Champabhatt v. Ut Of Chandigarh And Orther




 
    
 

!"!#$!%&'()** #&'&+',!%&'()**  

   

  
(  -.*  /.*



!"# $%&

! 

$'( #$%&



'"#$%&

  ) 


 " #$%&

* "

+ ,#$%&

   ) -.

 ,%(#$%&

  ) /
 000   /.0*     $ &"

..12..3

     4  

+ 

    &    

..

.53 6$ 7
..8 ! *'   $    ! !&  

..

.596$ 7
.8  .

   , &"  #  6  :

;853 5< .555   !"&   = $  !

> .55?% &  

5 .55>   "  $  7  & "

  @" 7  "



 .> 5< .59    %  "&  

 5< .59  @

 ,   & 6 $ 8 %& &  & 6 :

;8%"*"

  $

.
 &&  !            !     * !

       %  

/ .59!      # '-$&& # ,*!  @

    %&    ! "'

  2 2 & ! @"' $  7  ,*   *  

   A&

   ' * *     % &  

..

.59 #  & * %""'

 & 6 $ 8

*, &"&  ,*(% 

&  

..

.59 


 
 


 


  


 


 


  
 




 



!"#$ %#&'%(#)***
 
%+ , &'%(


 
 
  
 


-
 

. 
/
 



 





 
" 
01








2
%'+''$+3*''4('''



-




  








 

5


 

 
 
  
 


 


!"#$ %#&'%(#)**,
 
%+ , &'%(

 




















 
" 
01


-




  
&& , &'%(
.789
2 
:

  

-





  ;

/
 / &  

+&"&  ,* (%  !     $  &

!* "

 2  % "



51 5 .51 

  &" & '6A& 8#$ *

  !"" ,$  & 6 $ 8

  %  "

 

 .< 5?

.51  @

 $ &% ' && & ,  & 

     $  %      

..

.53          

&    ! !  %" &

  '

4  &&& !  7  & "

  & %"*"

! A& # $  4  !    &"   ' &

 

& &    

"'*    "

 <  $%&

 *  &  !    & * & ""

*' * &   *'

 !

&

*'$ #!

# &  * &  &&"

& * & ""

%  *'$   % "



3 5/ .55?

  

/ 5.

.55? &      $ # A& $&& 6(:;  8 & "

#.5556 : & "

#.555;8      & "

#

<
 .555! "'

!&"

  $  7&&

*' ,*(%  * & "*"

  %"*"

!    4  "     "" * %   & ""

 *'   $ # &    

 3 5/ .55?   !"* &  

$ "



.5 .555# 

 !

&

!   4  +# !

   !" *  ""

            .55? &

 " !&& !"

&   " !&&" ! $   ""

6A-$8 A%  !

""

   ! !

"'%& !& &"% '!

""* ""

 &

%"*"

  "  &     "C ! &

!        %"*"

 4     & #    ! %"*"

!  # # !@ "+ !  !+!   & .59 $'  '  !" "    =$ 

4 !"* * !+ "!



 
 #"

 & "   * "



 3 5/ .55? " *     &&  !   &     & 

/ 5.

.55?! *'  !  & "

# .555     &  

 / 5.

.55?  

"'

  2 2 &  &

  $  7&&

*'

,* (%    * &     &  &

    & "

#.555  '"



.?

5/ .55?# &" 

9


"'

 !" * "*"

  &

   $  7 &&

 *'

,*(%  * &  & &

*'A& #        "

 %   &  

& 6 $ 8  !"

&  !        &"

    !" *  ""

      !  &

& & !&"

  $  7  * &   

  2 2 & 2   "

%    *'

   %"*"

 !    &  &"    

7
&          & &&    & , &" "

+ '

.555   !"&   =$  !

> .55?

  #!    &

   '#  .59  &

   $  7 &&

 *'

,*(% 

  @" 7      '*     "* &    &    $   # ! !

 "' %&

  ! 


   '* 

 &  "   @

* &  & &

*' !   &"

# # 



 

+ &"&   ,* (% 

  &&" ,*(%  !

"

 ""' 

1
   "

9 ,*

A& $&& 6($8

%& "

#.5.6 :.5."

;8&

* "    &"

  $  7# !"* 

* &  & %  !"*

   !" * "&  *

  '"

&

&""'% "



 51 5 .51    &" & ' 6A& 8#  $        !  * &     &    $   7          "'

     *'  

..

.53 +  ! ! &  

..

.59

 ! !"

* & 

   

 

& 6 $ 8!   $ +   " ! &

 

&

 ?

4* *"'#          *'

4  &

   3$6/8 ,*

&"   B! 6E7

  8 $& # >>< & * &

!  %"$ # # 3$6/8   ' &  
 <

   ===

===

===

=== 0+1
>



 
  

5
 
 





5 






 ?



  
 




 ?

 

 











  ;

3
 >  %  

.5 .555%   

 & "

44   $  & "

# 

 6 $ 8!

% *, &  !"" * ""

    "

% &   & "

  & * "!




 < 
>
 
 
  
 

 >
>
  

-





  -
9
%)*,$ ::0*1$&'''#(*)(

  

&'

') &'''

@$




 


-




  AAA
2

 
9
B$::#-#CC#C&&%
 
09">
6:B29:.DB1
 
9
B$::#-#CC#&&)
 
%& &'''
 
9
-#B #B$%#CC#C*,C
 
&& %'

CC
 
9
B$::#-#&'''#%3,)
 
&% &'''

 
9
B$::#-#CC#%&C3'
 
+% %& CC
 
9 -#B $:#B$:::#CC#&C*'
 
&& CC
 
9
B$ ::#-#CC#&%'C
 
C + &'''
 
9
-#B $:#B$ :#&'''#%'+&
 
* &'''



 





  
E > 
  


 

$ 
0+1

 
,%01


 
-




D 5
0B  

  1
 
%CC3




 $::

 

-




  
5 
 
5 
 
 
 
3)
0   1









 $::
 




 +  
















5


 

 


 

?
   
