High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1855/2016dismissed

Shiri Bhagwan & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2022-08-31The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

"#$ % &

#'#( "#$&

)*+ +*,-.,#)*, /,,#"0* 1 ' )0,0 , 3,#,,#"0* 1 #0 5$ 675)2)89) 675)77

#0$ 5 ),#"

4)*, /,9"!(,0 9

0* 5 #:' 5+00,;9 ""; "!(,0 # ,;9 , 3,#,9.+0* 5 ),' ,<* 5,-9 0 "!(,0 # ,; , 3,#,9 ,#" 58'*,;"

485,#(*,#",9"!(,0 9

0* #0 +#0,#0 4 0+0+# *, <

# +;

" (;,+/+#- 0*,0 0* ,(='++0+# 4 (

"+#-(, + "'0!+"

#0+ +(,0+#+'

"'#"

) (0+#>? 7,#" (='++0+# (09 %> ",0 & &

& ,#"

(0+!

;3@ ;;.

"<30* ,., "",0 %

90*

<3,(='+ +#- ;,#" ,4'<;+(4' 4 9#,/ ;3 0* "

#0,#"'0+;+A,0+# ;,#", +"

#0+,;,#"// (+,;) (0 >%

9' '- ,/=',0* + ;,#"(/4 + "+#8*, ,BB

C D+0',0 ".+0*+#0* #'

0,0 2+;;,- ,"*,*4' 9 *+;? +0 +(0' '- ,/*,;,4 "+# !+ . 4 !++# ) > C D +-*0 0 ,+ /4 #,0+#,#" ,#4, #(3+#7,#"(='++0+# *,<+;+0,0+#,#"

00;

#0(09

&C * 09E0*

&FD

.+#-00* (#0 !

3 '40 ", -, "0* +#0 0,0+# 4 !++# )

&9;+:

/,#30* . +0 0+0+#90* 4 (

"+#-+#0* +#0,#04 0+0+#.

40+#,< 3,#(

,.,+0+#-0* "

(++# )'4 ' 0* (#0 !

3., +#,;;34'0 ,0 0 <3 0* #0+0'0+# #(* )'4 ' 0 +#

! #';0+/,0 4, ,- ,4* .*+(*+ 4 "'( "*

+#< ;.$ "# $ % & '

('( & ) % &

& % & % *+ %

%& % * & )- ) )) %% .& , & - % & + &,

& & '

('-(% & % * & % / % - * 0)"1 & '(- )

-"1 "1 0 % &2 &, & '(% & % * 3

&) & % %% &

& % & + % - 3&

- )+ & - 3+ &

- + % &

- + -

3 0 .

4 4 %

& '(% & % * & %&

& 0&2&%5 & '( & - ) & 6 % ,

-%& '

)( % %& % &2 & % & % /

- &

&&& ) % & % * & - , & * % &2 & %

/ -% %

+ & *% & &-, 75 %&

' & (

% &2

&, & % 5 ) &

6 % ,%% +&

& % * - 8 )8 % %& % &2

& % & % / 9 & - &

& * '

(% & %

/ + & &2

& '( 5 5 %&

& 0- , &

- , & * '

(

& ))% &&

) , %& % , &

+ & & &2 &,

& '(% & % * ! 0 & '(% & % * - % & '( % & '

('-( : 0 % 3, & % / &

& '( - ),%2 ; <&) - 3, & !% & % / +

& '(% & % *+&

- 3 & '( / 0 % & '( ,% % &,

&- & % & 3

% % -% & % *& %&+ &,%

&2 , ) &&

0 % - & %

-& -.& &

% %

& '(% & % * , ) & % & 2 , % && &, % &2 &

&, , %%& % & % *+ + 5- & &&

) ) 2 , % % 3, &,

% %&

% & &2 1 & '/,#"'<0,#( +#0 0,0+# ) (0

& <3 0* )'4 ' 0 + 0*,0 0* + 0 ,#" /0 (#"+0+# 0

: ;,4+#- + 0*,0 <0* 0* (#0+#- #(+ 4 !+"

" + ,<'00* 4*3+(,;4 +#,#"0* 4,3/ #0 (/4 #,0+#, 0<

+;;

"9/ ,#+#-0*

<39+ +0* (#"+0+#+#0,0+ + "90*

.';"< #;,4+#- , ,0* <;+-,0+#0/,:

4,3/ #0+#;+ ' ;,#" ,(='+ " + (#( # "9 +0 *, <

# (;, + + " 0*,0 '(* <;+-,0+# 0 4,3 + (/4;

<3 0 #"

+#- 0* (/4 #,0+# .*+(* .';" / ,# 0*,0 0* (/4 #,0+# ,/'#0 ., /,"

,!,+;,<;

0 0*

> ;,#".# ,#"+ * *,#0,(( "0* ,/ 9+0.+;;#0< ,!,+;,<;

0* ;,#" .# 0 (;,+/ 0*,0 0* (/4 #,0+# *, #0 <

# 4,+" )+/+;, ;39 0* . " G"

4+0H *, <

# +#0 " 0 / ,# "

4+0+#- .+0* 0* 7 0* ,' 3 0*

#( ' 0 ,.+#- 4,#(*#,/, *, <

# (#+"

" 0 < , !,;+" 4 0,:+#- 4*3+(,; +# ,#" #( ;,#" 0,#" !

