High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1935/2015dismissed

Dharambir & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2022-08-31The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli15 pages

!"# $ %&'

()*"

# "#"" +!,(* (-.-(/"#"" 0++12+)0( 34( 5(-( 6+!+7+++)0( 3(4)(

(*8 & 6

)+/),+/!04( & 9-&+/)) ),++/+7++:0 & 6+-+20 &+./ (((+ ),+ + +7++ +) &( ;-(0+)4;&+,0+)+/),+/!0(4)( <<<< 0(+40+)2!),+1.0+0+,=-( 4,).(,+)-)0!,+(((-)-)6,>%?! 0 @+) ,=-( ,/ > )+) "

"## +) "A

"##" (4,7B!:)270+:+))+)">

"##>/027+,=-.0 +)!+4-2,4-4(/+17!0)41+)-C+!+) +( ()+/ +) 11,+ 6, A 64+B =-+ 0 +) ! 0 4(0+(+4():!04((!6,">$"'!0 .0 +14(++)+(4+,7@+),=-( 0+2+ +) (1,/"#

:.0,(7-4)+(.+)(04+ !04(!6,">$"'!0,!"# /91+70:

4(/ 0 4,).( 0 (+ 4 : 94 +27+, +:+.0),(!06-41-!)+ 0,(7:+( !+74-+(27+(-,0!06-41-!)+

!/4-1+4++.+40(0!+4)-,)02:*8 "# $ % & '

('( & ) % &

& % & % *+ %

%& % * & ) - ) )) %% .& , & - % & + &,

& & '

('-(% & % *

& % / % - * 0 ) "1 & '( - )

- "1 "1 0 % &2 &, & '(% & % * 3

& % % % &

& % & + % - 3&

- )+ & - 3+&

+ % &

- + - 3

4 4 % & '( % & % * & % &

& 0 &2& % 5

& '( & - ) & 6 % ,

-%&'

)( % %& %

&2 & % & % /

- &

&&&) %

& % *& - , & * % &2 & % / -% %

+ & *% & &-, 75 %&

'& (

% &2 &,&%5 ) &

6 % ,%% +&

& % * - 8 )8 % %& % &2 & % & % / 9 & - &

& * '

(% & %

/ + & &2

& '( 5 5 % &

& 0- , &

, & * '

()) % &&

), %& % , &

+ & & &2

&, & '( % & % * ! 0 & '(% & % *

- % & '( % & '

('-( : 0 % 3, & %

/ &

& '(-), %2 ; <&)- 3, & !% & % / +

& '(% & % *+& -

3 & '( / 0 % & '( , % % &,

&- & % & 3 &

%% -% & % * & %&+ &,% &2 , ) && 0 % - & % - & - .& &

& '(% & % * ,

)&%& 2 , %&&

&, % &2 &

&, , %%& % & % *+ + 5- & && &,

)

) 2 , % % 3,

&, % % &

% & &2 1

0+0(-1+)(-2(+,!04+!6,"> $"'!0,!"# 270D26-41-!)+(0+0!( +) !1( ,) (9 +4(. ( 0+ 20 0 ,.,( 4)) +2-0407(,+4((((+)04+71!,14(+ + 2 !-!)/ 1+. 027/ ! 0 ! 0 ,)( ( (+(!)/0 :-)2 +4(.

(!+ +(0 2.+ 1+9 0 4+71-!0+)+,=-)(,,)/0+(2,+!)0+

(-,0 2.+ 4+7 ( ,14 27 ). 0 ,14(+ :0,0 :-)1+0+0,14(++1-:+(1+)+++20+) :+)!00+(+,,4)0(+1/:2+++2!0 +):,+10+0,14(+0+(24+) 61+7/0 :) E)4(F 0+( 2 4) 1+ )4(. :0 0 @+) ,=-( , 0 +(-7 0 !, - +:. ! 4+,0+1+ 0+( 2 ,()) 2 + +) 4! ! +9. 407(,+ 4((((+),0+)(+)(()06+/0()(. 4)) -) 6, "> $"' ! 0 , ! "#

0 D2 6-41 - ! )+ 0+( !-0 ,+!) 0+ 0 4) ! :0,0 +7 1 ):+(4+/:2G,-)):0,14-.0.+44)! !7+( 61+7/0+(2,+!)0+6,">$"'!0,! "# )(.(+:,+-(!+,=-(0.+7! ,,-))4,).(!+)+,=-(+(+44(70(,+(( :004,).(:4).0)+!!,1!,! "#

> (40,+(4-!02704(/07+:(! 0 +) ,14() ;0+(+ HH # $ ?' +) "I $#8

' + 1+(-.I&++((-+)0-(+!5+.+.+;++/ 6-2 0( +/ (, 64+ 0 +) =-( 07 0+ ,(-,) 0 ()+ 0-(( 0 (+) +) :+( +,=-) 27 0 1 ! +7++ 27 ((-. !,+( )+) "

"## +) "A

"##" -) 6, > % ? ! 0 @+) ,=-( ,/ > (4,7 !:) 27 +:+) )+) ">

"##> ! 0 4-2, 4-4( +17/)41+)-C+!+)+( ()+/+)11,+ 6, A/ 64+ ( 0 ,+( ! 0 4( 0+ )(4 0+.

+-,)0+:+)">

"##>/0(4)(0+!+)+90 4((((!0+)=-(+))+07+04((((! 0 0-( ,(-,) 0 07 0+ !-0 4+)) 0+ 0 +1- ! ,14(+ 0+( 0 2 4+) )4() :0 0

!, - 0!/ 0 +,=-( 4,).( =-+ 0 +) =-((+)(+4():!6,">$"'!0,!"#

!+).0,(+()270(4)(/ (14+2,)0/0+0-.04+7,+-(!04:+( (7)01++(2: *8 = ) % & 2,

, %& & !% &2 & + / +.>;>;

& + )&+ % -,- + )% + & + & -, ) %

& '( % , ?

0 & &2 + -

& + *+ % & +9+ !+:+/+ +

+ '(+ !+9@/%0&2 & + / -, % & ',(+'%(+'6(+ + '

(+ +:+/@ % 7 & , > + + & &

% % > - 3

- A + -, %

% 6 &2 ,&&&-, % & + !+ + + * @ * % % + %6 &B ((+7 0 ! 0+( 2 ,+1) 7 :0 (4, 0 +44,+27!6,">$"'!,!"# +)+,,).7/::2 ,(). 0 ((-( +() 0 (+ 4 +( .+)( 0 4+ ! 6,">$"'!0,!"# 7 ?

,+/ & 9- &+/ +) ))+ ),+ + +44+. ! 0 (4)86+ ! +7++ (-21( 0+ 0 (+4)((2)(1(():!0+:+)):270 D2 6-41 - ! )+ 0 ,+( ! ) 41

-07$(-4+'+(!0,.,(4(,2)6,">$"'! 0,!"# +!-!) 0!(+)!1(=-1,+1 +4(. ! +,=-( 4,).( ( 4 0+ 0 +) : ( 4((((!0+)=-(/:0,004(0+!+)4 +(04((((!0+)=-(:+(+92706+27,).

+4+ C+1,0+ A )+)">

"##>/:0,00+(20)+(++) 1) ! +9. 4(((( , (-,0 4(((( ( +9/ 0 +) (( +2(-706++):0(+(1+(04((((! 0+)/0(+(4+(( !-0(-21(0+02.+!06+ 4+70,14(+(+)()-7)(,0+.)+(0,14(+ +1-:+())+01!+-,1!+:+)+):+(1+) +++2 0 +) :( ( .+)( 0 +) =-(/ 0 ,14(+ :+( )4() 0 +,,- ! 0 @+) ,=-( ,/0!/(+++2!)(2-(1 (-21(0+1( !0G4(!+:1+))41-07$(-4+'0 2.+ ! 0 6+ 4+7 0 ,14(+ ( )(,0+.

