High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18484/2016allowed

Lakhvir Ram v. The Addl Deputy Commissioner & ORS

2018-07-05Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath6 pages

! !"#$#%& ' (

)*+,#-. ! # #%!- /$ +!001 !23 4..#$$#%!-"3.22!11 !-#53%16778-%0 +!-$ !$2%0!%

9&:)97;7;9 9&:)97;7;9 9&:)97;7;9 9&:)97;7;9

-!$!% & 9-7-<33-#60," !6

- +!2! # #%!- 9-7+#17+-.6 63%<5 9-77 +1#=160," !6

--!$2%0!% >

;7;96?)@ ;7;96?)@ ;7;96?)@ ;7;96?)@ +#$ 2! # #% #$ 0#-!" !0 8#%$ +! -0!- 0 !0

' 2$$!054 +!9#% !%%"!-#53%161"+3-6 #$ -#" 778-%0 +! -0!-0 !0

2$$!054 +!9#% !%%"!22!11 !-#53%1677 8- 54 =+#"+ +! 2! # #%!-6 =+ +22!%!0 5! +! $%#%1= -!$2%0!% >6+$5!!%$001!0=# + +!1#5#1# 4 24.#% !%%"! +#.#% !-.$ +!2-,#$#%$ +!9#% !%%"!%0!1 -! -!% $ %07!%#-# #A!%$" 6

(B -$+- C +!" :D )!-%!0 "3%$!1 - +! 2! # #%!- +$ -#$!0 $35$ % #1 E3!$ #% 1= + =+! +!-$%#%1=#$1#51! 24.#% !%%"! +#$

+!-#%1=F )!-%!0"3%$!1 - +!2! # #%!-+$$35.# !0 + +38+#% ,#!= ".2-.#$! +!2! # #%!-+$1-!042#0 1*+$ -!$2%0!%

>53 5!#%8 +!$%#%1=+!=310%!# +!- 11=# +#% +!0!

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

% 8#%$ %!-.-! +#$"+#10-!%6=+.4% 5!.#%--"+#101!$$$!%#- "# #A!%8#%$ +#$-!1 #,! $3"+%221#" #%#$ #1!06# +$ 5!0!1 =# +54 +!-#53%1"%$ # 3 !03%0!-7!" #%( +!" %0#% !-.$ +!2-"!03-!2-!$"-#5!0#%7!" #%' +!" #$$35.# !0 + +! -#53%1$=!11$ +!22!11 !-#53%1+,!"..# !02 !% !--- 1=#%0!"#0#%8 + +!$%#%1=#$1#51! 24.#% !%%"! +! 3%!

2!-.% + -!$2%0!% > #$+=!,!-6$35.# !0 + +! 2! # #%!-=310% $* - +!-!",!-4 1*+=+#"++01-!042#0 -!$2%0!% >#%,#!= ".2-.#$!!% !-!0#% 5! =!!% +!2- #!$ 5!

-! +! -#53%153 # #$$35.# !0 + +!2! # #%!- +!-=#$! #$% 1#51! 24%4*#%0 .#% !%%"! +#$ +!-#%1= )!-%!0"3%$!1 - +!-!$2%0!% $+$$35.# !0 + +!-!#$ %!---#% +!#.238%!0-0!-$5!"3$! +!2! # #%!-+#.$!1 +02#0

> 1*+$ +#$ +!-#%1=6 +!-!

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

2-,#0!0#% 7!" #% +! " % -!8-0 +! 2-!$!% "$!6 +! 0! C"+#10-!%:6 C.#% !%%"!:6 C2-!% :6 C-!1 #,!: %0 C$!%#- "# #A!%$: -! -!1!,% %0-!-!2-03"!0$3%0!-& H+#10-!%I#%"130!$$%6038+ !-68-%0$% %0 8-%0038+ !- 53 0!$ % #%"130! .#%-I H9#% !%%"!I #%"130!$ 2-,#$#% - 06 "1 +#%86 -!$#0!%"! %0 .!0#"1 !%0%"! %0 -! .!% I H-!% I .!%$ +!- - . +!- =+! +!- 5#18#"16 02 #,! - $ !2 +!- - $ !

