Gunjan v. Malvinder Singh
! "#$$% &"'
$$$$(( * +!&!
), "- +. "/0 $$$
!("-
.# +$.&" )0 -0 1.
" +-,
+$3 +( ). "/00 4&+1-,
"
!("-
$ "/ //+ - 56 '&-/7 "- -
8$8$( -- ) !
&-/ 10 "- / +0120
(
" ) - 56 (
! &"- + .
" 9 "-& 1%%:"!0+ ;
<=+- !!)& "7 56
-1 !("-
((+ 0 !&+ 562 6 "!
)$ $ 0
!1 "5+ 1"
+6+- !(!
) (+
) !"
"7 65 "
-$ +) !("- )
"&"-
"9 +- !!)& "7 56
- ,+ ()
- "/
+ 0 ! 7 0
"$$91!0 77
--
!7 !! " 77 !! " 7&"
"/ 7
) +& 6$ (""
+, "/ +7 !7 "$ "
))61 -(
! )
3&+&4!0
20 02 "!
0 "- / +0&"- +- +! 0 !&+ $ +7 ()
- "/!
!1 !!& !2 + !("- , - "
!&((+ 0 ! $2 +1-&+ "/ " 6 -(
"1
' "
(()
! ) -"$$>565
!!
4 "/
"-7 +(
"-+ ", "/ "
+- ,+ $ 0 (()
5
! ) -(
"&"-
+ - !!)& "7 $0 ' "
5
!2 )!+ -">$$>20 561 6!
62 ) , "/!
)6! "
$%$? "-0 -- - ,+
0 +567& !" (!! 5) 7 ) ,
/
!0&!5 "-2 " &"
7(
)- !$ !( + 7(+7 !
/+
!("- 0&!5 "-2&)- 6) " &"
( +7 ) 7"6+ +!
) "-+0 +7 "+- &/0
+202&)-+ "2 00 +$
)! /+
!("- 2&)-+
&+"/)-"
4)
"- -2+6 "-2&)-( 6 !&7%) !"+5 ?$$>
" "/ 7&"
%) !2 -" "
@
+ "/$0 -'&+"
8$$>+ 7()
+7!
"- "- "!
"! - (()
" ) -56
2
+6( + -! @7"
0!$2 +1"
8$$>1 (+ ! - "/ + 2 ! " )
-'&+"
9$$>$ " --
-"
- " " $$> -'&+"
- $$$0
+1!0 - -"
+"$%$ "-%$%$
"-!0
-">$%$"20 0-
!0 !- +
+"9$8$$ "9$8$1
"-7
!
!0 - -" / , - ,+ !("- 56 7& $2 +1!0 -7
!0 -+
!&7 %) !+7 !("- 0&!5 "-562 6- "--+ $.0 )!
-7
- 0 +
- "
4)
! ( + 7& ) !
(
@
- - 1 +4 "- 2+
2+ "/1 +4$0 ) &+
+ "! - + "/
"!5
(
!1 , - '&-/7 "- -
- 8$8$ -
"-(
$
(+
)56 2 $ 9$
+"
- &"!
) + !&57
-
+6
!5 !(&!
!2
!
"-7 "$ !&+/
) &+
",4 "/ (+, ! "!.
"9:=:55= ++"
&!)6
!(
))6 -- ) "
7
"- 7 "$ ! "
) &+ "
'&-/7 75 6 /0&+ ""# $%$&'()) $")&' *+') , $")&' '-.$/- *+') 01 "2$% !
! 7 !()
&) +)620 -'&-/7 -, ++&) ( @&+ "
"# 3()&'#$ 4),- , " $(.$&' 1$.&((+
)!-+ 2"+7 '&-/7 ( @&+ ""(3#- $'$(-%$ , $*/$% $'$(-%$
5 6 5-,-76 1!$ ?$ !( + (+ !("- !!
+, @
!0 -+ &!
+
!&77"!$"
!(+ "5 ) !("- %$
+ "/)
+"
- &"!
)+ "-( +&! "/
+-12 "-+ " !&57 !! "!7 56)
+"
- &"!
)+
1
!!&
+ !
!+ "! -
" " 0 !
) ! &"- +# C0
+ "
"- + &7!
!
)&+ ! " +++ " ))2 "/
&"-
)
!D 8$ @ 7 " "/ !!& + ! "/ "
)1 "
5)6 7 .
"9 $
-! 0&!# 8! 4-,
(9) 2% "3#3$7 9 *&)*#:=.&5'
(+, ! "! 0 ! (
" + - !!)& " 56
7 65 (+
- !
&+ 565
7
/
+1 20
+ !& 0 7 ! !) 7" E +
77
2!:7 "-7 = 181:8>8="
/+&"-
60
") , "/!
)6+
+ -"
6
++7+
60 "
5) ) , /
+
6 0 7& ))6
/+
7 !0&)-5 - !!), -$ := 7 "5
!7 "
+) + " ! @ 7"
0!
