High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/116/2009dismissed

Munesh Devi v. Ashok Kumar

2015-02-24Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri11 pages

! "# $%%&'(' )* +,$- %(.%/' 00%11

$ 2%3(-( (.45-, 3 %(0

+) 3 +.

3, 6 /& $%3$.%

$ %3$.%3%(0

$ !

# /'

71($8%3%$.%'($3'&$- 7%6 %9 3''

0%$'$'

'1% -

%3+%&$' :$.%'

- 33'

7%&$6 !'

(.3$;$.%&$# 3 '((1-$' , 33'

7%8< %&3%% '/3&%6$.%9'%

(

003 &.% $.'(-3$8<9 <'

1&.

11% 7'

7$.%=- 7,%

%&3%%

-$ (.3$1<6 $.% &$( %&%(( 3< 3

=- '& $.% 03%(% 1

$.%3%'

, <8% $'&% .%, 33'

7%$.% 3$'%(9 ((1%, '?% :> @ $/'11 7% ( -

&&3 7$ '

-3'$%(.%, 33'

7%9 (& (-,,

, 1%&.'1 6

,%1<6 /'

9 (83 : -$$.%( 9% 1&4.%%A0% (%( $.% %1'/%3< 9%3% 83 % 8< $.% $.%3 $.%

$ .% 3%(0

$(%% $.%&.'1

%71%&$% $, .',

.%3%(0

.'( ,'1<,%,8%3(9%3%73%% <0%3(

$.%< $3% $.%

$9'$.&3-%1$< &&- $ %,

93<9 ('($%3( $.%

$ 9%3% 1( , 33'% 9'$. $.% 83$.%3( $.% 3%(0

$$.%( ,%$',% -1<6 @6$.%3%(0

.'( ,'1<,%,8%3(.

$.39 -$ 11$.% 93< 3$'&1%(83-7.$8<$.%

$ .%3%(0

$($ $%34'11'

7$.%

$6.% 9-1 7%$.',(%13%, 33'% 3'&. ,'1<+.%9 (& '

3, 39.1% '7.$

9 $03/'

9'$.,% 1(9%/%36(.%%(& 0%

9'$. ''&-1$<

$1 $.%'

$$.%30 3% $(

$.%3(/%

$.%%/%

4(.

6$.%

$9 $ 119% $7$.%3 3% 1.-(% * 6 $.%%/% 3+

$'6$.% $.%3 $.%

$& ,%$.%3, 1.,%8-$.%9 $ 119% $ (%%.%3+.%9 (7'/% 8% $'

7(8<.%3,$.%3'

9 1 79'$.B-A,'

%/'

5-(.

%/' .%<9%3%$ 14'

7 8-$(%$$'

.%3 '3%($.

$$.%3%(0

$&-1 8%3%, 33'% 9'$. (%3/'

77'31

( .% 9 ( C1''% ,%&.

'& +.% (%&3%$1< %(& 0% 3, $.% 1.,%

( /% .%31'%+.%1 &3','

1& (%-

+%&$' (*@6*6::6$.%

1 % 1'&%($

5.1 ($$.%3%(0

.'( ,'1<,%,8%3( +.%.

$.% &$&3-%1$<$.%3%(0

$.%.

%(%3$%

.%33,$.%<% 36%/% $.-7..%8$ %&3%%33%($'$-$'

& =-7 13'7.$(-

%3+%&$' $.%&$

%71%&$% $ .%3&&3 71<6$.%

$'1% 0%$'$' -

%3+%&$' :

$.%&$3 '((1-$' , 33'

7%8< %&3%% '/3&%.%(

0%$'$' 9 (& $%($% 8<$.%3%(0

$8<'1'

7 93'$$% ($ $%,% $ %('

%(3 '('

7/ 3'-(03%1','

3<8=%&$' (6'$9 (01%

$.% .

8$ %&3%%-

%3+%&$' $.%&$

$.%

$-$

$ .%39 9'11

9'$.-$

<3% (

81%%A&-(%9 (1'/'

7 $.%3 3% 1.-(%%9 (3%

9'11'

7$4%%0.%39'$..', (.'( 9'% %.