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

#%# #%$6 +!C2-!% :.45!$!%#-"# #A!%=+!-!$C$!%#-"# #A!%: $+3105!2!-$% 4!-$-5,!+!C"+#10-!%:=310#%"130!$%6 038+ !-6 8-%0$% %0 8-%0038+ !- 53 % .#%- +! C-!1 #,!: =310.!%%41!81+!#- +!"+#101!$$$!%#-"# #A!%=+#$% .#%- %0#$#%2$$!$$#% -=310#%+!-# +!2-2!- 4 +!$!%#-"# #A!%

!- +#$ 0! + +3$6 +!-! #$ % -!

!-!%"! $%#%1= !# +!- #% +! C"+#10-!%: - #% +! 0!

C-!1 #,!: % "$! +! C-!1 #,!:#$!G2%0!0!,!% +!% +!$%#%1==310% 11 =# +#%# $2-.! !-$5!"3$! +!)!8#$1 3-!+$2-,#0!0 +!0!

' C-!1 #,!: .!% + %41!81+!#- +!"+#101!$$$!%#-"# #A!%=+#$ % .#%-%0#$#%2$$!$$#% -#$1#*!14 #%+!-# +#$2-2!- 4 !-+#$ 0! + % +! 2-!$!% "$!6 -!$2%0!% > #$ % "+#101!$$ $!%#- "# #A!%5!"3$!+!+0 =$%$8#%$ =+.1$ +!-#53%1+$2$$!0 +! =-0 .#% !%%"! +! 2! # #%!- #$ % ",!-!0 !# +!- #% +! C"+#10-!%: - C-!1 #,!: % +#$ -!8-06 +! <308.!% +#$ 3- -!1#!032%541!-%!0"3%$!1 - +!2! # #%!--!%0!-!0#% +!"$! H15#- ;3- 15#- ;3- 15#- ;3- 15#- ;3- /$ -!$#0#%8

#"!- -!$#0#%8

#"!-"3.

"3.

"3.7 9 +! 9#% !%%"! J 7 9 +! 9#% !%%"! J 7 9 +! 9#% !%%"! J 7 9 +! 9#% !%%"! J !1 -! 7!%#- # #A!% -#53%16 !+ !1 -! 7!%#- # #A!% -#53%16 !+ !1 -! 7!%#- # #A!% -#53%16 !+ !1 -! 7!%#- # #A!% -#53%16 !+=6 #$ -#" ;3-3*$+! - %0 =6 #$ -#" ;3-3*$+! - %0 =6 #$ -#" ;3-3*$+! - %0 =6 #$ -#" ;3-3*$+! - %0 +!-$I +!-$I +!-$I +!-$I

'?>@) =3101$5!-!1!,% #%=+#"+ +!.#% !%%"! =$ =-0!0 8#%$ +! 038+ !-#%1= %0 +#$ 3- +$ +!10 + $+! =310% 11=# +#% +!0!

!# +!-C"+#10-!%:-C-!1 #,!:%- +!

+!-#% + "$!=310 11=# +#% +!0!

C2-!% :7#.#1-14#% +#$"$!1$6 +!0!

C2-!% :$2-,#0!0#%7!" #% ?0@ +! " $4$ + # =310.!% +!--. +!-=+! +!-5#18#"1602 #,!- $ !2 +!--$ !2. +!-6$ +!"$!.45!6=+! +!--% +! +!-- +!. +!-#$$!%#-"# #A!% 0!$% 1* +!-#%1= - +!23-2$! 0!

+!C2-!% : )*#%8 -.%4%81!6 +!$%#%1==310% 5!1#51! 24%4*#%0 .#% !%%"!#% !-.$ %-0!-+,#%85!!%2$$!054 +! -#53%1- +!22!11 !3 +-# 4%%221#" #% #1!03%0!-7!" #%

+!" +3$6 +!E3!$ #%2$!0#% +!5!8#%%#%8#$+!-!54%$=!-!0#%

#-. #,!#% ,3- +!2! # #%!- +10 + +!$%#%1=#$%!# +!- C"+#10:%-C-!1 #,!:%0 +! +!-#%1=#$% 2-!% $=!11

% ,#!= +! 5,!6 +! 2-!$!% 2! # #% #$ 11=!0 %0 +! -0!-2$$!0545 + +!.#% !%%"!-#53%1%022!11 !-#53%1-! +!-!54$! $#0! ?;7;9@ ?;7;9@ ?;7;9@ ?;7;9@

' (

+! +!-$2!*#%8K-!$%!0 &

!$K +! +!-!2- 51! &

!$K