M/S Arun Bhatta Company v. The Presiding Officer Employees Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal & ANR
! !"#$#%&'('$ )*
!
#
$ + )
$ , ,,
- ./0 $ ! %
$ + , %
$ !
$ , ) %
$
) )
%
$ ) )
&
"
& '
$ ((( /& 12/ 334 5('!678& )
*
+ ,-./012-23.45
+ ,-.637/-23.45 $ 8 %
+ ,-.637/-23.4 .9091-2330 /427 /42/-23.75
+ ,-29/3.-23.2 ./012-23.4
.0910-23.75 8 :
%
+ ,-29/3.-23.2 .0910-23.75 *.+ ,-.9091-2330 /427-23.75 & 8 :
& "
;
+ ,-/42/-23.75 (((( 34 * < =
" =
=
=
>
, " *./01223.4 29/3.23.2
.0910 23.7
" "
-
,*.637/23.4 .90912330 /42723.7 /42/23.7
" "$ ! 2 !
"
> , *./01223.4-
!
#
9 = <
303123.4 +?-95 " !
"
# + @ 9! ::!;; !
5#7'% ;@5 "
"
+
@
@5 23A
=
"
"
8 -
< ?. 2
2/3423.4+?-15 6 !
=
" >>
=
B
>
>
= >
=
C
!" 23.1
=
..3023.6 =
$.0 ..2- = 30.00/ 23.9 $.9 743-
" "
= =
?
-
" " =
=
= " "
3.3423.1 ,*.207923.1
=
= ="
203723.1
!
"
303123.4 +?95
- 23A
=
" *2C
$2 .12-
"=
2.3423.4%= *2
= = " "
&"<
" " =
..3023.6 =
=
$.9 743- $.0 ..2-
=
" <
=
=
"
1 C " *2
>
-
303123.4 +?-95"= ,*.637/23.4 @
>
&
4 @ !
.012+
@ 9!" @5 "
.2A
"
" .2A
"
=
=
.1
=
! C
"
@ ! D
= &
.6-
&
.6-
=
"=
& " .00/
2334
&
7- =
2334 $.2 /9 726-
&
7-
) 23.2
=
?
=
=
.93923.6= "
=
=
"
= "
"
= ,*.207923.1
23A
=
"
C
= "
"
= "
- ,*.637/23.4"
4 '
>
C
!
%E" & /<$#%6'$ %#=!$2 6>$
%#% %6# %6 9!5$* 3 %E"
-
!(#% ; 5?#6!% '%6 ==#$$#%!5>$/<$#@@ 5(5 6$2#=# !6 %6 % 9!5* + *6!"#6!6% , )A # ; :!5 #?!3'( 5 /#;;$2 6>$9!=:;8!!$ 5?#6!% '%6::!;; !5#7'% ; %6 9!5$*
) *6!"#6!6% A9! !(#% ;
5?#6!% '%6 ==#$$#%!5 >$ /<$ 39#?% % !5% #% ; %6 % 9!5* ) * , ) 7 %
" "
=
"
-
"
=
=
=
=
=
.1 = &
.6
"
=
>"
=
=
=
=
"
=
"
&
7 .6-
/ C/<$#%6'$ %#=!$2 61$" $!-$':5 0 %E" ?
" &
.6
=
"
=
!
" FG2/ !
=
" F
&
.6-
=
=
8 " " H
$ !
>
"
<
H
"
=
"
"
D
"
<
" 8 "
" HI 0 C 5( % 9!=#" ;%6'$ 5#!$.% 9!5?$ %#%
%6# . 9!5$ -03
FG
=
.6-
=
@< -8 @
= " =
"
I .3 %E" ? " 5( % 9!=#" ;
%6'$ 5#!$1$" $!-$':5 0
=
="
= " =
= =- 43A
= "
?
"
" > =
"
"
"
"
13A
" = =
" "
.. C
==
>"%E" -
/<$ #@@ 5 (5 6$ 2#=# !6A # ; :!5 #?!
3'( 5/#;;$2 6A %6/<$39#?%% !5% #% ;1$" $!$-$':5 0 .2 =
>"%E" ? /<$#%6'$ % #=!$ 2 61$ " $! -$':5 0 5( % 9!=#" ;%6'$ 5#!$1 " $!
-$':5 0
>"
-
= =
8
=
!
"G I'
"
"
.9 C =:;8!!$ 5?#6!% '%6 5( %#$ #% >$ /<$
5( # 3#;#"%!$ 2 6 %6 % 9!5* +) ,
213723./
=
!
8 .6 =
>"%E" ?
, " *./01223.4 "
,*29/3.23.2 .0910 23.7 " %
,* .637/23.4 /42723.7 /42/23.7 " ,*.90912330 "$ !
=
"
- -34 0 '('$ )* ,
> J F K ,
" J K