Rama Swamy v. Central Administrative Tribunal And ORS




   
 





 

  





  !"#"

$%!&'

($("%!%() !(*#$&+
,$'(-!,. $/,+
,$'(-!,$'%, !" 
01 23.4056
5786004 23.4056
05 ! " $% 0!$(",8# !+')/% +

!%, 9 %(%($ ! :::

 
  ,  9 %(%($ !+    9 !

$ $%  ! "(' $%    ()! 9#! +  $'#!(  .&/;  < (&  '#=+  "  !;($-  "  (&  - !  "($/   >  2("  " !)(/ "  !  %!$"

!! '  %  0#$(/(9& 
!9!%($+
,$'(-!,+)(' 

'% '?

$%, $%( (/%($  ) $'% ! -!'($-  %!$"

!    ,("  " !)(/ "+  ,("  '%    *(!%,  "  ! /!' '  "

@ > ? A  ,  9 %(%($ !  /&( "  %,%  /%#&& +  ,("  '%    *(!%,  ("

@?>

A2 ) !+,  "$% !  %, ! /!'($- ,(" !$- '%  *(!%,($%, $%( (/%($'% '?

" &&"($%, ! /!' %, ! "9$' $%
!9!%($%/ %,(";$ & '- $& ($%,  $%,  *!#!

++ , $,("" !)(/ " ! ! -#&!(" '* %, ' 9!% $%)('

!' ! '% ' >  <$$ B#!  1= , !  % !+  % ! *%($($-  ,("

/,&  4 )($- 
!%( (/%  '% '     <$$ B#!  1= 

$/, %6$($& $%!

/,&+()!9#! +$'!(.&/;+ (&

11 '#+%, 9 %(%($ !"#* (%% '! 9! " $%%($'% ' <$$ B#!

1>=%%, #9 !($% $' $%$-($ !+0#$(/(9&
!9!%($+
,$'(-!, <! "9$' $%>, ! ($=+%/!! /%,("'%  *(!%,($%, ! /!' %, ! "9$' $% 
!9!%($   @ > ? A  %  @?>

A  ,  "('

! 9! " $%%($ "! C /% '* %, B /#%() $-($ !+
()("($ <'=+
,$'(-!,<! "9$' $% , ! ($=)(' !' !'% '??

<$$ B#! 1 =$%, -!#$'%,%%, ! 9! " $%%($ !/,$-  '%  *(!%,/$$%* // 9% ' % ! !" 99($% $%+"//!'($-% ?

<%  = %, #$' $%&#& "D#99& $%!

#& "+'%  *(!%,  $ 9& /$* /,$- '$& $/  (%,($? !" ,("99($% $% ,  "('  !' !  "  /,&& $- '  *  %,  9 %(%($ !  * (&($-    '% '

 ?<$$ B#! 1?=* ! ! "9$' $%6&%( % & +)(' !' !

'% '  ?  <$$ B#!  1 =+  9"" '  *  ! "9$' $%  +  ,(& '("

(""($-%, "(' %, 9 %(%($ !+%, !' !'% '??," * $#9, &'  2 $/ +  *     %,  9! " $%  !(%  9 %(%($  #$' !  !%(/& "

 E %, 
$"%(%#%($ $'(+%, 9 %(%($ !("" ;($-(""#$/  

!(%($%, $%#!  / !%(!!( !F#",($-%,  ! "('!' !"'% '

??<$$ B#! 1 =$'? <$$ B#! 1 = > 4 !$ '/#$" & !%, 9 %(%($ !!-# '%,%%, 9 %(%($ !+

, " !;($-"(& - !"($/ %,  ! >+ "$ ) !"; '$

'/# $%! -!'($-,("'%  *(!%,) $%%, %( %!$"

! ,("

" !)(/ "%! "9$' $%
!9!%($$?

+,  "$%"; '% "#* (%$ '/# $% (%,! -!'%,("'%  *(!%,"9 !%, ! & )$% #& "$%, "#*C /%+! F# "%! -!'($-/!! /%($ '%  *(!%,($%,

1>1 ! /!' %, ' 9!% $%/$*  ' * %, /$/ !$ ' 9& (%,($?