8%% 4%%0'

7$.%

$030%31<8-$(.%1%$.%3 1.,%9'$.-$

<3% (

81%& -(%.%$.%3 /%3,% $(

$.%0%$'$' 9%3% '%

03 <%33 '(,'(( 1$.%( ,% (,

%+'

&%$.%3%(0

'1% $0 <$.%,

&% 0%

$%1'$%

1'$'7 %A0% (%(6.'( %% &%9 (($3-&48<$.% $3'

1&-3$/'

%3 %3

*@ : .%

(-003$.%3& (%6%A ,'

.%3 $.%3 (

D %=

.%3(%1 D+.% 1($%

%3% &-,% $('

.%3 %/'

&% * .% $3'

1 &-3$ 003%&'

%/'

&% 1% 8< $.%

'(,'((% $.% '/3&%0%$'$' /'

%=- 7,%

%&3%%

> .1 7 $.

$ $.%

$ .

'1% $ 03/% $.

$ $.% 3%(0

$3% .%39'$.&3-%1$<3.

%(%3$% .%3% &%6$.% 03%(% 1 B% &- (%1 3 $.%

$ (-8,'$$% $.

$ $.% '

7(3%&3 8<$.%$3'

1&-3$$.

$$.%3%(0

$$3%

$.%9'%9'$.&3-%1$<9 ($$.%3%&3 $9 (-3$.%3(-8,'$$% $.%3%(0

.'( ,'1<,%,8%3(9%3%.

(('

7$.%

8-('

7.%3$9 (-37% $$.% %% &%$.%3%(0

$9 ( ($3-&4 -%$ <,% $,

&%0%

$%1'$%

1'$'7

%A0% (%(

6$.%3%3%6$.% '/3&%0%$'$' 9 (1'

81%$8% %&3%% $%3.% 3'

71% &- (%13$.%

$69% $ '

<,%3'$'

1 > +%&$' :! #!'

#$.%&$%,09%3($.%-3$$ '((1/% $.%, 1$'%(8%$9%% $.%0 3$'%(8< %&3%% '/3&%

% 0%$'$' 8<%'$.%3(0-(%9.%3%$.%( (0-(%.

(8%% $3% 9'$.

&3-%1$< $%3$.%(1%, '?

$.%, 33'

7% 3-%1$<.

$8%%

$.%&$8-$/ 3'-(03 - &%,% $($.%0%A-3$

$.%3'7.-3$(.

/%-$1'

$.%(&0%$.%$%3,E&3-%1$<E3-%1$< '( %/'

$ 9.%3% % (0-(% $3% $( $.% $.%3

'%($( (-&.

%%1'

7($9 (.',3.%3 ($& -(%3% (

81% 003%.% (' $'$ 9'118%.

3,-13'

=-3'-($1'/%9'$.$.%$.%3(0-(%3-%1$<, <8% 0.<('& 13,% 1D.%$.%3 (0-(%'('

1'&$% 9'$.0.<('& 1&3-%1$<3

$6'$&

8%=- $.%8 ('( '3%&$%/'

&%9.%3% (,% &3-%1$<'($8%'

%33%

1<?'

7$.% &$- 1, $3'A% &.& (%

7& &1-(' $.%3% @ .%0%A-3$'

&'(')* *+,(*-"*(.*/"*(0'#

1129.'1%%A ,'

71%7 1030('$' $.% (0%&$&3-%1$<.

8(%3/% (-

%3) ;$'((%$$1% 8<&

%&'(' ($.

$,% 1&3-%1$< &

& -(%%/% ,3%(%3'-('

=-3<$.

$.%0.<('& .

&3% $%'

$.%,'

$.%'

=-3%

(-&. 003%.% (' ('(& $%,01 $.%+%&$' $'($8% %$%3,'

9.1% &$($.%& (%

$.%, 1 3%1 (8%$9%% $.%(0-(%(

,- $$&3-%1$<6$.%3%,-($8%(-&.9'1-1$3% $,% $.%0 3$<9.'&.& -(% (-%3'

8 <3,'

%'$.%3

&$- 1 &$38<9 < 003%.% ('

(-&. ,

%3 ( $ 3%

%3 $.% & $'

-% 1'/'

$7%$.%3(0-(%(.

3,-13'

=-3'-(.

73%7

$$.%&'3&-,($

&%($.%& (% .%93 E&3-%1$<E.

$8%% %'

3 .

(8%% -(% 3%1 $.-,

-&$3.-,

8%.

