Suman v. Karamjit


 

      

   

 



     

 

                 !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,



  

   

 







  

 

  

     

00#..3+$  '*3+  4"-  ,'55#%#(  3+  #6
03%$#  (#7%##  5-% (1,,-.'$1-+ -5*3%%13)#1+ $"#0#$1$1-+ '+(#% #7$1-+  -5$"# 1+(' 3%%13)#7$8

51.#(/9"#%"',/3+( 3%3*&1$"3,0%#5#%%#($"#0%#,#+$ 300#3.



"#%#,0-+(#+$"#%#1+51.#(30#$1$1-+1+:-;1+)$"#0%-:1,1-+, '+(#%#7$1-+-5$"#1+('3%%13)#7$0%391+)5-%(1,,-.'$1-+-5 *3%%13)#41$"$"#%#,0-+(#+$-+$"#)%-'+(,-57%'#.$93,4#..3,(#,#%$1-+

#"3,7-+$#+(#(1+$"#0#$1$1-+$"3$$"#*3%%13)#-5$"#%#,0-+(#+$"#%#1+ 41$"$"#300#..3+$43,,-.#*+1<#(-+=  88  5$#%,$391+)41$"$"# %#,0-+(#+$5-% (39,$"#300#..3+$,$3%$#($3'+$1+)$"#%#,0-+(#+$ "# 3.,-3/',#($"#%#,0-+(#+$ "#300#..3+$43,>'3%%#.,-*#5%-*$"#:#%9


/#)1++1+) "#',#($-017;'0>'3%%#.-+0#$$9*3$$#%, "#0%#,,'%1<#( $"#  %#,0-+(#+$  $-  -%)3+1<#  3  ,#03%3$#  #,$3/.1,"*#+$   #%  $%#3$*#+$ 7'.*1+3$#(1+*#+$3.3+(0"9,173.7%'#.$9$-$"#%#,0-+(#+$ "#300#..3+$ ,$39#(41$"$"#%#,0-+(#+$5-%&',$ (39,3+($"#%#35$#%,"#.#5$5-%"#% 03%#+$3."-',# "#3/',#($"#%#,0-+(#+$$"3$"#43,+-$3,'1$3/.#*3$7" 5-%"#% "#43,/%-')"$3)31+$-$"#*3$%1*-+13."-',#3,0#%3+7"393$ (#71,1-+/'$"#%/#"3:1-'%%#*31+#($"#,3*# "#73..#("#%*-$"#%
1+
.34  ?'("193?

 "#  $"#%#35$#%  .#5$  $"#  *3$%1*-+13.  "-',#  41$"-'$  3+9 1+5-%*3$1-+  "#  ,$3%$#(  1+,'.$1+)  $"#  %#,0-+(#+$  "#%#1+  #:#+  1+  $"# 0%#,#+7#-5"1,5%1#+(,$-$"##55#7$$"3$"#43,+-$3,'1$3/.#*3$7"5-%"#%

+,01$#-5$"##55-%$,$3;#+/9$"#*-$"#%-5$"#%#,0-+(#+$$"#300#..3+$ %#5',#($-7-*#3+(.1:#1+$"#*3$%1*-+13."-*#



"#300#..3+$"#%#1+%#*31+#(#6
03%$#/#5-%#$"#$%13. -'%$ 35$#%,"#51.#(4%1$$#+,$3$#*#+$  =

+$"#,1(#-5$"#%#,0-+(#+$$"#%#,0-+(#+$43,#63*1+#(3, !"1,/%-$"#%*3%&1$3,!3+("1,*-$"#%'++1#:13,!

"#$%13. -'%$"3:1+)3(:#%$#($-$"#'+%#/'$$#(#:1(#+7# 3(('7#(/9$"#%#,0-+(#+$7"-,#$-)%3+$3(#7%##-5(1:-%7#-+$"#)%-'+( -57%'#.$93,4#..3,(#,#%$1-+

@

#3%+#(  7-'+,#.  300#3%1+)  5-%  $"#  300#..3+$  :#"#*#+$.9 ,'/*1$$#(%#5#%%1+)$-#7$1-+-5$"#1+('3%%13)#7$8

$"3$#:#+ 15$"#300#..3+$%#*31+#(#6
03%$#$"#$%13. -'%$1,/-'+($-)%3+$$"#%#.1#5 -+.9 35$#% 1$  1,  ,3$1,51#( $"3$  $"# )%-'+(,  3..#)#( 1+  $"# 0#$1$1-+  4#%# #,$3/.1,"#(



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

!#51+($"3$$"#3/-:##:1(#+7#4#+$7-*0.#$#.9'+7"3..#+)#( /9$"#300#..3+$"#%#1+4"-%#*31+#(#6
03%$# +-'%7-+,1(#%#(:1#4$"# $%13. -'%$"3,%1)"$.9#:3.'3$#($"##:1(#+7#$-,3$1,591$,#.53,$-4"#$"#% $"#)%-'+(,-57%'#.$93+((#,#%$1-+"#%#1+4#%##,$3/.1,"#(

$43,5'%$"#%,'/*1$$#(/9.#3%+#(7-'+,#.300#3%1+)5-%$"# 300#..3+$$"3$+-1,,'#3,%#)3%(,(#,#%$1-+43,5-%*'.3$#(/9$"#$%13.

