← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20046/2014dismissed

Naresh Kumar & ANR v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-03-31Mrs. Justice Raj Rahul Garg26 pages



      !!!!!



         

 

       !

"#$

   



  

!

"#%$ & 

'  



  

!

"#(%$ )*+ 

 



  

!

 "#,%$

  

 



  

!

"#%$   



  

!

"#$(( -  

 



  

!

"#.%$ -"

 



  

!

" "#( /   



  

!

"#.(

 

 



  

!

"#(%$    



  

!

"#$((

     



  

!

"#(%(

 " 

 



  

!

"#(((



' 

 



  

!

"#($(((

    



  

!

"#($,,(



 



  

!

# "#..,(

  



  

!

"#.$,(

 )* 

 



  

!

"#..( /  

 



  

!

"#.,(

 

' 

 



  

!

"#.%(

+  



  

!

  $ %& &

   00 +

'1&/ !   0 /2!1&&21  0 + *1

&/ 3  0& '2*1&/   ! . 0

/-

'*1&/ 456 07'8 0* -1&/ !!* 

"0.$(:

00

1&/ !!* 9

"05($: 02

1&/ !!*

"0%:

0 

*1&/     



 

    

   

 

  

  



'  ;

+'  **

! "#$$ * '  3   8/     3   !

 '    

< *3   

/*/

**!

 =

-     /

1     /  8  >     "#  $$ ;!   -

'< 

' *  *

9&

>  ?:  38       /  8 *    !!

       !        ;   !      

( /

 @ ,9&

>?: ;!  8

'* 8* <* !!*  !       ; 

 !        /

 9&

>?:&**  **8 13 ** /  @ 

  3 **

/ 3 ; *  *

9&

>?:3 

!*  

*  38

     !   ?

  *  ; 

*  ) / *8 *   8*   1  ! 5 @2 15 @ "15 @)"&15 @)") A 0@2 0@ "1  A 0@)"&1  A 0@)")  '  3  *  /           ' 2 @ "@)"&@)")   8 *     !   

 

 9&

>  ?.:  

 1   *;  *  )1   -*1  * .,9&

>?,: ($ 9&

>  ?%:

 8  "      2/    

   3

 (%$8

" # *



'   3 8 /!  ' /   3      !          3    -      <*     3  

!*  * ' 3     *  

*  3>- 38'

/  '<*   ;!  8

'!  '  8 33 -  5 !   %%$1 *



*   3  

!*    %$ 

 3      

/

'! '<*  3'

/ 3-  '

) <*  -  8



/ 3 3- 3  

* *

 6

 **1' / ! 3 3

'3 -  '<*   *3 *8

'3 - 

/ 3-!

* *  & !   * 3 1.C- 3    <* 

C- 3

/ 3 

    

 "    ,.(1      1  A*  A  3    *

 /  3  /8  8' 

 3 !

 8 !3 */

'     

3/8  8' 

6  !* 

1

 /      %,(  3   *  8  0  0/     -1

 1   *  "

 *

'



!8 !! !8"

 !

*

'  *      *   ! 

  

  *    ( 9&

> ?@:18

!*  2/  

*A  ! 1" '1 / 

*

3-

' 

  *  ;  *   )  9

;

):

 -*        0

 *    3      8 !*       

! *        *   "

": -* *!

'"  1 ;6

   *  *          *  ; 

*   )  9

;

):  

       ( 9&

> ?@$:18/ 

* 3* /*

*      */      3        (  9&:   8*+

   *  "

 ;

 1   *  "

 * /  ! 

  

  8      *  ; 

*   )   6

**1     1     *  ; 

*  )/

,.!  ;

 '  

  ! > !03

  .!  ;

'      

   03   *  /   /

    , 9&

> ?:  ;  *

  !!* 

 3 ** ' ' "?&"0* !

) %$9&

> ?@(: "  -

'

* 

3 

* D8) ,9&

> ?@: &  

/ 3  3    1    )   */  /    *

% $,$ .,$ 9&

> ?@.

 ?@,:  !  /*!8*   *  

3 !! !*

' 38



;

) 3

   *

A  !  ; * 3 !8*

 $,$!  ;"'  .,$!  ;"' !  /* ;1)1/ * ,$9&

> ?@%   ?@:          *

      !      ;

"'   2 *A* A 

 =

 !* $

"

"#$ *E! " #$ #

%     &'   )  /    *  $  

(%$9&

> ?@: */ * **11 "'1=B 10B 1&  - 16 / 3 -     2   *  -     *   *

     "    8 !* 38

) 8+  *  ** 8 

' %%% 8!* ) 38

 3 !

