Jasbir Singh And ANR. v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corp. Ltd. And ORS.




  
 
 



!"# 


 




    



  


















    $"  %&$  '
''&

 

 


 
! "
# 

$
 
! "
# 
  
$ %

 &
' 
(!)
  ''(! )(*(+( ,- .(+/ * 
&
+  
,-,.-,%/
0! 1
23
 
 



 


 
 "

 '
4
 

'

#  " 4



4 * 

 4
#
 
  5   
'



 

("5 5 


 
"


#
("
 

 
 
  

#


,/,6-,%/

* 
 4"
#" 
'

  "&

 & 
 
'
 
 
"


 
'  

7


""

 
 
 

'


,-,.-,%/
'



# 
-
 
-

##" '
 
'

##"
4
  
("


  5   

*




'

'
#
 
 


 "#"
 



"


    # 
 
 
 

'

  
'

 # "

 
 
 "  
 
 

 
# 
 "
 ' "  

8-

 

"


# "
' 

 


 #
'


 "&
 
 
#
/- 622  
# 
4
-,%25%/
 
-,%/5%9

7
'
# 
#
  
'
""

:7
$ %-
 

'

"

"" "
 
'




'   

  
$ -

25 
  "
;
  
 
  
4
& 
# "
 
'
 #"

'


 

2

 ' 
#
 & 
 
 
  
'
"

"
4
  7


 
4
"

 
# 
   
%




2%,2-,%<
 

 
 "

#
 4
 




'


1   #
 
4 

 #
2

 
  



#

& 
 
"

  
'



 4
"



  

7

# 
 
 


 
" 
 "   


"

"
 
 # 
  
4
"

 
   
'


 4 
 

# "


 
 " 



 %<,9%.86
0! 1
/3
"


' 
"  
 
 

)   

'
 
 "4  
  #
)   
 4
 
 "4
 
'



 4
 

* 




' 
 
"
 #
2


 
 # 
 
'
 
#   

 
  
 " 


 

= 4

 
)   
""

$  %-8,5-586>%96,.

%< 4
%.86
# ( 
#
 
 
! 
#  


?
#
( 
"
" " 5
  #
)   
@ 45 '

) 
 "4 * 
)   

" 4
'
 
 "4   #
)   
 4
  "


 
 " 
 "
 '

*   " 


 

 " " -
@4
  
# 
  #

)     4




"#4
"


 
 


4
#
"" "
#4
#4


 





 
 
 

#
"

  

 


#


 
#"
"
# 


 

 4 " 




"

  "

"
 &4

"
 
 

  
 "

A 4





##" 
  #
 
 4
"

" 

 

#


  4

 #
'
' 

 
 " 2
@1"

"
#

  "4

 4






 
 

 
"



 
 
 

1   
 
#  


  #" 4

B 

 4

 "# 
"  
  
"






 4
" 


' 

 


7
" 
"





' 
 




 


  /
* 
 
 "
#
 
"






 +4
 
& #
"
'
 
 
#  "

&

 
"




"


' 
 #

4
# 

#
   4

7
"
'



"
" 

& 

 
#

4
 
"

" 
 4



 
# 
  C   
# 
 
  5  
"



 
#"
"
 

"#"
 
 "


#
 
 

#
 
'








&

'
 
#"
 
"" "
 
   
5# 

'

#"
 
'

 #
'


 
 
 
4




" 
"

#



 


""

 
#
   "



?

'
 
#"
 
 

 #

 
% 4
 
9



4
 "
 
#
 





!

 
 " 
 "
 
# 
 
#
2

 
  
'
 

 


5"


 
'



#
 


  
'

 
 
'
 


 



 
 
'
"
 
'

 
   
&
 
 
 
 
'4
# 




##"
'

&
# 
 




 "
 4


 4
"



* 


  




 
   

 
" 
 " 
 4
 
 "
 
 

   !1
 


   

            

      

 !"



+4 "
 
#"
 
"" "

 
"

* 



 4
 
 
  
'

4
#"

 
'
"
 

'

 
 


5# "
# 





 
" 

 
 

 
 


 

=6
 
"4
" 
#  

 4
  4

 4

  

# "

#



 
7#


# 
   
 
#

 '




       4


"


  '


 

 


( >" 4  " 
 4
"

 "
'
4

 
 " 
 
 
 
 
'


 
#
 
 
 4
" 
# 



4 .
 "
 
#
 

 '  #

 4
"


 
 

 1" 4





* 
 


## 


 4
#
   
 
"


#
 "4  
 
 #

( 


 
  1""

# 


# 4
"


'
  
 " ## "
?
  

 & ' 
 
#
 
'


"



'
 1 4
&


 
  

# 
 + 
 +4
 
 
"  


 

 " "
 +4
"

#
 

'
"


 ""

  

 
7 4
 
  
' 4
"

 
 

 
 

1"4

 
 
 





4


  ""


 
 #
 " "
 
""
;
'


 
  #" 

 
 


 1"
 

'
 "
 

 

#
%-%9
'


 
5
DB
'


 '
'

 4

#

 4

 
"



D 7


 
1
!  
 
  
E 

#
!"
 
 


"   " 
 
""
 
  4
 





4  
"

!"
%-

E 
(" ?



%./6

 
5
D$ 
 
 "

4
 # "
' 
"4
#4


"

  "

"&
 

  
 
@4 
 



 
 " 
'
  
"

 # "

"&D

 " 4
 
@ 
  
?



 !"
<0%3
 
 
D
 
  #

" 


 
 #
 4
" 
"


  
4 

 


#
 
"

' 
  
D
 


"



"
  D4 
"


'

" 
## "
 
 
 " 
 
 
4
""


'D %/
B
 # 
"
 
" "4
#

 

A




1 
4 
 

#
' 
   
  
#
 >  



 + 
##"> 4F
#


 
#
 >  


  




# 
1  
!

 
"

 
 
)   

#
 #
 
"

" 

 4
( 

 4




#

##"
' 

 





 4  "

 
"

"
 

4

 
'

4

# " 
 
  
 * 
)   
4





# "
 4   
"


 
 " 

 






# "
B
  &
 
' +4
# 
 
 4
"

G
 "

#

 4
 
 





4

 
  

 
 
#
 
)   

  " 
B
"

G
 
 
 

; "




" 

+
 "

 
#
4
 




 
  ?

'
 
  #



 



"

 
"
'
  '




"

4
 
 
#
" :  
 
" #
 
 
  "   
 

" 
 

 
 " 





4 "  


'

 
 
4
C  4
&

'
 
 
 
 
'


 '
* 
" "4

 




 #
2

# 


'  # "
* 

""

 4

 
#   
 

"

+ 
 #
 # -''&
/



,#