High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6385/2011dismissed

Ashwani Singal v. Educational Tribunal Pb. & ORS.

2017-03-29Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi8 pages

!" # $ & '( ) * + ,* (+-* (* .-" ' /

$ 1 "$2"

0 33&&-"& $2% &&& "$2"

4&)5"$ ($26 ("* .-

+ 0 (

%0 5 (( ' $

7*8 #9 0

-: ,* (+-* (* .-" ' "% *0 ( -:% %;

< - " " %0 " 00 0 4* : ( ((' = 0("4* " ((>

-:00 ( =. * 9 9 0 00 ( % - :

; . '< *-; 0 (:

*(:% (':% ((

;(: * %' %- * 2* 0 0 ' ;

* 0 + (.(* :; 9 --:% - 0 (2:2 *' % (2-* 0 (?* /. ("$

"( &*': # --:% '% * 5 %('

;2 '0 --:;

*( ?*-* '

-(*- (2(+ 2 0 ' --:; 0( 00; *(-'2 & --: - '" % (0 ;

--:% ;* ; -:

+ ( '

0 ' ' --:; * ; + 0( (('

* ( 5 ' 70( % 0 0(

! ! " 0 2;;* ; 2 0( :;;@*(: : ' %

;;0( % ' * ' $

0; 0( : ;; % 0

2 ' ' ; " 0 *-;

* 5 ' % 0(':+ " %00 ( %

* 0 =%2"-:(

" %; 0(*

00 ( 0 2/*(! ( '% ?* 9"

8A (* ; B (:$''2'

" 0 0 %0 *"

% %

,* ( +-* ( (

% (%/ +-* (" ' *

( 0 "

0 -:;0*'

#9 $'

-: +-* ("

- ( $ 1 "( *

(00 - ( " ;0*'

#9 (('( 02 2 - A < '*

' .* ; 00 -: ' ';; * 00 * :%*(- ' ';; 0(<

* '* 0

;;0(: ((' % * ( ''*(0; ( ?*: *( - ; 9 "3&&&-"( & *

(00 - ( " *-; %

;< *-; * /*(! : ( ((' &2 /*( "

: 0

0- 0"

;:-

'% ( ' ;7;*;0 : ((('4* < * *-; %( '(

;0( '

%5 0(; : ?*:

; % '

% * '; ; ' 0( (('

< 2 *

( 0 %

2' *' + 0 % 00 -: 00 ( % % 0 0 %*(-0(

0- 0 : ; . '<% *

0 %5 * *

:" ;0( 0 " ;:-

; ' =%2" %5 * * : 0" ; '; ;:7 0 * ;" ;:;

(* 00 ( 0 * ' 0

0- " (* '7

" *(- 0

% % *

' : % 2 0- 0 %(( *;((: 7 * (

; '(* 00 ( 0 00 0 %(( -

; % ' *

*( ;0( 0- :

0 (* '7

+ % 0- 0

; % ' 4 *

( %*((52- ( ! 9"%

7 $

7*8 " C 0(

; ; ;0( 0- 0 0

" " ( -

* %

=%2" (

( * (* / -:( ! 9 ;(:

; 0 %*(;0( 0- 0 -: 5 (

; 0 ;*(:* '

-: = 0; - - 4

! 9*( -

(

;

%5 : - /*(! &2 /*( : (((' * ;

0*(

:0" 0 ; "

;:-

' 0 *

:0- 0;:-7 ; # 4 *

( 0 % * :

?*:- ' (;.0 (:

(*( 2- ;0 *0 < '"( 0(*0 .*';

!"#$#%$& ' ( ")

$" ( "#*+,-.,/-0* 1 2#$3 " "3 !"#$# 4 ")

("# ,00, .*/ 50 '* 0( % ;0 0

* ;0*'

; 00 -: ' ;; (('+ .*'; " (*0 -: *

((: 00(-( 0 '* -(<

6# # *0" ; %

* 0; ;0(:% % 0( * * 0

# ' * /*(# =: 2(&2

* ; $00(/*( !

#% 2*0 ;-:;; !# + 0 *-;0(:

1*'"=

"52% 0 ; ' 0(: % ('*(0; ( ?*: 0;0 0 (:

( ; 2<%

" * ( % * ( ''*( ?*: *( -

; 2<

" -

; 0*( 2 ((' ;

00 (,2 '*; 0( ;0 * :

* % * :- " 00 ($

7*8 " -

*-: 0($ 0 0(: (" 0 0( -

* D ; 2

* (

'*(D 8 '8 ; % -

+ (%' '; ' 0- %((A

(+ ; 2( ( ' 0* 2 '; ,;0(:;

*-(: ;0(:

.-&( ' ;0(: " * ;0(:; *-. ;0(:- '

;0(:

*-(< 2 ";0(:

% 0 ;

;0(:" ;0(: ; - ;0( 0 < %" "## ! ($ )! &("

.*++7/88,+" = >-($07* (

! + &*0; * < ; )

# ( "9#32 "

.*+,+/*;*8 - 2 ; ' *

: 0-

- - '; ((% 0 0( *(.* % (; ' 0- <

" %;0( -* %5

0 - '2 ?*% ' '< %5

:"% %((% '

;0(: (('; $0* ( ;0( '; *<;(: E

!"#$%&%'()*++ '*''*++ , + " 2% *

-2" ( %

; 2" (('-:

;+ 00 ( *( 2* ;-'** %

0*(

2%((- ' 0

(-0- "

(( ' -

*% * ( ?*:$ ;0*'

* -: ;0 "%

* 00 ("

- ;0*'

*-:0 ;0 < 2% -2

;: +-* ( %0

- '% * :; "*0*+,5 .

/ 05 '8 F