'

'"& 

'*1  3 !*8) 38

 %$6              )    3  -    ! ' @0A3



/ 3-  *

   -  * !'

'3 *!*

   )  38

 ;1  

 

-  3       /

 

  3  !*      )B  38

  

%$ &'

''

 / 83 '   - 8

'3- ! ' 

'3- 

/ 33 8 * 6  !* 

"(,(10  / & 

1 !'3

/!* * 38

 8     *  /  %,(  / 1   3 3-

' !'

   8

  *  ;  *   )  -*

'! ,(;

33 /*! ; *  

'* /

* 8

 1  FG  /  (1   *  !  %   *    **   3    !

! 

   *   ! 

 3

* D8  *;  *  )9

;

):

 !        *     ! 

  

$,$&-

'

=

* *  3   - 8  )     3  !*    38

;8 -! *8  *3  " * &

  !  !3 3 '

/  -

'!    *  ! !3  /" *&

   -

' &   -

'      3  !*      38

  

%$;)1  ' *    3   8 * *

  -

/ /?/ 3    ! ! * ; )'

  -    *!

3 

3  * 3!!* 

! *1  *1/ //  ' *=*     *  3       

'  **  -     

<*  ''8/*/  * H1 1 ' 1     2 @0A1 0 *1 

 !  8

/ * *! ' 3 ''@ * -

 *    / /?/  

       *   * *1   *

/ 3- 3 3 ! '

- 

/ 3- 3 *- 13 * 

*  3  3  *

 -   &     1    )  '

 !*    *  

;

)38



3 

  

' ***  



 *

  3   3  !*    %$     %$  5

,(1  3    

     /  

8 *  !  3 ! 

"13  ! ! 3 

!

*  * * 

< ; 3     8  *     -! 

          '

 9&

 :

";1/  * %(1  !

    " * =

G8  " '  3 '      /      >!* 

 '

/  8   !       *     ! !'

  /  *88

";   3 *    *D



@

8 * !  ! 3  /8    !*

' /

 /

 * 3 3 *

'

   '

9&

 :

"63

         

@

8 *  !  3* 8 - !

8   D 

  

!



'"    3 * 3*8!  *

!   '

9&

 :

"

 D



 ;!

  3 '

"

* / 8 >

'  3 + %(;8/   

3'

/

-!

'

/ 33  



 * "   -     )*+

 

'  3       

 

" 

** * *   *

 3 -  6  !* %(10) -1 !   1  " * =

 G8  * ! %( &! *

! 3 " * !/%  FGAI / 8  

**

 > ?

1 1 1 $  .;3 8 -! *

' ;  9 ;: 

 1    '    8   8 -!   * 1 

;

)J"J J""J  3  /> ?

$ ; 8 -! *  * 8 ! 3 8  31 FG /(= * 8 8 -! * 1 ;J8 -!1

*1 ;/8

 /> ?

. ; 8 -! *  * 8 ! 3 8  31 FG /( !  3 3 !

8* 

' !

' *



' 31" * !/%3 ' ;3*/ *8 8 -! * 148 -!

*2;/ 8  />  .;!   / & 

1'1

"1 -* 00 + 1&

 

"1" '3! 

** 

  / %(1.%(1,%(1%(1 $%( %%(

 "= G1" ' 63  

!   () #  *   +'  ,

'  %##-'

-   



 

./0 

 

          #  (.

1 .   (-   ),$   3 )

%# #4'  ."           

              3536 37   

  $  8



%##-'-  () #* + 



         #  (.

1.    (- ),$ 3 )

%# #4'." 7    () %

 



 



 

                       ./0 

   3536 37(%# #4'- 9.

.

-  ( 1*),$ 3 )  $  8



%##-'-  ()% 



*#

 -  1-'     

 $     3       $ $1$ "

   #     

     0   /   & 

1  "! '1 !

3 '

/  8  3 - 38  *1 2 @0A *  -   3- 

# *

/ 3- *   '

2 ;*8



3- 3 / // - 3 

  ** 3 / / /  -     8  8

    

! 

3/1

!%(" *=

G83  '8 * 8

"

%("= G * !!* ! (6 

!!*   !1    3  *       31  " * !/%  8 1 FGAI 9 < 

3 (:/ 8  

**

> 1 1 1

$  .;> ?