/'-3$'($.%&

-&$'

3%1 $3'

3%(0%&$ , 1 -$'%(

81'7 ($'( &-3(%

-&$

% 9.'&. '(

/%3(%1< %&$'

7 $.% $.%3 .% &3-%1$< , < 8% ,% 1 3 0.<('&

1 3 -

1 .%3% , < 8% & (%( 9.%3%$.%&

-&$&,01 '$(%1'(8

% -7.

0%3(%- 9-13'11%7 1.% $.%',0 &$3$.% =-3'-( %%&$ $.% $.%3 (0-(% %% $ 8% C-'3% $3& ('

%3% (-&.& (%(6$.%&3-%1$< 9'118%%($ 81'(.% '$.%&

-&$'$(%1'(03/% 3

,'$$% F

-3$.%36(%$$'

7-$'11-($3 $'/%& (%(,% 1&3-%1$<6$.% +-03%,%-3$'

*4*567 87-*9*67 87#

1% 3.

.%1 (-

%3) ; - '3, ($

%/%3 8% 1 9 3 7-'

&%6<%$9% %%,'$ 00303'

$%$% -,%3 (,%'

&%(.-,

8%.

/'-39.'&., <8% 3%1%/

79'$.$.%& (%(E,% 1&3-%1$<E .%'

&%('

'& $.%(-&&%% 70 0.(

3% 1<'11-($3 $'/%

$%A.

-($'/% !'#

& ('

&,01%$%, 11'% $.%0 3$'%(6 &-$%,% 10 6 7 <

(-%3'

7 ( 9-1 $, 4%0(('81%3$.%0 3$'%($1'/%9'$.

&.$.%3&-1 &,%9'$.'

$.%83

0 ,%$%3( ,% 1&3-%1$< !''#

&,03%.% ('/% '( 1 $.% % $'3%

11'%$.%0 3$'%(6'$8%&,%( 8-

$1< &1% 3$.

$('$- '((-&.$.

$$.%93 0 3$< &

$ 3% (

81< 8% (4% $ 0-$ -0 9'$. (-&.

-&$

& $'

-%$1'/%9'$.$.%30 3$< !'''# %3% &1

%(( 3 1 &4 %&$' &

,- $ $ &3-%1$<6 3%C-% $ 3- %(( 1

77%6 0%$-1

&%,

%36'

'%3% &%

%71%&$, < 3% &.(-&. %73%%$.

$'$, 4%($.%, 33'% 1'%3 $.%$.%3(0-(% 8(1-$%1<'

$1%3 81% !'/# % 1&3-%1$<'( ($ $%,'

.%%%1'

%%0

7-'(.6 '( 00'

$,% $6 3-($3 '

(0-(%& -(% 8<$.%&

-&$$.%33 1 7$',% <1%

$,% 1&3-%1$< !/# (-($ &-3(% 8-('/%

.-,'1'

$3% $,% $& 1&-1 $$3$-3%6 '(&,, %33%

,'(%3 81%1'%$.%(0-(% !/'# +-($ - =-($''

81%&

-&$

8%.

/'-3 %(0-(% &$- 11< %&$'

70.<('& 1

,% .% 1$.$.%$.%3(0-(%.%$3% $,% $&,01

$.%3%(-1$

7%33 003%.% (' ,-($8% /%3<73 /%6(-8($

9%'7.$< !/''# +-($ 3%03%.% ('81% &

-&$6 ($- '%

%71%&$6 '

'%3% &% 3 $$ 1 %0 3$-3% 3, $.%

3, 1($

& =-7 14'

%((& -('

=-3< $,% 1.% 1$.3 %3'/'

'($'&01% (-3%&

,- $$,% 1&3-%1$< !/'''# .%&

-&$,-($8%,-&.,3%$.

=% 1-(<6

1 (%1'(.

%((6 0((%(('/% %((6 9.'&.

& -(%( - .

00'

%((

'(( $'( &$'

%,$'

1-0(%$ < $ 8% 73-

3 73

$ '/3&% $.% 73-

,% 1&3-%1$< !'A# %3% $3'/'

1 '33'$ (6 C33%1(6 3, 1 9%

$% 3$.%, 33'% 1'%9.'&..

