Bhagwati And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.
!"#$ "% % & '" (%) "% *+ !"# $ %"& !"# '"& (")%" %
% ", %- . %/&$"
%(% -&" #"./&. %"+ % %/ 01%,./ ,/&.2 %,.(%)
$ %"&* '"+ %"% "&",, #"31 $"% 1 4 "5 /31 /.
%"%.7"6
/7$%1
8
.
%+&,)'", 1 &,,# 0 %+1%2"".(9
46. '", % 21%# . $ 1#" 9 31% % " &,+ 1,: "% % * ,. %, ;
1 ,. % </.21%# $21%1#% 5% 1 , % " + % 19 " " 31 31 ",+ ,)
/."9 1+%%" "*#"=% + '% +% ) 5 /31 .*"9, *, /.
8 %"%.7"
8/7;
8/. 31 "9"%1 %",/.
,)."6
/.$""$"1 "% ;
"+% .
/ $1
'"1"9 # 9)=1,,! "
"1% 8
>?1# 86
."9
+ " ,)"$"%
/"9 1+%%
." 1%"%+% # 9 %%
8/. %"%+, 6
/
8/%+%1"%1 % <
+&#, " "!"-# & #! ./ .012 % &
& ! %'
- & " # !" #
3 $" # )" #
"/. ) # 1 %"5 /31 /.6
.< $"% $%1 % " 5 /31 / " 9 . " . ,, +%& "/%, #"%
+ ",,++,)@% 9$"% $%1 % "9
." 1"+% #",, 11 %" +%& "5 /31 /. /" 9 %+,A '" ,+ B+%9)"=1,,! " "1%
71+%.B%9,$ < '" +% # +1%1
/%, ,)
%+1%+ 1 #+%, %) 31%) %%) # 1 " 1%&) 19,) " , +%+ 9 31% !. ++% "
8 , % "++%+%2&% C
31%", "") ,9? .
) ,"%"9? 9 =%"+1%+ +) + .
" ",
/90 %"+1%+ B #" %9+ %+19, , +% %: "%% 1%"%% .
9. "%%,"#."% ,)%,'"% %.& "1#" "
/0 " %"% % + 91 &%", 9 0 " #1 %"
/'"+% # %31 99 ,) %1++,
$"""# ,%
/ '"5#,1%9)
"$
8/"+%& %", +% "&,+ % 1 %",
/;+%&" $" # )" #
8/ )", 31 #D C1 %",6
/$"% $%1 "% "9
." ,,"+%&
8/ %, #% + %++,) '"++,9,) "+%&
8 / %+) + $1, ,)9
+% #1 %",6
/"9 9 %
$"""++ ) %"
%
8/ '"++,9,) "$
8/$"",$"%+, & #,%
"B &#"",6
/",, %+,'"
19 " &"%$+%&
8/." %+, 1 % 19 ",, 9 ", +%?1%
"# %,++, 2/*+, % %
% 91 19 + # "
" 5#,1% ;
" "% B+%,)%9) %) +,
8 /$9%#%$+
/ $",,)% +%" $1,9 ,% %+,'"%+, %+
/ , % 19 $
8/+%&@"$&%.9) 19 +%?1%
"# %,++,
2/ '" $
8 / +%& % &%, +%%). +%#%& ,,) 9 , ,#,& 1%9%0 #$) % "
"+%",$ +%& " % , + +19, +1%+ $"" "%
/'"$
8 /9, $%+%& # %"9 , +%& ,#, ", %$", 1#"931%"")#"9
" $,#,&+ '" 11
/9 %"++ )
%"$
8/$1, 1%
+%& 4
2/ ,) "+% #1 %",
/ "& 9 D C 9 %
$""$1,9""%"9 1++,
,,$9),%
/ # / +19,"1 , 6
/ "
, 2: 91 "
$++%,% %" "$
8/
$1, 91 9,
,$", 1"+19, "#& # 1"+19, 90 " +19, " ; ,) " +19, ", " 9 ""%$ "
+% 9," ,9? " '""% # 9? 1 </ "+19,
/$1, 9+% 9, %%+, %
8/ %
"+% #
9"& 9 D C1 %",6
/ " ,% 1 % 4 "% " 9
1 ,)$" ",% 1" ", +% 9"&9
D C;
"%$%. ,%
%
/ 9 %
.", #
9"&9 "% %.
$1,,+9)&%1
"$
8/A 5% 1 , %" +1" % ,#, + ;
" . " $% $
1 9) " 5 /31 ,,% 8
4'" 1 $ %&9)" + % / %"% #,% 1 , %"+% % # "19 9& "&$B+%9)=1,,! " "
4 1%
71+%. 1%&$." %
/.
8.",+31"+ %.
,%
/" 9 19 % %+,
/
8/
;
+% 1 % 4 " / $ 1
($&%." ",,9,9%)"% %"
+% # %31 % #$"", % +1%" #E% #", % $",$. ",
31 %31% % +, ) +%? % "%$ '" + %",, 131%#% #", 31 % +% B " 9," 0 /,,"%1 % "$%+ %, + "1%" B+% ) + "% '"$%+ + % #,) *?"! , -1#
21%& % #"2,, & -1# ""%+0 #E% FE ""%*+%9, FE