High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16998/2022dismissed

Balwan Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-01-25Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

"#$

"#"&#'

"#$ (

)

*$ +, *

- -- .

+, *-

- -

-* !"# $%&'$'()*+',& $' &'-')*+' $ '.'(&'-')*+'' $ &/&')*+' 0& $1$'()( ) '"'',& $''!&$' ) ) '"'' $1$'()*+',& $2&'( 2')*+' $&*'- ' )*+' $&'&')*+' 0 3 -- .

5 & &&', )& '"0 &-'1 0'-''- +3 5)&6,& &'

'783559)-'1'0 ('0&'+:(')&-0+(';0& (+"

'5<=>?=5@7835=9),&)&'0 '"'') &'-''+('&'+:('),&+&+'! (6!"& ? 0 + -'1'"'.+') )& ,+('-)-+'"0& )

'( %3?A?;53?=5B),&!"&"+('-(00' ('

+(''! -'-0& *)-! +?<7?90& &'%- ''' '+" ' +:) &'!(' ' (- +) ?=5C 7&'00&0'&D+0?=5CD9)!&)' +('-,''('0& ! '' ',&& (')',-'*'5@5??==?)'?B=B?=5? ''??=@?=5?&&',+'- 0&' 5;55?=?=) & % + -'1 & & &'0 8'+

" # $

! # $%& &' !$

( $ )! * ! + ,-

! # -' $#+ %% ./$ --

# $ ! $'

!$ #- 0 ! !

! ! # !$ %1

! 2# $ 1 3 $% /+ ! $ $

- ! 4

C ' 0&'!*8'+)*'(&'& +( 0 & '!' & +('- 0 ' (' +(''! -'-0+?<7?90&D+0?=5CD <

,*)0' -! '(' &(' 0&'+:(')&-0('-'0'*0 -('("' )&-','(5@=5?=?5 A &0),&(0'+'0'+&' , '-('&-!&, 7 '9),&+&,'&!.+!0&%)&!"&' , ,''&' 0!+- !0& %)'&+('("&!"&+0) B & &&+(0& &')'- +'

)0-& 0&'!*+):'&'!*+ !+- ''+&' )!",&&)& '(, )&'

'&,&%$BA@0?=?5) '-'?>=A?=5>),&,&&"+('- '"*3'3* &('(++),&(',('0-'+:

,*),&&*"'-() )!"&

) & 0 & +('- '" &,&) '& & !:, ),&+&& ('(") +,&'*+'!('&''8)&) '!(& )&++'&%)' ' '

(" &!:, ,&+&&')'& &+0)&,) -'0'+)&' , )&,'-3+ ; &''-'")0'7 '9),&&+(0 & '!' & '"(' &!+- ()

)

&-'1 0'('

+(''-0+?<7?90& D+0?=5CD)&!"&%:!&(* -'1 ''.+' +&0 @ +*0&0'+&'&', &!"

&+0))"&+('-0'-''-! -' & ++)-'1'+ &'

')!&+('-'&)0& ! ' ' ' ,& & (" -('(" ' (' ( ++)'-("$& &)'&'('+('-),&+& ':!.+ > & ' 0 ', & '!* 0+) !+- '(*'60-&0'+-)&'&('','-'0'*0 &'$& &),'& &'-'?>=A?=5> &'!+'-!'1 &0'+-&'&'$& &),''+ 0'-'=C=@?=5A)!"&%) %35ABBB3?=5A) ,&) & ' $& & +('- & -'1 :'&-0'('

+(''-0+?<7?90 &D+0?=5CD 5= '('

'&'& &'-'?>=A?=5>) &'

'0&'$& &,'+' +0('+- 2&''CBEE?A)(0' ?555?=5;,',&&+)&'(0&(':' ,&+&&'+: + )&'('

&&' ,' *('-' >5<=>:-00+ & 0++0''0&>@:-0(',('(! *00+ 55 &0) ,& ' & (*' ' ) &

(

++),'('('

+(''-0+?< 7?90&D+0?=5CD)'&*,0&-''+!"&

D!( 8%&#

*&#0'0123

225'62#!

*0 00723 -"32#50/

1"8 !

) 9:

;(($*),&&' ('

+('',''(-'0'*0&'$& &%:(")&!"!,&&'0(' ,''+'('&'

+!+'-+- ( ,&&0)&'+'!+!'(-' '

(+'!(& '( 5? %'(" '( ,& ,& & & '!' &+('-(' &-'1 0'(' +('' -0+?<7?90&D+0?=5CD!'''(+(('" &) *&0'+7 '9)(' &('-'0'* 0$& &)&! +- (("+'+& 0'+ ' &') ' ' 0- & ) (1 &

+'7 '9)'&'!' &+('-0&-'1 0'('

+(''*3'3*&'+:(' 5C :(),&&'!*'

'3+*"

3&('79-':'$& &'&('79 +('-!"& )'&- &0)&!" !+( &+('-0('79)&-&0)'-'!" & !*("& '(+('-

'",&&'$& & 5< $*) & '( 0( %3?A?;53?=5B) !" &

&,' -!,&',)*' 5C5??=??)') '!"&%&0)'(,&&'( , +' -(' (0E '" ' & '- !

