High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2378/2020dismissed

Vinod Kumar And Another v. Elizabeh And Another

2025-12-09Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl20 pages

! "#$# %&'()(*

& +, (-./-,( !"

# $

% !"

' % !"

# ((( ./-,( ) ! #

"**+# , #- #

)./)*/).0 1 ))2 3

,!4%04 &!25

1" , 6*78#*/)8!9" '"

8+,, 9 :

**8 ;,, * < "

" " "

9 =4% & =99#4% & ! # %# !"

/;/**/)79"

# 3 ! 3 ! "% % #

3> 9 3% = # < 9

# # %!

- , , -,

- 7 ?

" #

) 1 3

"#" '"

% '"

)7)/*/)@0 1 A2#3 1" "% -

#3 !

) 9

!# 8/8;3

! * ?

# "

% 9

/;/;)A.@ -

# "

/+/7*/).0 1 );29"9 %! #3

)./)*/).

!9" '"

# 9 - #

" ) 1" " ! " # # ) 3

3 % "

*/)# - ,

).+*-

" " " '"

# 3 ! 9 % ! 9" '"

! ! 1" "

# 3

3 * ! - #

#3 !9" '"

# 9 3

3/@/A*/).

39 ## ! ## ) # "

3 #" -

/@/A*/).9 " %3 3#% ,*;/*/)A9"9 9

# B

3 % 1 % -

3 # "

9 ! '"

"# #

) "

%!"# "% 9 9 ! -

! ! 9 - , , -, - - 8 ?

9 # 3

) * !"

"#"

* ?

)

* ?

% -

)9 # *

99 *-

9 % !

% "%

/;/**/)7 9 "

# ) # *# > -

;# '%

/;/**/)7

## ##"

*9 "!%

3# )9 #

3 # )9

3 !-

"%# ,

## ) # *

##"

9 1

3# ! *9 # "

; -

#3 3 B

! ! #3 ) 9 3 $% ,

/8/+*/)@

3 # $%,

3" 9"9%

3 1" "% " 3# !

)7)/*/)@9"9 #9

# #

#'% ,7A*/)@ ##"

)9 1 !%-

# )9 #

" ! ! '"

! 9

! -

# # 9 9

4% & =99#4% & 9 !"

# 3 >

1" %,

!%> 9 #

) #1" % '% "

"# #

%% #

3 # '"

" "% ## ! "

9 # 9

3 "3#

# 9

%C 9 3 1"

# !'"

! # %

3'"

9 ##"

" % 3 #!"

9" % '"

9 "

%'"

9"9 ! # 1" %,

? #3 ?9"9 # *7/A*/)@ ! % )*/A*/)+ 9 9

99 " % #"

"# #

)*/A*/)+# $D ,

! ,

@ -

"% "3 "% #3

)./)*/)." 3 ""! "

9 9 > 39

9 /;/7*/*/3 # %

/+/7*/).9"9 3 "!

"9 " ! 9 #

# " #

) % "!

- #

! # 0 1 *)2 9" ! 1 9!

#3 9 9

# # #3

9 " % 3% ""

3 # 3

! %

9 9 #3 -

! "6! */)A!E);//=

" % '3% #

3 > - #

> 7////= 9 !3" + ?

"# "

## !

/8/@*/).9"9 "# B

1 %9 <

## !

5 # # ,-- - . <,

% #

)./)*/). "" "9 9 !

% ! # # A

=4% & 99#

=4% & ! ! 3 !

% # > # !%##

/;/**/)79" $% ,

# ?#3 9 9

99 " %#"

< "

# #9% )/ :*/)/*//) ) *

# # '"

)

# * # > -

) # !"

9 "#"

) *

3 *9 "!

#'"

"! 3# "- #

"#"

* )");/@)AA7! 6

))/@)AA7< 9

)# 9" !

!"# $ %

& '%

()

*** *** ***

% (+

, -

' -%

(

- +

. -

% '

/ ---

% /

, .

