Jarnail Singh & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

 
 

   !

 
   

"#$ %$&'(')*



"+)"',-')./")%#/$+( $#'#')$+( 0 -#"#$ "+1")"")%#/$+(  $(2)%$)#(
 * 34 -
---  34- -
4- 44 +$($)#*+ ".%'(/")&/")%"5 %0&"#$")% +6+2+$$# "1'"5 %0&"#$ +#/$2$#'#')$+( +")%/'+-')./5 5"+1")"7'#/ +8/,"59$&6#'0$).')$$+5/".."+"#$+  -$+0'&$( '0'(')5-'+(" + "(:')%$+-').//')%5 %0&"#$  +#/$"22,'&")#(')
 ;<

 ===== --- 5 /$2$#'#')/"(>$$) ',$%>1  "+)"',-')./")%#/$+( 2$#'#')$+(6)%$+ +#'&,$(

?

; #/$
)(#'#6#') )%'" + '((6")&$ "7+'#')#/$)"#6+$ &$+#'+"+'5:")%":6(")%('& +  ")1  #/$+  "22+2+'"#$  7+'#  +  @6"(/').  #/$  "&#')    #/$ +$(2)%$)#('))##"A').")1"&#')#&/"))$,'B$#/$37"+">")%'3  '9"#') #6+) +'++'."#') ,")%",,##$%##/$2$#'#')$+(?

')/">'#")#( 0',,".$",7"+"8/6+%5$/(',,,$)">"%5 '(#+'&#-'+(" ")%#/$+0',,".$(#/"# ",,6)%$+#/$,,$)">"%,&A5 '(#+'&#-'+(" ")%",( +)##"A').")1"&#'))#/$&:2,"')#(:"%$>1#/$ 2$#'#')$+(")%#/$+')/">'#")#(##/$$

$&##/"##/$,")%7)$+( )$"+>1#/$+'0$+7$+$&::'##').#/$ #  7"#$+>1 &"+0'). 6#

  ',,$.",6#,$#(7"#$+&/"))$,( +#/$'+7)>$)$ '#')&))'0")&$ 7'#/#/$

'&'",(  #/$ ++'."#') $2"+#:$)# %6$ #7/'&/ #/$ &+2( #/$')/">'#")#( #/$"+$"/"%>$$)+6')$%%6$#,"&A

7"#$+ +#/$,"(#:")11$"+(  6+#/$+%'+$&#')'((6./# + %'+$&#').  #/$  +$(2)%$)#(  #  &/"))$,'B$  #/$  37"+">")%'3  +  #/$ ')/">'#")#( #/$0',,".$",7"+"57/($ '$,%( ",,')#/$-6#/ /".."+
")",3-
3
")", +(/+#")%/"A+"
")", (#',,

6+#/$+%'+$&#')'((6./###"A$"&#')"."')(##/$2$+()(7/ 7$+$&::'##').7"#$+#/$ #>126##').',,$.",7"#$+&/"))$,(') &))'0")&$  7'#/ #/$ 

'&'",(C >$('%$(5  %'+$&#  #/$  +$(2)%$)#(  # 2+0'%$7"#$+"(2$+2+0'(')( #/$"+1")"
")",")% +"')".$

&#5<;

3#/$ &#3 +(/+#")%6,$( +":$%#/$+$6)%$+")% ",(%'+$&##/$+$(2)%$)#(##"A$"&#')"(7$,,"(')@6'+$')##/$ :"##$+  "(  #/$  ')/">'#")#(    #/$  "+$"  /"%  :"%$  :")1 +$2+$($)#"#')(>6#)"&#')/"%>$$)#"A$) /$ 2$#'#') &":$62 +/$"+'). )  < <

")%"

&21 #/$2$#'#')7"(.'0$)#-/+'")%/'+-')./5 5 "+1")"("(#$)">,$/':#($$A')(#+6&#')( /'(
6+#)



2"(($%#/$ ,,7').+%$+* D 6+').#/$&6+($ %$,'>$+"#')5'#'( ".+$$%>$#7$$)#/$,$"+)$%&6)($,"22$"+'). + #/$  2"+#'$(  #/"#  #/$  +$2+$($)#"#'0$(    #/$ 2$#'#')$+((/",,"22$"+')#/$

