Ashwani Kumar And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"!
#$%&'&' ()* ( ''''
( + ,"-"
( ( '''
( ( $ ./ ' ( *
#$ ,'(#0
1*-2,34 1
,"' ,'*-#7+!8#944 -#0:'
,'-9 "5*-2,5#;,4 1
"'# '
*4'< /= 8 38
6, # 6 #4 5 6 ," , "
9!#;
>-"5!#;
'%% ''%-# #"4?%4?
!# '%@4 ''%4 , ;!"
, 5
6-#!"5:7 #?%44?# ?
7!
(!
,847# 5,<## A-, = :"!"
'
#''45
3!#; ,3"6""
$ B5 6, # 6 # 5" :
# 2 !#1 9!#;
0-,!" ! !
5!" -,-# #?&,'
''"
9!#;
>-"5!#;
'%% ''%-# #"
4?%4? !# '%@ ''%-# ( #" ?%44? # ? , ;!"
7!
(!
# ,8 !",! 7# 5, # 77 "-:"
!#;",!"!#;5 :"!"
' / ,# -#"
7
# "55
2 ,7, 8"# " 1!
%''%<## A-, ='
2 #'
,',-#;;,374( #!
,'4 -#0:66 ,"
# 6"# #:
57
'%( ,'-9 "5*-2,4 1 66 ,"# 6"
#:
57
'# # 2!"5
!#; 3
"' #1!
3
:
45 !, 66 , :
7 ,# ,!7 -,C77>;!", #@''' #5 !,
!#;"
45 7 ,# ,!7 -,C77>;!", "577,
, 5 !, " #"# -,#!"5!", , 5!" -,:85 A
5 ,!#;
3!#;"6 "$ %'-2:
,"
#",,8 " -"
!#5 267!#'
')5 ,#8 -"
!"6, 7!2
,D ' )5 , 5 !" ;
#-!# 4 1 7-#,8 # 3!5 -#8
, !
,-# - !# 7- ?')5 -"
,"
#", !#1 !##8 "
,# D E'5 ,!7 -,!"7"
!,
, 5 " #
#1 "!;!#;
, " 5 3 2#8 1! !2"C
267!##", !#5 267!#'
68
,:
7"
"
#
;!",,- ! !7
5!" -,'
"" "85!# "
,#8, "
" #"
, ,
"! 45 7 ,# ,!7 -,C-8 ;!", "577:
7!:
,8 775 ##8 , :-# 7 ,5#3
95 ,' -6 #%&'&'' 7!" 7 #;3!5 ?%%'F '
-,"-# 5
"! ,4 , , 2 - ! !7 ;!", "7""4 5!77-, %'&'5":
#,
!1 435! 5 !"9 #,
, ' "6 ,45 ,!7 -,5",
"
3"$ B 2 "!"
5 5 !" ;
#-!#
:
3
"# 5 "2 -
!, 3#
3!77# 3!5 -#8
4
, !
,-# -
!# 7- "6 ," #
!#1 "!;!#;
,4#
-"
7, "6, 7!2
,!#5!" "
#8 , ,!2!#7 "
"6 " #
!#1 "!;!#;
,45
-"
,"
#", !#1 !##8 "6 " #
#1 "!;!#;
,45 !"
#78 267!## #2 78 !!# *-2, ::! # # ,1! !2C!#0-, #2 78(-2!*-2,::!!#5
# "
'F ?'
/ ' -#"
766 ,!#;
' 2!"5
6,!
"51!#; # " "55 5"# :0 #!# "
# 776,
!#;""-:"
#5 ;!#"5 ,",
>-"5 E'
(!2!7,78/ '( -#"
75"" :0 #!# "
!">-"5 :"
-6 @'
51 5 , / ' -#"
7
"# 51 ,
-778 ;
5, -;55
, "
"
'
,!#;0- ;2 #, :85 6 A -,!# !#(!#;51"'(
-#0:# # ,4%<%=(4(
58 , "5 1"' /A2! ,8# # ," <%= E(@&&4 *-73!# ,(!#;5G ,"1"'(
-#0:G# ,4<=
<,!2!#7= %E # 2 67 # # , 1"' (
58
, "54%<?= ''
'<,!2!#7=<,!2!#766 7 '%?&
% #5
( 6 2:
,4%=4 5 6, "!!
735
,;
25
"! !"!
#", :86 A -,# 5!"
-,!"$ <=
,-C"?&,'
''1 " 3!55!" -,!"
:8( #
<:= ,43!
,;, -!
#'
? < = 5 ,7!#!#;6,!# !67 35!7 , !"!#;"- 5 , !" 5 ! # :
!#1 >-"5 5
!#;" ,
;#!H!#; :
3
# 5
6,!
"!#5 2 ,"35! 5, ,35 72!#;78#
2!##78
!1!7 5, , 7!9 , !7 ,#" !
#" ,,!"!#; -
2,!2 #!7, 7!
#"5!6
2!78 !"6- "' < = 5 "! 6 ,!"# :
, !"
!# 5 6, -!
#" !#1 71!#;5 !# -"# "
,!
-"
2 #7 6,1!8
"7!9 2-, ,4 ,6 4 !8 '""- 5
6,!1 !# #-, # 51 "
,!
-"!26 #"
8'
< = ( #?&,'
'' "" -8-6 !;5 -, 1# !# "
0-"!
"3 77'!"!#
;#!!
5!" -8 " -6 !;5 -,4 56 A -,5 7 55 !;5 -,3 -7 #
-"
>-"5 #2 78:
-"
!# "2 #!
' !;5 -, #""
""
#-,
!#0-,!
" "-"!# 4 35 , "- 5 !#0-,!
!# 7! #1!7C 7! 6,"
8C#-,
6 #"-"
' < = (- 5 , !"
5 5# "
!;5 -,3 -7 :
,2!""!:7 #78 1!
!#1 "!;!
## 5,;
"5
!" !7 C 5,;
,2
-,!#;5 ,!7'(- 5 , !"
## :
,,!
- 35!7 2 ,!""!77-# ,!#1 "!;!
#' <;= )5!7 >-"5!#; !# # # -# :7
#35! 5,
6,!1 !##-, 4!;5 -, !" , >-!, , #
#"
5
-"
4 # -
-"
# 35 ,5 3"
:"
# !#; , 35 , 5 5" 2#;
5
267!## ,!#
E &' 5-"49
6!#;!#1!
35
"! "# !, -2"# "4 5!" -,!"
6!#!
#5!!" ! "
, !"
0-,!" ! !
#1 " -C"?&,'
'' >-"55 "$ <!= 5 6, # 2 ,
" # 77 3!5!# 5
6!
#"" ,1 -!# /A2!,8#."
"
<"-6,=' <!!= 5
6,!1 #-, ' <!!!= 5 "51 <!1= "6 ,,
!1 !"
"! 1 7-#,8!#!"#-, <1= 267!##C1! !2 5"
!#
#5!" 3#1 7!!
#' '
#"
#784 5 6 # !" 77 ' '%%
''% -# , ( #" 4 ?%4 ? !# '%@4
''%4 , ;!"
"6-#!"5:7 #?%4 4?# ?
7!
(!
# ,847# 5,<## A-, = # 77 6,
!#;" ,!"!#; 5
24 , 4 5 :84 >-"5 >- 5
,"'
< *= %&'&' 6,8 )5 ,"6 9!#;C, "
$ "C )5 ,:7 $ "C