(

$ ( %

' -%

23445,

3445

( ,%( %

-%- 6 )) < !"

9 % !

% "%

# - "

# ) *

) #

* )* -

! '%

/;/**/)7 0 1 72 '"

#3 ) *9

9 % # "3 = 9 "

9 # 9 #

# # '%

/;/**/)799

# )

* 9

3 ) * "!

3 /)/8)AAA 1" " /)/8)AAA ! "

# * ?

9 " 3 ,

9 ## ) *9 "# 9 "

/)/8)AAA 9" ?

" 1 1)< !

;

)+# '%

/;/**/)7# ,

9 ! 9 "

! " 2

(

-. --

', .

%'(

- (

. -

-+ (

.( --

%- 8444"

- (

%- 8444 9*** ***

% % ( :

& + (

+ ( -.(

8444 +

(

+ -, 1;<+

, . +%

, -%

(

8444!1;# (+= ;

, ;52>>: %

(

(;

( - ('@44@ 84446 )7 -

3 9 !

"% 3

) 9

3# )9

# # )

3# )< '% 3

3 )

#,7A*/)@9" 3 ,

5"# ,

/8/+*/)@0 1 82:

3 ,

# 3

9 "

% 1 !%

3 # $%,

!9"

! #3 9 !

/8/+*/)@< !

# # 1" "% )8 < #'"

)7)/*/)@ 1" "% '"

1" "% 3 " " # ? #*7/A*/)@!&

367**7;#*/)@ %

"# ,

"# ? #3 )9""

9 ! "

# 9

# ## ) #" % #"

)*/A*/)+ ?9 9

)*/A*/)+ ?#!&

367**7;#*/)@

" FA;?A;7B< BC ;?;

7;? B<

BC34>3$>9

!#(-

, C--

!?# <5$$52$>3

!# ;A ;

!# !BC<34>3$>9:DB"

;CD&7?C#

=$:>4:$>9 '

+ (

. 7

!# ) / .C, ?

!# C:6

% " ,

#9% :& & ?% ( -

(

+ + (

(% (

( '

- '

+ + :

C<ECFC;B"C;

;B;C;6 ); -

#!"

*/)7

# !"

?<'"

3 ' 1"

"% % ##%# ?

39 3

% "% #"

? 9 ! " :" 9 "

) % 1 = ! * %

3 9 !

# ,

3 # $%,

9 3%

" % !"

4% & =99#4% &

# # 1" "%

3 1" "%9" # "

%!3 $D ,

#0#2

%4 50$.$( %# %4 5007 0 4 $*-

%1#%-*9" 1" %,

! "

# 1" "%9 1 )@ B

# %

)./)*/).! 9" '"

#3 9 99

8 "#"

3 "

3'"

9"9

3 4% & % " #

% 9

1" 9 " % "

# " -

% 3

9"9 ! # 1" %,

< !

" % #

3'"

3 4% &

9" "

9 ! # 3 !9 "

1" %,

9 # 1" %,

<'"

3 % 3 '"

3 1" %,

3 !%

/;/7*/)7 $% ,

! ?#3 )9 ! % 9 9

9)*/A*/)+9 " %#"

< %

% '"

# ,

)+ !"

3 # ,

##"

) 1 " !

# ! #

)+# '"

)7)/*/)@0 1 A29 '"

9 ) ! 6&

) " " -

9 % !%> ""

1" "% - "! !9"9 3 $%,

*/)@

% 9 !

# 3

*/)@ 1" "% '"

# # 9" "

39 #

)+/+*/)+#3 '"

"#"

%C "% %9 %! 9

3# ! *9"9

% 9 #

# 9 #

3 ## ! # ! #"

9" "

9 !<

# 3 " 2

(

. % ( -

% (% + - '

(

+ / + -

+ B

! "# $%&''#( )& *&" + "

+) -" +'&

.*'

'*#"&( #&"&/* ''& "&( #""#&"*

. E

+ , '

, %-

+ , .

B (% % '

( C

(( , ( ,%( "

. -- .

-.( - - ?- ( %'

+ 3'& '&#'&"&* ' , +'&% 0#&1& + ! *'

' &", #&# ' '& 2 # )&

E , -

.%'

+ ('

- %'

6 ). - 3 "#"

)8 #

3 '"

# 3 4% & )@/.*/)@

# 1" %,

! "# ,

## -

)+#

3 "#"

3 1" 3

)A.@9 % "

# "3#

)9 ! %C %9 # ## ! 3

3 " 3# ! *9

" )A < #

"% #

)./)*/).!9" '"

#3 9"9 3

3 B

! "% " ## ! # 9" ! ,

" #

% " #

% 3

# " C77B CB B

!"#B :-

52@$

?% "

.+ ?

(

4828$ AC:

. (( '

(+ =:

B '

(AC % 99.

B '

, .'% , <%

B ' , G C(( , ;7(

B ' , B

.(%

C(( , 5>8$>9%.

. %

$B ' +

(-- .

<):$$?

; )

% -%%

B C'

, B '

- '

(AC!A?

( B '%

/ (

, '

-- .G

B , ,

+ ( C

. D / <25

224@3 %.

' !"# %

'% %+

; <

)

% -%%

B 5

+ (C

=224@3

(

+ '

( 7;;B , <

+ (C

( '

+ (C

)

(

+ (C

. (

+ '

( 7 , 8

B , )

/C%

+ %

)

!"# %

=>39@>>>>>>35$>9B-

('AC

.B ' - ;

!'.

- +# % %

+ '

)

!"#B, '.-

G'. , + .

$>> B '(% C(( , . 8 .(E%

:$>@6 */ # ! ## ! 99

3 )

" #C

%++3

# ## ! )7/8*/)+3

9" 3 "

" <#

1" % 9

# "" 9"9 %

3 # C %!< %# ## ! 9

34 6

3", # 0C 2-

" 3 # ! '"

*) "% " #%#

)./)*/). "

3 "# # %

# #

9 !

# 0 1 *)2 99

# # #3 /8/+*/)A "%

# #% 3 "

/)/.*/)A**/.*/)A*@/A*/)A/+))*/)A

3 3)+)**/)A

3 "

# #< # # 3 " "

# # 9 9 !

/;/7*/*/3

##%

< #

/;/7*/**3 ) %9 "- %

% %

# "% %! 9 %

9 9 9

9 ** B

"% " 3

5" # ,

)+/)*/)A ! 9"

# "! !" %%

/@/A*/). ! #

# ! 9 9

# "

# B

% "

9 ## B

3 # "

# #

9 " 9 9 9

9 % 4%

$%,

#(( 3818.$(( 4#9#0442:

)''#;< 3

"# " 3## # - "

! #

# 1" "% 9 # '% 9 ! " %

1" "% # '%

# 3B

# #

" "

9 9 "

! ! # #

! 3 ! 3&

3 ! '"

# 1" "% ! 9 9

4% & =99#4% &

! # )% ! %

1 < ! 3 9" '% "

#(( 38180

2 " 3## #

*7 <# 3#

##"

) 1

# #

# ) 9 # * "

;# '%

/;/**/)70 1 72

* 3 "!

3 # ) 0 2 /)/8)AAA < #

;# ,

9 "

! B !

3 ) # *

* 9

3# )0 2

# # 1" "% ##"

3# *8 53

%# !'"

# > # !"

!% 3

*/)79"

# 39 ! 3% "6! */)A- "

> 7////= : "" ""

" "

= # " 6! */)A %

! 9 %

"%# " % = # ="

"" "9 9 *; %!9 ! # " " " %

)./)*/). 0 1 ))2 ! ./-, '()(* "

%= H=6 G

H=6