,&',)&'(-'1&', '

'0-! &!"& + (0)$'(!+-+*!"& *+0-'()'!+'--'&'(, 5A * &, & % +' -'1 & '!* -''- & ++)')+' +'((" ( & (")'00'*)0&&, !"& )&'&'+:(''' '( '0&('"

('),&!"&%!+-+')&1,& &'',('" ('),&+& !''(("0'+('*)0 0& & !(+ $*),&'. -+ !"&%+'('

!"## $%& '

( % )

* + ,-

)&%&'( &'(,& -(' ' ' & ' , & (*'

'' '

&0&*+7 '9'8'+&'0 56 ! - ! $ ! $

! ) $ - )

78 ./0 ) $ #1

) %& 2 2& ) 3# # 4 5&6#

17& 1 % "!

) #&

+8&1&3# !15

5) % "! + &6# #

2& ) 9 : ./0 )%& 2 2& ) & $! 8&#)& + )!#)

8 & & + & $ 8)# & &# &6# &

$+ #

2& ) 9 :

./0

8 & & ! $ &6#

1&3# !15

3 5+ $#

1 # 4 ++

# 1 + ! ) # & ) 8 :

;

6 % # %&$ !

# $ ! -!

- ! 0 -

-$ -

# %&$ $

# 1.

1 $ !

! 8

# 1.

$ - %8# # %&$ 9 # :

%1$ !

;

< -!

# 1.

$ ! $ - !5-4

5 8 49

-$ $

=! -

%8# # $ #!! # $- . %8# < -! ; ! -

/ # 1.6 - ! $ !5-45 4

&% ! # %& / # 1.6!

%8#-$

/ # 1.6$

= %8# $

$ - %8#$ - 0 $ $ 8

! - $ ! 8 < -!

!) -

$ 0 & !

$ - %8#

< -! 8 $ ! > $ ! 8 5- 4 5 8 4 ))&&##1& #.# /

&1# -

? ! $ $ %8# # %&$ > $ ! ) !

< -! 8 $ - # 1.

- !5-45 8 4 $

-$ = 5

< -! 0 8 $=

%8# # %&$

-$ - ! -

0!! # !! !

+ - $ !!

$ - ! !!

=! 8

6@ $ - < -! ; $ ! !$ $

- $

. $- - ! $ $ ! -$ = !78 5;<2=%%<>*(.=/ $ %8# # %&$ 5 >4 $ ! ) -! 8 $ # 1.

$ $ - ! 5-45 8 4

;<2=%%<>*(.==/ :

- %8# -

$ # 1.

;<2=%%<>*(.===/ -

- - - ! 5-4 5 8 4$ $ - >$ $

$- ! 4 5B &0) & (' +( 0 & &' '!(" ('1&'!*' -)& -+5=53 0&D+0?=5CD +(';0& (+"'5<=>?=5@ 7835=9 5; % +("'(,&&'!'!"&(' '(*+' '() '"''&',&','(0& (+"

7 '9'+*+'0& '&'*"

&("& (+"7 '9(1("!3+'(( 5@ &-) * 0,& *&'+: (')& ++)&&'

'+790 0+'790'+:)&!",&&'!+-'!( ,0&'+:(' ('("&*-0+- ( '!(,& *&'+:('& 3') &-'1,((- ,),&&'-!0&*+ !" D!( 8%&+'03% )?@( A( B 5+2=C -%- +

2'=&0 !

32#!

86"&>6 1&?30'

2&'80"#&)&*0! (6)&8+ 0&'!* ,!"''!(,) '&'!()'&!"&'+-'!+-0+&!" &'0 '"'')&,('((&!3* - & !(+ 79&0)8+ '*"'8+ '(

++-'+)'-+&') +++0 -!) 8!' - 0 +- ' - ! -) & -'1 &(:')+''!&' 8+&:)&)&!"&'" ''-03'(" *'!("00&'+:(')-'"!+-' !"

&'0 '"'' ,*)&'!*8+ ''*'('!( &+0&+' 5> $*)&'*-'& '++ *+-'79)*3'3*& 79&)& & '(-'1'(( +0+'+0+-'79*3'3* &('(++)'-+&')&'-! & & 83B3> ?=

,*)+&%0'7 '9&'-''

0-++(&'&'+:(''' '(+- 0& ('" (' &) & ' ++( '( & ('3( +++('- '",&& ("-('("' '&(++:',&-('79,-')!&

-&'&('(',' '(+- 0& ('" (' ?5 &)&' -7 '9-3()').+ 0#23 !

"&8

?? '0-'&)&%0-&, ) '),&&'!*!*')&'-- ?C '+ ?< +&-'+'(0&'!+)&)'((&

(+'79)0'")'('79 0

9-- .:

-*:

(

) 1'* &&& '1 E' #

E && '!( #