(   * 8 



'

';  *8      

 

* 

 8  >  3      

1  

 '

  '

 

'



1

  8    ' 

 **3

 63  >!*

   A> ?(

   1 

 

 *  

1  3/1  '

'  *    8         

* -*  31" * !/% 8 1

FGAI 9 < 

3(:8

**



> 

3/1  

 

 3 "4   3- 1

*/3   

8 /@ /; !* 38

 %$ %$  8  

> ?

1 1 1 $  .63

>!*



!

  "  -1 

 /1*!   - */ 1- 3 

/ // - *

/ 3- - 

8    *     -    !

*  * !* 38

 %(6   )*+



'1 /9(:- /8 3 / // -  9:-  8   -



* * !* 38

 %(;  83  

* /

 *!* 38

 %$ %$ !  /*/8  8-  /      8/

-1 / 0  / & 

  

%(  K0     

 "

 :   $$   3;

'' '< '.

< 2*='*. './  

    $     

     

2 " 



$ $$   

  L 3  8  &   3   3- *3-   <*   ;

*!

    

    8/1 

*?>!*  

!

8* 

* * /*

  *!*  8

    

   

 !! 

/

   !!* ! *   -   /   3

!

8* 



- 8 >!*

5 ,(1

! 8

 8*  1

( !

* * 3 "3 

* 

3 -    3 8

/ 3 " & 8 / 3 8

"!  1  !

* *3  1  *3  

!' / **

  1

-  !

  

* *  

'

/ 3-       

/ 3!

'

/ 3

/ 3  - !* /!* '! 8

>  1  1   3 '

/   *

/ * /    / ?

/ 3

'"   "  >!*

'

!     !8      *     *  



  8     

/ 3

   13 3

/ 3 & /     '3 1    "       * ;  *  )1 -* 7'

 1 08  *;  *  )1 -*   2  "   1    08      * ;  *  )1 -*8  *

 !*  ,( &   0+ 1A>?081

;

)    *81 /  * 8 *6  /  *8"  08 1 

      

'           )    3   

!

   ;3 

 *!

* !

           2/  @"

   ;   /*    8 !! 

) 80 '3 3 !!

 "  

  *  ;  *   )   ;   

/ 3 " 3- / // >  -  *;- @3    3

/ 386 / 3" 3 *  ;

/ 3 * !

3 

  - 8  3  - @3  &

/ 3 1 * 3  !*  *-         / /  /   3             *

  3   

'* !!;

/ 3 3*/!  !

' * ,   * **3-

' %(! 3  *  ,@%     3    !!  8    

/ 3        '

/       !!> *  (@.(   

!!/86 / 3"  ;-

3



/ 33 * 8



 3   /  *"  

*  ;  *   )   ;   /   *  8   08   *

"   &  '

'  '    !      "= G   %( ( 3**  /  *80  /  & 

1"!'1   *  "

3 8 /" *&

 "!3  / *8*;" *&

 "!

8  ! 3 3  

' *  *13 3 

$,$;

 !3 !  ,$

*     !!    



'  !!

   *   ;  )  3

8     $  8    5

   ;  " * &

 "!3

      *

  &

8

')1 ! 3



    A   !        !

*     3



 "

!

 '

/ 8  

*  ;  1   A  3

  *  / 3 '

 3 3  *

'  

" *&

 "!1 3 3 '

/ 



 3 3 / *8*3 

/ & 

 =

 3 

*3 /

 " *&

  !  !* 3 (1  / 3

*  8  0  0G    -1  6& 1    1      A 

  -*  6  

  / 1        '/   *  / ! 3 3 /8

*  ;  *   )1   -*  * '  3    !

  *A  ! ;8/

 ! /*8  / 

"

,(;) /

 

!*

  

  !   1



  1    *A   *

' !  

* '*  

 ' ;) /

'

    !  8  **

'         !  

" *&

 "!;



/

    *

    !     /         / &

> ?666 (  &  * / 3 *  *80/   -1

 1   *  "

 

  2/    /        $

8 @!*  *;  *  )& 1 9 

;

)& : ** 3 

;

) 3

!  3  

          *   "

 -*     

              A 

  

* * 

+&*31 + /

1

-3

     0 +  1  &

  3-

' 

;

)1  -*      *   0

 *    3  !*     

! *

"1 -** '3  !* 

;

)  *!