+
(+
"
"+ "!&5!
:= "-"
/0
"7"
0!
1
" !" 2" " 7
&+ !0 ))1"5 "/!
! -1
+ "/
+7 4 "/!& 0 "B& +6 0 "4!
7 !5
"!) 7" E
+7 ! "
+& 1( !!
: - ,+ + "/ 7 - !!), -2
+7
$< $ () "+
- "/!&5!
":=!02!
7 20 + /+
56 7& ) "!
7
!0&)-5 - !!),
" /+&"-
60
") , "/!
)6+ + -"
6
++7+ 15
6(+
"+- ,+ !
&+ $ "(+
!& 0(
"1!
562 6 +!
7 "2&)-5 -$
+!&5!
":=1!
"-7 "2&)-5 7
20 0!0&)-5
+! @7"
0!+7
(+
"
"+ - "!&5!
":= "-"
/0
"7"
0!
+7
+!
7 "20
"0 !"
"2 2"$ 0 &+ 1"5 "/!
!
+ "/
!( !!
- ,+
+7
$ >$ "! - + "/ !!&
"/ - ,+
&"-
( @&+ "3()&'#$ 4),-& 9$&) 5&3;($6 0 -0 )- !&"- +# ;>$ 0 B& 020 02 +"
- !
!( "
"6
- ,+ ! ( - 2 2
"!
/ ,
"$0 "
-+
&-6" B& "0 + !
"5
&!
!-" !(
42 0"
, "
0 ! !(
75 6 /0&+ " $%$&'()) $")&' *+') , $")&' '-.$/- *+') 01 " !
1 0 @(+ - , 2
+& ) "!
+- ,+
< 92 20
! ) -$
"!
!,)&"
+ )6/ , 2&)-" (!! 5)
+ "6( 6 "&)) 6
"562 2 "/
"!
$ 0 &+ 0 ! -+ 2" !&((+ 0 !
" )&! "+7 (+ " () +)6 "/ +- +FF
&) - , ) + -&+ 20 0(+, -
!& ! ) -' "
)656"
+7+ () !1 !& 0 !& + ) 7 "" "-"
+2 2"56"
() !+"
!& )0 -(
! 7 ) +) "
+
!" "/ " "# '$*+)( $*#$ , $*& 3"$( $*+ *( 0 4)7'- !
-06 !0 /0 &+ " ))*$ 43##$ , *-(3+' 43##$ =01> 4 !00 )! 4
! 7 ) +, 2$ $ & 3 " '$*$* , ))/$2$- 00 )($7$ &"'
5 +6 /0 &+ "
$(9'$($* $3( , $9''$##$( -*?' 00 3*/$2 @ $(%$*$
'
" /0 &+ " $*# &'
3"$(- , A-()*+($ 3"$( 0< $/$&#'$* 0 0
+6, 2$ !5
" "
10 )-
! ( "
!(&!
2 2
"!
/ ,
"6
&+
+- ,+
!
"
&+
+ 0)- "/ " "B& +6 5&
"& "
!! "!
1"
+ )6 "
7()
"((+ &"
6+
+ !(&!
2
"!
3 "( &) +&) -& (()
" )/6&"- + +- +FF
&) - , ) + -&+ ! "
!
- !! 7 )
+ ! "/&"-
"9 G FF FF FF $ .&5!
":=+ &+ 0
!20 07
"!5
!$"
6!
H0 2"76 "!
H1+H 7" 2 )) "/( 6 - ,+ H1
&+ "" !!
"!
$ &+ !0 )- 0 (2
!) )65 -" "
)(
"1
20)
7& )6 "- "!
+ - ,+ $& - ,+ ! ! "
B&
""+( !! "/
+- ,+
9$& !0&)- "
"& )) - ,+
!( -$ ! (!
&+ ( !!
$H0 "!
7&!
"& -
" ! "-7&!
, ) -!&5! !
"/ "!
20 !0
+-H$.
: = )!5&+6 2!"/) "-1 &+ 0- "*)$9( 8?%I: =
6- "" ,+ 1 0-$*)$($ "-: = )$7)& , )$7)& 5 77 << $# <1$ 9$ " &+ , 21 "
+(+
" / ,
0
" 56 /0 &+ ! 3 1 &"'
5 G +6
'
" " - - ! "!
+! ++
"-2 +7
, 2$0
! "! !75 61 )0 -06 !0:!&(+ = "" 0 -2" 2 ++
)6 6!
"-, ++&) -$< $ 0&!1
)+ ) &+ 0
!
"-7 "5 "6
-$0 .
"9:= , "/"
7() -2 01 ) &+ ! " +++ "( !! "/
$ +- "/)61
) ! '&-/7
-8$8$( ) &+ !!
! -
" ) -&"-
"-!- !7 !!
-$ 5
6 4B $*3$(%
: 5 6 /5!
4B