High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2005/2014dismissed

Rajwant Singh And Others v. Registrar Cooperative Societies Punjab And Others

2017-12-04Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!""#$%$&' (

)* &!+$&,-!-".% // "!$!$&".% 0".%1%

",$%!. ./2+#$"!$"%3 1&) 4 &5!-".% // "%2&5"&!%

."%"&!'/

. +6 &,357# !".!-"2"!$!$&".%

.7$&$!7 %!-$33 1&) 4

"!$!$&".% !!-"2$&!$9$&,!-"$&%! &!*.$!2"!$!$&*"." 9 %%/ ":29;""% !-" ."%2&5"&!/ .$: .; 2". !$7" ,.$#19!1."

+".7$#"+#$"!; "!$!$&".%& &5*"."!-"":29;""%."%2&5"&! &/-""-. :+ .$%-! 2". !$7" 19!$/ 1.2%",.$#19!1."+".7$#"

+#$"!;<!532"!$!$&".&= &":29;""."%2&5"&!&=/-"$&2 9>" 2". !$7" 19!$/ 1.2%",.$#19!1."+".7$#"+#$"!;<!5$&2 9>" &5 2"!$!$&".& &":29;""."%2&5"&!& /-"1,.$2". !$7"

19!$/ 1.2%",.$#19!1."+".7$#"+#$"!;<!5 &%! &!2"!$!$&- %4""&$9"5%"">$&,!-"$%%1 &#" .$! ".!$. .$.?1 %-$&,:":5 !"5=$%%1"54;!-"$#"

",$%!. .3 2". !$7" +#$"!$"%3 1&) 4 & !-" %14)"#! 2".! $&$&, ! #9 .$$# !$&.", .5$&,$&#." %"!-" ,"."!$.":"&!4;&";" .!-" ":29;""%!-"7! 1&%"9 22" .$&, . !-" 2"!$!$&".% *195 29 #" -" 7; ."9$ &#" & #::1&$# !$& 5 !"5 = &&"@1." / &5 *195 #&!"&5!- !$&!".:%%1#-#::1&$# !$&!-" ,"."!$.":"&!%!5

// "&- &#"5 4; &" ;" . ":29;""% 149$# +"#!. &5".! >$&,3 1!&:1% &5".! >$&, &5 2"@ 2". !$7" +#$"!$"% % 9% !-" "&!. 9A .$: .; 2". !$7" +#$"!$"% 1&%"9 #&!"&5% !- ! #::1&$# !$& 5 !"5 = &&"@1." / *195 ! &! :1&! ! #- &,"!-"%".7$#"#&5$!$&%!-"2"!$!$&".% &54;7$.!1"*-$#- !-"2"!$!$&".%*"."7"%!"5*$!- .$,-!"&- &#":"&! ,"."!$.":"&! &5#&%"?1"&!9;*- !%! &5%,. &!"54;7$.!1"&&"@1." /# &&!4"

&199$$"5 4; 7$.!1" $%%1 &#" %14%"?1"&! :": 5 !"5 =

&&"@1." /=&!-".%14:$%%$&. $%"5$%!- ! %$&#"#::1&$# !$& 5 !"5 = &&"@1." /7"%!"5 %14%! &!$ 9.$,-!$&!-"2"!$!$&".% !-"% :"#195&!- 7"4""&5$7"%!"5*$!-1!,. &!$&, &22.!1&$!; -" .$&, 1&%"9.!-"2 .!$"%- 7"4""&-" .5 !9"&,!- &!-"#&%$5"."57$"*!-$%1.!3!-"#9 $:%"!.!-$&!-" $&%! &!2"!$!$&$%&!*"991&5"5 +".7$#"#&5$!$&%!-"2"!$!$&".%*1954",7".&"54;!-"

1&) 4 +! !" 2". !$7" ,.$#19!1." +".7$#" +#$"!$"%3 +".7$#" 19"%3 BB( -"."$& !".!4"."".."5 %!-"+".7$#" 19"%3BB( 19"B*195 4"."9"7 &!!!-"$%%1" !- &5 &5$%."2.51#"5-"."1&5".'/

! "#"

$ % &'

"("

) *+

, & *

/=/ 4 ."2".1% 9!-" ."."2.51#"52.7$%$&*195: >"$! #9" .!- ! ,"."!$.":"&!" #-":29;""!-"%#$"!;$%%!$219 !"5 % C;" .%"@#"2!. "&%/#1:/-*>$5 .%3*- ."!."!$."& !! $&$&, !-" ,"C;" .% 1.!-".:."3!-".19"$!%"9&!$#"%!- !!-" ," ."!$.":"&!9 %%DD":29;""%!-"+! !"7!$%E;" .% &5!- ! 9 %%DD":29;""%$%$%C;" .%;7$.!1" & :"&5:"&!1&5". 19"

B *"=."!$.":"&! ,"%1#-":29;""%!4"."#.1$!"5 %14%"?1"&!!=* %4.1,-! !2 .*$!-!- !7!":29;""% -"2"!$!$&".%-"."$&*"."."#.1$!"52.$.!= -"#::1&$# !$&5 !"5 = &&"@1." /# &&!4"

#&%!.1"5 % & :"&5:"&!! 19"B% %!7"%!$& 71.!-"

2"!$!$&".% &;4"&"$! %.", .5%"&- &#":"&! ," -$%*1954" 22 ."&!.:!-"99*$&,."#$! 9$&!-"#::1&$# !$&5 !"5 = $!%"9 &5!!-"99*$&,""#!'/ !

$ / -

&5".%1#-#$.#1:%! &#"%3!-"2. ;".: 5"4;#1&%"9!- ! 7"%!"5.$,-!$&9 *$%%1,-!!4"! >"& * ;4;7$.!1"$%%1 &#" $:21,&"5:":5 !"5= &&"@1." /=3# &&!4" ##"2!"5 -"1&#&!.7".!"5 #!1 92%$!$&$%!- !!-"2"!$!$&".% % 9 %%/":29;""%- 7"%12". &&1 !"5&#:29"!$&C;" .% ," % 2". 19"B!-"+".7$#" 19"%3BB( !!-$%%! ,"3#1&%"9 22" .$&,.!-"2"!$!$&".%*195: >" & !!":2!!$:2."%%12&!-$%1.!!- !!-"." ." 7".:"&!%: 5"$&2 . !-"*.$!2"!$!$&!- !!-"#::1&$# !$&5 !"5 = &&"@1." /

/ / :1&!% ! :"&5:"&! !-" +".7$#" 19"% &5 *-$#- - % &! 4""& %2"#$$# 99;5"&$"5$&!-"*.$!!"&%! !":"&!$9"5!!-"*.$!2"!$!$& 7"&$!- !4"%3. &;5"#$%$&!4"! >"& %.", .5% "&- &#":"&!."!$.":"&! ,"3!-"."- %!4" %2"#$$# :"&5:"&!!!-" .19",7".&$&,!-" ,"%12". &&1 !$& &54;99*$&,51"2.#"51."

9" 5$&,% & ."#.5 ." #:29"!"9; %$9"&! % .", .5% &; :"&5:"&! #!1 99;- 7$&,! >"&29 #" 19"B %$!%! &5% %5 !"$%!-"% :" % - %4""&."2.51#"5 &5&!$#"5-"."$& 47"$&!-$%.5".

&5". %1#- #$.#1:%! &#"%3 & $&!"."."&#" $& !-" : !!". $% # 99"5.

"!$!$&$%5$%:$%%"5

91#>;

-"!-".%2" >$&,A." %&"5'

"%A -"!-". "2.! 49"'

"%A