 $::

 
 
  
 

 ;

 !  9





9





 
2 ?
 
B>:"9
" :B2
0  1
 "

01
+
2
)3''$%')3'









 
5









 5     6 $

8!&  % "



5< 5< .55?  $ < &" . $   ""

6A-$8#  *'#9

. $   ""

6A-$8!

%"*"

!   %" 

*'  $  $  %   &  

 / 5.

.55?     $ #A& $&& 6(:;  8 & "

#.555 4     & "

#.555%      &   ' !'  .55?   # $   

"'

  2 2 &   $  &

 7 $ &&

*'

,** &  &

A  ' & # & 

/ 5.

.55?! *'  !  & "

#.555  & * "!



>
 <>
%+ 
 
&''* 9
!"
0:1$&''*$%'+C
:
 


5







+'C

 

:

 
5 


:


-   

7



9





9"

2+&),
 
%
9

%C))

  
E 
> 
  

 ?



5 
 




 

 


  
 


 
6

 
 
0 $
 1
2 
2 
&'''
  @$

1
>
 
 





  
 


 
6

 
 
0 $
 1
2 
2 
0 
 1
&''*

1
>



 



 










F 

1
:

  
 



 
6

 
 
0 $
 1
2 
2 
&'''


 


 

 
9
G%%G

 
G- 

2 
5 

 
 


 




# 

 



 








 G
 

5
 G


 





5 




  @$
G. #

# 


  
 



1
 


  
 


 
6

 
 
0 $
 1
2 
2 
&'''



 


 

 

G%%G

 
G- 

2 
5 

 
 


 




# 

 



 








 G
 


01



5 




  @$
01
>





. #

# 
5



 

 



B  


 


 


5


 



 



 
6

  
  
 





5
  




 


 

 
 



 





G ;
 % &  

.?

5/ .55?

   &  *' &  

.?

5/ .55? 








<" #$ $% ! % &$#'  #$( 




" :B
"26B2
:
 

5

 

 


 


 




-




  


%' 

 
 

&C , %CC,




9
!"
0%1$&''*#%'+C
 
%+ &'*
0 
%+ &''*1
0 
 1

 
 
6

 


 
  
 


  
 

 


  
 


 
6

 
 
0
HH
 1
2 
2 







. #

# 
5



 

 



  


 


 

5


 



 


 
6

  
  

 




 














-




  


 














 


  
 

 ; .

$& 

& ""

"  "

& %   $   % &  

*   &  &

 *'  $   

 2 2   %   2$   ""

   %"!



 3$6/8 ,*

&" $&

F"

 %"#$  


 &"

  !""* ""

   &"

 *' &    

 .?

5/ .55?#     !

 +       ! "

"

 &       &   !  &  %&

!

&    &" !

+  

 

        *" 

  *

& % &%&#!

#& * &

&  &" & && &  &

 *'!'   &  

 / 5.

.55?     &  "

# .555  '   # "'

  2 2 &  !

  

&

   $  7 &&

 *'

,*   ' !

  "*"

* &   & & 

&" 

 

 '   #

   

  "'

 &

  7 $  &&

*'

,** &  & &

*'  4 * &    &  *'  # "'

&"   $  7&&

*'

,** &   &

$

"'

 C 7& &   & * &   C !  %"  

  *'      &    *'   $ 

 "   "'

  $  7&&

*' ,*(%  * &   & # % *"

&&"    *'   

 3 5/ .55? 

  &  *'  & "

#.555   " %  ""  ! 

.
 / &  "'#      

 &    & "

#.555 *' &

&

$  !  & "

#.555*'!' & 

/ 5.

.55?

   # "'

 !



"*"

 &

  $  7&&

*'

,* $  & "

#.555# "'

!&"

  4-44 $  7 * & *  &

' *

"'

 ' 2 2  $ "

96<8

,*

 A&   $&&  6( :$;8 %&  "

# .5.#  &

* "   %  $  7

 4-44 @ &    %&

D  &    '*  #   %& &

 !+ *  !""  ,  $    &    %  "

 

5 .51*

  !"" ,$  ,$ * &  ! *

  *

  '" &    

   * &  & ,$     <  &

  $  7&&

*'

,*    &

 7  & "

#.555   !

"*"

 * & &   & "

#.555 ! "

 *'

,* 4   &  7 ! & "

#.555 $ "

# &"* & *' ,& &

*'$   &" *"! &"   &" * 

& %*"

"

% %*"

/
     "

4 !%*"

 , & &

*' #!

# !%*"

   

"

$ #     "&   

& 4 * &  

& # !* * %  *' & "

#.555

D'# ,* % &

 

& & A&

*  %& &"

  4-44 $  7 '  

    % A&

4  & # $ %   $   ""

6A-$8   F"

&  

    & # ! &"   !"*  ""

     A%   &&  "'!

""

  



+ %      

 &"   " *  ,

  %&      !       &    $ &""

  ! *' !

&

*, &  !"* ""

   !* ""    !

 

&   4   &  & &

   ! 4 * 

+%"$     !   !  ""   ! 4 * &  &&"

!

""& # !@ ""  ! !**' ! *' !

&

  9 & " >'

% ! 

  

D" && 

 

<


   &

*"

 %   *

""!"&*"

"

 "  1 4 !+ *% &#   &       %  *     &&"'   3

 & "& 68#'#"""  

  /.   )**  G F  +2   H 2) F   *"

2) Date of Uploading: 20.01.2026