← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/953/2009allowed

Sachin And ORS. v. Ramesh Chand And ORS.

2025-07-22Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

     

    

!"

#$%$!&'

()* +   





  

  

 '

,-

./ . .  .  

   



  

  !

   

  "

  # 

  $

%%%% .  .

/

&          '

       

     (  ) * +,   -. / .   

    '

        &



0 # 

 

!

&         '  

       1    2$ "223

    !44  

  !3551 '#  '# 6

'

             & '     7

 8 & '891  

.

 

. "

:  2!

"22;

      1   &     #  ' 

   *!4* *$344 1   1    ' 5!2

1       0<    !

   '     =*!3* *"44;     '     



 1    1

# '  

 1 0 =   1     '



$

>         

 1   #  6   

?

 

& '

  1

 *  

 





 

  

!"#$#$$ %

&!#'##$$



(

% %  *+!!

 

  -

 (        

   (.)  ,( ,  *+!!

/     

  

    

   (  %   ) *0(  (( )0   +! 1     )  

  ,

%   

  (   )  %-

  ,*+!  (2 . ...

 -

.-   .

;

The learned counsel for the appellants-claimants contends that the learned Tribunal has dismissed the claim petition only the ground that

Ram Piari (deceased) herself was negligent in driving her scooty. &

 #  ' 1

      

 *@  #    

  !"  1

#     #' 

&# #

 

    @     

  1 

  



  

 

#       1 1    * 03345 +  

 





 6 

   3 !"#$## /'$$   %   &!#'##$$  

  

(

% %   * +!!

 

   ( 



  







 (    %   7   %           (    

  (









(3 7 %

( 

     (    ( 0 ,(( ) 

,( 

  8 ,

,)  ( , ,(   

!#

9

 



9)  (  

,

( 

(



 3  

( 

+

 9( ,)   ,(!#

 % 7 

,( ,))





, ( , %  (

, ( ,

(3  )) ( , % 

  (

%









(% 7 %  +    

%  

 &

 

  

% %% 



    ,  )

9) 

( %

  

 ) 

(  

     9

  ( %   8 ,   %  

    

))       

 ,  



% 



 % 





 %

  3 

(

) (  ) 

 7        3

  (% : %   ,









(3 7 %

: ( ,)

(

 %

 

 (

 

  

% 

) 

%:  (    ( ) 

    

%

 

%

(

 (

  )        

  

 

     

  

(% 7 %  

 / 080 

%

,

9)  ( 

%

,( ,%

  9



3 " % 

 

% %

!#:

)  !#   % 

, ( ,% 8  , 

) 80% %

  (    %

   3         

0 ,()  % 

 



%  ,) % %&

     9

(%

3 3

 ,  %   ( ,% 3 

,  

) %    %% :  

(  

) % %

    3 

) (

     9 3

   (% 10 (



,

 % 0 

 (

 )  







(% 7 %   :



 ( 



  

  -

 (        

    (.)  ,( ,  *+!!

0



)

    

7   ( 

 -

% 

"(

 ,

 

  

 

     

   

 % %

 (  



%)   ,)



( ,     (   

  : 

 



 0        

       & '   

           '#    6

= 6  

     

  1   & '

 

         B 1  

@  

  ,@  1    # #'#  &00   ,@    ,@ C # '   B

'

1 1    # 1   

  # D*"&00 1  #*1

  



  '  # '#& ' =      '

   

     

 # '#   B

) ' 'E  #  

*F     #1   

'#   '

!!

& & '  1

  

       ,@     

 1   '  1

  &   # ' @    

1,@  F '#   #

 @   #     1   

 F     

 &

& '

  

  ,@   1 

'

   #  '  

!"

, 

 *  7GF *!9 #     (E # / '#

'

- 

&       #1   

 



  

0'#  

  1' 1 '  ,   

 '

1    '##  ' #    

!$

@  1   

  

      

C   





'#   ' ' '         ''

@     

#   '  &     #  D*"

   

'

  '#    ,@         # '       ''#

 

   



'#  B

!?

@ 

 

    1 

  '#     & '    1 2$ "223 ' # 1  #

    C# 



!;

= 1

  1  '# & '  @

 "



       '0    & '    

 " ( 

-

 (        

   (.)  ,( ,  *+!!

!4

                 '

    & '   2"

"2"; & ' '



F  #

'#1   F 

 #

!A

 

 #   

.  .  

 

 

  D 06 * 00   D ' H