High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8400/2010allowed

Ved Parkash Gupta v. Hry. State Fed. Of Consumers Coop. Wholesalre Ltd.

2017-03-14Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan9 pages

!"#$#%&'&() * +#$!,-!'. /0"!

#"&"&(#, '

+#,'/'

!,1!(!2"!"##$#,!"&( ('/3#,' 40#,!"&5#.6#'!6#'2",#'

7&3&"#$!($!(".#, #'0($#(" '

) 87 2 9 72 ,#'#(")4 ,'(/ .!",!".9!0/,:2#(&,$5%!"#:;&".:

'&%.!!('!6:$5%!"#:,".#0#"&"&(#, ,3&"!&';!6!($,##0!-!61!(:$5%!"#': ,,#'0($#("'

.#".#,".##0,"#,'6%!6(#;'0!0#,3!1<#!66;#$" '##".#=/$>3#("?

<#,##,,#$"".##0,"#,,(" .#".#,".#=/$>3#("'./6$<#,#0,"#$&(".#$&>#'"? 44 44 72

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

'&(%#* @*A/,&(>

44 ".#9.!,&!,-#"&(>2#!'( 4:.#;!'0'"!'!&'",&%"!(!>#,:

!"9!,(!6 .#0#"&"&(#,;!'06!%#$/($#,'/'0#('&(:5&$# ,$#,#($,'#$(

!($%.!,>#;!'.!($#$5#, ", 2.!,3!:&'",&%"!(!>#,:

:9/,/-'.#",!7!"#,(:

".#0#"&"&(#,;!''#,5#$;&".!%.!,>#'.##"$!"#$ A /($#,/6#'D !($D".#2"!2#,5&%#/6#'".##$#,!"&(: &(;.&%.&";!'!66#>#$".!"$/,&(>".#9.!,&!,-#"&(>2#!'( :.##("#,#$&("!(!>,##3#(";&". '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&:(

,'",!>#!($3&66&(>0!$$1!($$#6&5#,1 /'"3&66&(> &%# &('.,"8 8 "$ ,0,!"&(($&! &('.,"8 8 D A 0!$$1;!'.!($#$5#," '!.!<&,&%#&66':($&,&:<1".# 0#"&"&(#,:;.&%.!&6#$"3&66".#0!$$1!($$#6&5#,".# "".# /0" .#,#,#:".#!%"&(;!'$&,#%"#$"<#"!-#(<1".# &'",&%"!(!>#,:

:9!,(!6:!>!&('" '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,& ";!'/,".#,/($".!"( :!(!>,##3#("#B#%/"#$<#";##(".# 0#"&"&(#,!($ '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&:;!'("'&>(#$<1".#0!,"(#, .#,#,#:(!%"&(%/6$<#"!-#(!>!&('"".#'!&$3&66(".&';!1:".# 0#"&"&(#,.!'%!/'#$!6''"".#

"".#"/(#' :

:D:

5!6/#'"%-'E>/((1<!>'F@ :A :

@ 4E&("#,#'"' @:*:@/0" <1 (" >#""&(> !>,##3#(" '&>(#$ ,3 ".# !/".,&G#$ ,#0,#'#("!"&5# '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&:( ,#5#,:

.#!6'!&6#$"3!-##,"'">#"".#0!$$13&66#$!($$#6&5#,".# " !'0#,".#!>,##3#(":;.&%.!3/("">,''3&'%($/%"/($#,".# 2"!2#,5&%#/6#D ".##$#,!"&( (".#,#061"".#%.!,>#'.##":".#0#"&"&(#,$#(&#$".#%.!,>#' !($%6!&3#$".!"!"#,".#0!$$1;!'("3&66#$<1 '!.!<&,&%#&66':

44 ($,&:".#0!$$1;!''.&"#$,3 '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&:" '

!,&!3!,!'!3"&'/,".#,%6!&3#$".!"!"#,".#'/'0#('&(".# 0#"&"&(#,(

:&";!'".#,#'0('&<&6&"1.&''/%%#'',"3!-# !,,!(>#3#("3&66&(>".#0!$$1!($ $#6&5#, " ";!'

