← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4289/2019disposed of

Vodafone Idea Limited v. Yogesh Kumar Gupta And Another

2020-02-10Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat4 pages

   

  

 

  !"#!$%&%"'())  

 



      

 

 ( *+  ) ,

 , -   

 

! "#$% &'

 '

(

) !"#$% !

   *+ !"#$%  "

"

#',, & (!"#$% -$ +''$

  & '

(& !"#$% -$+$"$ .

  / *)  & '

!"#$% -$

 '

0

 !"#$% -$+$"$ , -.) /0

")12 

''  ++('% '$-$+( %',$%$"3*4.5$ 416  -$  7',',  &8""''$ (   %  "  $%*)  $  %$"

*79*$-'(',$-+#''$+''$ $      $  )'$"  '   ++('% '$!      )  '

(($&"

%%$)+ ',"$%*) 

$%$"



") 

'  '    ++('% '$  -$  +( %',  $  %$"      $ *7)''$7& $- --'"

#' ($,&' 3*4.8.$4.86 "

-$3)+'$-$)-'(',$',' (8%'-'"%$+'$- '"*3 $  $)'$"'  ++('% '$!  )'

 (($&"

%%$)+ ',"$%*) 

$%$"



+''$

-'(" '+''$%

((,', $" "

".:

;< 1;.5 "1;

;< 1;.5+ "7 0'#'(=*",> '#?!

  (!'0'#'(*'$ ..1<$-1;.5!& 7 $% (0$))''$ & $""$7 ++$'"@ " '')$"$- *9*$& + "

&((  +$$- $% (0$))''$!"

".:

;< 1;.5 '%$""7 ( " %$*(-$ +''$

*'7+$"$ .& -'("$.< ;< 1;.5  ) *$-- *"

*+$ %$)+  "*+$ 0$*! +''$%$)+ &  $& $

#7*'" $*, $ #'"*) !& $

$%$%'$ &' +''$4%$)+    )"

'

.< ;< 1;.5!$'%& '*"-$.:

;< 1;.5!'

&' , +$-$"

.:

;< 1;.5! 0$* ++$'" $% (0$))''$ " ($$*, +$$ )"

7< ;;

# +$$*, 7 (0$*& $-

+%'-'% '"& '% & $7-' +$"$ .8+( ''-- %'+ $- +$!')+*,"$""

"1;

;< 1;.5

7+ "!$"', ) ' '',  *9*$, "', *'+$+  '-* *7)'"

-* $"+ "7 (0$*'(- $&

+''$ %$)+ & ##"&  ''9*%$-#

"

 +( % (( $"

#7+ "7 '" 7 % $- +''$4 %$)+   "  7  "$+',     - *"*(  )   7     +$" $ .8+( ''-- '!'%$((*'$&' +$"$   '-* +$'"$*7 ( " %$*(-$ +''$ 

 ' $9*'$$- %$)+$ + $- +''$7% * +''$4%$)+ 

"#7#"&' 

 *))$$$'%$- *'-$) 0$*

+''$% )$ $&

7$* (( 

++',!$(&  + '#$- %$)+  &+#"-$)', *'+$+7 +$"8+( ''--

"  -! -'($- *'7-$ (0$*& '+%"

%%$"',(! ++''$

7-'("

 #'&$- - %!'' *7)'"7 ( " %$*(-$ +''$

')+*,"

$"!  ($,&'  %$)+  +$%"',  "#  $  7    '"  "

++$+'

  %'$  "#  $  7  '''

"  , '     +$" $ .8+( ''--      $  

"!  ( "  %$*(  -$     +$" $ .8+( ''--

*7)'"

')+*,"$"' $"+ "'

 ++('% '$)$#"-$'')('-

 '"$"' ++ 7($ $&#! +''$

$-'("  ++ (7-$ ++$+'

 0$*  ! +''$

* "$ ', 0$*"'%(  ' -*  *7)'" 

   +$"$ .8+( ''-- 

" -*' "  ,'" %$# -$  --%', #'%  '   *'@ *+$   +''$ $&#! %$*(

$+$'"$* +%'-'%"

$& '% +''$)', 

#7#"&' *))$$ $"+ "7 (0$*  #', " ( "%$*(-$ + '! '0$*' $- #'&

'% ) ','# %' , ' '')$"+ "

7 (0$*! -$! +''$ $*("+-  *$ ++ ' -'' % ")'"(!'% ')+*,"$"&+ "

#7-$ --%',#'%*+$ +''$! -$!'&$*("7

++$+'

!'- --%$-  )' +' 7 %'(("



 +''$ ++$ %  ++(( 0$*' ++ %%$"',(! ++''$'"'+$"$-&' ('7$ +''$$ ++$ % 0$*7($&' ++ (@' -'' % &' ' +'$"$- &  '-* $""

-$ +'$"$-  & -$)$"

! '')$"+ "7 (0$*! &((  %$)++$%"','''

" , ' +''$!

(() ' "

'((-* ''"'%"

++ (-'("7-$ $&++((  0$*!'- !

((7"%'""3+"''$*( , -

 

.;

;1 1;1;

 -3! 3!/&4!5%'67/!&"'!89!&7"

-3! 3!//!4"/ :0!9 !&7"