" +# 0* )0,0 9 0*

+ # "+!

0+#-4 !+"

"'#"

)

&* )'4 ' 0*, ' 0* (;, + + "0*,00* +" .*+(*,#3+#0 +/ "

., +# 4 ,0+#9 .+;; < I(;'"

" .*+;

(/4'0+#- 0* -,4 4 +" +!

, )+/+;, ;39+0*,<

#(;, + + "0*,0)

&" #0-+!

+ 0,# .(,'

,(0+#0='

0+#0* ;

-,;+03 (#(;'"

"4 (

"+#- ;,#",(='++0+#,+0,44;+ 0#;30* (, .*

+#0* 4 (

"+#-.

#"+#-#0* ",0 # ( #0

& > 4 (, 4'0 0* <3 0* 4 9 0* 3 , .# 8*, ,BB

C D+0',0 ".+0*+#0* #'

0,0 2+;;,- ,"*,*4' 9 *+;,#" +0 +(0' '- ,/* ,+";,#".,,(='+ <3 0* !

#/ #0 , 3,#, <3 +'+#- #0+ +(,0+# ",0

& &

&,#"

>'#"

) (0+#>? 7,#"(='++0+# (09 %> ;;.

" <3 ,., " ",0 %

0* 4'<;+( 4' 4 #,/ ;39 "

#0 ,#" '0+;+A,0+# ;,#" , +"

#0+,; ,#" // (+,;) (0 >%

9' '- ,/0+0* (, 0*,0 "

4+0 *,!+#-,##'#( "0* ,., "# %

90* #0*,!

,+;

"00,:

4 +# ;,#"+#='

0+#,#" #0* ,/'#0 (/4 #,0+# *, # +0* <

# 4,+" # "

4+0 " +# 0*

#( ' 0 *

9 0* ,(='++0+# 4 (

"+#- =', 0* ;,#" +# ='

0+# 0,#";,4 "+#!+ . )

*,!

,; ,+ " 4;

, "+( +/+#,0+# ,#" *,!

4 ,3 ;

, + ;,#"

*'-*+#0* 4;

,"+#- 0+0+#90* *,!

,+ 4;

, "+( +/+#,0+#<3(#0 #"+#-0*,0,;;0* ,"J,( #0;,#" *,<

# ;

, "9*.

+#"#/ +0+#0* 4;

,< +#- ,+ ",+0+*+-*;3!,-'

,#"++# ,(0*+0<3"

;,3,#";,(* 9+#( ,(='++0+#4 (

"+#-0"(#(;'"

".,3<,(:+#0* 3 ,

,#" ,0 ,#4+ /0* 4;

,"+#-+0 ;

9,0#4+#0 0+/ *," (*,;;

#- " 0* ,(='++0+# 4 (

"+#-9 0*

9 (#+"

+#- 0* (4 +#0,#0. +04 0+0+#9.

.';"< (#+"

+#-#;30* 4;

, ,44;+(,<+;+03 )

&#0* ,(='++0+# 4 (

"+#- 0* ;,#"+#='

0+# (#0 ,9 5 #:' 5+00,;9 ;

, # " ('# ; ,44 , +#- 0*

#0 )0,0 9 '</+00 " 0*,0 0* +#0,#0 4 0+0+# "

0 < "+/+ "+#!+ . ;,.;,+"".#<30* )'4 ' 0+#0* (, #"

#0 '0* +03 C'4 ,D , ## (#0+#- #(+ ( +< "+#)

&, ';

+;;

"* + 0,#"

/0 ='+ #0 0 (;,+/ ;,4+#- ,(='++0+# 4 (

"+#- + 0 4 !

0*,00* ;,#".# ++#4 +# ;,#"+#='

0+#9.*+(* 4 *,!

,+;

" 0 *. , 0* 4 +# ;,#" +# ='

0+#.,0,:

#<30* )0,0 <3 ( "+#-,4,0A#,/(*,

",0 %

9 ,#" ,/ *, <

# * ;" , , !,;+" /"

0,:+#- +##( '(*4 +#+0,:

#90* ;,#"!