<1'%9-1 $8%

%C- $%373

$ '/3&%

$.%73-

,% 1&3-%1$< !A# .%, 33'% 1'%(.-1 8%3%/'%9% 9.1%

%9'(1 ($

&%(/%3 0%3' <% 3( 9'11 $ ,- $$&3-%1$<.%'11&

-&$,-($8% 0%3('($% $ 3 '31< 1% 7$.< 0%3' 6 9.%3% $.% 3%1 (.'0 .

( %$%3'3 $

%A$% $ $.

8%& -(%$.% &$(

8%.

/'-3 (0-(%6$.% 93 0 3$<'

('$%A$3%,%1< ''&-1$$1'/%9'$.

$.%$.%30 3$<

<1 7%36, < ,- $$,% &3-%1$< !A'# .-(8

(-8,'$(.',(%13

0%3 ($%3'1'?

9'$.-$,% '& 13% (

9'$.-$$.% (% $34 91% 7%.'(9'%

(','1 31<'$.% 9'% -

%37%( / (%&$,< 3 83$' 9'$.-$ ,% '& 13% ( 39'$.-$$.%& (% $34 91% .%3.-(8

6(-&.

&$$.%(0-(%, <1%

$,% 1&3-%1$< !A''#

'1 $%3 1 %&'(' 3%-( 1 $ .

/% $%3&-3(% 3 & ('

81% 0%3' 9'$.-$ $.%3% 8%'

<0.<('& 1'

& &'$<3/ 1'

3% ( , <

,- $$,% 1&3-%1$< !A'''#

'1 $%3 1 %&'(' %'$.%3 .-(8

3 9'%

$%3, 33'

7% $$.

/%&.'1 3,$.%, 33'

< ,- $$&3-%1$< !A'/# D.%3% $.%3% .

( 8%% 1 7 0%3' $'

--((%0 6'$, < '31<8%& &1- $.%, 18

'(8%<

3%0 '3.%, 33'

8%&,%( '&$' $.-7.(-003$% 8< 1%7 1$'%< 3%-('

7$(%/%3$.

$$'%6$.%1 9'

(-&.& (%(6 %(

$(%3/%$.%(

&$'$<, 33'

7%G $.%& $3 3<6'$ (.9((&

$3%7 3$.%%%1'

%,$' ( $.% 0 3$'%( (-&. 1'4% ('$- (6 '$ , < 1%

$ ,% 1&3-%1$<F -8$6$.%$3'

1&-3$/'

%3 %3

*@.

($3-&4$.% %% &%$.%3%(0

$.-(8

&&- $

<,% $,

&%0%

$%1'$%

1'$'7 %A0% (%(+$'116$.%

$9'%9..

(-7.$ '/3&%3,$.%3%(0

$.-(8

(3%C-'3% $03 -&%&7%

& /'

7%/'

&%( ($($

.%39 %%$$%($ 81'(.$.%73-

(&3-%1$<

%(%3$' ($ $.%3%(0

$.-(8

A ,'

7$.% &$- 1, $3'A$.%03%(% $& (%6'$, <8%

$'&%

,'$$% 1< %&3%%3%($'$-$' & =-7 13'7.$(.

8%%

((% @ ($$.%

$.-7.$.%3%(0

$&-1

$ 03 -&% $.% ( %&3%% 3%&3 8<9 < %/'

&% ( .'(

%% &%9 (($3-&43 <,% $,

&%0%

$%1'$%3 1'$'7 %A0% (%(68-$$.% &$-, %&3%%&-1 $8%& $3/%3$%

8<$.%

$9'%%A&%0$$&1 ',$.

8%% '1%

8%3%$.%'7.-3$

= ($.

9.'&. &$9 $(-8($

(

$.'

8%% 03 -&% 3%&3 $/%3'<$.%( ,%/% '$.%

8%% '1% &.

11% 7'

7$.% %&3%%

@6'$9-1

$ 03%/% $ $.% %&3%% 3%($'$-$' 3 & =-7 1 3'7.$( $ 8%&,% 0%3

1- 1%(($.%0%3 $.%( =- 7,%

%&3%%9 ( ($ <% 8<$.%.'7.%3&-3$.%0 (('

7$.% %&3%%9-1 03/%$.

$.%3%(0

$$3% $.%

$9'$.&3-%1$<

%(%3$%

.%3('

&%.%3%3%6'$'(03/% $$.%

9'$.

