High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15230/2017allowed

Chameli Devi v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-07-19Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath3 pages

!" "#$%$&'

!" "#$%$&'( ( ( (

)

) * +",$ "-$ "!$!$&". /% ! !" .0 & &1!*".% "%2&1"&!% 3'4 53 3'4 53 3'4 53 3'4 53663 663 663 663 ."%"&!' 3. *781-# !"8

.!*"2"!$!$&". 3. 7. 9*3*7&! 8 8 .0 & 6638 6638 6638 6638 *"2"!$!$&".$% ::.$"-"1 : $&%!!*".1".%1 !"1;

< 2 %%"190!*",,"#!. &11 !"1<

2 %%"190!*"++$%%$&".8 $% . $-$%$&8$% .90=*$#*%*"* %9""& %>"1!2 0 ;8 ?& ##7&! 1"

$#$"&#0$&! +2 7!0 &1.":$%!. !$&#* .:"% &9.$"

8!*"2"!$!$&".* 1! >"&, &1+" %7.$&:

> & , + ., & ," %" . 2".$1 ; 0" .% -$1" .":$%!"."1 ," %" 1""1 1 !"1

!#&%!.7#! :1=& &1 7.!*".!1",$-".$!! *" !"&1". !*"2"!$!$&".= %&! ##"2!"190!*" &1!*"."

."8!*" 2"!$!$&".# &#",,"1!*"," %" 1""1& ;;

<& ##7&! & 71$! &!"8!*"+ !!".= %."

".."1!!*",,"#!.$&.": .1!!*"1"

$#$"&#0 ! +2 7!0 8( 8 ? &1 .":$%!. !$& #* .:"% <8

?8 !! ,

+7&!$&:! ;8 ?.#""1$&:%="."$&$!$ !"190!*",,"#!.7&1". %"#!$&< !*"&1$ &! +2#!8)((@ .%*.!A!*"#!4B &1.",0$&: 72& !*" 71$! &!" &,08 !*" 2"!$!$&". = % % 11,"1 =$!* !*" ,$ 9$,$!0 ::.$"-"1 : $&%!!*"% $1.1".8!*"2"!$!$&". $,"1 22" ,7&1"."#!$& <C<D !*"#!=$!*!*"++$%%$&".8$% . $-$%$&8$% .8$&=*$#*$! = % ,,":"1 !* ! !*" 2.#""1$&:% $&$!$ !"1 !". ,&: !$+" $& !".+% "#!$& < !*" #! $% $,,": , 97! !*" 22",, !" 7.! #&%$1"."1 !*" ."

"."&#"7&1"."#!$&<C D !*"#! &1*",1!* !!*"#:&$E &#"# & 9"! >"&90!*",,"#!.=$!*$&!*.""0" .% 5" .&"1 #7&%", . !*" 2"!$!$&". * % %79+$!!"1 !* ! "#!$& < C D !*" #! $% &! 22,$# 9," 9"# 7%" !*" ." "."&#" * % &! 9""& + 1"90!*" 7!*.$!$"%+"&!$&"1!*"."$& &1$&!*$%.": .1*"* %.",$"1 72& 1"#$%$& !*$%7.!."&1"."1$&FG9 ,$&:* &1!*".% FG9 ,$&:* &1!*".% FG9 ,$&:* &1!*".% FG9 ,$&:* &1!*".%/%! !" ! !" ! !" ! !" .0 & &1!*".%H .0 & &1!*".%H .0 & &1!*".%H .0 & &1!*".%H

C DC$-$,D ; * -"*" .1," .&"1#7&%", .!*"2 .!$"% &1 !"."I +$&$&: !*" - $, 9,"."#.18 + !*"#&%$1"."12$&$&!* !!*"," .&"122",, !" 7.! * % &! 1. =& !*" 1$%!$&#!$& 9"!=""& !*" ." "."&#" + 1" 7&1". "#!$&%<CD &1<C D !*"#!9"# 7%"!*"."

"."&#"= %+ 1"90 !*" 71$!2 .!0*"."

."8 + !*"#&%$1"."12$&$&!* !!*"+ !!". ."G7$."% .",>90!*" 22",, !" 7!*.$!0 &%"G7"&!,08 !*" 2."%"&! 2"!$!$& $% ,,="18 !*" $+27:&"1 .1".1 !"1<

2 %%"190!*" 22",, !" 7!*.$!0$%%"! %$1" &1!*" + !!".$%."+ &1"19 #>!*$+!1"#$1"$! : $& !".:$-$&: # !":.$#

$&1$&:&!*"$%%7" 22,$# 9$,$!0 "#!$&<CD &1<CDC D !*" #! .!$"% ."1$."#!"1! 22" .9"

."!*" 22",, !" 7!*.$!0& < )

) C663D C663D C663D C663D ( ( ( (

)

) *"!*".%2" >$&:?." %&"1 '

"%? *"!*"."2.! 9," '

"%?