High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13151/2018dismissed

Rajbir And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-08-31The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli10 pages

"#$ %

#&#'

"#$

()*+ (#",- . / & 0,(, ( 1(#((#",- . #, 3$ 4530/0670 453055

#,$ 3 0(#"

20-( 8(7"!'(, 7

,- 3 #9& 3+,,(:7 "": "!'(, # (:7 ( 1(#( ;+,- 3 0(& (*- 3(<7 , "!'(, # (: ( 1(#(7 (#" 36&-(:"

263(#'-(#"(7"!'(, 7

,- #, - +#,(#, 2 ,+,+# -( *

# +:

" ':(+8+#< ,-(, ,- ('=&++,+# 2 '

"+#<'( + "&,!+"

#,+ +'(,+#+& "&#"

0 ',+#>?@ 5(#" '=&++,+# ',7 %> "(, @ %%A (#"

',+!

:1B ::;

"*1,- (;( ""(, >

7,-

*1('=&+ +#< :(#" (2&*:+'2& 2 7#(8 :1 ,- "

:28 #,(#"&,+:+C(,+# :(#"( +"

#,+(:7'88 '+(:0 ', >A7>%(#"

7& &< (8=&( + :(#"8 (& +#<('

'82 + "+#6-( ( DD@DE@F7 > E F7

E F7@DDEA F7

DE F7 DE @F,,(::(#" 6(#(: %3( :(+,&(, ";+,-+#,- #& ,(, /+::(< "(82& 7 -+:?

+, +',& &< (8-(:(2 "+#!+ ; 2 !++# 0 F +<-,,(+ 82 #(,+#(#" (#2( #'1+#5(#"'=&++,+# -(*+:+,(,+#(#"

,,:

#,',

E - ,7G,-

;+#<,,- '#, !

1 &2, "( <( ",- +#, ,(,+# 2 !++# 0

7:+9 8(#1,- ; +, ,+,+#7,- 2 '

"+#<+#,- +#,(#,2 ,+,+#;

9 2,+#(* 1(#'

(;(+,+#<,- "

'++# 0&2 & ,- '#, !

1;( +#(::12&, (, , *1 ,- #,+,&,+# #'- 0&2 & , +#

! #&:,+8(, 2( (< (2- ;-+'-+ 2 "&'

+#* :;$ "# $ % & '

('( & ) % &

& % & % *+ %

%& % * & )- ) )) %% .& , & - % & + &,

& & '

('-(% & % * & % / % - * 0)"1 & '(- )

-"1 "1 0 % &2 &, & '(% & % * 3

&) & % %% &

& % & + % - 3&

- )+ & - 3+ &

- + % &

- + -

3 0 .

4 4 %

& '(% & % * & %&

& 0&2&%5 & '( & - ) & 6 % ,

-%& '

)( % %& % &2 & % & % /

- &

&&& ) % & % * & - , & * % &2 & %

/ -% %

+ & *% & &-, 75 %&

' & (

% &2

&, & % 5 ) &

6 % ,%% +&

& % * - 8 )8

% %& % &2

& % & % / 9 & - &

& * (% & %

/ + & &2

& '( 5 5 %&

& 0- , &

- , & * ( ))% &&

) , %& % , &

+ & & &2 &,

& '(% & % * ! 0 & '(% & % * - % & '( % & '

('-( : 0 % 3, & % / &

& '( - ),%2 ; <&) - 3, & !% & % / +

& '(% & % *+&

- 3 & '( / 0 % & '( ,% % &,

&- & % & 3

% % -% & % *& %&+ &,%

&2 , ) &&

0 % - & %

-& -.& &

% %

& '(% & % * , ) & % & 2 , % && &, % &2 &

&, , %%& % & % *+ + 5- & &&

) ) 2 , % % 3, &,

% %&

% & &2 1 - &8(#"&*,(#'

+#, ,(,+# 0 ',

*1 ,- 0&2 & , + ,-(, ,- + , (#" 8, '#"+,+# ,

9 :(2+#< + ,-(, *,- ,- '#,+#< #'+ 2 !+"

