"')');##$"&/$+( ,$+)7$)#&00$;$(83$&)#').$%#3$/$"+% "0);9'#/ #/$ #/$+ &))$&#$% 4$#'#')( 4$+#"')'); # #$"&/$+( #/$

)',$+('#<")%'#("

'0'"#$%4+',"#$0<7")";$%&00$;$( 0#$+)"#',$0<8 /$ (.37'##$% #/"# #/.;/8 ) #/$ 4')#

2.+'(%'&#')8 /$ &"))# 32$&# # #/$ 7"##$+( 3$'); #+")( $++$% # #/$ +'3.)"08/9$,$+8')#/"#$,$)#."0'#<"0(8#/$(#"<+%$+3$"009$%# &)#').$#4$+"#$")%#/"#'((.$3$"0(%$&'%$%3<#/$+'3.)"0 $"0((.;/# .+#/$+#'7$#"+;.$#/$7"##$+)#/$'((.$

&)#').")&$ #/$ (#"< +%$+8 #/$+ #/") ,$/$7$)#0< "+;.'); #/"# #/$ 4$#'#')$+(9.0%"0(3$$)#'#0$%##/$3$)$ '# &)#').');#'00#/$";$

> <$"+(8 ') #$+7( #/$ 0$##$+ #/$ ,$+)7$)# )%'"8 %"#$%

= +1")2$$,1/"+7"8/9$,$+8&)#$)%$%#/"##/$4$#'#')$+( )#3$');)#/$("7$ #');"(#/$$740<$$( #/$ )',$+('#<")% 4+',"#$ &00$;$( "

'0'"#$% # #/$ )',$+('#<8 #/$'+ ($+,'&$ &)%'#')( )$&$(("+'0</",$#3$&)('%$+$%')#$+7( #/$$B'(#');(#"#.#+<+.0$(")% #/$3"0")&$ &),$)'$)&$3$9$';/$%"&&+%');0<$(.37'##$%')#/"# +$;"+%8#/"#'),'$9 #/$ "&##/"##/$4$#'#')$+("+$)#"#"00$)#'#0$%# &)#').$')($+,'&$3$<)%#/$4$+'% $B#$)(')"0+$"%<;+")#$%##/$78 '

#/$<$,$)#."00<(.&&$$%')#/$'+&0"'73$ +$#/$+'3.)"08#/$+$0'$

9.0%83,'.(0<3$;+")#$%3<'#"&&+%');0<89'#/+$7$%<";"')(##/"# 4$)##/$+$(4)%$)#(! )#/$#/$+/")%8' #/$'+&0"'7'(+$2$&#$%8#/$)'# 9.0%3$'74(('30$ +#/$%7')'(#+"#')#+$&,$+ +7#/$78#/$("0"+< #/"##/$<9.0%/",$$"+)$%")%&)($A.$)#'"03$)$ '#("+'(');#/$+$ +7 $)&$8'),'$9 #/$(#"#.#+<4+,'(')(4')#$%.#8/$(.37'##$%#/"##/$ ')#$+'7+%$+%$($+,$(#3$,"&"#$%

$ +$&)('%$+');#/$7"##$+9'#/+$;"+%#&)#').")&$ (#"<+%$+4$+#"');') ",.+ #/$4$#'#')$+(8)7$+'#(8'#)$$%(#3$ (#"#$% #/"# #/'( .+# /"% '# 7"%$ ,$+< &0$"+ # "00 0$"+)$% &.)($0 "44$"+');8$,$))= ")% 9/$)#/$7"##$+(/"%$"+0'$+ 3$$)0'(#$%8#/"##/$'((.$ &)#').")&$ #/$')#$+'7+%$+89.0%3$ %$&'%$%3<#/'(.+#4('#',$0<#%"<")%#/"#&.)($09.0%"%%+$(( "+;.7$)#() #/"# '((.$8 "'0'); 9/'&/ #/$(#"< 9.0%3$0'"30$# 3$ ,"&"#$%$)&$8#/$(.37'((')7"%$3< +1"&/%$,"#/"#/$3$;+")#$% 7+$#'7$#"+;.$#/$7"##$+#'00#/$)$B#%"#$ /$"+');"

#$+#/$9')#$+ 3+$"@!8'()#"&&$4#"30$##/'(.+#8'),'$9 9/"#/"(3$$)"+;.$%) 3$/"0 #/$+$(4)%$)#%7')'(#+"#')83#/89'#/+$;"+%#2.+'(%'&#')8 "("0()7$+'#( &)#')."#') #/$+%$+;+")#');(#"< )7$+'#(8#/$&)#').")&$ #/$')#$+'7+%$+8')#/$4')') #/'(.+#8'(9/00<.)&"00$% +/$"

+$("'%+.0$(;,$+)');#/$ &)%'#')( ($+,'&$ #/$4$#'#')$+(/",');3$$) +"7$%.)%$++#'&0$ #/$)(#'#.#')8')7<4')')8#/$("'%+.0$(8A.",$+)7$)# $740<$$("("+$3<;,$+)$%#/$789.0%/0%#/$ '$0%,$+")%"3,$ #/$ )',$+('#<"0$)%"+")%8.)0$(("7$)%$%8#/$<9.0%4+$,"'0,$+")< (&/$7$ +"7$%3<#/$ )',$+('#<+")#(77'((') ("7"##$+ "&#8#/$/)530$1.4+$7$.+#')

!=1>8/"%&)('$+$%#/'( '((.$")%/"%/$0%"( 009(*:

<&= *

& &-

& 6=-&

# #

0 #5

,++A

+) &&

%1=

+++) -

# # #

< 74/"('("440'$%3<#/'(.+#!

