High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19850/2015dismissed

Sham Lal Gupta v. Commissioner Faridkot Division Faridkot & ORS

2018-01-30Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath3 pages

! !"#$#%&

! !"#$#%&'

()*+,- ! # #%!. /$ ))#$$#%!.0.#12 #3#$#%0.#12 %1 (!.$ !$-%1!% $

4&5*4664 4&5*4664 4&5*4664 4&5*4664

.!$!% &7 4.1# 8 $$,.013" !0

. (!-! # #%!. 4.# 00,%9:

6640;*< 6640;*< 6640;*< 6640;*< (#$ -! # #% #$ #+!1 "(++!%=! (! .1!.$ -$$!1 :8 (! ++!" .0 4%$ 1 !1

%1 :8 (! ))#$$#%!.0 .#12

#3#$#%0.#12 1 !1

>(!?.# -! # #%?$ #+!1#% (#$,. % %:.#!

0 (!-! # #%!.?$++ !1: (@-+ $# , !1 #%%94%1#0.1,+=.(:8 (!1)#%#$ . .0!?4%1#?%$(#-0#% % -!% ," #%0 . $,)

@7 % > A' (! -! # #%!. (1 ++!=!1+8-#1++ (!#%$ ++)!% $%1"%3!8%"!1!!1?$!B!", !1:8 (! ! ,%9: (.,=(1)#%#$ . .0!?4%1#?%$(#-%A

!. (!!B!", #% (!"%3!8%"!1!!10 (!-! # #%!.-.!$!% !1 (!$#1 "%3!8%"!1!!1:!

.! (!,:!=#$ ..0.1,+=.(@.!$-%1!% ' . (! -,.-$! # $ .!=#$ . #% % >C

(!.!

!.0 .!$-%1!% C 3#1!(#$+! !.A @61 !1>

$!% (!"%3!8%"!1!!1 1 !1>C

.!$-%1!% ?# ( (!.!"))!%1 #% 2!" #%

,%1!. !" #% CA7 (! %1#% )- " 0 D . $(. E (! " 5F =#%$ (!-! # #%!.%"",% 1!

#"#!%"8#% (!$ )-1, 8 :!-#1 :8(#)(!++!" . !.#$$,#%=% #"! (!-! # #%!.%1 2#%=#% "%$#1!. #% (!!3#1!%"!:.,=( :!

.!(#)-$$!1 (!#)-,=%!1.1!. %

(+1#%= (!-! # #%!.+#:+! -8 (!1!

#"#!% $ )-1, 8 (! ,%! CC0

@7%1.!=#$ . #%"(.=!$ (! ,%! C

@7+%= ?# (#% !.!$ GH-!.%%,)0 !.$$!$$#%= (!3+,! (!+%1G +" ==.#!3!1 =#%$ (! $#1 .1!.0 (! -! # #%!. #+!1 (! $ , .8 --!+ :!

.! (! ))#$$#%!.0 .#12 #3#$#%0 .#12 0 ?(#"( ?$ 1#$)#$$!1 %

> (! -! # #%!. 1#1 % "(++!%=! (!

.!$#1 ?.1!.$ .:, 8!.$$ (!-.!$!% -! # #%($:!!% #+!1 % *!.%!1 ",%$!+ . (! -! # #%!. ($ $,:)# !1 ( #% (! )!% #)! (!.! ?$ % )!%1)!% #% (! ,%9: )- ; !+#%= %1!.73+,!1 %$ .,)!% $< ,+!$0 ' D . $(. E (! ,+!$5F :8 ?8 ,%9: )-;

!+#%= %1!.73+,!1%$ .,)!% $<,+!$0

% # #!1 %

3#1!?(#"(B-+% #%($:!!%11!1#%,+!'7 #$ $,:)# !1 ( $-!. (!$#1B-+% #%3+,! (!-.-!. 8?,+1:! 1!!)!1 :! (!"++!" .5$. !?(#"(?$ #B!1 (! #)! ++ )!% (!#))3!:+!-.-!. 8!($+$.!

!..!1 (!1!"#$#% (#$,. .!%1!.!1#%C # +!1$I6)+!$(%#%1% (!./$ ))#$$#%!.0 .#12 #3#$#%0 .#12 %1 (!.$J 1!"#1!1 % A

% (! (!. (%10 +!.%!1 ",%$!+ . (! .!$-%1!% $@ ! ($$,:)# !1 ( (!?.# -! # #%#$(#=(+8:!+ !1$# ($:!!% #+!1 !. =- 8!.$%1#$ (,$+#:+! :!1#$)#$$!1%+8% (!=.,%1 1!+8%1+ "(!$ (3! (!.1 +!.%!1 ",%$!+ . (! -. #!$ %1 -!.,$!1 (! .!".1 (!.!#$%1#$-, ! ( (!#)-,=%!1.1!.$?!.!-$$!1:8 (! ++!" .%

%1))#$$#%!.%

>(!)!%1)!% 0 ?(#"(($:!!%.!+#!1,-%:8 (!-! # #%!.?$% !3!%#% (!

#%=$# ")!%

#!),"( !.-!.#1 (.!!8!.$ .) (!1 ! -$$#%= (! #)-,=%!1 .1!. :8 (! ))#$$#%!. %

> (! -! # #%!."%% 2!13% =! $,:$!K,!% % # #" #% !.?# #%= . $)%88!.$ "(++!%=! (!#)-,=%!1.1!.$ #$?!++$! +!1 ( !3!% "#3#+$,# .1!"+. #% !.-!.#1 (.!!8!.$#$% )#% #%:+! ?(!.!$#% (!-.!$!% "$! (!-! # #%($:!!% #+!1 !.-!.#1 8!.$ .) (! 1 ! -$$#%= (! #)-,=%!1 .1!. (!.!

.!0 #% )8 "%$#1!.!1 -#%#%0 (!.! #$ (,=! 1!+8 #% #+#%= (! ?.# -! # #% "(++!%=! (!#)-,=%!1.1!.$ # ( (!$! :$!.3 #%$0 (! -.!$!% -! # #% #$ (!.!:8 1#$)#$$!1%1!+8%1+ "(!$ ;664< ;664< ;664< ;664< '

(! (!.$-!2#%=@.!$%!1 &

!$@ (! (!.!-. :+! &

!$@