" + (*&,,- 2-1+'(:2 +#(#",- 2(18 #, '82 #(,+#( ,*

+::

"78 (#+#<,-

*17+ +,- '#"+,+#+#,(,+ + "7,-

> ;&:"* #:(2+#< ( (,- *:+<(,+#,8(9 2(18 #,+#:+ & :(#" ('=&+ " + '#'

# "7 +, -( *

# ':( + + " ,-(, &'- *:+<(,+# , 2(1 + '82:

, *1 , #"

+#< ,- '82 #(,+# ;-+'- ;&:" 8 (# ,-(, ,- '82 #(,+# (8&#, ;( 8("

(!(+:(*:

, ,- :(#";# (#"+ - -(#,(''

2, ",- (8 7+,;+::#,* (!(+:(*:

,- :(#" ;# , ':(+8 ,-(, ,- '82 #(,+# -( #, *

# 2(+" 0+8+:( :17 ,- ; " I"

2+,J -( *

# +#, , " , 8 (# "

2+,+#< ;+,- ,- 5 ,- (& 1 ,-

'& , (;+#< 2(#'-#(8( -( *

# '#+"

" , * ( !(:+" 2 ,(9+#< 2-1+'(: 2 +# (#" #'

:(#" ,(#" !

, " +# ,- 0,(, 7 ,-

+ # "+!

,+#<2 !+"

"&#"

- 0&2 & ,-( & ,- ':( + + ",-(,,- +" ;-+'-(#1+#, +8 "

;( +# 2 (,+#7 ;+:: * K':&"

" ;-+:

'82&,+#< ,- <(2 2 +" +!

( 0+8+:( :17+,-(*

#':( + + ",-(,0

" #,<+!

+ ,(# ;'(& (',+#,=& ,+#,- :

<(:+,1 '#':&"

"2 '

"+#< :(#"('=&++,+#(+,(22:+ ,#:1,- '( ;-

+#,- 2 '

"+#<;

#"+#<#,- "(, # '

> ('# =& #'

,,- (")&"+'(,+#8("

*1,- 0&2 & ,7 +#,(#,2 ,+,+#;(,(9 #&2 +#(:- ( +#<7;-

+#(22 ( +#< ,-

#, 3 #9& 3+,,(:7 :

( # " ""+,+#(: "!'(, # (: ( 1(#(7-(,(9 #(2 :+8+#( 1*) ',+#(*&,,- !

18(+#,(+#(*+:+,1 #,- < &#",-(,,- -(!

#:'&,(#"+,8(+#,(+#,- +#,(#, 2 ,+,+# ( ,- + 2 "

+# +#,

,7#(8 :1

, (87 ;- ;(;# +#,- ( (+"6-( (,,- K, #, D>,--( :" -+ -( , # &2+#"

6(& !+"

" "(, A %% + *

+&(#'

#,+ +'(,+#&#"

0 ',+#> %>(#"(

(;( ",(, #,7,- '82 #(,+#-((:

("1*

# +!

"*1 &2+#"

6(& -

7,- ( #, #,- ;# :(#" +# =& ,+# (#" ,- 2 # , ;-8 ,- :(#" ;( :" *1 ,- "

+#+#,

, -((:

("1 +!

",- (8&#, '82 #(,+# & ,- &*8+,,-(, #,- 2 +# :(#" +#=& ,+#,(#",(9 #*1 ' "+#<(2(,C#(8'-( A"(,

7;-+'-+(!(:+"8"

,(9+#<2 +#(-(*

#- :" *1 ,- 0&2 & , +# ,- '( #"

:28 #, &,- +,1 E&2 (F(('# =& #'

;-+'-,- :(#",(#"!

, "+#,- 0,(,

8(:: #'&8* (#'

7+#!+ ; (',,-(,## '#"+,+#2 ' +* "+#0

( &:

+::

"7 +#,(#,2 ,+,+#"

"+8+(:(#"

':( (,+# ,- :(2+#< ('=&++,+#2 '

"+#<'(#* 8("

(!+#< - ( " ,- ',+!

( <&8 #,7 <+#< ,- &<- ,-

',+!

