High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6382/2011dismissed

State Of Punjab Thr. Publici Prosecutor, Ropar v. Kiranbir Singh Kang & ORS

2016-01-11Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain6 pages

#$% &%'()(*+

!+ , -!.. - /%)%*$+ !/(0%)1 1#/&2#34 %56$7&8'#$%%*%/#046*3#9 !/!#*()1:%/;#4&8'#$% //%)5*&%*$ !/<#*2#03($.(*=14.%*(/&8'#$%2($1 !/#)2#*$.(*=14&8'#$% /$1%#550('#*$(* ! >?

#3%)1 (*&#0 1%.$#$%1#) (0%&$1%5/%)%*$5%$($(*(;56=*(*=$1%/&%/ &#$%&

45#))%&970%#/*%&.%))(*)6&=%465*#=#/421%/%97$1% #550('#$(* (0%&97$1%5%$($(*%/6*&%/.%'$(* / /2($1&/#2#0 5/)%'6$(*@6#$1%/%)5*&%*$)42#)&();())%& -%#/*%&'6*)%0 /$1%5%$($(*%/)69;($$%&$1#$A> &#$%& ?

B2#)/%=()$%/%&*$1%)$#$%;%*$ .#;#*&%%5.(*=14 .40('%.$#$(*4<1#/#/6*&%/.%'$(*)

4 ?4B 4B>4 >#*&

$1%*&(#*%*#0&%#*& A $1%/;)'$%5/$6*&%/ .%'$(*?

"/2#)5/%)%*$%&(*$1%';5%$%*$'6/$*

B 1#/=%)2%/% /#;%& #=#(*)$$1%#''6)%&*

? .;% #''6)%&49%(*=#==/(%8%&4 (0%&2/($5%$($(*)(*$1()'6/$4(*21('10( %#*& 0(9%/$7 $1%5%$($(*%/)$1%/%(*2#)&(/%'$%&$9%5/$%'$%&1% (/%'$/ %*%/#0 0('%4 6*3#94 8(&% /&%/ &#$%&

? &(/%'$%&

'*)$($6$(* .5%'(#0*8%)$(=#$(*=%#; /)1/$4,.,"$)69;($($) /%5/$. 6*&$1%'#)%#=#(*)$$1%#''6)%&$9%#9)06$% #0)%*$1% 9#)() $1%/%5/$ .4$2)6550%;%*$#/7/%5/$)2%/%)69;($$%&9% /% $1%'6/$ ()'1#/=% $1%#''6)%&2#)#0)5/#7%& /$()$1%# /%)#(& #550('#$(*421('12#)/%3%'$%&97$1%'6/$9%028(&%(;56=*%&/&%/ &#$%&

* $1% # /%)#(& #'$6#0 ;#$/(D4 0%#/*%& '6*)%0 / $1% 5%$($(*%/)69;($$%&$1#$*'%(*8(%2 8#/(6)/&%/)5#))%&97$1()'6/$ #*&*,90%$1%.65/%;%6/$(*$1%5%$($(*) (0%&97$1%#''6)%&4. 2#)'*)$($6$%&21('14# $%/$1/6=1%*@6(/74 6*&$1#$(* #'$$1%#''6)%& #0/%#&7*#;%&(*$1%2%/%*$/%#0'605/($)4#)$1%

%*'%1#&9%%* ';;($$%&97);%*%%0)%4$1%.$#$%1#&/(=1$07 (0%&$1%#550('#$(* )%%E(*=2($1&/#2#0 5/)%'6$(**%)160&1#8%9%%*;#&%$ #'% 5/)%'6$(*( 1%2#)*$(*808%&(*$1%'/(;%$1#)&(/%'$/%0#$(*2($1 1()0(9%/$7 * $1% $1%/ 1#*&4 0%#/*%& '6*)%0 / /%)5*&%*$ )655/$%&$1%'#)%)%$6597$1%5%$($(*%/ -%#/*%&'6*)%0 /$1%#550('#*$)69;($$%&$1#$($()#'#)%