'"  1 ;6 " *

   

;

);   *  "

* 

 ($$( ;!

  *  "

3  

 ((

  0 +  1  &

   3  3          " *  )   8      *  ;  * 

) /     (  9&

> ?@: 

 

   *  / 8

;

) ; 1         " *  &

       * ;  *   )  3  8'  8    0 +  1 &

    * 

       *   "

   



  

   *  "

*

   3 /  -  /  8     

*        

*  "



* 3  1 &

     

" *)  3 *  

'  /     -

'  /  3           

3  

*/ D 0 +1&

  &**



*

'  "!   

;

)  3  

        A  1 

8

'

 *;  *  ) 

 *

* (9&

> ?@: & !"= G!%(10 +1 &

 ! 8   ! *   !

!

*  * 9 ?  ; 9":&/@:

;

)1 -*6 / 3 

 1   3 '

/   1  

*  "

 /!  /18   ! *   !

!

* *

3    0 +&

  " *=

G81" '33 ** *D   8  *!3 '







  6  !*           1  " * =

G8  *!, 

!!* !  "

*      !   / * '    

 - 8 !

/

' *

3 3

 ! 38

 %  %(3  ! / '

/ 80   / & 

1

-   - ! ' 3''  * -

  *      / /  /  

       *   6  

!!* !(1"= G  '

/

>!*     ''

'  * -

'1



- *     *  ! 

3   < 

/ ' 8!*   ' !  / * 8



!   0 +1 &

     3 

  3   '

/    " * =

G81*  ;



!

 / *8%(  !! 

3

!  / * 8 !;'   

*! 

* 8*8+ 

!*  '  !      '

/ 8

"1  "= G>

 ! 3 3 80  /  & 

1  '    !*

'     *    %(   %(13    '

/ "= G>

 

* *$,$ ;

 *3

   0 +       

   

 /       !   ( 8"= G;! 0  /  & 

1  '1 

"1   -*     0  0 +  1 &

  

"1  " '  3  !   

**    

  / %(1.%(1,%(1%(1 $%( %%(

 "= G1" '

"     8/     @

    

    3   - ' 

* *1

>

3

  8"= G3 *!!

'!

3/1    8+       !     

  ! !  / *8%$ 3 ' 

 3 < 8 *00) -1!   9

:1" *=

G8

! 

"3  *"= G! 5 <!8 

"1 



!  /



!  /! ** '3  

3  3 

 3 

!

 /;

 

>!*

8!"= G & !!13   * !**8-     * * ! ; 8 8 -! *  *  / > A

'

/ 8*3  



 



     

  

  

  

    

     ; * !3 * 3   ,$ !**8 -3 * 3   % 

* *3

!! $,$3  8 

!  / ,$  18



! 

* 8 

 3 

!

  /    %     ,$     3    !   ,(  8 

;A> ?A 8 '   * ' 

'=; '  * 

?/

0@ 2   36 14 &5 8

 !

/   !  /

 *  *    !/  1   *       3      *1  * !9 /> A:1  8   

  

 $  '  %   (<2 .<2*=2 '  *. '  ./2)    <  (

25>'! $2<

233)'      '       $          '    

  

 $  '  %   (<2 .<2*=2 '  *.   ./2)    <  (

25>'! $2<

233)'      '              ''  '   '

 *

             

?

"

 '% (<2 .<2*=2 '  *. '  ./2)    <  (

  5>'  ! $2    <

233)  $  

 

 

#   $       

      '  -  "'%# $'+ '#"/$ 4 #  

    

 $      $  & !"= G!1 * !/    * !    3 '  

"   -1     /1  *!

1  - *  /     )*+



'1

* !(1  8 >!*

 *  - 3*88- 

3 !

8*8

'

  *!*  

 8

/* *  >!*

 

   *   !'!      !   (

'

''>

 ! ,  !!* ! !*3  <!8

"0) -1!  1" * =

G818 8 -! *  *

    /           0 +  1  &

 " *)  3 

* *3 !!

$,$1

  '



* *  *

!/   * !   1 ! **1-!

'

/ 3 



!  / !&

>&? 3  !!* 

 !      *  8     



 

    

8

!  /$ ;!  3 *'' /8

-

 *!* % % 



*  *$,$

   



!*

* * 

- -

  <* 

3** / // 1 *  ! 

 < 

 ;

 

3 !