/,".#,%6!&3#$".!"!'0#,".#!>,##3#(":".##("&,#'"%-'0!$$1;!' '.&"#$"!(".#,3&66.#,#!"#,:".#&(C/&,1&%#,'/<3&""#$".#&(C/&,1 ,#0,"$!"#$ A ((#B/,#44 (".#&(C/&,1,#0," ((#B/,#4 4 :&";!'.#6$".!"".#!>,##3#("#B#%/"#$<#";##(".#0#"&"&(#,!($ '

!.!<&, &%#&66':($,&: ;!' $##%"&5#!($ (" !0,0#, !>,##3#(" ;#5#,:&";!'/($".!"".#0#"&"&(#,&'(",#'0('&<6#,".#6''" ;!'/,".#,.#6$".!"".#0#"&"&(#,&',#'0('&<6#,;,(>3&66&(> (( $#6&5#,1 /0"

.#0#,!"&5#0!,"".#&($&(>',#%,$ <1".#&(C/&,1&%#,&',#0,$/%#$!'/($#,)4 ,3".#!%"'(,#%,$!($>!".#,#$$/,&(>#(C/&,1 0,%##$&(>': &" ;!' #'"!<6&'.#$ ".!" 2. + /0"! ;.&6# ;,-&(>!'9!,(!6.!$#("#,#$&("".#!>,##3#(",".# 3&66&(>0!$$1;&". '!.!<&,&%#&66:($,&!($".# !>,##3#("#("#,#$&(";&". '!.!<&,&%#&66:($,&;!'

$##%"&5#!($;!'("0,0#,2.+ /0"!06#!$#$".!".# ;!'06!%#$/($#,'/'0#('&((

!($.&''/%%#'', >"".#'"%-0.1'&%!6615#,&&#$!($>"".#'"%- D 4A 0!$$1&("!%";&".".#&66#,!($".##("&,#'"%-';#,# '.&"#$,3 '!.!<&,&%#&66:($,&" '!,&!3 !,!'!3:($,&( <1.&''/%%#'',(".#$&,#%"&( !';#66!'&'",&%"$3&(&'",!"&( ,3".#,#>&(>!%"':&"&'#'"!<6&'.#$".!"!>,##3#(" #("#,#$&(";&". '!.!<&,&%#&66:($,&<12.+

/0"!;!'("0,0#,!($!>,##3#(";!'$##%"&5#;#5#,: &(5&#;!$3&''&( !($2.22!&(&:;&"(#''".# 6''' :

:D:

40#,"!&('&(".#'.,"!>#'"%-

44 ;!'("%!/'#$$/#"(#>6&>#(%#2.+ /0"!!'".# '"%-';#,#",!('#,,#$,3 '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&"

'!,&!3!,!'!3:($,&;#5#,:2.+ /0"!;!'

,#'0('&<6#,((3&66&(> (($#6&5#,1 "".# /0"

!'0#,".#"#,3'".#!>,##3#(".#%.!,># ".!"2. /0"!#("#,#$&("!(!>,##3#(";&". '!.!<&, &%# &66: ($,&: ;,(>61 !($ !>,##3#(" ;!' $##%"&5# &' 0,5#$I

(".#<!'&'".#'!&$%.!,>#'.##":!'.;%!/'#("&%#$!"#$

*A ((#B/,#44A ;!'&''/#$:;.#,#&(&";!'!$$#$".!"$/#" (#>6&>#(%# ".# 0#"&"&(#,: ".#

.!' " '/#, .#,#,#:

"#("!"&5#0#(!6"1$&'3&''!6,3'#,5&%#;!'0,0'#$ .#,#6#5!(" #B",!%"' ,3 ".# '.; %!/'# ("&%# ((#B/,#44A &' ,#0,$/%#$ !'

/($#,)4 #>6&>#(%#&(".#0#,,3!(%#$/"&#'%!/'&(>6''" ".##$#,!"&( .#%.!,>#'.!5#<##(#B06!&(#$&($#"!&6&(".#'!&$ %.!,>#'.##" -(;".#!%"'".#%!'#:2.2 .&66(2 (#$;!'!00&("#$!' (C/&,1 &%#,:

5&$# ,$#, 4

@ $!"#$ /($#, &("&3!"&("1/ .# (C/&,1 &%#,%($/%"#$".# #(C/&,1 &( !''%&!"&( ;&". 1/ !($ ".# ,'#%/"&(>

&%#,.# (C/&,1 &%#,'/<3&""#$.&',#0,"5&$# 6#""#, $!"#$ ADA ' 0#, &($&(>' (C/&,1 &%#,!66#>!"&('6#5#66#$!>!&('"1/'"$ 0,5# %01#(C/&,1,#0,"&'#(%6'#$ !>,##;&". ".#&($&(>' (C/&,1 &%#,/#"1/,(#>6&>#(%# ".# (#$.!'"'/#,!6''(#!,61'@6!%'!' 1/$&$("#B#%/"#!0,0#,!>,##3#(";&".".#&66: ;.&%. ,#'/6"#$ &(" (( $#6&5#,1 ./># C/!("&"15!6/#$(#!,61'@6!%'I .#,#!"#,:!"#,<"!&(&(>".#,#061$!"#$*A

4A4

((#B/,#44D :".#0/(&'.3#(",$#,#($,'#$( @A * ;!' 0!''#$: ;.#,#&( ;.&6# <'#,5&(> ".!" $/# " #B#%/"&( ".# $##%"&5#!>,##3#(";&". '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&:".#

.!'