-'%$  /'$  3  51+(1+)  43,  )1:#+  $"3$  $"#  300#..3+$  3.,-  (#,#%$#(  $"# %#,0-+(#+$"#%#1+



+  -'% 7-+,1(#%#(  :1#4 $"# (1:-%7# 0%-7##(1+), '+(#%  $"# 1+('3%%13)#7$8

3%#+-$$%13.0%-7##(1+),1+3,'1$4"#%#3,0#% $"# -(#-5 1:1.%-7#('%#$"#$%13. -'%$1,/-'+($-5%3*#1,,'#, :#+ -$"#%41,#4#51+($"3$$"#1,,'#"3(/##+1+3(:#%$#+$.95-%*'.3$#((#,01$# $"#537$$"3$$"#%#,0-+(#+$"#%#1+"3,,#$'0,0#715173..9$"#)%-'+(,-5 7%'#.$93+((#,#%$1-+1+"1,0#$1$1-+3+($"#300#..3+$-+"#%03%$"3(*#$

=
$"-,#0.#3,,#$'0/9$"#%#,0-+(#+$1+"#%4%1$$#+,$3$#*#+$  !"#+$"# #:1(#+7#-+%#7-%(4-'.()-$-#,$3/.1,"$"3$$"#)%-'+(-5(#,#%$1-+3.,- 43,  #,$3/.1,"#(  $"#  300#..3+$  "#%#1+  73++-$  $3;#  3(:3+$3)#  -5  $"# 1+3(:#%$#+$*1,$3;#7-**1$$#(/9$"#$%13. -'%$ :#+-$"#%41,#1+-'% :1#4$"#*31+)%-'+(-57%'#.$943,4#..#,$3/.1,"#( ,1$1,5-'+($"3$ $"#300#..3+$(#,#%$#($"#%#,0-+(#+$"#%#1+41$"-'$3+9%"9*#-%%#3,-+ 3..$"##55-%$,$3;#+/9$"#*-$"#%-5$"#%#,0-+(#+$$-%#'+1$#$"#*$-,3:# $"#1%*3%%13)#"3(/#7-*#5'$1.# 

$43,5'%$"#%,'/*1$$#(/9.#3%+#(7-'+,#.300#3%1+)5-%$"# 300#..3+$%#5#%%1+)$-$"#(#71,1-+-5$"#1+).##+7"-53(%3,1)"

-'%$ 1+  

  

   $"3$$"##6
03%$#&'()#*#+$03,,#(/9$"#$%13. -'%$1,1..#)3.1+3,*'7"3, $"#0#$1$1-+'+(#%#7$1-+=-5$"#1+('3%%13)#7$8

43,0#+(1+) (1,0-,3.3$$"3$0-1+$-5$1*# 

+$"#73,#%#5#%%#($-3/-:#1$1,5-'+($"3$$"#415#4"-43, 1+0#+'%90%39#(5-%(1,0-,3.-5$"#0#$1$1-+'+(#%#7$1-+=-51+(' 3%%13)#7$51%,$1+0-1+$-5$1*# '$$"#$%13. -'%$1+$"3$73,#43, :#%93(3*3+$1+(1,0-,1+)-5$"#*31+73,#4"17"43,.1,$#((#,01$#$"# 0#+(#+79-5$"#0#$1$1-+'+(#%#7$1-+=-5$"#1+('3%%13)#7$ , $"#415#7-'.(+-$0'%,'#"#%0#$1$1-+'+(#%#7$1-+=-5$"#1+(' 3%%13)#7$#55#7$1:#.91$300#3%,$"3$,"#%#*31+#(#6
03%$#  3;1+) 3(:3+$3)#-5,'7"3,1$'3$1-+$"#$%13. -'%$43,1+"3,$#1+(1,0-,1+)-5$"# 73,#1+3/,#+$13-5$"#415# '$1+$"#1+,$3+$73,#4#51+($"#%#43,+- 0.#35%-*$"#300#..3+$$"3$$"#300.173$1-+'+(#%#7$1-+=,"-'.(/#

(1,0-,#(-5 :#+-$"#%41,#4"#+,"#%#*31+#(#6
03%$#$"#300.173$1-+ '+(#%#7$1-+=-5$"#1+('3%%13)#7$41.."3:#$-/#(1,*1,,#(1+ (#53'.$ "#,31(300.173$1-+73++-$/#7-+,1(#%#(-+1$,537#:3.'#41$"-'$ 3(('71+)3+9*3$#%13.$-,'/,$3+$13$#$"#7-+$#+$1-+$"#%#1+ +$"#3/,#+7# -5$"#300#..3+$4"-"3(+-$73%#($-0%-,#7'$#$"#300.173$1-+'+(#% #7$1-+=-5$"#1+('3%%13)#7$-%$-(#5#+($"#0#$1$1-+'+(#% #7$1-+-5$"#1+('3%%13)#7$0%#5#%%#(/9$"#%#,0-+(#+$1+-'% 7-+,1(#%#(:1#4$"#$%13. -'%$"3,%1)"$.9(#7%##($"#,'1$#6
03%$# +$"# 3/-:#537$,3+(71%7'*,$3+7#,$"#(#71,1-+%#5#%%#(/9$"#300#..3+$(-#, +-$300.9$-$"#537$,-5$"1,73,#



!#51+($"3$$"#$%13. -'%$"3,%1)"$.9#:3.'3$#($"##:1(#+7# 3+(  7-*#  $-  3  7-%%#7$  7-+7.',1-+  $"3$  $"#  300#..3+$  "#%#1+  +-$  -+.9 7-**1$$#(7%'#.$9/'$3.,-(#,#%$#($"#%#,0-+(#+$"#%#1+ !#(-+-$51+( 3+9*#%1$1+$"#300#3.

"#%#5-%#$"#300#3.,$3+(,(1,*1,,#(

    !

"

 39

    !

'.3$1 "