0,<;'0 ;3+# )0,0 ,#".* 0,+# /,+#+#0* 4 +# ;,#"9 * +,0 4, ' 0* '</+00*,00* <;+-,0+# )0,0 0 4,30* (/4 #,0+#0,#""';3"+(*, - ",0* #0+ (/4 #,0+# ,/'#0 ., 0 #"

" ,0 0* 0+/ ,##'#( #0 ,., " ,#" .,

/,"

,!,+;,<;

00* ;,#".# '</+00*,0, -, "0* ;,#"+# ='

0+#9 (/4 #,0+# ,/'#0 ., "

4+0 " +# 0*

#( ' 0 !+"

(* ='

# %&& ",0

*'9 ## (#0+#- #( 0(;,+/;,4+#- ,(='++0+#4 (

"+#-, ';

+;;

"+# (, ,0*,#",#"0* 0+0+#"

0< "+/+ " K ,!+#- * , " 0* (0+!

, -'/ #09 -+#- 0* '-* 0*

(0+!

,"+#-,#",<!

,;;0* I4+0+# #"

#0 '0* +03 C'4 ,D9 .

, (#+"

" 4+#+# 0*,0 0* +#0,#0 0+0+#+;+,<;

0< "+/+ / 0*,## ,# 4 +# 0* +#0,#0 4 0+0+# *,!

(;,+/ " 0 < +# 0* 4*3+(,;4 +# ;,#"+#='

0+#+0+!

(, 0'4<30* +0*,0 #0*'-*0* ,., ".,4, "# %

,#" 3 "+" #0 /,:

(*,;;

#- 0 0* ,(='++0+# 4 (

"+#- <'0 0* 4*3+(,; 4 +# *, #0 <

# 0,:

# / 0* / # 0*+ -, "9 0*

#0*,!

"0* . +00 #0,0 #0'</+00+#-0*,04 +# ., 0,:

# <3 " ,.+#- 4,#(*#,/, +# 0* / ,4,0 A#,/(*,

",0 %

.*+(**,<

#* ;",,!,;+"/"

0,:+#- +# ;,#") (0+# %>4 !+"

0*,0, 0,:+#- 0* 4 +# ;,#"9 +0 !

0 +# 0* )0,0

/ ,;;

#('/< ,#( *

#( +# 0*+ -, " + /,"

0 0* ;;.+#- 4, ,- ,4* /0* J'"-/ #0$

! "

#$ % & !

( "

) !

$% * +) ,

( "- "

K ! "

$% ."

)

/ ."

! )

" &

)

) )

" 0&."

! !

( "

%%& +) )&

& % / + - 3,

& % 03,

& % * )

3, & % =

> &2 )

% 3, + 3,

& % < ,&3%

))&&2+ >

&%& &

- % %)& -&2 &

& )

" ") )

% *'9.

, (#+"

"4+#+#0*,00* 4*3+(,;4 +# ;,#"+#='

0+#0,#""';30,:

#,#",/ *,!

"+#0* )0,0 *'9 0* 4;

, < +#- ,+ " <3 0* 4 < +#- +# 4*3+(,; +# ;,#"+#='

0+#+.*;;3/+(#( +!

",#"+;+,<;

0< J (0 "

! ! " # " #0 *,!

(,0 - +(,;;3 4;

" +# 0* . +00 # 0,0 #00*,00* ,/'#0 (/4 #,0+# 0* #0+ ,(='+ ";,#" .,/,"

,!,+;,<;

0,;;0* ;,#".# ,#".,"';30 #"

"#0*+

-, "95 5+00,;*,, "0*,0+#!+ . I4+0+#+##"

#0 '0* +03 C'4 ,D 0* <;+-,0+# )0,0 0 4,3 0* (/4 #,0+# + "+(*, - " + ,/'#0 (/4 #,0+# + 0 #"

.*+(**,<

#+#0 "0/ ,#0*,00* ,/'#0.,/,"

,!,+;,<;

0 0* ;,#" .# , < " +# , ,

& .*+(* + 4 "'( " *

+#< ;.$ 2*+ & !

' (

+ $ %

3 3

" 4

?) +& % -

) ) -&,% - ,

3 & & - % %

3, - "

" )

+ ++$! "

5 "

)

" ) "

+ %

)

) " )

+) !

* * +

6 "

7 8 "

) 8 " ,

+ $%)

?) + & ) , + -

& *+

& 6 "

7 8 " )

+ 9 !) ."

1 5 , 0,0 ,(0 (;

, ;3 ,; 0*,0 0* < !,0+# /,"

+#,<!