!" ,(" $%!

($%G) !$ $%" !)(/ $'($%, ($"%$%/" +%,  !'"

@ $%!

($%G) !$ $%" !)(/ A",#&'* %; $ >+ , $ " !)(/ " %, 9 %(%($ ! ! ! -#&!(" '2 $/ +)(' ! 9! " $%%($'% '  +(  (%,($%, "%(9#&% '9 !(' ? !" %, '%  ,("

$%!

($%G) !$ $%" !)(/ +%, 9 %(%($ ! ' ! F# "% !/!! /%($  ,("'%  *(!%,($%, ! /!' %, ! "9$' $%
!9!%($2 ) !+ ! "9$' $% + ,(&  !$-& /$"(' !($-%,%%, 9 %(%($ ! $% ! '($% G) !$ $%" !)(/ ($%,  !

+ , $,("" !)(/ " ! %!$"

!! '% %, ! "9$' $%
!9!%($+! C /% ',("/&( $%, -!#$'%,%,  '

%, ! 9! " $%%($" ;($-/!! /%($ ,("'%  *(!%, % ! !" ,("

$%!

($%G) !$ $%" !)(/ ( (&!)( ,"* $%; $* ! "9$' $% + ,(/,/$$%* "#"%($ '($%,  /%"$'/(!/# "%$/ " %,("/" 

  ,) -() $#!%,#-,% #&/$"(' !%($%%, "#* (""($"

' * & !$ '/#$" & !%, 9 %(%($ ! ? '

(%% '& + $ ?

+ , $ " !)(/ "  %, 9 %(%($ !

! %!$"

!! '%%, ! "9$' $%
!9!%($+$%( (/%($($%,("! -!'

"(""# '+ , ! ($,("'%  *(!%, "! /!' '"@ > ? A$'%, " '%  "/!!( '#%($,("" !)(/ ! /!'%/$$%* "('%,%%, 9 %(%($ ! "$% !  %,(" /%2 !

($ '"(& $% !&$-9 !('  !"$%,  ! + ,(& /&( ($-%,%/%#&& +,("'%  *(!%,("

@?>

A+,  ' ! F# "% !/!! /%($ ,("'%  *(!%,, !-# $% & !$ '/#$" & !%, 9 %(%($ !%,%%, 9 %(%($ ! $% ! ' ($%G) !$ $%" !)(/ $>+ , $,("" !)(/ " ! ! -#&!(" '+ /$$%* // 9% '%("%, '

(%% '/"  %, 9 %(%($ !%,%, C($ '"

(&  - !  $    >  $'  ,("  " !)(/ "  !  %!$"

!! '  %  %, ! "9$' $%
!9!%($$?

+! -!'($- ,(/,$%( (/%($ "

&"(""# ',#"+$%, "(''% +%, 9 %(%($ ! $% ! '($%G) !$ $% " !)(/ $%, "('$%( (/%($+'%  *(!%, %, 9 %(%($ ! "! /!' '

"@ > ? A+ ,(/,("9! "# '%* ) !

&& (%,($,(";$ & '-  ,#"+"9 !%, #& "+ (%,($9 !(' ? !" %, '%  "('

$%( (/%($+%, 9 %(%($ !/#&' ' ! F# "% !/!! /%($ ,("'%  *(!%,!9 !('  !"+, '('$% ; $ "#/,! F# "%

 $%,  ! "(' /%"$'/(!/# "%$/ " %, /" +)(' %, ( 9#-$ '!' !'% '? +! "9$' $%,"!(-,%& #9, &'%, !' !'% '? 9"" '* ! "9$' $% ! C /%($-%, /&( %, 9 %(%($ ! !/!! /%($ ,("'%  *(!%,($,("" !)(/ ! /!',#"+

! $%($/&($ '% $% !%($%, ($"%$%9 %(%($  ("

("" '  
!

    9% * !+  "  
#!

$'C   , %, !"9 ;($-E! "$ '

7 "E , %, ! 9!%*&  7 "