High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20072/2014dismissed

R.K. Malik And ORS v. Bhakra Beas Management Board And ORS

2015-09-18Mr Justice Jaswant Singh16 pages

!" "

#"$ %!"% &'%" !" (

! "# $%#%

!&%'( %## ) * !

+,*-& .

/0 !

1 (

! .

/0 !

+,*-& .

! ,#*(

*3. 3- !

/0 !

"#)*!"'+, ) "!("

",!*!$ !"-+, ,./"-

"0!."&+*", )1!

"*$'.$(+, ) ""(

4!(+("!)$&! "!

1& " 53$"!$" """6$!&! "( - 77

5,8$"73) 1!!! ' !("!)9"0

& "9""- '" 1!$ (("& !

!! !("6$" -)" " !0$ &'( 9-!/:9 $" $"!"!"( !&" ! 9 !' "$ (" 53;$1"!$" ' '$ "&! "( &"!("!(-

< 7 51!" < =3'( -" ") $96$ - 7< + '( 7-" ")1!

9 $ & ! """ & 1! " >

?("$'$&!" !")1" "&$ " ") " "$ 77 + ! ' ! 9 &" ' "

- $ ("9-!/:9 $"

! " 8&!(- +") ! ( ! ' !$ 9 &" ! ("1!

6$ 9 1! ?

" 3 *")("$ " !(""8" !"

! "

# $$%$

"& ' ' ()* +( ,

' ' -

( ,

/ ,

, ,

, , &

<3 ;!("1"

-(( !9 !4""&("'+* /"- ((' (" "

;!"

("1(( !-" ;!"")1" " %!"% &'%" 5 "!":%% %:31!!

$"-9 -$ 9-!" .)"'("

(") * 5 3" 1!* 573 !$09 "&@,+ 77

;!("1! 1"&!%% %+!"") 1""&$ "@ <9-! "( 4""& ("'+* /"-1 < ) ,8$" 3 ;! " "( %% % '&& ! %" 99""1& ! ") ! '( - "' ! 4""& ("' (""' -+$09+/"-+0! /'! " ! !" A "- %" 1 1!! 11"B 9-)&$9 *

! $09 "&@ ,+ 77 1! " " !"

"()!"6$C"!"!!*(") "- $ !%% % "'&

8( $ &! "

1 !

,!''%% %1! )&* 53 !$09*"&@,+ 77

""$ 1'( -$ ")"$' 1"!"& ! 9 " '! '" ("0 4 ! 9&"$ %% % 1 '( -!1!" ( 9-

"(""*=*A "-%" 1""$

73 ,

! ("

$ " ! " &"-

'( -!1!"( 9-!

"(""*+ ' -+* /"- "(""" ;! ("1"&)( "8"&** "%% % * *%% % 1!&!"!!*: $"

- !("( "%% % ;!%% %! ( *A% ("!-"

D77 ") (- %% %'( - 4""& 1& 1 %% % ! )"$ 1& 4""&1&+%" D

+." 1& C,D ,D: 3 ;!(""6$ %% %)("53

"$ " ) ,8$" " ! ($"( &"

(" -($( '9$ ("' = ) ("'

"= 7-"")!"()(1! $& ! ") " " ! 4""& ("'+ *

/"- "' 5(" + <3

"&$ "@ 1 < " " "

!$"( < " 1!E, ) &

< <

,8$" 3 ;! ""( %% % " $ -8'& '

! (" "0 !" &") 7 7

) ,8$"71!" "! !*$("'$" ( ) ,((

< 1!!1! ! !")9$ "! ($"( 8 &, '9$ ("' " "'C &&&") 9-! ""( %% % 77

+ ! (" 1" ( " ("

E" $ "!("$((" !("-"

$ !") "!($"( &" (" -( $( '9$ ("' = ) ("' "= -"")!"()(!) -" " "="$ "

7 7 " & ") (- %% % '( - 4""&1&("$ "

-"53F53,8" " (""(" $ !"