-/8 /,"5  9$&6#'0$  ).')$$+5  /".."+  "#$+ -$+0'&$( '0'(')5-'+(")

"#

":")%#/$1(/",,(6>:'##/$'+,'(# .+'$0")&$(5 7/'&/(/",,>$$9":')$%")%")$

+#(/",,",(

E >$:"%$# +$(,0$#/$ :"##$+   +$(2)('>,$ +$2+$($)#"#'0$    ,'&$  -#"#')5  ,,$)">"%  (/",, ",(  +$:"')  2+$($)#  ')  #/$  

'&$    -/  8 /,"5  9$&6#'0$  ).')$$+5  /".."+  "#$+ -$+0'&$( '0'(')5-'+(" 4'(# +/$"+').)

F )#$+:( #/$">0$+%$+5#/$+$2+$($)#"#'0$( #/$ 2$#'#')$+(7$+$#"22$"+')#/$

-/+'8/,"59$&6#'0$ ).')$$+5/".."+"#$+-$+0'&$( '0'(')5-'+(")

"# 

":/$17$+$#(6>:'##/$'+,'(# .+'$0")&$(57/'&/7$+$ #>$$9":')$%C>$('%$(5")$

+#7"(",(#>$:"%$#+$(,0$ #/$:"##$+ +$(2)('>,$+$2+$($)#"#'0$ ,'&$-#"#')5,,$)">"% 7"("(A$%#>$2+$($)#')#/$

-/+'8/,"59$&6#'0$ ).')$$+5/".."+"#$+-$+0'&$( '0'(')5-'+(" -/+'  ".%'(/  ")&/")%"5  %0&"#$  "22$"+').  +  #/$ 2$#'#')$+((6>:'#(#/"##/$2$#'#')$+(7$)###/$

-/+'

8/,"59$&6#'0$).')$$+5/".."+"#$+-$+0'&$( '0'(')5 -'+(") ;

#"22+'($/': #/$',,$.",7"#$+&/"))$,( #/"#/"%>$$)($#62#'( 6+#/$+(6>:'##$%#/"##/$1%'%)#. )  

  %6+').  #/$  $)#'+$  %"1  "(  #/$1  "22+$/$)%$%  #/"# #/$+$76,%>$#+6>,$ -/")%/'+-')./5 5"+1")")')(#+6&#')( +:

-/+'    8  /,"5   9$&6#'0$  ).')$$+5  /".."+  "#$+  -$+0'&$( '0'(')5-'+("57/'(2+$($)#')
6+#5(#"#$(#/"##/$

'&$+(

#/$++'."#') $2"+#:$)#7$+$2+$($)#')#/$'+

'&$ +:

":  #  G

 2:  )  

  #  $)#$+#"')  #/$  2$#'#')$+(  ') &:2,'")&$7'#/#/$+%$+ #/'(
6+#5>6#))$&":$

  -/")%/'+-')./5 5"+1")"/"(",( ',$%(/+# +$2,1  >1  7"1    "

'%"0'#    -/+'  -"#$)%$+  86:"+  62#"5  -5 -62$+')#$)%$)# ,'&$5-'+(")>$/", +$(2)%$)#(;")%  #'((6>:'##$%#/"##/$2,'&$%$2"+#:$)#/"%",7"1(>$$) #"A').2+:2#"&#')7/$)$0$+")1')&'%$)# #/$ # &")",7"#$+ 7"(+$2+#$%##/$&)&$+)$%2,'&$(#"#')#'((6>:'##$%#/"# -/+'/2-')./5- "22+"&/$%#/$,'&$-#"#')5,,$)">"%) < ;

E +.$##').2,'&$"'%+$."+%').',,$.",7"#$+&/"))$,(') 0',,".$(",7"+"")%/"+A") 2,'&$2"+#17"(2+0'%$%#/':

0'%$$)#+1 ))$96+$+$&+%$%')#/$3+"2"#+B)":&/"3 /$2,'&$2"+#1+$#6+)$%##/$,'&$-#"#')5,,$)">"%0'%$$)#+1 

 ))$96+$ +$&+%$%')#/$3+"2"#+B)":&/"3 )+$."+%##/$".+$$%+%$+2"(($%>1#/'(
6+#5'#'( (6>:'##$%#/"##/$+$2+$($)#"#'0$( #/$2$#'#')$+(7$+$#"22$"+ ')#/$

-/+'8/,"59$&6#'0$).')$$+5/".."+"#$+ -$+0'&$( '0'(')5-'+(")

-?-H'A"(",).7'#//'( (6>+%')"#$(5  '#  '(  (#"#$%  7$)#  #  #/$  

'&$    #/$  9$&6#'0$ ).')$$+5/".."+"#$+-$+0'&$( '0'(')5-'+(")

"# #/$.'0$)#':$")%#/$1+$:"')$%2+$($)#')#/$

'&$ +#/$7/,$ %"1>6#)$'#/$+")1 #/$2$#'#')$+()+")1+$2+$($)#"#'0$) #/$'+>$/", &":$')#/$

'&$%6+').7+A')./6+( -/+'  "(:')%$+  -')./  /')%5  %0&"#$  /"(  ',$% 
  ;<

)>$/", '(/2",-')./")%#/$+(

0',,".$(  /")'  I6A'5  />+'"5  ':")16  8/$+"5  -/"A/6  8/$+"5

:+'#("+  8/6+%  ")%  8",")5  "+#"2  "."+5  I6A/$+"5 "##'A'+2",5 "##"$#&$/(',,,$)">"%5 '(#+'&#-'+("")%0',,".$86##""%/5 $/(',  ")'"5  '(#+'&#  -'+("  +  >$').  ':2,$"%$%  "(  2+'0"#$

G +$(2)%$)#(')#/'(2$#'#') #'((#"#$%>1-/+'/')%5 %0&"#$ #/"##/$",,$."#')("(,$0$,,$%')#/$2$#'#')"+$##",,1 ",($")% /"0$  >$$)  :"%$  "#  #/$  >"&A    #/$  "

$&#$%  2$+()(  (  "(  # %$2+'0$#/$: #/$'++'./#(#'((6>:'##$%#/"#)(2$&' '&2$+()5 7/'((#"#$%#/"0$&::'##$%7"#$+#/$ #/"(>$$):$)#')$% ")%#/$+$'()(2$&'

'&",,$."#'),$0$,,$%"."')(#")1+$('%$)#+ ')/">'#")# #/"#"+$"57/'((#"#$%/"%&::'##$%")1"&##/"#'( ",,$.$%')#/$7+'#2$#'#')/$:#'0$ #/$2$#'#')$+(5"&&+%').

##/$,$"+)$%&6)($,"22$"+'). +#/$"22,'&")#('(/2",-')./ ")%#/$+('(#.$#")+%$+ +:#/'(
6+#"##/$'+>"&A7'#/6# ':2,$"%').#/$:"("2"+#1

+$ $+$)&$/"(",(>$$):"%$>1-/+'/')%5 %0&"#$# ")+%$+%"#$% G 

G2"(($%')
  

G#'#,$% 38"+")I'#-')./0-#"#$ "+1")"")%#/$+(357/$+$')#/$("'% 2$#'#') ',$%>18"+")I'#-')./")%#/$+(")%(:$ #/$:"+$ )72$#'#')$+(')#/$2+$($)#2$#'#')57"(%'(2($% 7'#/#/$ %'+$&#')  #  #/$  +$(2)%$)#(  #  &)('%$+  #/$  +$2+$($)#"#')  ))$96+$(1:2"#/$#'&",,1")%2+$ $+">,17'#/') '

#$$)%"1(') 0'$7 #/$62&:').2"%%1($"()#'((#"#$%#/"##/$&)&$+)$% -62$+')#$)%').).')$$+2"(($%")"22+2+'"#$+%$++$."+%').#/"# '((6$  /$  ("'%  "&#5  '#  '(  (#"#$%5  /"(  ",(  >$$)  ')#$)#')",,1 (622+$(($%>1#/$2$#'#')$+(#'((6>:'##$%#/"##/$2$#'#')$+( %'%)#"22$"+)#/$%"#$ '9$%')#$+:( +%$+%"#$%



 2"(($%>1#/'(
6+#"(#/$17")#$%#2,"1/'%$")%($$A $/"0$.'0$)6+#/6./# 6,&)('%$+"#')##/$:"##$+ /$",,$."#')(')#/$2$#'#')"+$#/"#(:$2$+()(/"%:"%$ ',,$.",6#,$#(?7"#$+&/"))$,(')#/$+'0$+%6$#7/'&/#/$7"#$+

 7/'&/'(#&:$#/$ "+:$+("##/$#"',$)% #/$7"#$+&/"))$,'( )#>$').+$&$'0$% )#/'(:"##$+5#/$2+2$+&6+($'(# ',$"

)$&$(("+1  "22,'&"#')  6)%$+  #/$  &#  ")%  #/$  6,$(  +":$% #/$+$6)%$+>$ +$#/$"22+2+'"#$ +6: ) -#"#$ ##"++"%$(/0-')./"+"-')./")%#/$+(5

< -
EG 5'#/"(>$$)/$,%#/"##/$+6,$"%2#$%')"1,+0 "1,+ ; 
/ 

'(7$,,+$&.)'B$%")%'( 6)%$%) (6)%2+')&'2,$#(+$(6,#'(#/"#'

"(#"#6#$/"(&) $++$%"27$+ #%")"&#")%/"(,"'%%7)#/$:$#/%')7/'&/#/"#27$+/"( #>$$9$+&'($%5'#)$&$(("+',12+/'>'#(#/$%'). #/$"&#')")1 #/$+:"))$+#/")7/'&//"(>$$)2+$(&+'>$% $('%$(57/$+$" 27$+'(.'0$)#%"&$+#"')#/').')"&$+#"')7"15#/$#/').:6(# >$%)$')#/"#7"1+)#"#",,")%#/"##/$#/$+:$#/%(

2$+ +:")&$"+$)$&$(("+',1 +>'%%$)/$2+')&'2,$>$/')%#/$+6,$ '(#/"#'

#/'(7$+$)#(5#/$(#"#6#+12+0'('):'./#"(7$,,)# /"0$>$$)$)"&#$%/$+$ +$57/$)","72+0'%$( + ,,7')."

2"+#'&6,"+2+&$%6+$5#/$)#/"#2+&$%6+$",)$'(#>$ ,,7$% ")%#/$#/$+2+&$%6+$("+$)$&$(("+',1 +>'%%$) /$2$#'#')$+(')#/$&'+&6:(#")&$(5:"1'

("%0'($%5 "0"',  #/$'+  +$:$%'$(  6)%$+  #/$  &#  ")%  #/$  6,$(  +":$% #/$+$6)%$+C>$('%$(5')&"($7"#$+#/$ #(/"0$>$$)&::'##$%5 #/$1"+$,'">,$#($$A#/$'++$:$%'$(>1,%.'). &:2,"')#(7'#/ #/$&)&$+)$%-#"#')6($

'&$+( #/$"+$"#'(#>$)#'&$% #/"##/$2$#'#')$+(+#/$'++$2+$($)#"#'0$(%$(2'#$>$')..+")#$% ")22+#6)'#1#"22$"+')#/$

-/+'8/,"59$&6#'0$ ).')$$+5/".."+"#$+-$+0'&$( '0'(')5-'+(")

"# 

":5%'%)# ++$"()(>$(#A)7)"22$"+

; 8$$2').  ')  0'$7  #/$  "&#  #/"#  #/$  2$#'#')$+(  /"0$ ",#$+)"#'0$+$:$%'$(")%#/$"22,'&")#( 
 ;<

 7/  "+$  ($$A').  #/$'+  ':2,$"%:$)#  #  #/$  2$#'#')  "(  2+'0"#$ +$(2)%$)#(5  /"0$  ($+'6(  >I$&#')(  #  #/$  &"($  "(  /"(  >$$) 2+I$&#$%>1#/$2$#'#')$+(5'#76,%>$I6(#")%$92$%'$)##/"##/$ :"##$+'(&)('%$+$%>1#/$"6#/+'#'$(&)&$+)$%6)%$+#/$ &# )#/$&'+&6:(#")&$(57$ ')%).+6)%#')#$+ $+$#/$ :"##$+"##/'((#".$ /$7+'#2$#'#')'("&&+%').,1%'(:'(($% 7$0$+5#/$2$#'#')$+(76,%>$"#,'>$+#1#"0"',#/$'+ (#"#6#+1+$:$%'$(')"&&+%")&$7'#/,"7 ---     4- 44

   

8"6)%", #$*  /$#/$+#/$+%$+'((2$"A').?+$"()$%* !$(

 /$#/$+#/$+%$+'(+$2+#">,$ * !$(