) , (-,0 +1-()) 1+)+++20+):( ,-+4+71 )4(0!,-(,((+7+)(0(+.) 0(,01!+)+,=-(,/ > ,,).7/00+(,)) 0+(,!0,.,(4))-)6,">$"'!0, ! "# + !-!)/ ),++ +( .+)( 0 +4(. ! +,=-( 4,).(,+21+)0.!+,(+),,-1(+,( I 0+( !-0 )+: - + :+)( 0 !+, 0+ 0 ,(-,+()2704((-+-0C)+(0(+10+(2 +():0-+9.+741((+))4(.0,(,0+.( 0-.00+)(4+!!

! 0 -J+2 6,0)-) +)( +) ) +( (,( !

.-+) 41 ,/

0!/ 1( ! 0 +: +) ):270D26-41,-!)+0,+(!03

%C >'

(/! %

+) 7) 73 D& &

% C

E> ::

% / 0 4( + ) +7 ! ( .+)( 0 0 4+( +() 27 0 4(/ 0 0+( (-21) 0+ 4( + 4,-)) !1 +(. (-,0 4+( +( 0 : 4 0+( 2!)+!

7+(!04+((.!+:+)+)+((-,004( 2+)27)+7+)+,0( 0+,0(.+)0+(24+,) 0J-).1(4+(()0,+(!

E'(

% C '

! /+ & & , CF,'(

/; )3> >

% 6 G0/'(/ +. 0+) 0 (4, +.-1(/ .. 0-.0 0 (4, 4+).( +) +2 + 0 G4( ! ) 41 -07$(-4+'/:+!0,())40+0(+4 (+22)(1(()!10++(

!"#$

$&$'( %"!&)&*+% ($& (!&) (!,%&

04(0(+40+,+1)20 407(,+ 4(((( ! 0 +) =-( ( ,+( ( -4 27 0

((0+0-.00+:+):+(4+(()">

"##>+)07 )),0+.0+,=-(4,).(2-0407(,+4((((0+( 2 +9 !1 01 0( .+)/ 0 (4)( 0+ !) 0 : (+1 (-21. 0+ 4(((( :+( +9 27 )+:.

4+,0+1+ 0 !1 ! +4+ C+1,0+ A )+) ">

"##> :0,0 0+( 2 0) +( + +) 1) ! +9. 4(((( ! 0 +) 6, ?!0,! >4)(0++!+9.04((((!0 +)/((06+!!1+,-12+,( 0!,0( .+)(1+)0!:.4++.+40(!10J-).1*8

! "

#$ %& !

( "

$% * +) ,

( "- "

" ! "

$%."

)

/ ."

! )

" &

)

) )

" 0 & ."

! !

% %& + ) ) &

& %

/ +- 3, & % 03, & % * ) 3, & %

A &2 ) % 3, +

3, & % < , &3 % ) )& &2+ A

&%& &

- % %)& - &2&

& )

" ") )

( 0-(/ : + ! 0 ,()) 4 0+ 0 407(,+ 4((((!0+)=-((+)()-7+9+)0-(/04+!0 4(!2.407(,+4((((!0+)=-((:07 1(8,,)+)(+22J,) $-#%& !($&!-$+&('$.( %"!&)&*+% ($&/!

(%&)%.%)

# 0 (4)( 0+ ,+.,+7 4+)) 0 : (+10+0+1-!,14(+!0+,=-)+):+( 1+)+++2+0+):( (0(+)!06+0+0 +1-!,14(++(.+)(0+)=-(:+()-7)) +) ( 7. )4() 0 +,,- ! @+) ,=-( , 0!/ : ! 0 G4( ) 41 -07 $(-4+'02.+!06+4+70,14(+()(,0+.)! 0+1-!,14(+()):0,00+(24)1+ 0+0+1-:+(1+)+++20+):(+(2() ++ "#:0,0(4)-,)02:*8 2*+ & !

' (

+ $ %

3 3

" 4

C) +& % - ) ) -&,% - , 3 & & - % %

3, - "

" )

+ ++$! "

5 "

)

" ) "

+ %

)

) " )

+) !

