Lal Singh v. State Of Haryana







 





 
 



 !"#"$

%

%  


     

  
















& '

$()*
&%
+# "!

%,%,- .- /

 


 
!

 
   


  "
"
# 
  $$$ %,%,- .- /

%
0& *1  % 
   

 
  
  
"


! 
&'

 ((
) 



 
 "
* 

+

!
,-
.
 '///
 
"


!  
&/

-(
 
!  
01212'

+ !

 !
 
(  
 
#  !
3  
 % 
,-

 
!
)
 
 
* 

 + 
+
*
 4
 

* 

4"

5 !
!6 

 
!+ 

*"
0&/
+

'///

  
 7"
+
 "


 
 
 
 "


)
 
 


"

!
5 "6
)



"



 
)
7"

) 


 

8 

)
 
 



 

 
 

 
4"

+

"




 





)

"


 
 
 

"

)
+
 


)


)
+
  
 
 
4"

 

 

"

 
 
*





8 


+
   
 
,-

 
!
)
 
 





 
    &  
!"



 
   
!  
 
 
   
 *



 
!
*


 9 9)

 
! 
" 
!  
 
 
   
)


 
!


///
 


!"

 

+

&

 
'
+ 

 
 
!"


 
+ 

 4
:

!+ 

*

!

89
)


"
 
!

 
!"   %)
+
+ 
)  

"* 
 


4"

5 ! !6


*
;+ 
*
 
 
("
 
 
 
)  




"
 
!

 
!"  
% "
 
!

!
  ! 

 
   

*<

 
!"


" 
!  
 !

 
+ 
)  


*
;+ 
 
" 

 
 
   

 
! ! 

* 
*
 
("
 = 
 

 

!"



 + 
 

+
*
 
!"



 
   
 "


 
    

 
+
!!"
) 
 
 

4"

5 ! !6

2 -


 
!"



 
 
 
"
 
! > -

* 
*
 
 ?*
"+
("

+
 2 $3 $
/"4 5"
6#%
7
-&+8-
-
"& &
 $ & *7
 091
,
:;

 
01

0&"'"$ *1
99 <

) @
-
3





"

4*
5"6
   (  " 
A
!  
 





 
 
  
 


  
 
! !"+ !

!

! *!"
 


) 

% 
("

BC
% 






 


  
+
   



(
% 
 ! 


*




!

 
D 


#! 





00> 
+
 

 
 ;
+ + 

 (  " 

E 


+ !
)

B-


! + 
!"  
 
!!"
 
 4
 



 

 
"* !
 B
-
+
*
 
"

!  
 
 


,
!

'0
! ?
% 
!?
* 




 +9 + 
 !

"
 
+4
 
 
+   !+ 

+ 

 
!" 

! + 
!
F A!<?
)
# !  
>
G 
 
//H
C2
% 






 


 

+  "

 
"

"
 
 
!!  
 + + 
 ; 
 
! !
!!+ 


!!" 



 + 
 
 *  

+ 


*  



!!"

 +
*"

 


! 


 



 
% 




*
!"


! 

 
 
!"

 
)

 
 !   


"
)
 

"

+ 



-

!


!

!+

*
 
!"

7"


!


 "



 
 
"

"
 


 ! 

 



 

)  +
 !+ 

!

 
C>
% 
! !


 



 !




  


 
"

+ 




 
 
 *

" 
 

"


"
(  "  
% 




 
*


)  
!"
 
+
* 
 
! 7" 
!! 
 
! "

  
+
 
 

   7" 
  
 
  

 
 
 *
4" !
 
+ "
+
++  *
 
 *

+
 
 + 
 
!++  

 
 !
 

! "++

   
!
*

- 
! ;

+
*

 
!  "  
" 


 

 !

! 
&/'

 
(

( + 
!"




C0
% 
("

" 
3 

+
! -
'0'
"+
("
&>/


A 
) 


) 
 !


 
(  " 

-  

* "
5((

C'

26
B.
!"
)


 "

 *
7" !<  
!
*
 

? *
 

4"?
 

)" 
"

 !

% 
! 
*

"*
 
 
 
*

 
)
+
 * ;  "
 

  
 
  


 "

+ 




 
 
 *
  

 !
 % 
7" 
)
)"
)
 



) )"
*
 
! 7" !



!!"


 ! 
 

 
 

"



*
 

 *
*
+  + 


"





 

  


"

+ 



"


 !

8"


*
  

*

"

   

+
  

 
+
 "


 


+ 

"

"


 

 +
 
!  !

+
 "!