'/#,#$".#6''"".#"/(#'@6!%' ";!'/,".#,.#6$".!"".# 0#"&"&(#,!&6#$">#"".#!00,5!6,3".#&'",&%"&66&(> 33&""##:

.#!$#$ <1 #0/"1 33&''&(#,: ;.&%. ;!' 3!($!",1 <#,# >&5&(> '"%-'0!$$1"".#3&66%%,$&(>61:".#0/(&'.3#("$&'3&''!6,3 '#,5&%#;!'&30'#$:5&$#,$#,$!"#$ @A ((#B/,#44* ";!'

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

*A.#!,$ 2.,& + /0"!: / ' !($$/,&(>0#,'(!6.#!,&(>:.#06#!$#$ ,.&'&((%#(%#.!5#>(#".,/>.".#,#%,$!($!>,## ;&".".#&($&(>'".# (C/&,1 &%#,#!&6#$"0,$/%# !(1%>#("0,&(.&'$##(%#/#"".#(#>6&>#(%12.,& + /0"!: (#$'/#,#$!6''!00,B&3!"#61'@ 6!%' !' 2.,& + /0"! #B#%/"#$ !( !>,##3#(" ;&". '

!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&:;.&%.;!'$##%"&5# ("0,0#,!'

("'&>(#$<1".#0!,"(#,#!&6#$"#B#%/"#0,0#,

4D4 !>,##3#(";&". '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&:;.&%.,#'/6"#$ &("((4$#6&5#, #!6'!&6#$""!-#!00,5!6,3 &'",&%"&66&(> 33&""##.#!$#$<1#0/"1 33&''&(#,:

9!,(!6:;.&%.;!'3!($!",1<#,#>&5&(>'"%-'0!$$1" ".#3&66 #3!$#%(",!%";&".".#&,3:;.&%.;!'("#5#( ,#>&'"#,#$#(%#".#&,3;!'<>/'2#%($61:.#$&$(" <".#,"%(5#(#!3##"&(>: ;.&%.;!'"<#.#!$#$<1 #0/"1 33&''&(#, .&,$61:.#!6'$&$("'#($".&'" #!$ &%#,&(!6!00,5!6 66".&'#'"!<6&'.#'.&'""!6 %((&5!(%#;&".".#0!,"&#' !$".&'!66(" .!00#(#$:

(#$;/6$.!5#<##('!5#$,3&(%/,,&(>6''#'"".# "/(#' %,,# 00,B&3!"#61 2/%.0#,'((#6!,# ,>/#&(".#'#,5&%#!($".#1.!5#(,&>.""%("&(/#&( '#,5&%#I >!&('"".#'!&$,$#,:".#0#"&"&(#,0,##,,#$!(!00#!6<#,# ".#!00#66!"#!/".,&"1(@A ((#B/,#44 :;.&%.;!'$&'3&''#$:

5&$#,$#,$!"#$@ D ((#B/,#44@ .#0#"&"&(#,%.!66#(>#$".# '!&$,$#,<#,#".&' /,"<1;!1&6&(> A**:"&"6#$ !'+#$!,-!'. /0"!+#,'/'!,1!(!2"!"##$#,!"&( ('/3#,' 4 0#,!"&5#.6#'!6#2",#'7&3&"#$!($!(".#,:;.&%.;!'$#%&$#$<1! &5&'&(#(%.(@

!($".#'!3#;!'!66;#$"

;!'.#6$".!"(#".#3#3<#,'".#!,$&,#%",':(!3#61: ;#6:;!'("%30#"#(""'&"&(".#3##"&(>".#!,$&,#%",'4 !00#66!"#!/".,&"1<#%!/'#.#.&3'#6.!'0!''#$".#,$#,0/(&'.3#(": ;.&%.;!''/<=#%"3!""#,!00#!6<#,#".#!,$&,#%",'";/6$ "!("!3/("<#%3&(>!/$>#&(.&';(%!/'#;.&%.&'&30#,3&''&<6#&( 6!;.#,#,#:".#0/(&'.3#(",$#,;!''#"!'&$#!($".#%!'#;!''#(" <!%-"".#!,$&,#%",',,#'.$#%&'&(.#,#!"#,:".#&30/>(#$ ,$#,$!"#$A@ ;!'0!''#$:0,!%"&%!661(".#'!3#

