Ram Chand Garg v. Food Corporation Of India And ORS

    

  

  

 

!"

#$%$!&'

( (  














) *%+% 

  

   

,



'  -. ,( ,
 ., ..

  
 






   






  !" #### ., ../ ( 


 

  
$
%&'

(


)*
*+

 

 (*
 

)),
 
) 
) 

-)
*+


%./&&01

(

 (* )
,
   2  


 *

3(


+
 
 
,
3




4 """
,


!  


"

%56.
,  
,
  

.57/.777
8( 
 %
,

))




,
,

+)*
 ++
)  




,
8 


 

)))
 
+

 

./70.77%
8( 
.


, 

,
( 


%/76.779
,


(



-* 
,
(
()
6:


!"


()
%56%

 ; 

.57/.776
8( 
/
,




  8 
 

./70.77%
, 
-*

) *
( * 
)*


 *


%777771
)
,
(


)

*
-*
 
 

 

 
*
,
(+()


,
+ 
)
 

 
, )
-*

 ,
,
()+)*
 +



 

.57:.7%/
8( 
 

"

 (+

 
+
 

/%7%.7%%
;  
( +

,))

))
 
,
))
-*

 
!<.9.%6.7%/
,
,
)),

7%%7.7%0
8( 
9  =
>
..0

.7%9
)
-*


,
 +



757..7%9

8( 
6 

+) )*
=
)
-*


,
) 
 +


7076.7%9

4 
 
-*





 
!< .9.%6.7%/
)
-*


,
)),

7%%7.7%0
*+

(



, 

) 

"
 

+


 

 ) *

 
)

, 
) 

)


>+- 
.7%9 
+


+(
(

 
, ))
-
,)


+  )



?
+(

) 






)*
) -*



.5%7.7%&


( 



>  ()

 

*+ +(


+ 

% :7 *

@= @ + %%17.1.7%% /95071 . )

+-( + %%17.1.7%% &&771 / .%
*
@= 7%17:1.7%% .////1 : 4 (*

!

.&17:1.7%% 6%99051 0 )
@=
A
= .517:1.7%% %&577%1

0 9 * 8 ;  + .:1701.7%% 55/:1 6 !
)
*+ 761791.7%% %9600/01 &



!

4 (*

.%1701.7%% .%00%1 5 (
! %.1761.7%.

%097%%1 %7 ;? %917%1.7%/ /%&0/1 %% ="
)
.7%7%% 51%71.7%0 56071 %. "
( (



 


)*
   761%%1.7%9 /7.%:71 %/ !"
!
%7'

%.1761.7%6 55.1 %:



!

4 (*

.91761.7%6 6.7571 %0 :7
*
@=
 

.7%7

%517&1.7%6 :7:01 ?;?=
B@>?

2@@>
"

/.0&9::1

, 


)


, 
+

  


*+

 
!

4

.675.7%6


(+

 ) %.

 )*
+
, 



(+


/:66751
,

 


(




7&%%.7%9


+(


(
+
+

) *


( (

 
 .57/.776 = 
( )



 (



 


( +
, 
 


)

  

)* *+

+



-+
(

+


, 
 )

,)

+(

 




-    

 

 (-+
,  

)

  
,  
   

, 

()
-
)),

  

 )*
*+
()
-


 




+


 -+
(

+

1 
 
) 
( )



 (
 )*



 *


%777771


-
()*
+ 
( 


 

./70.77%
 


 
, 
  
7%%7.7%0

!<.9.%6.7%/
 !  
,
) 


))

+
+(
(
, 

 



(-+
,
) 
)+ 
++)*
 
 +

)


) =

-*

C-)
( +
!( 

+

)


, 

 *
 

 
) 
( )


 



 (


)


"


)
 

 1  *
- 
 

 -(*



+)*
,)
)  1 


+)* ,(
*
(


( 

()D


+*

)-)

*   



+(


 

(3(  
)*

"

  
 



+

 


,

 


 

.57/.777
, 

,
8 



 
)))
 
+

 

./70.77%
,   

.57/.776
,




 
 

./70.77% 8 

 
)*
,
+)*
+ 
(
 

 

.57/.776
?   



 
, 
,))
,




,)

+(
 E( 
,


 

/%7%.7%%
,
 
 .57/.776
,
 *
+(

)
 C
)
))
  
.57/.776
,
+)*
 +


-*

))
( *
 .57:.7%/
!<.9.%6.7%/
)
-*


))
 


.57/.776

.57:.7%/
,
)),

7%%7.7%0

= 

 ( )





*

 




 
 7%%7.7%0
 
,

 +
 



-*

 
2



C-)
( +
!( 

"
, -*
 

 
 7%%7.7%0

!<.9.%6.7%/
, *

"

,


+ 

, 
-(

+)+


 

) 
 *+
(



++)*


) 
,

 -) +





 

7%%7.7%0

"

-
)
-*

()) 2

 
!( 


  

  



 )
- 

()
-
) 


  8( )*


) 
,
,
+

 +
 (+
 -*
) 
( )






, 

 ( (
+
)-)


   

  

)-)

-

-* 
 



*
+ 


,



  ,

 +
 

(


  
 (+
 

 (( )*
( 
-*
)  ( )







 )
, 


!<.9.%6 .7%/
,

-
)
-*

 

 *

  
,

 

 (+
-
E())*


*
+ 

3
"

 -


 



+)
(

,
)

!<%/%&0 
%55.
)
!"#  $  

7:7%%550 

 

 
 

,)
) *
,))

 






(- E(
, 


)+
  


 

) *
,
)*

 
,
)
)

  

 )*
*+
"
!"# %
 

( 
 C


) *



 ()
 
,
(
(
)(
-*
 (


 
,)  ) *



,

 
 +)
( 
 


2 ,)
 C ) *

 
  
"
(

(

,

-  

( 

 
   

    


 


  
 
 
        

 
      

 



  

     

     
 
 !

!

"# "

$ !

"% & # !

"%

!% '

!

"%  
  



($ '

!

""

)

    



 

  


  
 
 
  

 *

   
 


  + 
    ,
     



 ($ '

!

"" 
 -
  
 

  

 



   

    
  
  ,

-  

    !

( !

.   
        

       

   



 
 

($ '

!

""

/  
 



 

   
   0

 


   
 
 
  -

 

  


 


 




  
  0   


 
  
 1
   

  
  
 
         2






?   



 
,

 *

 

   

 )
, 

))
 

.57/.776
 .57:.7%/

-

-




)+
  

 )*
*+  G

,



 (+  
,)

 *
 (

, 
  

)*
*+
+




  +


 
"





)

  

+
,
+
 
7%%7.7%0




,
 
 .57/.776

.57:.7%/
, 

 
"
 
( 
 

   $
9'

(+



)*
*+

, 
7%%..7%0
))
 

()
*+
-
) 


 


) 
( )

 


.77771

< 


 )*
  
 

., .. ( ( 

 

()
<
1   B 1> <
 -) B 1>