" #0 ;

,#3 (4 "'<0 0*,0 0* )0,0 *, "+(*, - "+0<;+-,0+#0., "/,:+#-0* (/4 #,0+# 0* ;,#"

% ,(='+ " *

9 0* <;+-,0+# )0,0 0 4,3 (/4 #,0+# 0,#""+(*, - ,;;+#0 #0,#"4' 4 ""$ %&'%( %)*+" )'4 ' 0+##"

#0'0* +03C'4 ,D*, (;

, ;3 < " 0*,0 "

" ;,4+#- ,(='++0+# 4 (

"+#- '#"

)

&9<0*0* (#"+0+#+ 4,3/ #0 (/4 #,0+# ,#" 0,:+#- 4 +# /'0 #0 < ';

+;;

" + +

+0* (#"+0+# + ';

+;;

"9 0* ;,4+#- (,##0 *,44 # * )'4 ' 0*,< "0*,00* . "G H((' +#-+#) >

&/'0< ,",G,#"B# H ;

!,#04, , /0* J'"-/ #0, 4 "'( "*

+#< ;.$ 2- 8 " 5

$%) !

&")

)

! !

* +

" & ) "

( ") '

( " '

( ' ( ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, ,,,,

* - :; 7 & <

- =##) 8

> "

) ,

(

" " " - !

@ '$ +%- !

)

" - ")3 3 3 33 3 - =, 4

3 3 3

$ %!

) " ! ! 3 - ) 3& ,

(

) 6-&9673 ) !

" 3 )33 3

-) ) "

) ! !

)

! !

- " " ,

7 )*** $ %-) !)

)

3 3 ! "!

" "

& "

" - "

" " " " !

" ,7 )***5 $ 0% & ."

@ - "

A - " & "

( $ " % 0+ % % &2 &, )+ & '(%- - 3+ + & 3+ &

+ &2 &,

#1 #0* (, ,0*,#",

;

(0 /0* 4;3 +;

"9+0+ !+"

#0 0*,0 , ,., " ., ,##'#( " # %

9 0* 4*3+(,; +# ., 0,:

# <3 ( "+#- ,4,0 A#,/(*,

",0

,#" 0* (/4 #,0+# ,/'#0 0,#" 0 #"

" *

9 +#( ## (#"+0+# 4 ( +< " +# ) >C D (0

&, ';

+;;

"9,+"4 !++#(,##0< ;+ "'4#<30* 0(;,+/;,4+#- ,(='++0+#4 (

"+#-

13.

5 #:' 5+00,;9 # 0* 0 #-0* ,(0 4;

" +# 0* . +00 #0,0 #09*,!

* #0;3(#0 #"

"0*,00* )0,0 ,(='+ "0* ;,#" 0* 4'<;+( 4' 4 "

#0 ,#" '0+;+A,0+# ;,#" , +"

#0+,; ,#" // (+,; ) (0 >%

9 ' '- ,/ * ;,#" +# ='

0+#+!

3/'(*

#0+,;0,(*+ 4'<;+(4' 4 ,4 ;,3'0 4;,# , +0 ,

(0 "

#0 *44+#- +0 *,!

(#+"

"0*+4, 0 , -'/ #0 ,+ "<30* #0,#".

, +#

(/4;

#0 .+0* 0* ,/ , 0*+ + ,#+/4 0,#0 ,(0 0< :

40+#/+#".*+;

,;+#-.+0*0* (, , ++#-'0 ,(='++0+# ;,#"0,(*+ 4'<;+(4' 4 ,#"+0+0* )0,0 B+0,'0* +03.*+ +#0* < 04+0+#0"

(+"

,<'0'0+;+A,0+# ;,#",(='+ "9, +0*,!+#-<

"+#)0,0 14.

, ='

; ,<!

"+('+# ,#" +# !+ . ;,. '//, +A " +# 4, , && #"

#0 '0* +03 C'4 ,D9 (+ +(,;;3, *,!+#- ( "

"0*,0+#0* (, +#*,#"90* 4*3+(,; +# ;,#"+#='

0+#*,!+#-<

#0,:

#90* <;+-,0+# 4,3/ #0 (/4 #,0+#0,#""+(*, - ",#",;(#+"

+#-0*,00* ;,#"+#='

0+#+!

3/'(*

#0+,;0,(*+ 4'<;+(4' 4 9.

*,!

# * +0,0+# 0 *;" 0*,0 +# 0* +#0,#0 (, 9 0* )0,0 *, ';;3 "+(*, - "+0<;+-,0+#=',<0*0* (#0+#- #(+ ((' +#-+#)

&,#"+0< +#-90* +#0,#04 0+0+#+"+/+ " ,!+#- "+/+ " 0* /,+# . +0 4 0+0+#9 4 #"+#- ,44;+(,0+#9 + ,#39,;/

00* ,/ ,0 )0,0'='9+ ,#390,#"!,(,0 " C2)8D ) C77D &

#"J * 4 ,:+#-B ,#

B * 4 0,<;