Dilawar Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS
!"##$%&%'( $")#*+, %-!.!*/%'01 #"%"%'#* 2#*&3& /"!"# 3'4!) "1#*& #&5'6#'"&
!"#$ %&'()$
%$' ") * # !"#$ %&'()$ )(
# +++
*#&#'"( *!73-/1!*8!,69$!"#, *"1#5#"%"%'#*&%'!--$!&#& * !%/%'011!31!',69$!"#, **#&5'6#'":%'!--$!&#& &'3 !-,#53";69$!"##'#*!-, 3'4!) <<<<<
)(
#,% 1%&*6#*&1!--6%&5&#"1*##%9%-*%" #"%"%'&)#!*%'0 ,::!'6= !&$88'>3#&"%'-!.!'6!$"%& %'9-9#6 ' !-- "1# !*#8#'"%'#6 $!&#&, *#&5'6#'" :? *!8
!'$1!;!",/!'%;!-%-#6 !'!55-%$!"%'3'6#*/#$"%' "1# 3'4!) 2%--!0#88'@!'6
#03-!"%' $",+A!&!55-%$!)-#"/"!"#
3'4!) *&1*",+A$" &##7%'0#4#$"8#'" "1#5#"%"%'#*&*8 9!*%3&5!*$#-&-!'6&%"3!"#6%'2%--!0#/!'%;!-,#1&%-37#*%!',%&"*%$" &1%!*53* 1# $-!%8 "1# 5#"%"%'#*& .!& "1!" "1#; 1!6 )##' %' 5&&#&&%'"1#&3%"-!'6&%'$#A+!'6%'"1%&*#0!*6,*#-%!'$#.!&
!-&-!%6""1#$*&&?#B!8%'!"%'"1#.%"'#&&"1#*!8 !'$1!;!" .#9#*, "1# --#$"*, 9%6# *6#* 6!"#6 A ''#B3*# ? , .%"13"-7%'0%'""1#*#9#'3#*#$*6,%#,4!8!)!'6%#&*"1#;#!*& + ?, ++?A !'6 ?= 5!& "1# #4#$"8#'" *6#* 1# !*#8#'"%'#6 *6#* .!& !&&!%-#6 ); %-%'0 &"!"3"*; !55#!- )#*# *#&5'6#'" ? 88%&&%'#*, )3" 9%6# *6#* 6!"#6 A
''#B3*# ?
,"1#&!8#.!&6%&8%&=#*6#*&3'6#*$1!--#'0#!*#'" &3&"!%'!)-#%'9%#."1#5*9%&%'&$-!3&# %9 $-!3&# 0 /#$"%'
+A$"1#*#9#'3#*#$*6*#-#$"#6"1#'!8#"1#0*!'6?!"1#* "1#5#"%"%'#**#$*6#6!&C!%*!*3&%!94!D!)E!%!*%F ' '"%$#, -$7 #9#-58#'" !'6 !'$1!;!" %$#*, 37#*%!'%-#6.*%""#'&"!"#8#'"')#1!-*#&5'6#'"&"=""1# ##$""1!"!&5#*4!8!)!'6%#&*"1#;#!*&+=?=!'6+=?=A,*!8
!'$1!;!",/!'%;!-1!6)##'*#$*6#6!&.'#*!'6"1#'!"3*#"1#-!'6 .!&)!*!'%!'6&!-!),"13&,"1#5#"%"%'#*&$!''")#&!%6")#%'$3-"%9!"%'0 5&&#&&%'"1#&3%"-!'6""#'"%'"1%&3*".!&!-&6*!.'""1# 4!8!)!'6%#&!""!$1#6.%"1"1#.*%""#'&"!"#8#'"*#&5'6#'":*!8
!'$1!;!" 6%&53"%'0 "1# 4!8!)!'6%#& !""!$1#6 .%"1 "1# .*%" 5#"%"%', .1#*#%',3'6#*$-38'!*#!"1#-!'6,"1#'!"3*#"1#-!'6!&)!*!'% !'6&!-!)1!&'")##'6#&$*%)#6".!&!-&3*0#6"1!"5#"%"%'#*&1!9# !""#85"#6"8%&-#!6"1%&3*"*'"!""!$1%'0"1#$**#$""*!'&-!"#6 $5%#& "1# 4!8!)!'6%#& !'6, "13&, 5*!;#6 * 6%&8%&&!- "1# .*%" 5#"%"%'& #1!9#5#*3"1#4!8!)!'6%#&,''#B3*#& :G!'6 :G 5#*"!%'%'0""1#5#*%6+ ?!'6++?A,.1#*#%'"1#-!'61!&)##'
&1.'!&C!'4!*D!6%85!*" !*!'%!'6/!-!)F,)3""1%&!$"%&'"
-
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
C #%'%"%'&?'"1%&$",3'-#&&"1#$'"#B""1#*.%&# *#>3%*#&,?
BBB BBB BBB
C&1!8%-!"6#1F%'$-36#&?
BBB BBB BBB
%%% 1!&)##'5!*"%"%'#6!'6)*301"3'6#*$3-"%9!"%'); %'6%9%63!--!'61-6#*&)#*#"1#A"1!'3!*;,+H
%9 1!9%'0)##'!$>3%*#6)#*#"1#A"1!'3!*;,+,);! 5#*&');53*$1!&#*%'#B$1!'0#*5*5*%#"!*;-!'6*8! $?&1!*#* %' "1# &1!8%-!" 6#1 !'6 %& & *#$*6#6 %' "1# 4!8!)!'6%*%&&355*"#6);!9!-%66##6H!'6%&'"%'#B$#&& "1#&1!*#"1#$?&1!*#*%'"1#&1!8%-!"6#1
9 " %B BBB BBBB BBBBF 1301"1#.*%"5#"%"%'&!*#-%!)-#")#6%&8%&*'" 5*9%6%'0"1#$**#$"%'*8!"%'""1%&3*",)3"'8#*%"!-&,%'9%#. *#0%'0*#!&'&,.#6'"%'6!';%--#0!-%";*5#*9#*&%";%'"1#*6#*&
.
3'6#*$1!--#'0#0*3'6*%'"#*#*#'$#%&8!6#3" *%"5#"%"%'&&"!'66%&8%&
%$' ") * # )(
# %&*/$ %&*/$ 0 2, 34 6 6 57 38 9:
;
< 5:
6 6
31
< 5: