Mona A. Sreenivas v. The State Of Haryana
!"#$#$
%
&" '(& # )#)#)*+
! "
#$%&$'( )! "
#$*%$'(
+, - !.)! #)#)*+ ,#
"
! !#$%&'(
#$*%'( /
/
/
# 0 , ,0
'&'*'( / # 10 !+ !
/!
..
"
2( # # ,, 0
"" ! /
"! "
"
" "
" !
3'&'! "
/ .
#,,
!+ !
"
, " 0 4
0! , "" !
0
,
5"" "
..
" , ! !
#, 0 ,&'''3%'&'
" !4
0
"
"" "
*'2((3 "
6
!+
0
, " , ''&' ",
, "
" "
78258( ''&'4
0 "
" !
/ ",
"
!
" "
! "
/
.
#,,
!+ !
%'&'.
0
!#,,
" " 0. 0!
""9 "
!
/ !+ !: !
"" 9 "
! 6
+
+, !
""!
/ ! +
"
"
;
/ #,,
! "
4
0 ",,
0 " ; !
<"
,0 ,
./.
"/ "
"!
/
" / "
" ,
0 0
, #,,
0
",
0 ,
" ; 4 "
,
/ / " ; ! ,
/ ,
=4!
0 0
*2# #!
49
&&" ; ! "
",, 0 ,
, /
,
/ 4
0 >
!
" ; 0 ",
" , .=# / ! / 7 - 9
- #,,
"
/ "
!
/ "
/4
0""
" , 9 "
6
,
" "
"
"
"
!
"
/ !
0 , "
.
#,,
!+ >
!
"
, 4
0! " !2!'!'''5$! "
"
2?@
#
"!(33 ?
/
0
2@
" 0
" ; ! ,
= A!/ ",
..
""
0 !"
0 4
0 2 .
0 " "
0 /
"
# ! 4
0! , "" ! " $
",, "
/
&'(!&'!&%*!&%3 &*4# 2?@?@ #"!(33! "
0 " ,
& .
0 "
! , "" 4
0 ,
" ? <
$8@
2( # #'&'2,,..9!, !--+
!#
,!4 !
!
", ! !
.#+ $",$#>9!..!+ ""
/ " " "
? <
$%@
!
''8'2? <
$ *@! # 10 ! + !
" ;#
,!.#!+ !7
0! . 549!+ +, 00 ! #
0
!
# - !+ "
" 0
..9!, !.
: !
--+
!
, "
/
# !
"
/ # !
",,
'%'%//
0
0
" ,
0
/ #
.$.
# 10 " /
" 0 "" 4 /
;
,
0 /
,
/ / ,
"
0 "
0 8
!
?
#%& '(@
0
<
/ "
>
!
0 4
0'&'%'8 % 0 4
0! "" !,
"
2(
(2# # ,, 0/
""
"
? <
$(@ 0
/ / " " !
0 " ? <
$3@!
/!4
0 0 ,, 0/
,
/ # 10 !+
2'''%? <
$'@! " , *
? <
$'@ / 10 !+ !
"
" <, " 0
!
!
B'? <
$@>
!.
+
! .
" ?.", @!= A?@/ <,
" 0 !'3'8'(! / " "
0 ,
"
2(# #? <
..
$2@ ,, /
""
"
! / " " 0 ,
" '&'%'(? <
$&@
" '3'8'(? <
$2@!,
2(# #- "
/
#
,0
!
# , " '&'%'( " '3'8'(
2(# #? <
$2@ -
" 0 0 ,0
'&'*'( / # 10 !
+ !
/!
/
,, ""
" "
"" 3 "
0 /
?
#$%&'(@
, 0
, .
#,,
?.#@!+ ! ,''%'''!
!
, .
#,,
+ ,'' '*'8'
0 "
" , " 0 #, 0
#
>< "
9 "
6
!+ 4
0!
, "" !
0"" "
6
..!+ ! "
*'((3 ""
"
#, 0 ,&'''3
, "
/
0 /4
0
.%.
""
"" 0!
0 #6
/
,
" " 0 "
"
>
! "
"
/ "
! "
0
0
" "
0 ,
!