* * +

6 "

7 8 "

) " ,

+ $%)

C) +& ) ,

+ - & *+

& 6 "

7 8 " )

+ 9 !) ."

1 5 0!/0,!040+,14(+ +1-0+(2,)2701(1((+)0-(/(027J,) $&%$'( % $&)($& #.% .0%)&% ($&12314$'( % ($' 1567!.%'+"'""%)

0 D2 6-41 - ! )+ ) 41 -07$(-4+'0+(,+72()0+!)1)+4(.!+,=-( 4,).(-)6,">$"'!0,!"# /200,)( 4+71!,14(++)+9.!4((((1-(2!-!) ! 0 ! 0 ,) ( !-!)/ 0 +4(. ,+ 0+44 0 6-41-!)+0+(2()0+0:)EF,,-.6, ">$"'!0,!"# 1-(2+)+(E+)HF +4++(!10 J-).1+4)-,)02:*8 2 - 8 " 5

$%) !

&")

)

* +

" & ) "

( ") '

( "

( ' ( ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, ,,,,

* - :; 7 & <

- =##)8

> 8 "

) ,

(

"" " - !

@ '$ +% - !

)

" - ")3 3 3 33 3- =, 4

3 3

$ %!

) " ! ! 3- ) 3& ,

(

) 6-&9673 ) !

" 3 )3 3

-) )

) ! !

)

! !

- " " ,

7 )*** $ %-) !)

)

& !

3 3 ! !

" !

" " !

& "

" - "

"" " " !

" ,7 )***5 $ 0% & ."

@ - "

A- " &"

($ " % 0+ % % &2 &, )+ & '(%- - 3+ + & 3+ &

+ &2 &,

0,+(+0+)+(!,)!1047!)/() 0++!0+:+):+(+-,)">

"##>/0407(,+4(((( :+(+927,). +4+ C+1,0+ A )+)">

"##>+)0 ,14(+ +1- :+( )-7 )) 6, ! 0 ,)( 4(,2)6,">$"'!0,!"# +!-!)/0!/(+)

4(,+2)-4270 (,+1+4(.!0 +,=-(4,).(

%&(!"( $'( %"!&)&*+% ($&

& 9- &+ 0 (.0 ! 0 !+,( 4+)) 0 :(+10+(017,))0+06++,=-)0+) ! 0 4-2, 4-4( +17 ! )41 +) -C+ ! +) +(

()+/ +) 11,+ 6, A/ 64+ 0 +) =-( ( 7 1-,0 ((+ +,0 0 4-2, 4-4( +( 0 (+1 ( 2 4+) +) )4) +,,)+, :0 0 +7- 4+ 0+ ,()) 0( 4+ ! +.-1 +() 27 0 (4)( +) : + ,14+.1:00(+1+(0((+14+!+,294 1):0)+.:00,+(+(.-!0+,=-(!+) +,0 0 4-2, 4-4( +) ( 0 6+H( +-07 :0 ( 2( 4(),)+2--C+!0+)+,=-)/+!0+.2 ()06+

> 0 +) =-( ( (-+) :0 0 ,) ++ +( ),+) -) 0 4(( ! -J+2 6,0)-) +)( +) ) +( (, ! .-+) 41 ,/

?/ :0 ! +(.,(-,!+79)/441((!0,14+-07 (=-) 0,+(+0+)(-,041((:+(+9:0,014( 0+,(-,+()(-+-0C) (4)27& &++44+. 20+!!6+!+7++0+0(,-++,,+(+(:/ 0+(,())0+(4,+(:0002!!+(,+2.+) + +: 2+9 +) 0+( +(:) .+ 0 ,+( ) +( %/

) ! ,%(!& )+ !($&!"$ %( 8(!(%$'!.

!&!!&)$( %.

8" 9.(%(($& $::66$'155;271+9.0!:.2(+(*8 "........In this case, admittedly, land in dispute falls in the Controlled Area declared in the year 1964 under the provisions of the 1963 Act. No construction in the controlled area can be raised without getting a prior permission from the competent authority. In this case, a full-fledged building was constructed without caring for the existence of the provisions of law. Not only the initial construction, the petitioner continued to construct at different dates with a view to get recognition for running the higher standard classes. Furthermore, it is an admitted fact that the land in dispute falls within the limits of Municipal Corporation, Faridabad (previously Faridabad Development Complex).

Before raising the construction, building plan was not got sanctioned from the competent authority. Photographs Annexures P-4 to P-6 indicate the extent of construction as noted by the Land Acquisition Collector i.e. 30 ft x 80 ft. At the time of arguments, some photographs were shown to the Court, depicting that the huge construction has been raised on the first floor of the already existing building. When confronted, in affidavit dated March 9, 2011, Janak Raj Khatana, Chairman of the Society, has gone to the extent of For Subsequent orders see RA-CW-314-2011, RA-CW-3382011, RA-CW-370-2011 and 1 more. 1stating that the construction was carried out in the portion of land which has been released from acquisition and as per approved plan (P8).

The perusal of the document Annexure P-8 indicates that the so-called building plan was never approved by the competent authority. It is only prepared by an Architect, to which no sanctity can be attached.

raising construction during pendency of this writ petition. A litigant, who has no respect for the law, this Court feels, is not entitled to get any equity by invoking the provisions of Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India.

A litigant, who has no respect for the law, this Court feels, is not entitled to get any equity by invoking the provisions of Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India. Under similar circumstances, in a case titled as Cambridge International Public School v. State of Haryana and another, CWP No. 2958 of 2011, decided on March 23, 2011, wherein the construction was raised without getting any prior permission and a prayer was made for release of the land from acquisition, a Division Bench of this Court observed as under:

'...Otherwise also, we feel that on account of violation of the provisions of the Punjab Scheduled Roads and Controlled Areas Restriction of Unregulated Development Act, 1963, no relief can be granted to the petitioner. As per the provisions of that Act, to construct building/ change of land use, permission is necessary from the competent authority. In the present case, it was not done. It has become a fashion to violate the provisions of law and then to make an attempt to get relief in one way or the other. Attitude of 'sab chalta hai' cannot be tolerated, this has to be stopped one day, to make the people to be respectful to the law and its provisions.

A violator of law, who has no respect in the established system of rule of law, cannot be granted any relief when exercising jurisdiction under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India. Adherence to the duties as enshrined in Article 51-A of the Constitution of India is must. One can claim his rights under Chapter III of the Constitution of India only if respect is shown to the duties as contained in the above said provision....."

0 +!(+) : :+( +!!1) 27 0 4G - +( 0 64,+@+ !)+.+(0+!(+)J-).1:+()(1(()

# # "# "

+ +.1 :0 0 +!(+) : +) 0,+( + 0+)(+)((=-+7,):00++)0+2 (=-7/

0+. +() -+-0C) ,(-, :0- +7 4 +44+ ! 14 -07/ 2! ! +( ,+ 2 G)) 0 4(

( + (=- ! 0 +2 )(,-(( +) : ! +: (-11+C) 4++ ? ! ) 41 -07 $(-4+'/ (4,!,+7 +! 0+. ,)) 0+ 0 ,+( + 0+)/ 0 407(,+ 4(((( ! 0 +) =-( 0+. 2 +9/ 0 2.+ ! 4+71!,14(+)(,0+.)+)+(,().0+0+) =-((71-,0((++,004-2,4-4(/:0+ 0(+0)0+0(+,+(/06+0+(!-7)(,0+.)( 2.+=-+ 200 ,.,( ,,-.(,">$"'!"# ,+)2.(/0(+4()(1(()

I +. )(1(() 0 1+ : 4/ + 4). +44,+(/!+7/+(10(+1!+ 0:4()(1(() 6+-(=-/!+7/(+)(+,+) $ 56; ' 6 $

@@'

-.-(/"#"" +) 00(4+9.H+() (H 004+2 (H