! "

""#$ ##$ % %%$

$&&'# " %"$&( ) %"$& $&$ *( + $)$&& $%%&$ & !!,! - &&'#" $. /0%$)

$!!,!#&$ "%& $ '1 $# "%& !!,!(!!%)$#&$

+ "%& !!,!$"%$ $"%$ $&'$ $1) $&&'$ #$ % %% $ " %"$&( )

%"$&$&$ " &$ *( + $ )%) $"%& $#

$$& $" %$ $ " ) "'1$# $ #&$$ $$&$# /0$ )

$"%& 2#$'#3!$ 4

$ 5$& # 678 $ 784 8

&&'

" #&$ )

%$ $5)2$"%$ $" %$ $&'$ $1'&&'$ #$ % %%$ "

%"$&( ) %"$& $& $ *( + $)%)%9

4 1 $"!" 9- " $ " ! (" ! '"+ ! $" ! ! ! '( -1!1"(( !9 !") " " !9!4""&("'+/"-* 1$ 9$ "!($"( (" -($( ' 9$ ("' = ) ("' " = 7 -" ")!"()(4" "9$"(":( " ! < (

E, <) ,8$"< "() -

3 E" $ " ! " "( %% % )!' - !"53 !" " 77 53" : -.) %$ $& !!,!"%& 2#$#9 4!"1" + !")" " 9-! %% % !'( -" !9 "53 ! ! '( - 4""& ("'+ *

/"-1!")!)9 " %% % "! "!("53"- "! !")" " 9-'( -!4""&&+%" D

& C,D ,D:

"!($"( $&! ! ") 1" &" (" - ($( ' 9$ ("' = ) ("' "= 7-"")! "()(*!("1"

""$ ! 9!4""&("'+* /"-+! $ 98 !"!%% % !'( -41

$"!" !!"$"-"&$ =.)"' " "="$ "$! !")" " !4""& ("'+* /"- "!($"( &"&(" - ($( '9$ ("' = ) ("' "

= 7-"")!"()(

<3 ;! ""( $ $"!"$9' !! ( 9-!$" %% %1 "(" 9-%% %$ !' ( ! '"< 1!!) "'("+6$ -+

%% %$ " ' !("! " ! (("& ! $" ! ! (" !" 1" ($ %% % 6$ 8 & 9

" "="$ " 77 "4E, + !)%! (("! !"( E, 1"

- (( ! ") ! *

/"- $53 !"$ " 7 7 1 "(" (("(" -C$"!"! ""( $ " 1 "("

!"# # $

%&'

/" ! 0$ &' "!($"( $& ! ")1" &" 9 ("' "' ("'9 /" (" < ! 0$ &' / " ) ,((

<< * /"- !"#*' !" < , 8" ! 0$ &'"(" $ !" : $ $ ) # ;$) <"$4$'$ &1 " $ "$

) - #"$ =$ $$>=$ $$ >$ $ 7? 7$ /%$0 $ '$ % & 3$"$ & %

#$ 7$& **& " %"$& $& $

$& "

#'1$# $ )

* ' &(" %) $ "%& " $) #&$ ) $ %$&$ % 9

4)1 $53 !"$ " 7 7 " 1!! " +!("!)' $ "

"1!,8$"7 77

! (" 9 "0 E" $ " ""( ( $!

) ,8$" = +1

$"!" " !"$ " 7 7 (( 9 %% % !'( -

3 ;! "( $ 1! (& ! "&$' ! ""( $ $9' !!" *$"-$ =.)"'" "="$ " "$&! !")9-'( -!* "&" -") 9 /! ( $! !")" " 9- !("!4""&("'+* /"-1 "6$" 9 " 9-!* /"-!9

-"&$ 6$ $& !") '( - 1" ")9 '("'9 ,8$"" ") (- %% %'( - 4""&1& 77 1!!1$ 9-!%% %+!" "+! "( - "' ("-!("" '& " )&"$ " 77 $ 9-!%% %) ,8$";!" "+!("9"0 "

"( "

73 /" $ " ! (" ("$ ! '($& " "

4$ ($ !!("1"(( !9!4""&("'+* /"- !"

")1""&$ "@ 9-!* /"-1 < <1!!"")1" " %% % 4! 9&"$ +!")" " !9!4""& ("'+ /"-*$ 9 $ " ! ($"(

&"& (" - ($( ' 9$ ("' = ) ("' "= 7-"")!"()( 4 "(""" !%% %;!(":

!")!4""&("'+* /"- "'

5(" 3

5("<3!4""&("'+* /"-;!- 1" !")!%% %91

< ")"-!"(" !,8$" 77 ( #) * + #" $$,$ +" - & . &//)&"&" ! $90+ ) !! "$ " 7 7 (( ! #$$,$+" - & ' & $!

!'( -1!")!)9 " %% %! 4""& 1&+ %% % !"$&! /"- * ;!" "+ " !"$ " 77 9-!("""

!!$90 "$ " 77 "" '( - 4""&& %% %6$ 8 &")&"$ "

77 !'( -1!")1" " %% % " ;!("" $( ! $"( < 4! + ""( "("!&! &!!

!!!("!1"""$ ! 9 ! 4""& ("'+ * /"- 6$ - ! "$ " 77 (( 9 ;!" "+ $ ( " & ") ("$ " ! ("!"" 1!!"$ " 77 ! 9 /+! (( 9 ! (": * E,

<+1!"$ !("!"+! ! '( - 4""&("'+* /"-1

3 ;! ""( &$! (( 9 - "$ "

7 7 & ! (( 9 ! ! '( - %% % !$! ! !'( -

!(" /! !" & ! $90 ! " "$ " 77 +"- "

!(( 9 ! !'( - %% %E" $ "! ""( " ! "(" 5 3<*77

!"# # $

%&'

1!"!,(8$"!! !

!")9$ "!($"( 8 &") 9 )8" " <"

1 G7$ # " $"

!$ "$1&$$ "

%"$&$&'$ #) "%& & "%&# *( + $ #&$ ) ?1'3

%"$& " & #) & "%& $#&$)

"@#&$)4)$%$$#$%

"'$)

$ "%& $ #&$$%%"& & "%$ *( +( $) $ ) $"%$ 3$ '1 $# "%& $ A # " %"$& $& %"$& " 2 !$

$ $& )

"%& %) "

"$ $& %% #$ " %"$&$& %"$&"3$ # A%*( + $#&$)4

$ #&$ )43 $

'& $) A% @*( + $ )4 $)4=')3 $

"$$"%&$" "

B" *( + $#&$ ) $#&$)$$

#$ " %"$& $& %"$&"$$"$ 6

$" $ )3'& $ % '& "

%"$&$&(%"$&" $ $% "%& *( +( $ #&$ ) $ =# ""

#$%%&&$#) " "

#'1 $# )9

3 4 )1 ! ("( 1 ! " 0$ &'+!("" $ !") " " 4""&("'+* /"- "!($"( 8 &($( (-"("' 9 3 $ 7 %% % $ +

H %% % 5 $

'& 1" $ !"' D

" ! %" 3 &$ + 7 %% % ( )"$ $ ! $09) *");! $ &1!*! $ 4" $ " :+ ' $ !$ $"$ %' $ ! &$$&$3$ "$)$%%)$&3 $B '13$ &"3 $ #A% $&& 3 $$"$

3 $ $ 5)" 3 &3 "$$&3 3 #&$ $ &1 % & $ $

-$ /7" "$%7A>09 !012!3- "

-$ )&);&3>&"2%$2,$ ;& -$ )& ) ;&3 >&"2 %$22 /7%% $ "0 -$ )&);&3>&"22/;& &$#$ ) 6 09 & $ 7" 1!*! $ 4+ "! %% %!)

1 " ( )"$$ !$09)

*")$ "!($"( 8 &")9 '( - ,8" ! =

= 573=

" $09 .)"' D" "

" -*($(5D3"

1 :

6 1# % $

$3)"$&3$& $ & #$ / " %&$" $ )&)# A$ %$ $#&)&03') $)$&$ &$$ 3$&& 2 $"%& -$$&$$$##$"""$$ & %"'3% %% '& $ %%

$B$& "

"$&$

)

" "

""" $&$" $& A$

%$ $& $%%&$ "

$ )$%$&$$&$ $ "%& 4%$ A

% %"$

A$# $$&3'&& & $$% %$$&& $ $ 2 $"%& )$$& %$ "$ $$ %" $#$&$ &$1

%"%%$)$&$ & $)$$

%"$&$&3'& #$ '% %/0"&"9 3 " (" - ($( ' 9$ ("' = ) ("' "= 7-"")! "() ( ) =

== = 7

"7"

$ % & #

<3 4)1 ! " ($ +(":

!")" " 4""&("'+* /"- 9 $ 1" &" ( $( ' 9$ ("' ;!("!) ($!!"") 1" 9"9 %% % ' - 9 "$ "

+ 77 4' !)1!(": 1$ 9

! 4""&("'+* /"- /)&"&" ! !!"

4""&("'+* /"-+! ("!)( $-$"-"&$ =.)"' " "="$ " 9- 1!! ! ") " " ! 4""& ("'+* /"-9$ 1" &" ( $( '9$ ("'D!""-+!"("!9 !")" " !9 $ "!($"( &" (" -($( '9$ ("' = ) ("' "= 7-"")!"()( 3 C"

! " "+4' !(! '($& " "77

) ,8$"7" 1!

14+" & -+ '!9)1"( 73 " " 5 6

74189