("+#<(#"(*!

(::,- K2+,+# #"

:28 #, &,- +,1 E&2 (F7 ;

( '#+"

" 2+#+# ,-(, ,- +#,(#, ,+,+#+:+(*:

,* "+8+ 8 ,-(## (#

! "#

! $

% - 2 +# ,- +#,(#, 2 ,+,+# -(!

':(+8 " , * +# ,- 2-1+'(:2 +# :(#"+#=& ,+#+,+!

'( ,&2*1,- +,-(, #,-&<-,- (;( ";(2( "# >

(#" 1 "+" #, '-(::

#< ('=&++,+# 2 '

"+#< *&, ,- 2-1+'(: 2 +#-(#,*

#,(9 # 8,- 8#,-+ <( "7,- #, -(!

",- ; +,, #,(, #,&*8+,,+#<,-(,2 +#;(,(9 #*1 " (;+#< 2(#'-#(8( +# ,- 8 (2(, C#(8'-( A "(,

;-+'--(*

#- :"((!(:+"8"

,(9+#<2 +#

@ :(#" 0 ',+# @ ', %> 2 !+"

,-(, ( , ,(9+#< ,- 2 +# :(#"7+,!

,+#,- 0,(,

8(:: #'&8* (#'

-&7;

( '#+"

"2+#+#,-(,,- 2-1+'(:2 +# :(#" +# =& ,+# ,(#" "&:1 ,(9 # (#" (8 -( !

, " +# ,- 0,(, -

7,- 2:

( * +#<+#2-1+'(:2 +# :(#"+#=& ,+#+;-::18+'#'

"(#"+:+(*:

,* ) ', "

& # ' ! "#

(

! A - #, -(!

'(, < +'(::1 2:

" +# ,- ; +,, # ,(, #,,-(,,- (8&#, '82 #(,+# ,- #,+ (;( "

":(#" ;(8("

(!(+:(*:

,(::,- :(#";# #,-+ <( "73 3+,,(:-( ( , ",-(,+#!+ ; K2+,+#+##"

:28 #,&,- +,1 E&2 (F,- *:+<(,+# 0,(, ,2(1,- '82 #(,+#+"+'-( < + (8&#, '82 #(,+#+, #"

";-+'--(*

#+#, , ", (#,-(,,- (8&#,;(8("

(!(+:(*:

,,- :(#";# (* +#( (

;-+'-+ 2 "&'

+#* :;$

$ % &

=) +& % -

) ) -&,% - ,

3 & & - % %

3, ' &

( # ) #

* &+ &,-*

# % $

( % &

(

% &

/ %

(

% (

(

( & $

, &+ & *

, &+ &

& 1% &

2 &

# $

% (&3

% ) #

% (

=) + & ) , + -

& *+

& 1%

2 &

)

* 4

( 5

. - ( ,(, (',':

( :1 (:,-(,,- * !(,+#8("

+#(*!

"#,:

(#1'2 "&*,,-(,,- 0,(, -("+'-( < "+, *:+<(,+# ,;( " 8(9+#< ,- '82 #(,+# ,- :(#" ('=&+ " +"

-(!+#<, #"

",- (8&#,+,+,- 2 '+ +'2:

"'(

#,,-(,,- (8&#, '82 #(,+#-((:

("1*

# +!

*1# &2+#"

6(& ;--("2& '-( ",- :(#"+#=& ,+# 8,- "

+#+#,

, 7

,(87;-;(,- ;# ( (+" 6-( ( , ,- K, #, D>,- -( -

7 ,- *:+<(,+# 0,(, , 2(1 '82 #(,+# ,(#" "+'-( < (:: +#, #,(#"2& 2

') !

*+* *,-.'