/.(8'#($$7(3,'.(#/"##/$+.0$( +"7$%.)%$++#'&0$ #/$)(#'#.#')8"+$#/0%(9"<,$+$,$)#/$ $;.0"#')( +"7$%3<

#/$ /.;/#/'(#9.0%3$;)$')#') .+#/$+%$#"'03<#/$ 0$"+)$%+'3.)"08/9$,$+8'),'$9 #/$"3,$8 ')%"3(0.#$0<);+.)% #&)#').$9'#/#/$')#$+'7+%$+') ",.+ #/$4$#'#')$+( /$&)#$)#') +1"&/%$,"##/$$

$&##/"##/$(#"<+%$+ ') ",.+ #/$4$#'#')$+(%$($+,$(#3$&)#').$%"(')#/$&"($ 4$#'#')$+( ') #/$ #/$+ &))$&#$% 7"##$+(8 9/ "+$ $740<$$( #/$

)',$+('#<")%4+',"#$&00$;$(8"0(%$()#7$+'#"&&$4#")&$8'),'$9

#/$ "&# #/"# "%7'##$%0<8 #/($ $740<$$( "+$ ;,$+)$% 3< #/$ ")2"3

)',$+('#<&#8?")%#/$(#"#.#$( +"7$%#/$+$.)%$+")%#/$ )',$+('#< "0")%$+$#&89'#/)+$ $+$)&$#")<(#"#.#+<+.0$( +"7$%.)%$++#'&0$ #/$)(#'#.#')$)&$8#/$&)#$)#') +1"&/%$,"8'(9/00< 7'(40"&$% ') #/"# +$;"+% ")% '( +$2$&#$%8 ') +$0"#') # #/$3"0")&$

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

#$+7( #/$(#")%#"@$)3<#/$+$(4)%$)#(83$ +$#+")( $++');#/$7"##$+( )")<&"($8#/"#"4"+#8#/$&"($ #/$($4$#'#')$+('(%'

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

$+$)# +7"7$73$+ #/$#$"&/'); "&.0#< (.4$+"))."#'); +7 ($+,'&$8 "# ")< #'7$ %.+'); ")< "&"%$7'& <$"+ 3,'.(0<89'#/$"&/+$#'+$7$)#8#/$).73$+ #/$#$"&/'); "&.0#<;$( %9)8#3$5+$40$)'(/$%5)0<.4))$9+$&+.'#7$)#(3$');7"%$$)&$8 9/'0$ +$2$&#'); #/"# "+;.7$)#8 '# '( 7"%$ &0$"+ #/"# ' #/$ +$(4)%$)# %7')'(#+"#')'#($0 9'(/$(#&)#').$#/$4$#'#')$+(')($+,'&$8%.+'); #/$&.++$)#"&"%$7'&($((')8+3$<)%8#/"#9.0%3$$)#'+$0<"##/$ %'(&+$#') #/$%7')'(#+"#')'#($0 ")%,"&"#') #/$(#"<+%$+9.0% )#(#")%')#/$9"< #/$4$#'#')$+( #'(7"%$&0$"+#/"#"00#/$"

+$("'%3($+,"#')(7"%$3<#/'(

.+#8"+$)0<')+$0"#')##/$'((.$ ,"&"#') #/$(#"<+%$+%"#$% > 8'),'$9 #/$(#"#.#+<+.0$(4')#$%.###/'(.+#3< 0$"+)$%&.)($0 +#/$+$(4)%$)#(/$+$ $+$)&$##/$2.%;7$)# 1.4+$7$ .+# ') B

" C (.4+"! 9'00 "0( 3$ &)(#+.$%8"##/'((#";$8)0<#3$9'#/+$;"+%#&)#').")&$+,"&"#')

#/$(#"<+%$+/$0$"+)$%+'3.)"09.0%8)"#.+"00<89/'0$"%2.%'&"#'); .4)#/$&0"'7 #/$4$#'#')$+(8"('(7"%$.#3<#/$78&)('%$+#/$$)#'+$ &"($')$B#$)( 6$"+)$% &.)($0 + #/$ 4$#'#')$+( 0"(#0< (.37'#( #/"# #/$ 4$#'#')$+(/",$)#3$$)4"'%#/$'+("0"+'$( +#/$4$+'% +9/'&/#/$< &)#').$%')($+,'&$84.+(.")###/$')#$+'7+%$+ #/'(.+#8%"#$% > /$ +$(4)%$)#:

%7')'(#+"#') 9.0% 0@ ')# #/'( &)#$)#')")%'

#/$("7$'( .)%#3$&++$&#8("0"+'$( +#/$4$+'%#/"# #/$4$#'#')$+(/",$&)#').$%')($+,'&$83$%'(3.+($%##/$7 +#/9'#/ 9'#/.#")<%$0"<89'#/'))$7)#/"##/$7(# '#/#/$"

+$("'%3($+,"#')(8#/'(9+'#4$#'#')'(%'+$&#$%# 3$#+")( $++$%##/$0$"+)$%$)#+"0%7')'(#+"#',$+'3.)"0/")%';"+/ $)&/!8A."4$#'#')$+(#