90#$#*$;()6)% 52%/)97$1%.$#$%1%/%)5*&%*$)2%/%#''6)%&(*$1% /%=()$%/%&(*($(#007412%8%/42($1'1#*=% 52%/4/%)5*&%*$4 211#)#

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

5/)%'6$(*2#) (0%&97$1%.$#$%(;50%#&(*=*07$1%#''6)%&#)$1% /%)5*&%*$)*% $1%';50#(*#*$)2#);#&%$1%/%)5*&%*$$'*$%)$ $1% '0#(; 1%* $1% ';50#(*#*$) '#;% $ E*24 $1%7 ;8%& $1% #550('#$(*)%%E(*=(*$%/8%*$(*#)5#/$71%$/(#0 $1%#''6)%&(*$1%

5/%)%*$'#)%21%*$1%'1#/=%)1#&#0/%#&79%%* /#;%&4'#**$9%)#(&$9% #96)% 5/'%)) 0#2 %#/&0%#/*%&'6*)%0 /$1%5#/$(%)#*&5%/6)%&$1%5#5%/ 9E *$1%'#)%(*1#*&42#)/%=()$%/%&6*&%/.%'$(*)

?4B 4B>4 >#*&

$1%*&(#*%*#0&%#*& A $1%/;) '$#=#(*)$$1%/%)5*&%*$) $%/(*8%)$(=#$(*4'1#00#*2#)5/%)%*$%&(* '6/$4*21('1'1#/=%)2%/% /#;%&#=#(*)$$1%/%)5*&%*$)*

? *% $1%;#(*#''6)%&(*$1%4*#;%074<(/#*9(/.(*=1<#*=9%0*=) $$1%/60(*=5#/$7(*$1%.$#$%421('1'#;%(*52%/(*

B1%/%# $%/4 $1%.$#$%'*)$($6$%&.42($16$5%/;())(* $1%'6/$#*& (0%&$2 )6550%;%*$#/7/%5/$)(*$1%'6/$%D*%/#$(*=$1%#''6)%&#*&(;50('#$(*= #*$1%/)%$ $1%#''6)%&*$1%9#)() $1%/%5/$)69;($$%&97.4 #550('#$(*)%%E(*=2($1&/#2#0 5/)%'6$(*#=#(*)$#)%$ #''6)%&2#)

(0%&421('12#)&();())%&97$1%'6/$9%028(&%(;56=*%&/&%/1% #''6)%&4211#&9%%*(;50('#$%&97. (0%&!C!C A

#39(/.(*=1#*&$1%/)8.$#$% 6*3#9#*&#*$1%/4#*&$1%/'**%'$%& 5%$($(*)4(*$1()'6/$421('12%/%#002%&8(&%36&=;%*$&#$%&

A )%$$(*=#)(&%$1%)6550%;%*$#/7'1#00#*)5/%)%*$%&*$1%9#)() /%5/$

.#*& 6/$1%/#''%5$#*'% $1%)6550%;%*$#/7'1#00#*97$1%00#@# !#=()$/#$% 1(0%&()5)(*= $1%# /%)#(&5%$($(*)4$1()'6/$9)%/8%& $1#$$1%'#)%)(*1#*&2%/%=0#/(*=%D#;50% 90#$#*$;()6)% 52%/)97 $1%(*8%)$(=#$(*=#=%*'721(0%'*&6'$(*=/%5%#$%&(*8%)$(=#$(*)4$$#007 '1#*=(*=$1%*#$6/%#*&)'%*#/( $1%'#)%4';50%$%07%D*%/#$(*=*% )%$ #''6)%&5%/)*)#*&(;50('#$(*=#*$1%/=/65 5%/)*)4$1#$$ 2($16$5%/;())(* $1%'6/$ *$1%/(;5/$#*$ #'$*$('%&()$1#$*$1%9#)() /%5/$

.4)6550%;%*$#/7/%5/$&#$%&??

?2#)5/%)%*$%&6*&%/.%'$(*?

"/9% /%$1%'6/$421('12#)/%3%'$%&8(&%/&%/&#$%&

#8(*= #(0%&(*$1#$#$$%;5$4$1%.$#$% (0%&#550('#$(** B

6*&%/ .%'$(* / )%%E(*= 2($1&/#2#0 5/)%'6$(*4 21('1 2#) &();())%&8(&%(;56=*%&/&%/&#$%&

$%/&();())#0

B #550('#$(*6*&%/.%'$(* /4<(/#*9(/.(*=1<#*=*$1%)#;% #00%=#$(*)=$

>&#$%& >

/%=()$%/%&%D#'$07*$1%)#;% #00%=#$(*)4 * $1%9#)() 21('1 #*$1%/ .2#) '*)$($6$%&421('1 5/%5#/%&($)/%5/$#*&5/%)%*$%&'1#00#*%D*%/#$(*=$1% #'$(* #''6)%& #

(0(#$%& $ <(/#*&%%5 .(*=1 <#*=4 21%/%#) (*808(*= #*$1%/ #'$(* #

(0(#$%& $ #39(/ .(*=1 1% # /%)#(& )6550%;%*$#/7 '1#00#* &#$%&

2#)/%3%'$%&97$1%!#=()$/#$%8(&%/&%/&#$%&

1% /&%/2#)'1#00%*=%&(*/%8()(*9% /%$1%.%))(*)6/$412%8%/4$1% /%8()(*2#)2($1&/#2**BB

1%'*&6'$ $1%.$#$%#*&(*'**(8#*'%2($1$1%#''6)%&() %8(&%*$ /;$1% #'$$1#$)%'*&)6550%;%*$#/7'1#00#*&#$%& >

4 21('12#)/%3%'$%&97$1%00#@#!#=()$/#$%#*&/%8()(*#=#(*)$21('11#& 9%%*2($1&/#2**BB

42#))6=1$$9%5/%)%*$%&9% /%$1%0%#/*%& .%))(*) 6&=% * AA

* $1% )6550%;%*$#/7 '1#00#* &#$%&

5/%)%*$%&9% /%$1%0%#/*%&.%))(*)6/$4/%5/$2#))6=1$

/;$1%00#@#!#=()$/#$%421#''%5$%&$1%)6550%;%*$#/7'1#00#*8(&% /&%/&#$%& ?

421('11#&#0/%#&79%%*/%3%'$%& 1()6/$(* #39(/.(*=1#*&$1%/),'#)%)65/#" /#;%&$1% 002(*=())6%)+ G("1%$1%/$1%(*8%)$(=#$(*=#=%*'71#)'*&6'$%&*07$1%

6/$1%/ (*8%)$(=#$(* / /%C(*8%)$(=#$(* #*& ($ 1#& * 36/()&('$(*$'*&6'$ /%)1//%C(*8%)$(=#$(*2($16$5/(/ 5%/;())(* $1%6/$H ((" 1%$1%/ $1% 0%#/*%& $/(#0 !#=()$/#$% 1#& %D'%%&%& 1%/ 36/()&('$(*421(0%5#))(*=$1%#98%)#(&(;56=*%&/&%/&#$%& ?

#''%5$(*=$1%)6550%;%*$#/7'1#00#*6*&%/.%'$(* ?

"/H ((("1%$1%/$1()(;56=*%&/&%/&#$%& ?

#;6*$)$ /%8(%2 $1%%#/0(%//&%/&#$%&

**%D6/%CA"H 002%/%#*)2%/%&(* #86/ $1%5%$($(*%/)$1%/%(*4211#& 9%%*;#&%#''6)%&(*$1%)6550%;%*$#/7'1#00#*9#)%&*$1%(*8%)$(=#$(* '*&6'$%& 97.1% )$/*= 9)%/8#$(*) ;#&% 97 $1() '6/$ (* $1% # /%)#(&'#)%#/%%D$/#'$%&9%02+ G. #/#)$1% #'$)($6#$(* $1%5/%)%*$'#)%()'*'%/*%&4

A $1% (;56=*%& )6550%;%*$#/7 '1#00#* 6*&%/ .%'$(* ? "

/1#)9%%* 6*&9#)%&**$*07 6/$1%/(*8%)$(=#$(* 96$*# /%)1#*&&%*8//%C(*8%)$(=#$(*421('1'0%#/07 /6*) '6*$%/$ $1%8%/7)'1%;% $1%&% /(;(*#0 /'%&6/%*8%)$(=#$(*=#=%*'7'#**$9%5%/;($$%&$902 1$#*&'0&(*$1%)#;%9/%#$14'1#*=(*=($))$#*& /;$(;% $$(;%4#)5%/($)2*)6($#9(0($7 1%#/=6;%*$/#()%&970%#/*%&.%*(/6*)%0 /$1% /%)5*&%*$$1#$$1()6/$1#)=/#*$%&(;50(%&'*)%*$$$1% (*8%)$(=#$(*= #=%*'7 / '*&6'$(*= %8%* $1% /%)1 (*8%)$(=#$(*4()*07$9%*$%&$9%/%3%'$%&49%(*=#21007 ;()50#'%&#/=6;%*$$()))#(&9%'#6)%$1%(*8%)$(=#$(*= #=%*'72#)&6$796*&$)%%E5/(/5%/;())(* $1%0%#/*%& 6/$ ';5%$%*$36/()&('$(*$'*&6'$ /%)14&%*8/ /%C(*8%)$(=#$(* *7 5)$C #'$ 9)%/8#$(*) ;#&% 97 $1% 6/$4#*&$1#$$(*#0$=%$1%/&(

%/%*$'*$%D$4260&9%

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

5/)%'6$(*=#=%*'7 $1%.$#$%#/%8%/7(;5/$#*$#=%*'(%) 2150#7)69)$#*$(#0/0%(*$1%36)$('%&%0(8%/7)7)$%;#*&#/% %D5%'$%& $ '*&6'$ $1%;)%08%) (;5#/$(#0074 #(/07 #*& &(0(=%*$072%8%/49$1$1%)%#=%*'(%) $1%/%)5*&%*$C .$#$%1#8%;()%/#907 #(0%&(*$1%(/&6$7(*$1%5/%)%*$'#)% 1()2#)$1%/%#)*$1#$$1%(;56=*%&)6550%;%*$#/7'1#00#* 6*&%/.%'$(*?

"/1#)9%%* 6*&$9%$1%/%)60$ #* #'$(* 2($16$ 36/()&('$(* #*& $1% )#;% '#**$ 9% )6)$#(*%&4 /$1()/%#)*#)2%00I 1%/%()#*$1%/=&/%#)*#8#(0#90%(*$1%'#)%(*1#*& (*8%)$(=#$(*=#*&5/)%'6$(*=#=%*'(%)$1#8%9%1#8%&(*$1();#**%/#) $1% ;#(* #''6)%&C<(/#*9(/ .(*=1 <#*= 2#) %0%'$%& #) .%*(/ :('% /%)(&%*$ .1(/;#*(E#0( #0 (*$1%7%#/

B#*&'*$%)$%&$1% %0%'$(*) 6*3#9:(&1#*.#91# /;$1%)#;%5#/$7 /$1%/%#)*);%*$(*%&#98%421%*$1()'6/$(* #39(/ .(*=1#*&$1%/),'#)%)65/#" 6*&$1#$$1%(*8%)$(=#$(*=#=%*'7&(&*$ 1#8%$1%36/()&('$(*$/%C(*8%)$(=#$%$1%;#$$%/2($16$5%/;())(* '6/$#*&$1%#550('#$(*)%%E(*=2($1&/#2#0 $1%5/)%'6$(*2#)9#)%& ;%/%07*$1%/%5/$ .'*)$($6$%& %8%*# $%/ /#;(*= '1#/=%) #=#(*)$$1%#''6)%&4(*;75(*(*4$1%/%()*%///(*$1%/&%/5#))%&97 $1%'6/$9%02 ''/&(*=074$1%5/%)%*$5%$($(*()&();())%& #3%)1 (*&#0"

6&=%

;E % %/$%5/$%/"