High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14920/2017dismissed

Baldev Raj Chadha And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2017-07-28Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari10 pages

! "#$#%&

'& ()'

***)

! " **) +, - ./ # $ %!

" "&"' %(()&

**' + , - $

$ % $ " !

.//% , ,"

" # - "" 0$ "

0 0 $, 1 , +" 2 3 %. ,

, ,

0 "+# 14+

5, ,, $ " 60 .//%

" /3/..//%&!+-.'# "

" ",

" # " , 0 0$ , $ 0

/%/%%((3.//%! $ $

" 1 0 2 % "

$ "

, , 2 % . 3, , "

" # " , 0$ $ " 0 7 "

8-%/9%9-.//3

!! "

" /:/;.//)&!+-)' , " , + %.!

! $ , $

, $ < $ %(/:.//9 0

," "

$ , 0 ,$ 0

0" "

0, " ,

, " $ $ "

0 "

.//%! " . , , 0

$"$ 0" " $ ",

5,0 !+

"-" 0

$ " $ 1

! " <, + , ,

" ""

"0 $0$ , 0$ $, $ < !"%;

1 ,+ 1, ""

$ ,+" ,

,$ "

0$ 0 , 0$ ""

"<""# " , =.:# $", $

$ $ "0 0 , "0

&%'2 , " $0

" 00+$ 02 $ ,

" , 0 !" %;

1# " 0 "

" " " 0

0 # , 0 0"

0 &.' , " 0 " , "

$> +" "

, "<""#

$ , $ " ""<" , $ 0" "

"" "

" " 0 $ " 0 + # , 0"- "

"<"" , 0 $ "

&:' , +"

", $ "0

, $ ,

$0 ,

8 "

" 0$ "

+ 0 "

" "", 0 " " "

" "

$ & @ AB 1&'A $

$ 0

$ "" 0

+ $ " 0

$$ $

, $ 0 $ +

"<""C "" 0" $ !+

' (

) * , 0 - $ $

3 , 0 "

$"" , "$" $ +%, - % .&'/

# 1$

0 3 # $

$ 0

=# "

0 , " $" " , " ,

" , "

D " 2 "

D " "

+ $ " $"

" ,+ "

%E6

"" "

0 " "

$ " $" $ " " # " " "

+ 0 "

1@ ,

5 $

$$ 7" @ # $ .//3&.' #;%9 &.//3';

:..

" , , , " -, $ 0 %3 1 A

&%(99':

:(3 0 $ " + # ", A!@ &%(93':

E9( %91 "

2$ 5 F 7&.'

./%%&.' #9%. &./%%';

:9; - G$"

" G$ 5 %(()&%' #.3 &%((93

E:) " 0 $ 0%((9 , $ 0 99%((. %) 1 #2 .//9&;' #;9.

&.//9'%/

%:9

$ <" 0 " "

$ $ " 0 - =$ ,

7 "

" "

, < , " 0 ""

$ 0, 0$ !"%;

1, 0", , ,

$C %(# "0 " " "

0 "

" <<0 0 0" , 0 # " 0F

5 G

./%/&%' #%3(

&.//('%E

:.% ./12,7 "

"$ .//9&.' #3/% &.//9'(

.9)

$ $ , !"..3

1 ,

0 , 0 1 " , "

" 0 $

, +" " " .% $ , , -G$"

" , # 2 &%(9E'%

%E. , 0 , $$0

, +

+" ,!"..3 "0 ",

" $ "$ 0, 0 ,+" "

+" + ,!"..3 " ,

+ ,

0 , $

," ..80 "

" "

0 # 0 0 $ "

0 ,

0 "

$ 0

",! ,

$ 0 ! , " 0 $

" " " " 0 ,

" 0

$ 0 " "

$$"

" ,

" "

" " 8 0"0 "" " , " "$ $ $ " $$

00 0""0 $

0 0$0 " +"

<$0$ +

# " 0 "

8 $0 0

0 <, $ #$< 0" $ " + , "2 $ 0 $ 0 , #

0 $ 0 $"$

" 0$,

C 1

0 4&

44&/

5' (

660&

(, #$

1 "

$""0 $

$ "

$ " " 00$ " " " $ A%:/9./%9 ,$ ,

, " 0 , " , "

,0" .//%

, , 0 " ""

" ,

," $ $ ,0" .//90< " "$ " " 5 .)/9./%9C

$ $ !+

0).4

#"$

*1 0 $ + ,"$" " ,$ 0 "

! $ , $

, #0 " +

0 )" -+ 1 , "

"" " !+

$ 0 "

" $

$ "

", , 0$" " 1, ", " 0,

%E0" - $ $ ,

0"0 """ " " "

' 1 #1$

*1 , 0 ,

, ,0 ,0 0 " :)

$ , 0 $ G$# 7 "

$ 0

H3I # !+

0" : $ , %3, " <"

, , 1 " , 0 0"" ,0 0 " $ "

+" ,"$ $, $ ! "0 "

00 , , "

$, $ "

" 0 0 " , 0+

, $ )

7/ "

#$ 8) ,""$ +

-" "

, ,$ !+

+$ $ "

<<" ,"< , 0 " #

$ !+

"" , 0

"" " , "" " 0$ 0 ,

01, ,-

, "> ", , +" " $ " " # , 00 0 !+

-0#%!123 -*-#0 $ ($"&' + $, 0 0"

, "" $ ,

$$ $ $"$ " ,

# $ 0 "

, 0 "

<" , , ,0 !+

"0 " " $ .//% !""

$ , 0$0

0 .)/9./%9 ,**)/

#! $% & ' #(! ) & '