← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18843/2016allowed

Tripat Kaur v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2024-02-21Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj19 pages



  

      

   

     

 !

    

   "#$"#

%&'()*+ ),)-.)&/*0$11 %&'()*+-/*/%*2)&/*011         

 !

     

03 4

1  5  1

 1 6666                     ! "#$ %

   &'  (!"    ) **** 5  1

 7 1

 "    +  ,     +   +%  -- . - ,        /   ,  +     - (01&22)'   34&5 "  67   

   $ % 6

(""         "   38&&3443  +%  (-- 1-1 "   %   # -  $ % 9 -   $- 

   ,""    ( "   4&4234&5,/"(-- 1-1 "   %  # -   $ %  9 -   $- 

      "- -"%    

): -.   +       + ("1;" "       "+ 

" -<    "  ="--  +%     $ % +  " "      -   >+ ?

-+ &82)  !  "% --       @        -   -     ;       -+   + &44 " "" "% <  <""   ,   

-     )A     

  ++      ) "  ,     

    ) 43&&&82)/;

'3B," "   # 

,#  -  

  )C3&)2&)8)'5'43 ;(+% -   -"%--+   7   --+ ?-  -"%    ) <""+%-+"+, ,   --  B444?1, 3B&&&82)7 ,- -   



-   "   "   -  34444?1  +%  # -   $ % "    -7 ,""  )  ?  --+   -"%<""+%-+  (0 &355& &88B"6",    $ %   6 , "   $  (    <  -      - 7 - ,  &54)&882"    ?-   , "    - 

'C4444?1    + "", 9!  9" $  (   (0 &)38   &885 "  6!.     9"- 64C4B&885 /  +. - 

  !

 "! , 

"",  # "$%&%& '(

 ) *& +), ,- ./) /

, (!$   434)3443 7 (   %   # -  $ %," +%( (""  -   %- -- &82)    "  - ,      D -           %- ; ,       ""  -?      - "+  -  %- - ;-"   +%(  %&%& '(

 )  "!0 +",+%  $ %  "- -< -   &82)&44B3443 E -  .  

         )  +-   "  45423443     "  "  % /;

,""  7-, 



(- %   %  7  (""< -    - &82) ,     $ %,"+"   -F+  -, +%

 9%(-- # "  " % -       - -  9% (-- 9" 0  -    "     ),-<"" &82) #  ;""   ): -.   +       

334&344'  

"%" "    ,  ,  ,

 ,,<""  &82)+, - -  - ;  < -  3'444?1   -  &'34444?1 ,  +% - ;  +

  +% -.  , ""%  "  ,  ,  -"%  .   A    7 "     ,"   ,   ,"  +%9%(-- 9" 0   -, ""%    -.         -  5    ;  -  344C +  -  , "% ,   &'4'3445>    - -"-", "+%      -.  +  ( A"   #   )5B)52)B&)34&341!C45&BB&2&



&23&8&&83&85&88344 ;(344'3445-- # - $ %"- - &82)  - 'C4444?1 BC4444?17  -,, +  -.  ,   -" 7 " ( (01)2&8 3445 <  < , ("- ') D"  38&&3443+%

"   -       - <""  &82)  "       - 9+ -      - , %+%(   3B4'3445""      9  % , - -, 

+,   )1 -.  ,       - 

- # -   $ %     

    



D 1&2+  ( 7+,  (01)2&81 3445,  "%  +-, ,   4B4C344B, "-+, 

 "%2%   , ," ,   $ %  " &)4B34&C  "   C44444?1   &82)< 7"-     ,  +%

"   , "  "      )  " , - %   +%      9% (--  #   4C4234&C   "        



--,""7 @,  , +% 9%(-- #  "   %9 - $-

   $ % ,, <  (@"%A   1    ( +%

"    +   (01&8CB8134&C 7 + -     D    ,""   , %+%(   &54834&C --# - $ %" (-- ;@ %  - &82)     "" $(""    9 # % 34&& ( - $6+"  A7# 

;,   +-+%A7#  (--  " 4&4234&5,+%"(

  %   # -   $ % 9 -   $- 

      "  &C44444?1  +  "    ,     - ,    + "       )1  -.    " ,     - +%     3)4234&5   < %+ -D        -   ,      +- +% A 7 #  (--   )1 -.

 +,<      -    -" "  - <""&82) + ""%, +  

(01&22)'134&5, "

        0 0 -+"

   &'  

"   %# - $ %9 - $-

  + ",  "    +  " - &82) ,;+    (""  %- -- &82)  ,  &34B3443,  " 38&&3443  -""+ "-,-    7  " +   (01)2&813445  < @  "- " 38&&3443,"- -     -   &82) <  ,  +  ,   - - , 

 +,       ,         , -+% +  1  ), (0 )2&8 3445,, ,4B4C344B 7  - ,  ""%   -- $6+"A ,(--"   ,   -  # -   ;   ,   -  -,-+""% ,  -  "      "- ,  @   + +

" 3C4C34&5# - ;+   # -" %<,"-< " %-     "% $  - @ ,    + - ,   -  "     -,"-,+ ;

  -"  % ,  "   -  ,    - - D+,  ;     <,"    9" $  (    . -4)4B344B-  $%1 & 23  !

*! 

4( %   54 ,- 6 () /  (!$"-    &82) <  -  + @ ,       ,"  "    +   "",+%+   

         

      

   





 

    



 

     



       !

"  



  #   $   

#

    " %  





   # "

# &    ;,,  -  "-   "   38&&3443 "  -   ,%        % ," + "         - "--" ++ < -, - " 

       1    ,  - , "  +"

   

)1+    , ,  "

#

+++.   "   

'44)344B   2    - -%,

   "- %   -$  "%  - D

,    +     "- - 7%     - "- %   -  ;, %  + +   ","+"+- ; + -"        +-+ %   -    ; " "       -  "+" ", +"  7     %       

  '44)344B D +%     "    +% 

)   ""%  (01)2&813445   + ,    "  ,     +     7    

 

'"  (  ) !*

 %

+

 $   , -./0$  (1 ) $

- 2 

 $ "   $ 



 



   3 



.

  "  " ! %    

,4     

      

    ,4  ( 5 +





 -

.678   

/

 

  ,  





     1  .9:7  

       

  

  "  " ! %   

 

  , 

8

  ! %     



 ,4  ( 5

  -++  ,4  ( 5

+



 /08/66;

 ,4     

 -  (        

     

 " !

%

7        

  /60/66;

<  

         -7

 "  " ! % 

    "

  

2



$ =

 -8   7

 " >1 %

  /8666*     

.8$/6$666* 

 8

;

    

 % + 



1  "  8<6     

      

   

   "  " ! % 

 

     *1



     8<6  

 .6</660

  ,2?

1 @$ 8.$ 

  $

-  '$ % .$ - 2 

   -

.:.:67$ .:.:68  .:.:6/  1 "

     "  

 % +





* @







 .:7/660    

  ' %.0

0

 

"    +      

,

     



  



 

 % +

    





 

!% - 7:.9  "     

"

-  +  ="  

   



.9:7  

 

 % +



* @

$





* 860/*/$ = -.6$ + -$ - 2  ..666:      







  

    

 .9:7    

 

 +  

    

"   "



 $ 

  



  

 



$

:

   "    

   ;

"$



"     "  " !

%       " ! %$

"  

   

 &   ("    )" " -    B +

-G  7 ,-   .+   ( , +

," +       < + -    -    --+%# - "  - !  H  , =+     "   @      7$6+"  -( ",+ 



-  $& 6  ) 7//3 *!  & '"" 7,$   # 

%

& 7 "D  -     +",

.8 '

    



 

 "$

       ,

 

    

 "   "

 !"    

  1

  "$

$ 

 " 

 



" 



" +  !"  

"

     2  "





          



 



     

    

     

  + 

   

  1

    " 

  

!"    1      !" 

    

 

 

 

       

 !" 

  $ 



"    "

  "  



"  

 

  

       "   



"

  

     "

     "       

  

 

     

   

  



 " 

"            

 "    

 "    

  $   "  

  4   

  "



1 

    

 

       

  

"

 

 

+

        



.7

5    

      

'   

   '

   

     ' 

  

 

 +      

   +  "  + 

' 

 ' 

   

"    '

      ' "  

 



   &

81"()  ""

)/

  7 ,    

 -+%$6+"  - ( -  A%   ,- 9:

*!  6;)/!



%)<( =(

!

/ , (!>    %

7 "D  -     +", ?

..& 6, !) ,-

);!

80  (1 @  

  

 

5**      " 

      +     

      $

 



1



" 



1     "     

 

          



     " 3

 78.$  :C

: D"      "









  

 1  +

!" 

 

       



1  "     



  1  +  E

8:

 $  "   

1

  

  

     

$

   1

 

     $   



"

  " 

   

    $  

  

  1   

 "   

*  

 

  

 "  $

 "    

   









   % ++

" F    %2 21 B.C " 5 G



C

89

 %  ' >

  (  B%C @

 

  3

 7<0$  /;C

E/;

'  

$     "

       

    " H 



 

 

 ""     





              E

76

  "

       

     







  

% 5 



I  B%C @ " 5  %     $



          "



7.

!"    

   

""         $

"$

$ 

 "$ 

  

"$ 



" +   $      

      

 "    

 

" "$  

   

    



1   $



  B>

2 1 @ " - (1 )  1 ) $

   -

" $ ( 

   " = J+

$ ' ,   @ "

 

 +

 $



5

( 

" '

  ( $

11



' "

 

11

 )  

" %  C

7/

    (   = 

" 2

,1 

4

'







"*

   

3

 ;<$  .7.<C

E.7

    "$ 



"

  

      

"         $ 

  "

G  "    



 

     



.<

      $ " 

         "$    $



     

    $   " 

 

   '  $     

    $ $   

"   

 70       

  E

78

 $ 

"$      



 





 $       

1       $    

  

"

 " ,"$   

1 



 $

   





   

1   

$ 

   

 *    



 + '$  $  

$    

"    





   

            



-  

   "* 

   "   

*+  

     " 

       

   



  

   

&

81"() % ""

)/

7$6+"  -(    "    . -   @( +/3,< A /& *!  +) / %")!)  A /&$   

% 

"%    . - &

6  ) 7//3  "!&

     

  '44)344B +- +%     (01)2&813445      "     

    " " ,"""-    "       -  &82) <    " % %  +.%(  ",, +,  ,  "  "% +  +- % ?  -%    ; - " ",",+%$6+"

 -( -  & 6  ) 7//3  "!,"" -  %   ,- 9:

*!  6;)/!



%)<( =(

!

 "!      ,  "    @   -   +  " "@-    <,       +  "-    " ,D  ,  %,".%/      " "@-  "% +-  -7 +, ,  -,    ,  1D   >  +  -  ,

- ,6  - , $      "      -          "% + ,+% %  - ;     

+ ,"D,+%  " 

"

,-   +. -    - " % ,   +    )1 -.     +  $  (  ; ,  "%      - -  

3'444?1  ;  <    &'34444?1   " + +%  ) ""-       + ""%  ""% "    - 

'C4444?1, % , ,,   "     B 

+-      %    +.  "    -? "   );, - + %,"" %"-     -? "   "%+.%(  ", 7   

, D ,

+D+%  

,"    "%     -  ,  +. -   (01)2&8134457,     +.  <"-  + D 

"  " %     + " +%  # - 7    ,     ,      -

,  "  

7%+   ,   ""    -  "" 7 "- +%      ""   "-    'C4444?1  ,  "% +         D1  " "",+%# -," - D-+ +  "%",   <%   - -   -? "  $  +   ,"  ""%-

,""-%  %+@- -?

"  ;,""" "",-+  ,"-", ?" + "   -7   - +  -- "   -,"  -    - "      +

-   ,    - --%-

  7 -    -?

"    "% 2 %      "- +,       ,  +"%           -     +   , ,  ""%,

 %   -? " -%+ +%%+@  ?<+%# -

#

7 +.    )      "@""   -? "   -    

  '44)344B   +   ,    ""         +.    "  +         ,    -    "-   + D +,      +  -?

"  "    - 

'C4444?1

""       "--   +%  1    -    . -   $6+" 9"$ ( +%"  " ," "%-?

";-         "   -     -< - &82) < -     -?

"   +  ?  + "     )" $ ,  "",& ""   - "    % "       "% 5  1



!



7       !9/!

!

  1*

J*-

!

   

J*-