 
)"
!  "
  


"

+ 


"


 !
B 

56
"


A

#
+  
5-6
56 " 
3 
5-6

+
!


A  5&6
" 
3 
5-D6

+
!

 
 
56
" 
3 
5D-6

+ !


A 


A 
 
526
3   



A 
5--6
5>6
%D
D )
 

%.
 
506
*"
 + "


.< CC
% "
 
("
*

 

4" ! 
 "

!+ 
 +  
 
9+  
 

 

 

 !

 
"

+ 




 
 
 *
  

 !

 
 
)
+"
 "
? *
4"
   ?
!"
) 

! 
!

 

 !  

 
("
<
 B
% 
("
" 
*




B'
=
!"




 +







 !" 
"


 
 ! 

 
!!"

!
"


 )
 
!"
4" !
*


 

! =
 
 

 
!"




*

!

*
<



 
 *
4" !
     

*
"
*
 
!!"
*
 * 
 

+ 
)  
 
!!"


! +  !


*
 








  
) 
"

 *

)
!"
*
   
* 
!
9
56




56
 
4"  ! 

 
5&6
 
!!"?
 







  
56
4" !
!"

 
!!"
*
"!

 )
 
!



  

 ! !"+ !

!

!
*!"
 


)  
"!



  

!!"



 ) 
+  ! 

! +
 




)<   
  

   
 
 *
* !
 )  

)  
!)
!<
 
 

 !"
!B
0  I*
 
"+
("

+5".

$ "
 & #"'-+*+
$5

- &#
4%
+)*"!
&# !+ &7

:=9
,
:



"

 9

 







   

                 



              !



        "  #



      

    

     

 

   $   

   

       

        

          

                 

 %     & '(

 

    



 



 &      






>

       )(  *  $#  # 

    

 

  +   

 

%    

   





  +  

    

   

   

 

               C -
+&) .#-
,"$8-
,"))"

!
6#
-
,


+$3 )7


:9
,
>
 I*
 
"+
("

*

"

 9

  

  

 #  

 + 

  % 

 

    

    



        

 + !, -  

. %  %

/ )*0 #$(!, -%

-12#



  

 







 #



   

 

& 



     



 



    +  

    

    



   3 %   

 

  . % 


     

#

 3  -,4

5%

   3 -6,

/ %# 

3  

. %    

 

  

      

    3  -,1

  

 3 -61  . % 



      "

"

   3 -,4





     



  "


=

 3 %  



  .  %          !"#$%%          &# 

     



       

 

%7% 

  



 

" #

    #

         +

      

 

  

 

  +

   

 

    . %  

     +

    

 

. % # 



 



   

 

%

 

 

. % #

  



             +

  

 



     

  3 %  

    8 69:  ; <$ 





& 



          #

  

 

    

      

   

    <

' 
 
 


*
 
 
*4!

 
* 


!" 
 !

 
!!"

 
 
 
-


*
 
 
*4!
 * 

  
"

 

  
 
  

 *
+"
*  

"

+ 
"




7" 

 "
 

!!"


) 
 
 
)
!
" 
 I*
 
"+
("

*

! 

4" + 
 
)



"


*
 

* 

!

 
+
"
) 

*
!  !

)"
*


9



 
! !

 
 *
  

(  " 
;!

!
) 
 



* 
 

+
" !
 
)  
- 
 


 
9!  ! 
  
 "

*

 ;!

!

! 

!"
  !

 
 

"
+  
 
!!"
) 
+
)  
)  



 *
/ ,+
 
   


 
,-


 
  "
   

*

 
 
   

 
!

)
 
   
!


*
<
*


*

  
 

%    
)


 
!

///
 

)
 
"
 
!" 

!+
 
!" 
  !
;  "




! "!


 
 


 
!" 
 
 




  )

" 


!  J
"


 !


 
(  " 
 -  

G 
 

!"



 



!
 
 
  !



*

*
 
 
   

 
+


 

 
!

 
!" 

 
!

 
!" 

)
 + 
*
 
 + 

* 

 "* 

4"

 
 !
!

)


 
+
 
!
 

 
  + 
)  


"
 
!

 
!"  


+ 
 
   


!"

 

+
 



+ 



 

!"


 
 ;
)  
"


'

)  

*
;+ 


 
 


  !

 !
 
   


 
 
*
 
 
("

 
+



 8  "
!++

 
" 
 
+ 

 
!
  
  

)
 
 
   



*


*  "*4!


"

* 
* 1"
* 

 
 ! 

 
 


:

("1#"
1( 
K" ! 

! ! 
0%,%, ?

@1

%

% 













+  
<

1  L1.
 
*

L1.