" ,
0 / ; !4
0!"" "
"
0 ",
" ; ,!
" / " /
0
" , ,
"
0
"
"/ 4
0
" ;
" " 0 , 0
0 0 , .
0 .
/ 09 "
! " 0
( "
0
0
.#!+ ! ,''%'''!
0 " ; ,
""
.#!+ "
/4
0
0 /
! ""
"
! " ;
/
0 0 ,
" ; 0
/4
0!
, "
9
0 0
" ; ! 4
0! "" ,
.3.
" ; " , , / 4 , /
"
5""
" , "
!" ;
"/
' "
0 4
0!
" "" " " "
0
!
!,
0 , 0
, <" ;
B
'! #,,
" " 0
0 0 "
0
4
,
;
;
*'&'? <
$@
! 0 0 0 "
",, /4
0!
"
=4
" >
0 "
0 ! = A/! /,
/ " ; ! "
,
0 0
""
""
",, /4
0!, "" 49
"
,
""
0
0 ! "
"
4
0",, !
" ;
0 / ..9 "
" ,0
/
#
0 0 " 4"!
!
!/
,,
",, "
2?@?@ #"!(33
..
0
4#
! ,0
/
0 0
" " ;
A " "
"
/
C/ <# ,
!"#$%&'$'
(&#)* + (,
-./ ( !!)$*& '$'
(&0))1
0 A "
0
" !
/ "
0 "
!
B'7
#
,,,
/.
- " # ,
!"#$*&'$'
(&"1
! #
$
!"!
! !# $%
!"!
!
!
&
" ' ()!%
* !
..
"
/,
"" ! " ,
"
2(# #! "
, /
# >
!
,, 0
!
# "
"
"
"! "
< 0",
"
"
2( # # ,
/ ,"
" ! " "
/ # 10 !+ >
!",
0 / " "
, ,
"
2(# #
" >
# ,,
/",
0
2(# # /
0 ,
" !
"
, 0
"
0
2 "
0 /
?
#*%'(@ , 0, "
/,
, ,/
4.
0 / , " "
>
! /
,, "" /
0 "
"
"
;
"
!0
,0
/
,
"
0 ,! /
,, ""
..
& 9
! "
/, , /
0
/
,,
<, 0 "
"
! , " ,
"
"
2(# #/
# 8 4
"
" % 4
" !, !/
/ "
0 " // , "
"
# ; !
"
" ! /
"
<, " "
(* # #
, "
(*2 ( # " ,! / "
<,
"
"
, "
00 /
!
/ "
(* # #/
"
/ $ "23
4 5
6 ( 4
+ ,- * .
/$
$
01 &
..
+, $ $
$ 2$ /3 + , $ $
$ /4 5"
+ , " + ,)
67 $ + ,
& / $& / !8 5(& ! 9
%
77)$ 77:$ 6;$ 6;)$ 6;:$ 6;
$ 6;<$ =>$ =6$ =7$ 5 =7)$ =7):$ =7 $
=7<$ =7<)$ =7<6> #" !+;6 ?7>,!8 +',@
01
) 92 $ & /!
+ , /$ $
+',
+9
./.
$ $
& / & / !
5+
), @
+ ,$
0 1 $
9
" + ,) 67 $& /!
+
:, @ $ /10 $ '> ) $
" +),)$ $ "$
" + ,) 67 $
/ 0 1!8 ?&@ / /$ $ $ $$
..
* $ .
$
A! * 4"!
0
;
, "
"0 D"
"
! ",, // "
!
(*# #! /
"
"
, C/
, #
7 6(( 87 ."2)) 6
' 03 " " /
" (*
"
, "
" /
$ B ?!@ =
" $ C !
:
& $
!
!-D E-
F
F!C - EC! !@ !#
$
$
!#$
$$ E C G EC3 $
.$.
GE
C3$E C3 $ EC! @ G $%
$
$ ! $ $ $ $
!#$ 3 $ $
$ $
3!
$ $
!$ $ $ %
$
4$
$ !A 3
! +
$ !!#&* '')0*1 C/
, # "
"
"
, /
$ B'6! 0
&
..
!# !:
% !# $
=+ , 0
% =+ ,
!