.%3(%1 3, $.% (&'%$< $.% 3%(0

$ 9'$.-$

< 3% (

81% %A&-(% -3$.%36$.% 11%7 (&3-%1$<1%/%11% 8<$.%

$8< < '

/'$(.%3(%1

.%3 $.%39%3%/ 7-%

7% 1'

$-3% .%

$ '1% $03/% ($.9(.%($ <% $.%3 1.,% $%3-1<6 @9.% .%38%1 7'

7(9%3%$.39 -$ $.%, 1.,%+.%&1 ',% $ (.%9 ( 8% 8<.%3,$.%3'

$.%3(

(.%1%$$.%, .,% $.%( ,%

<9%/%36(.%.

<3%03$

<3( $.%3% $%3+.%1 & (%8% 3'

7 *-

+%&$' (*@H*H3%

9'$.+%&$' :*$.%

1 1< : : .%3%3%6 3%1'

&% &-1 8% 01 &% $.% %/'

&%1% 8<$.%

$.% &$(

&'3&-,($

&%(&-,-1 $'/%1< 1%

($'33%('($'81%& &1-(' $$.%

$9 %'$.%3$3% 9'$.

&3-%1$<8<$.%3%(0

3.%.

%(%3$% .%3 .%$3'

1&-3$ 003%&'

%/'

&% 3%&3 .

3'7.$1<.%1 '

7&3-%1$<3 %(%3$' &-1 8%3%&3

/-3$.%

$.%3%1%/

7(3%&3 8<$.%$3'

1&-3$ 3%

$.-() ; /% $.%39'(%6$.% 11%7 ($.%0%$'$'

.%30%$'$' 3%7 7&3-%1$<69.'&. 3% (-7.$$8%03/% $.% '

/'$($.%0%$'$'

.%3 $.%36 3%/%3</ 7-%

7% 1'

$-3% $ %( $8%&,%&1% 33,$.% /%3,% $($.% 0%$'$' %3 ($.9(.%($ <% $.%3, .,% $%3-1<6 @6$.%, $..%3, 33'

7%6 9.% .%3 8%1 7'

7( 9%3% $.39 -$ .%3 1.,%+.%9 (($ $8%&,'

73, $.% ,'1<8%77 3( %&%,8%3 @6(.%.

( &1 ',% $(.45-, 33%(0

%&1 3%

$.%9-1 7%$3%, 33'% 3'&. ,'1< $%34'11'

.%3

$.%.

4%0$.%3& '

3,3

9.1% '7.$

9 $03/'

9'$.,% 1( +.% .

( 1( &1 ',% $.

$ (.% %(& 0% 9'$. 1$

''&-1$<9(.%%(& 0% '$.%3%(0

.'( ,'1<,%,8%3(9

$%1','

$%.%3'( C-%($'

9.'&. %( $'

(9%3'

$.%01%

7($.% 0%$'$' %33.%3%/'

&% '($.% 1<

$% 9.'&.(.%&1 ',% $(.%9 (8% 8< .%3,$.%3'

1 9

$.%3(+.%.

(&1 ',%

<6(.%.

11<1%$.%3, 1.,% +.% $1 7%

<3%03$ $$.

$$',%3(

$.%3% $%3 .% 3%03$ 1 3

% &% 0- '(.

81%-

%3+%&$' (*@H*H3%

9'$.

+%&$' :* $01'&%($ 5.18<9 <

*'(

: :.'(-3$.%3(.9($.

3%1'

&%&

8%01 &% $.%%/'

&%1%

3-$'

%3$03/%$.'( 11%7 F : B% &- (%1 3 $.%

$ 9 ( -

81% $

%, ($3 $% $.

$ $.%3% 9 (

< %333 3 0%3/%3('$< '

$.% '

7( 3%&3 8<$.%$3'

1&-3$8 (% ,'( 003%&'

3,'(3%

7 %/'

&% 3%&3 9.'&. , < 9

$ '

$%3%3% &% 8< $.'( -3$ &&3 71<6 '

7 ,%3'$ '

$.% 16 $.% ( ,% '( .%3%8<

'(,'((% * B% &- (%13$.%

$($ $.% %( $ 03%(($.% 001'& 8% 3'

%3+%&$' * $.%&$373

&%0%

$%1'$%

1'$'7 %A0% (%( &&3 71<6'( '(,'((% $03%((% !

:6 ,;5<*59 %#

3 " 78( :6