4*4 >,/($!66#>&(>".#(#>6&>#(%#".#0#"&"&(#,&($##%"&5#!>,##3#(": ;.&%.,#'/6"#$&(6''!00,B&3!"#61' %,,#"

(".#;,&""#('"!"#3#(":,#'0($#("'.!5#"!-#(".#06#!".!" ".# 0#"&"&(#, ;!' >/&6"1 #B#%/"&(> $##%"&5# !($ (( #B#%/"!<6# !>,##3#(";&". '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&.#&''/!(%#'.;%!/'# ("&%#:0!''&(>".#0/(&'.3#(",$#,!($".#,$#,".#!00#66!"# !/".,&"1;#,#!''#,"#$"<#%,,#%"#$ ";!'/,".#,'"!"#$".!"".# $##%"&5#%(",!%".!',#'/6"#$&("6''' :

:D:

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

&("#,3'".#!>,##3#(" .#0#"&"&(#,;!'06!%#$/($#,'/'0#('&((

!($".#'.;

%!/'#("&%#$!"#$

*A ((#B/,#44A '.;' ".!"".#0/(&'.&(> !/".,&"1 ;#(" <#1($ ".# &($&(>' ".# &(C/&,1 &%#, &"./" ,#%,$&(>!$&''#("("#!($%(",!,1"&($&(>".#&(C/&,1&%#,:&";!' <'#,5#$".!"$/#"".#(#>6&>#(%#".#0#"&"&(#,: (#$'/#,#$!6''

'@6!%':;.#,#!'".#,#!,#%6#!,%/"&($&(>'".#&(C/&,1&%#,".!"

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

;!'/,".#,<'#,5#$".!"'/%.0#,'(6&-#".#0#"&"&(#,!,#,>/#&('#,5&%# !($".#1.!5#(,&>.""%("&(/#&('#,5&%#.#'#!66#>!"&(';#,#(#5#, 0!,"".#%.!,>#'.##".#!%",#3!&('".!"".#0#"&"&(#,.!$'&>(#$!( !>,##3#(";&". '!.!<&,&%#&66':($,&:!($'/006&#$".#0!$$1" ".#"/(# D A( ";!'/($".!"".#0#,'(:;. '&>(#$ ( <#.!6 '!&$ &,3: ;!' (" #5#( !/".,&G#$ " $ '

('#C/#("61:".#0#"&"&(#,;!'06!%#$/($#,'/'0#('&((

!($".##("&,#0!$$1'"%-;!'.!($#$5#,"!(".#,&,3:(!3#61: '

!,&!3!,!'!3:($,&(".&';!1:".##("&,#0!$$1;!',#%5#,#$ ;&"./"!(16'' .#".#,&'".!",3 "

:".# 0#"&"&(#,$&$("'/0#,5&'#".#3&66&(>".#0!$$1:;.&%.3#!('".!"".#

4@4 &,3$&$("3&66".#0!$$1!($".#0#"&"&(#,$&$(""!-#!(1!%"&(, ".!":".#'!&$&,3&'!6'"<#3!$#6&!<6#,("!$.#,&(>"".#"#,3' ".#!>,##3#(";#5#,:!%%,$&(>"".# (#$:".&'%/6$("<#$(#!'

&";!'!<>/'&,3(!(1%!'#:".#0!$$1;!'.!($#$5#,"(#;&,3<1 ".#'/%%#'',".#0#"&"&(#,:(!3#61:, 2.!,3!!($,!(1!%"

!"#,

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

$/,&(>".#.#!,&(>(".#0/(&'.3#(",$#,:".#0#"&"&(#,%!(,!&'# !66".#06#!'!5!&6!<6#".&3&(%6/$&(>.&'!$5!(%#$!>#:>,!("6#''#, 0/(&'.3#("!($>,!("0#('&(#"%.#,#'.,$#,:&0!''#$:'.!66<# ##%"&5# ,3 ".# $!"# ".# &,'" 0/(&'.3#(" ,$#, $!"

((#B/,#44* ;!'0!''#$.#0,#'#(";,&"0#"&"&(&'!66;#$"".# !<5#("#$#B"#("

* '=-' .#".#,'0#!-&(> ,#!'(#$ ) #' .#".#,#0,"!<6# ) #'