! $
H $ % !"
H $ $
! < %
H $
! $
H % =+ ,
" !- =+ ,!- % !# A!
.%.
(
! ,
(
6 .6 4 ( 1 ! % ''9( '2!!1
C/
, # 0 <, "
(*?@# # $ B;?! " .$ 6> 8( $ !!3&"
''"#
4 B6>! ;'>
;7=$;7?$;= '> :
!# $ !A ; ! I $
$ $ 0 !
6>! :
! 6> "0 : + , !# $ ;'>$;7?$;= '>:
+'>>=,
.3.
$
"
)! =
!$ 6>"0 : 0 & H
$ !#$"0 : + * ,
$ & $
0 H
! # $ J0 K . + , ; "0
: $ 6>& !
6 !@
! $ 6> "0 : $
! %
!
6'!#
$ 9#J
$ "- 7$)
$) ;) 6!) 9#J!#
"- 7 ?) !
)
..
!: .:(L )
) ;$$ 0 !#.
$
$
) $ $
$ =+ ,
!
! # $ ) 0 =+ , $ ) $ #"
A!
' ,!
" !
!
/
,,
# " -
"
0
! /
"
(
#
"! " "
,
,
( # " $ "2
4 6 4 + , @
0 1
5 =$ $ 68
=$ >$ $ 6 )@! 7 '> ?$ '7!=!'> ?!8
$& $
..
+,5 $ $
8 5
)@! 7'> ?$'7!=!'> ?!8 2
/$/3 + ,5 $ $
8 5
)@! 7'> ?$'7!=!'> ?!8
/$/3 +,$ !
5"% $ $ / $ $ / 01
$
+,
3 +, '> " $ =
4
..
" % $ /
4 " /
$ %
$ 4 " $ $
% $ $ $ & 4 " /$
$ ! (& ! 9
+ ,$ &
+,
3 + ,
!8 +',- %
+ ,
/ / $
..
/
!
+ ,@
" $ = +' =;,$ +,$
*
$ $ $
$ %
+ ,$ $
H 3 + ,
) $
$ $
H 3 +,
)
& % $ $ !
+;,#
+ , $$
$
$
H
!
(& !9 $ +,
3
./.
+ , %
%
% A! # ; !/
#
"0 D"
0 / "
"
",,
#"!
"
2(# #! / , , ( # "4
"
0, ! 6
1 ! *. 6
' % 221 C/
, # , $ B?!-
+ "
, "
" $ % !: "
H 10
"
!
#+ (,
1:$ !!)&" ''
3!2;1 &
"!
)
!"
!$ 4 01
=$ >$ $ 6
$& +,+,
!#
$
..
01
=$ >$ $ 6
!!! +;, $ "!
)1 "
$
4 !!!!!!! )
> "
!) * " )$ ??$ &
"
&% 0 1% ! +?, !# (
<
(1$ !!3&"* ''
30%1 4 ) + (, 4 :$ !!)&"
''3!2=$ !!#&" ''$'
&3 3; H G )$
! +;, >! + , "!
) 0
.$.
!#
$ !"#&0 ''3 1 =
"
H
1 4 $ = G +
" ),
% H 01 + " $
,!
G
! =
$!!!
01 & !!!! L0
+ , " ) !" !
+ ,@
01!!!& !!!!
01 ! !
$ H 01 ! $ 1 0
..
$ = +
, % ! !#
01
=$ $ M 6"!
!)$ "
$
% "!
)!$
"!
) /$
"
!#$
$!# !- A!
4
" ! "
",, /
!
" 0 0" "
"
>
! " "
" /, , / "
# ; !
, 0
(*# # ( #" /
# ,
0"0 D"
"
! <"
" ",
! # "
"
/, , / "
.%.
/ "
" !
# "
,, /
/
0
2(# # 2 ,!
" !
0
"" ! !
=4
!
/ 10 # >
, !
0 "" !
!
/ "
" >
!
!
"
,
B
,, 0
! # ,
/
!
"
, "
"
""
..9 , , "
"
! "" / 0 ..9 "
"
/
,
"
%# #!
" ; ; ,
"
, /
" 0 49! !
!. 4"! # 0
# "
/
" /
0 , 4"! ,, 0"" "
,
,
<
"
0
2(# #! # / "
"
" 4
" !
#
"
, "! "
<
#
.3.
"
"
, /
5
",, /4
0!
" ;
0 /
!
0 " ; ..9
0
"
"
0 "
! " ",,
0 " ; ;
!
!. !
"
,
%# # "! " /
",
"
/
49! ,0
/
/
0
0 "" / "
&
!
0 ,0
!
#
"
,
!
.#!+
"
/4
0!, "" !
0
0 #6
"
" "
0
0
" "
0,!
" ,
0 / ; !4
0!, "" "
"
"
0 ",
" ; , , , / " /
0 , 4 4
0 " ;
"
" "
0
"
" ! ..9 " 0
0
..
" ; .
0
!4
00 0 " ; ,
0 " ;
,, "
5
"
!
/ 0 0
, ..9! 4
0!
"" ,
5
" ; 0 " , !/" 0 / "
!/
" ,0 ! "/
?
# %&$'(@ 0 / "
!
" !
, "
..9! ! -- +
! .
: #
,
,,
2(# #.
0 "
!
, "" 4
0 "
" ,
!
0, '2!
, ..9!, !#
,!.
: -- +
/ "; " "
" /
; ,
" !
; " ..9 4
0! ",, "
/
, 8 ,!
"
?
#%&$'(@ <, / " B' 4
0
,, 0
!
# "
"
,
B'
B.
+
./.
4"! ,0
/ / $ / # 0 4"!
# ",, 0
,, 0 0! /
"
"
,
2 4 >
"
"
"
" "
"
/ C/ <# ,
7 +
4
<
> 7 8 ! *.? '#0"1
! C/
,
#
, 2 4 >
"
"!
" / /
"
, " / ,
< "/
"
/ $ B'
!)
!"!
!$$
$
!"!
!$ = !)$
!
$ $ $
!"!
!$ = !
';! # $
!"!
!$ =
"- G@ "&
./.
!> !'>''!
$
!> !'> 7!
$
"- G@ "!
'6! ' $
$
H & ! $
$ H !# !# ')$
#I
&
A!
%
!
,
"
!
"
0
0 ! '&'2! 4
0! "" ,
"
2(# #? <
$8@ ,, 0
"
/ " "
, /4
0!, "" !/
0
./.
? <
$%@ " >
!
, /4
0
#
# ,
0 0
A
!
" 0
/
# ! # /
0 " /
0 "
//
, /
#
? <
$*@
!0
!
"
/ 490 !4
0!,
" ? <
$3@
2( # #
(2# # ,, 0/
? <
$3@ / " "
? <
$(@ 0 "
2( # # ,
2'''% ? <
$'@! # 10 !+ ! ,
" 7 !
" ,
2(# #!
/
/ ,, "
!
2(# #4"! 0
"
"
2(# # ,
/ , "
" ! " ,
/
"" , / 10 ! +
! " ? <
$2@ ; ,
/ / " " !
0 / " " /
# ! ,,
! " ? <
$&@ ,
" ? <
$2@
.//.
!
# 0
" ,0
0 / * 4
" !
;
,
/
,, /
"
2( # #!
"
0 , *
/
<, / " >
! " <, ,
!
"
2(# # ,
/
# A
!4
0!/ , /
# "
" ,
3
! C/
, #
,
4 ( 4 @
'
( 8
.
@
1 !!!$ &'$'
(&3)= !!!. 6
' "" 3 $ B '!:
$
!
& H !#
!)H &
$0 $
%
$
!#
./.
!
!# 6(' 6 + ( 7<
@9 1"20%$"&'$'
(&3%="20%$"& ''" 0 $ %
$
01 !
* 4 :
&
&01 0! ;! 0 $
+;,$
&! $ &
& !# & % H &
0!2
./$.
A!
( 4
/
" ! # ,0
'&'*'( / # 10 !+ !/
/ ", 0
0
"
! " /
,
/ / ; / # 2'
"" 0 #$#$ 4#)#)*+5 , B
5
0
:
57 B
/
:
57