# ! - 0&2 & ,+##"

:28 #,&,- +,1E&2 (F-( ':

( :1 * " ,-(, "

" :(2+#< ('=&++,+# 2 '

"+#< &#"

7*,-,- '#"+,+#+ 2(18 #, '82 #(,+# (#" ,(9+#< 2 +# 8&, #, * &:

+::

" + +

+,- '#"+,+# + &:

+::

"7 ,- :(2+#< '(##, -(22 # - 0&2 & ,-(* ",-(,,- ; "I J''& +#<+#0 >

8&,* ("(I(#"D# J :

!(#,2( ( 8,- )&"<8 #,( 2 "&'

+#* :;$ --' 3

( $ &

( % & & (

( $#&

+ &,-*

% & * & + &+#

$% 5 & #

(

' 78 2 + + % 9 & ' :

;;( 3 < &

% &

$% (

= % &

& & '

% > ' &

( & &

& & '

! #

! '

: &

" # &

$ &

! $% !+

(

% ! '

( !

# & $ &

$ &

(

% 1'412! ( %

(!!

% '&(

(

% (

( # &

$ (

*'&(

(

$% (

$% &

& $

& &

2 (. 0 5

> '

% ? '

0+ % % &2 &, )+ & '(%- - 3+ + & 3+ &

+ &2 &,

% % #,- '( (,-(#"(

', 8,- 2:1 +:

"7+,+ !+"

#, ,-(, ( , (;( " ;( (##&#'

" # >

7 ,- 2-1+'(: 2 +# ;( ,(9 # *1 ' "+#< (2(, C#(8'-( A "(,

(#" ,- '82 #(,+# (8&#, -( *

# +!

" *1 # &2+#"

6(& ;- -(" 2& '-( " ,- :(#" +# =& ,+# 8 ,- "

+#+#,

, !+"

""(, A %% 0+#'

## '#"+,+#2 ' +* "+#0

( &:

+::

"7,-

7(+"2 !++#'(##,* :+ "&2#*1,- ,':(+8:(2+#< ('=&++,+#2 '

"+#<

! "#

10.

3 #9& 3+,,(:7 # ,- , #<,- (', 2:

" +# ,- ; +,, #,(, #,7-(!

- #,:1'#, #"

",-(,,- 0,(, ('=&+ ",- :(#" ,- 2&*:+' 2& 2 "

:28 #, (#" &,+:+C(,+# :(#" ( +"

#,+(:788 '+(:0 ', >A7>%(#"

7& &< (8- :(#"+# =& ,+#+!

18&'-

#,+(:,('-+ 2&*:+'2& 2 (2 :(1&, 2:(# -(!

'#+"

" ,-+ 2( , ( <&8 #, (+ " *1 ,-

#,(#";

( +#'82:

, (<

#,;+,-,- (8 (,-++(# +82 ,(#, (', ,* 9 2,+#8+#";-+:

(:+#<;+,-,- '( ( ++#< &, ('=&++,+# :(#",('-+ 2&*:+'2& 2 (#"+,+,- 0,(, D+,(&,- +,1;-++#,- * ,2+,+#,"

'+"

(*&,&,+:+C(,+# :(#"('=&+ "7( , +,-(!+#<*

, "+#0,(, 11.

( =& : (*!

"+'&+# (#" +# !+ ; :(; &88( +C " +# 2( ( @ #"

:28 #, &,- +,1 E&2 (F7 '+ +'(::1( , -(!+#< ' "

",-(,+#,- '( (,-(#"7,- 2-1+'(: 2 +# :(#"+#=& ,+#-(!+#<*

#,(9 #7,- *:+<(,+#

2(18 #, '82 #(,+#"+'-( < "(#"(:'#+"

+#<,-(,,- :(#" +#=& ,+#+!

18&'-

#,+(:,('-+ 2&*:+'2& 2 7;

-(!

# - +,(,+# , -:" ,-(, +# ,- +#,(#, '( 7 ,- 0,(, -( &::1 "+'-( < "+,*:+<(,+#=&(*,-,- '#,+#< #'+ ''& +#<+#0

> E F ',

', (#" +, * +#< 7 ,- +#,(#, 2 ,+,+# + "+8+ " (!+#< "+8+ " ,- 8(+# ; +, 2 ,+,+#7 2 #"+#< (22:+'(,+#7 + (#17(:8

,,- (8 (, 0,(,&=&+ (#1,(#"!('(, " E/06F 0 E55F

#") - 2 (9+#<D (#

D - 2 ,(*: